Chap 4 EE

Raymond Hames Author

08/18/2017 Added

164 Plays

Description

Chapter 4 for Introduction to Cultural Anthropology (ANTH 212)

Searchable Transcript

Search:

[00:00:00.000]Chapter Four we're gonna deal with
[00:00:01.999]explanation and evidence.
[00:00:04.320]Basically it'll focus on how anthropologists
[00:00:07.459]do the research in terms of the source of questions they
[00:00:11.394]pursue and the kinds of evidence they present,
[00:00:14.059]so we'll look at explanations, why theories can not
[00:00:18.052]be proved, in fact they can only be falsified
[00:00:22.247]in a technical sense, how theories are generated,
[00:00:26.750]how evidence is collected to test explanations,
[00:00:30.960]and they types of research in cultural anthropology.
[00:00:36.121]Okay, we'll begin with explanations.
[00:00:38.364]An explanation is simply an answer to a why question.
[00:00:42.198]For example, in the online reading, why is there
[00:00:45.890]variation in the use of spices in meat dishes?
[00:00:48.986]We'll use this example a little bit later.
[00:00:51.900]What anthropologists tend to do, or any scientists actually,
[00:00:56.366]is to look for associations or relationships,
[00:00:59.885]that is how certain kinds of variables seem to
[00:01:03.903]hang together to be consistently present
[00:01:07.929]in a variety of different cases.
[00:01:10.563]And it's important to understand that when we talk about
[00:01:13.988]explanations we're talking about hypotheses
[00:01:16.958]that are deduced from some kind of theory.
[00:01:20.495]Now this is a very important point.
[00:01:24.963]It may come a surprise to many of you that theories
[00:01:28.084]can not be proved.
[00:01:29.578]Theories can never be proved with absolute certainty
[00:01:32.340]because we are unable to test them under all situations
[00:01:36.922]that are possible to test a theory.
[00:01:41.471]So what we do is employ the method of falsification
[00:01:45.143]which shows that a theory seems to be wrong
[00:01:47.721]is the main way in which that theories are judged,
[00:01:50.494]that is if we fail to falsify a theory
[00:01:56.223]or actually a hypothesis drawn from a theory
[00:02:01.147]then we can be confident that the theory or the hypothesis
[00:02:08.415]is reasonable and probably correct.
[00:02:14.806]According to the authors in their section under
[00:02:17.609]generating theories, there are two methods that have
[00:02:20.623]helped anthropologists produce explanations
[00:02:23.170]of cultural phenomena.
[00:02:24.855]We have the single case analysis.
[00:02:27.427]For example, we might see a pattern
[00:02:30.382]in our field data that shows that polygyny,
[00:02:34.302]or a man being able to marry more than one woman at a time,
[00:02:39.296]and status are connected.
[00:02:41.664]Therefore we might look through our data and see
[00:02:44.727]how many men are polygynous and have high status
[00:02:47.732]versus how many men are monogamous and have
[00:02:50.501]moderate or low status.
[00:02:52.575]This would be a kind of single case analysis.
[00:02:55.650]On the other hand we might want to find out if this
[00:02:58.839]relationship holds cross culturally, and I'd like to
[00:03:02.308]point out again that your authors Carol Ember
[00:03:06.046]and Mel Ember are really leaders in the field
[00:03:09.475]of comparative analysis, and so we might gather
[00:03:12.568]together a random sample of, let's say, 50 societies
[00:03:17.195]and look to see if indeed in all these societies
[00:03:22.223]there's a relationship between polygyny and status,
[00:03:25.990]and if we can't find a relationship then we've perhaps
[00:03:30.109]falsified the theory and we have to go elsewhere
[00:03:35.030]to figure out what polygyny is associated with.
[00:03:39.183]And so this is the value of comparative study,
[00:03:41.374]we can move from a single case we've observed in the field,
[00:03:46.263]in our own research, to see how well that idea plays out
[00:03:49.868]across the globe through some kind of comparative study.
[00:03:55.586]When we try to test a hypothesis we need evidence,
[00:04:02.487]and one of the first things we have to do
[00:04:04.334]is to operationalize the variables.
[00:04:06.607]For example, we're talking about the relationship
[00:04:10.298]between status and polygyny.
[00:04:13.043]Now, the variable status is what we call
[00:04:16.113]the independent variable or a factor
[00:04:18.600]that we think determines a dependent variable
[00:04:22.295]that we call polygyny.
[00:04:25.340]And so, how do we kind of operationalize our variables?
[00:04:31.954]Well for status it could be a bit complex,
[00:04:35.246]that is we would perhaps do a survey and ask people
[00:04:39.625]in a particular community to rank order everyone
[00:04:42.354]in terms of their high status to low status position.
[00:04:46.565]Or we might think that perhaps certain offices held
[00:04:51.280]by individuals are indicative of high status,
[00:04:55.046]and so we get a sense of how to kind of measure what we mean
[00:05:00.522]by high status, and this is called operationalization.
[00:05:06.111]The way to operationalize polygyny is fairly
[00:05:10.379]straightforward, does a man have more than one wife
[00:05:14.286]at the same time, a very kind of simple sort of thing
[00:05:17.153]that we can observe.
[00:05:18.594]We also, when we do our research, want to generate a sample,
[00:05:23.110]and that sample needs to be random if we're going to do
[00:05:26.755]any kind of statistical test on it.
[00:05:31.375]That's an absolute requirement,
[00:05:33.354]and sampling and random sampling ensures that
[00:05:37.386]our collection of individuals that we include in the study
[00:05:40.741]are not somehow biased unconsciously that
[00:05:44.827]perhaps would allow our ideas to be more easily proved.
[00:05:50.850]We want to make sure that there's no bias in the sampling.
[00:05:56.128]Here is an example presented in Table 4.1
[00:06:00.149]of a kind of cross cultural research that looked
[00:06:03.685]at the relationship between the availability of protein
[00:06:07.149]and the duration of the portpartum sex taboo.
[00:06:11.347]The availability of protein has to do with availability
[00:06:14.315]largely of meat resources in the diet,
[00:06:17.096]and this can be accomplished by doing
[00:06:20.165]dietary surveys in societies and making measures
[00:06:25.554]of high protein availability to low protein availability,
[00:06:29.970]fairly straightforward.
[00:06:31.673]And so is the duration of what is known as
[00:06:34.481]the postpartum sex taboo.
[00:06:36.601]Well, what is a postpartum sex taboo?
[00:06:39.798]In many societies couples, married couples,
[00:06:43.569]are not permitted to have sexual relationships
[00:06:49.278]so long as the child they've produced
[00:06:53.401]is continuously nursing.
[00:06:56.304]The taboo ends typically after the child ceases nursing.
[00:07:01.897]It can range from a very short period of time
[00:07:04.713]to a couple of weeks to up to a year
[00:07:07.452]to more than a year.
[00:07:09.795]And so with this idea that there is a relationship between
[00:07:13.934]availability of protein in the diet
[00:07:16.959]and the duration of postpartum sex taboo,
[00:07:20.749]John Whiting looked at the relationship
[00:07:25.575]and he had measures of protein availability,
[00:07:29.080]high, medium, and low, and then also measures of
[00:07:33.789]short and long postpartum sex taboos,
[00:07:37.984]and as you can see where
[00:07:41.482]protein availability is high there tends to be
[00:07:46.556]a short postpartum sex taboo, and then if you look
[00:07:50.367]at the intersection between low protein availability
[00:07:55.314]and long postpartum sex taboo, that's higher than
[00:08:01.484]if you look up the column where societies have high
[00:08:06.642]or medium durations of, or excuse me, intakes of protein.
[00:08:13.035]And so we see a kind of pattern.
[00:08:15.034]The pattern is not strong but it's consistent
[00:08:17.445]and statistically significant.
[00:08:21.837]And so this is a way we can being to try and understand
[00:08:26.205]an interesting phenomenon, the duration of a postpartum
[00:08:30.000]sex taboo and why in some societies it is very short
[00:08:34.579]and why in some societies it is relatively long.
[00:08:39.241]Now, clearly this doesn't really unpack some of the details,
[00:08:44.053]that is, why should this relationship exist.
[00:08:47.641]The idea here is that high quality protein in the diet
[00:08:52.506]is a kind of measure of the ability of a mother to undergo
[00:08:58.701]short term periods of nursing, which then allows her
[00:09:02.698]to wean her child making sure that her milk is replaced
[00:09:06.547]with high quality protein,
[00:09:08.631]and so we have this kind of short postpartum sex taboo.
[00:09:14.877]In Evidence Testing Explanations we again look
[00:09:18.530]at operationalization.
[00:09:20.952]And what it says here, in order to ensure research is done
[00:09:24.370]accurately, a researcher typically provides an operational
[00:09:28.031]definition of each concept or variable.
[00:09:31.382]Operational definitions are really important
[00:09:33.910]because it provides clarity in terms of
[00:09:37.365]what is really meant by something,
[00:09:40.078]as we mentioned before, having high status.
[00:09:43.631]And also it's really critical because if someone wants
[00:09:46.578]to test another researcher's ideas, he needs or she needs
[00:09:52.595]to know exactly how the variable was measured,
[00:09:56.173]so operationalization is really critical,
[00:09:59.885]and because it essentially deals with how
[00:10:03.314]the variable or the set of variables will be measured.
[00:10:07.929]We're gonna look now at the types of research
[00:10:09.679]in cultural anthropology, beginning with ethnography.
[00:10:12.027]Ethnography tends to be descriptive.
[00:10:16.154]When people do ethnographic research they're not
[00:10:18.537]necessarily trying to test ideas scientifically
[00:10:22.936]but rather just to describe what goes on in a particular
[00:10:26.826]culture in terms of what are their patterns of marriage,
[00:10:31.263]how the status system works, how they adapt to
[00:10:34.560]the environment, et cetera, et cetera.
[00:10:37.033]But we also might want to move to within cultural
[00:10:41.019]comparisons, and again, the example of polygyny and status
[00:10:45.700]will give you an idea of how this works.
[00:10:48.423]For example, we know that there's some variation
[00:10:51.130]in marriage patterns.
[00:10:52.329]Some men have one wife or they have no wives
[00:10:56.130]and some men have several wives.
[00:10:58.623]And so if we want to try and discover
[00:11:02.072]within that particular culture what seems to be associated
[00:11:06.466]with polygyny, and here we mentioned before it was
[00:11:09.079]high status, we could do an analysis within
[00:11:13.113]a particular culture.
[00:11:15.038]And then we can move to regional controlled comparisons.
[00:11:20.370]Or we might want to look at, for example,
[00:11:24.029]the relationship between having herding
[00:11:29.268]as a major part of your economy where you have
[00:11:32.142]animals that you have to graze
[00:11:34.984]and the relationship between a pattern of descent
[00:11:38.557]such as patrilineality.
[00:11:40.666]And so we might restrict our analysis to sub Saharan Africa,
[00:11:46.125]as an example, and look at maybe 30 or 40 different
[00:11:48.939]societies in that particular region.
[00:11:52.764]And indeed the search has indicated that there is
[00:11:56.443]a strong relationship between patrilineal descent
[00:11:59.697]and having herd animals.
[00:12:01.775]The agricultural peoples in sub Saharan Africa
[00:12:05.224]tend to be matrilineal or bilateral in their social
[00:12:09.406]organization, you'll learn about that later,
[00:12:12.023]but almost all of the herding people are patrilineal.
[00:12:16.829]And then we can move to what we call
[00:12:20.258]cross cultural research which was presented to you
[00:12:24.640]a little bit earlier in Whiting's research on postpartum
[00:12:28.345]sex taboos and the availability of protein the diet.
[00:12:33.948]And then finally we might want to look at
[00:12:39.168]how a particular society or a set of societies
[00:12:43.040]have changed through time.
[00:12:46.015]As certain factors become more important
[00:12:48.811]other factors change, and we can do this temporally
[00:12:53.012]or historically through historical research.
[00:12:56.626]The other kinds of research across cultural
[00:13:00.696]or regional controlled comparisons are typically
[00:13:03.540]what we call cross sectional research
[00:13:07.028]because they occur at a particular moment in time
[00:13:11.154]and not through time.
[00:13:13.688]Again, in your text it looks at ethnography.
[00:13:17.031]And after doing a spate of field work
[00:13:20.614]typically lasting more than a year, an anthropologist
[00:13:23.871]may prepare an ethnography, or a description
[00:13:27.473]and perhaps some analysis of a single society,
[00:13:29.981]so that's what an ethnography is all about,
[00:13:32.759]and most anthropologists engage in ethnographic
[00:13:36.233]kinds of research.
[00:13:38.704]It's also important to do research ethically.
[00:13:42.941]For example, before we can do any kind of research
[00:13:47.903]we have to present our methods to what is known as
[00:13:51.643]the IRB, or the Institutional Review Board,
[00:13:55.844]which is for the protection of human subjects,
[00:13:58.901]and we have to convince the IRB that we have safeguards
[00:14:04.351]in place to protect our research, our subjects
[00:14:11.341]in our research, and also the American Anthropological
[00:14:14.826]Association, or the AAA, has its own code of ethics.
[00:14:18.402]The preeminent one is to essentially, in your research,
[00:14:21.695]do not harm the people that you are studying.
[00:14:27.811]In the types of research in cultural anthropology
[00:14:30.355]we can look at within cultural comparisons,
[00:14:32.834]that's testing a theory within one society
[00:14:35.239]comparing individuals, families, households, communities,
[00:14:38.429]or districts, for example.
[00:14:40.467]And again, as I mentioned before,
[00:14:43.467]looking at the relationship between status and polygyny
[00:14:46.661]would be a kind of within culture comparison.
[00:14:50.999]Another type of research in cultural anthropology
[00:14:53.106]is a regional controlled comparison.
[00:14:55.938]And it's an ethnographic comparison between societies
[00:14:58.371]in the same or similar region.
[00:15:01.471]And the example I gave you before was herding
[00:15:04.263]and patrilineal descent in sub Saharan Africa.
[00:15:07.985]And what we found out, or what researchers have found out,
[00:15:11.689]is that there is a powerful association
[00:15:14.175]between patrilineal descent and dependence on herd animals,
[00:15:18.080]largely cattle but sometimes camels and horses
[00:15:23.702]in sub Saharan Africa.
[00:15:26.410]And again, to reiterate on cross cultural research,
[00:15:30.463]these are worldwide comparisons between societies having
[00:15:34.079]and those lacking a particular characteristic.
[00:15:37.047]This method is beneficial in that the conclusions drawn
[00:15:41.140]probably are applicable to most societies.
[00:15:44.152]And indeed, cross cultural comparisons,
[00:15:46.846]both in anthropology and the psychology of sociology
[00:15:50.889]are kind of a gold standard.
[00:15:52.903]If our ideas are true within a particular society,
[00:15:56.740]we find them true in a controlled regional comparison,
[00:16:02.475]then if we can't successfully test them cross culturally
[00:16:07.011]through a worldwide sample, then we have
[00:16:10.770]a great deal of confidence in our theory.
[00:16:15.592]Lastly we have historical research,
[00:16:17.919]sometimes called ethnohistory.
[00:16:19.965]It consists of studies based on descriptive materials
[00:16:22.875]about a single society at more than one point in time,
[00:16:26.970]but actually you can do this kind of research over
[00:16:30.217]several societies at more than one point in time.
[00:16:33.927]For example, you might want to study the impact
[00:16:37.985]of contact in terms of trade and commercialization,
[00:16:43.679]the subsistent systems of a particular group,
[00:16:46.977]and you can look at what they were like
[00:16:50.013]prior to the impact of commercialization,
[00:16:55.048]and then as commercialization gained steady hold
[00:16:58.631]you can look at the various sorts of changes
[00:17:01.047]until they're completely commercialized.
[00:17:03.066]And so this is an example of historical research.
[00:17:05.911]It's done through time, and so what happens is that
[00:17:09.746]as certain variables, the impact of commercialization
[00:17:13.019]as an example, begins to slowly increase
[00:17:16.694]and we make predictions about the certain kinds
[00:17:19.719]of changes that should occur through time
[00:17:23.217]as commercialization becomes stronger and stronger.

The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!

You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.

Comments

0 Comments

Chap 4 EE

Description

Searchable Transcript

Comments icon comment

Related Channels

Comments