Chap 3 ANTH 212

Raymond Hames Author

08/18/2017 Added

145 Plays

Description

Chap. 3 212 from Ember and Ember 14th Edition

Searchable Transcript

Search:

[00:00:01.141]Long and detailed,
[00:00:02.830]largely because Carol Ember and Mel Ember,
[00:00:05.926]the authors of your text, are psychological anthropologists.
[00:00:09.392]So here are the major topics that are gonna be covered.
[00:00:12.437]The universality of psychological development.
[00:00:15.879]The anthropology of childhood.
[00:00:17.936]Cross-cultural variation in child-rearing.
[00:00:20.864]Psychological explanations of culture and variation.
[00:00:24.555]Psychological variation in adulthood.
[00:00:26.621]And individuals as agents of cultural change.
[00:00:30.954]Now we're gonna turn to the university
[00:00:32.443]of psychological development.
[00:00:34.607]So in what respect is psychological development
[00:00:36.647]the same the world over?
[00:00:38.397]And in what respects is it different?
[00:00:40.734]If we turn to the issue of emotional development,
[00:00:43.241]and we don't have a lot of data,
[00:00:44.836]initially there were Freudian interpretations
[00:00:47.754]using such concepts as the Oedipus complex,
[00:00:52.320]but research by Malinowski, as pointed out in the text,
[00:00:55.655]in the Trobriand Islands showed that Freud's ideas
[00:00:58.918]didn't fit there or they fit in an opposite way.
[00:01:02.241]And in truth, we know very little about
[00:01:04.737]the cross-cultural variation and emotional development.
[00:01:07.884]However, if we turn to cognitive development,
[00:01:09.768]we find that there is a great deal of similarity
[00:01:12.530]from culture to culture in terms of
[00:01:15.156]the sorts of cognitive skills
[00:01:16.849]that has to do with language acquisition
[00:01:19.889]and other dimensions of cognition
[00:01:23.556]that are the same world over,
[00:01:26.322]and that children tend to develop
[00:01:29.712]certain kinds of abilities
[00:01:32.212]in a rather similar time scale.
[00:01:37.660]Some of the research done
[00:01:39.577]by the Swiss psychologist, Piaget,
[00:01:43.211]on sensory motor development and the like
[00:01:46.339]has shown to have some relevance,
[00:01:48.997]at least in the early dimensions of childhood,
[00:01:53.335]in terms of its universal patterns.
[00:01:56.665]Look at the anthropology of childhood.
[00:01:59.221]And we want to kind of deal with explaining
[00:02:02.356]variation in childhood and beyond.
[00:02:04.461]So we have topics such as the parent's belief systems,
[00:02:08.113]and there's a nice description of Dutch parents
[00:02:12.100]and how they differ from American parents
[00:02:14.336]and the kinds of ideas that parents have,
[00:02:18.586]which the authors called ethnotheories
[00:02:21.612]about how children should develop.
[00:02:23.943]It's also maybe possible that there are adaptational
[00:02:28.076]explanations for childhood development,
[00:02:30.517]in that we should expect
[00:02:33.881]that in certain kinds of environments,
[00:02:35.789]certain sorts of skills
[00:02:38.152]and cognitive orientations and emotional responses
[00:02:41.891]would be adapted, and therefore selected for.
[00:02:45.471]And there's also a possibility
[00:02:46.833]that there are some genetic
[00:02:49.609]and physiological influences on development.
[00:02:53.062]The work of Friedman, for example, is highlighted,
[00:02:55.570]when in finding that, for example,
[00:02:57.697]Asian children and Native American children
[00:03:00.252]are much more relaxed and passive
[00:03:02.798]than children in Western societies.
[00:03:07.956]And so research in this area is ongoing.
[00:03:12.774]If we look at the cross-cultural variation
[00:03:15.125]in childrearing in greater detail,
[00:03:19.013]we want to ask the question
[00:03:19.964]does variation in childrearing customs account for
[00:03:22.530]the observed psychological differences of people?
[00:03:25.680]So the whole set of topics here
[00:03:27.001]that deal with parental responsiveness
[00:03:29.135]to infant and baby-holding.
[00:03:31.076]For example, we find that in many societies
[00:03:34.052]children are held a lot more,
[00:03:36.091]especially in tribal societies than in modern societies.
[00:03:39.910]Looking at parent-child play.
[00:03:42.110]In our society, for example, we emphasize that.
[00:03:44.915]In many, many other societies
[00:03:46.269]parent-child play is not emphasized.
[00:03:48.563]In fact, children spend more time playing
[00:03:51.083]with other children and not their parents.
[00:03:54.027]And then there's parental acceptance
[00:03:56.272]and rejection of children.
[00:03:59.121]Depending on whether they're engaged
[00:04:01.187]or whether they are kind of cold and aloof,
[00:04:04.757]the research of the Rohners is exemplified
[00:04:09.686]in a section in the text.
[00:04:11.497]And then parents attitudes towards
[00:04:13.681]compliance or assertiveness in that
[00:04:17.002]are children expected to behave
[00:04:20.197]or to kind of be independent and assertive?
[00:04:23.374]And there are different attitudes
[00:04:24.276]towards aggression in some societies.
[00:04:28.245]Aggression is not put down by parents.
[00:04:32.970]In other societies parents use aggression
[00:04:35.074]to stop aggression, which actually leads
[00:04:37.078]to more aggression later in life.
[00:04:39.300]And then task assignment in terms of
[00:04:41.636]in many, many societies children
[00:04:43.781]are put to work very early.
[00:04:45.988]That is they are responsible
[00:04:47.474]for a care of a younger sibling,
[00:04:50.464]gathering water, and helping out around the house.
[00:04:54.572]And then also there's a great variation
[00:04:56.849]in the kinds of settings that children have.
[00:04:59.465]In Western societies, they're in houses or other structures.
[00:05:03.870]In many, many societies throughout most of human history,
[00:05:08.072]time outdoors is the predominant kind of location
[00:05:11.136]where children learn and grow.
[00:05:15.439]If we look at psychological variation in adulthood,
[00:05:19.216]one of the more studied areas have been concepts of self.
[00:05:23.118]So many anthropologists have concluded
[00:05:24.793]that the concept of self in many non-Western
[00:05:27.030]societies is quite different from Western
[00:05:30.507]conception of the self.
[00:05:32.043]In general, those from the west
[00:05:33.537]tend to be individualistic,
[00:05:35.403]while those from the east tend to be collectivistic
[00:05:38.250]and the text spends some time dealing
[00:05:40.183]with the research on this topic.
[00:05:43.698]Another topic in psychological variation
[00:05:45.614]in adulthood is perceptual style.
[00:05:48.514]That is differences in field independence or dependence.
[00:05:52.246]And here we're talking about cognitive differences.
[00:05:56.825]They ask might the environment influence
[00:05:58.663]the way people in different societies think and perceive?
[00:06:01.729]And they bring up the issue of field independence,
[00:06:03.803]being able to isolate a part of a situation from the whole,
[00:06:07.890]or field dependence, parts are not perceived separately,
[00:06:12.511]rather the whole situation is focused on.
[00:06:14.594]So people have different cognitive abilities
[00:06:17.407]depending on the kind of environment in which they live.
[00:06:19.594]And what was found by a number of researchers, for example,
[00:06:22.335]is that in hunting and gathering societies,
[00:06:25.987]a field independence is very important
[00:06:28.739]because one has to be able to pick out game
[00:06:33.835]and other resources in a complex kind of environment.
[00:06:38.481]Although they don't give you much information
[00:06:41.216]on some of the tests used,
[00:06:43.024]the frame and rod test in the next slide
[00:06:47.592]will show you what that actually looks like.
[00:06:51.243]I pasted this in the slide set to show you
[00:06:55.507]what the rod and frame test actually looked like.
[00:06:58.655]And it's the ability to,
[00:07:00.601]you see those rods standing up,
[00:07:02.195]the ability to note whether they're vertical
[00:07:05.803]or slightly altered in a frame
[00:07:11.129]and your ability to perceive straightness
[00:07:16.107]will be a test of your field independence.
[00:07:18.978]People who are field dependent
[00:07:20.989]will tend to look at the frame
[00:07:23.418]and see and orient the rod in it
[00:07:26.548]and not be able to tell whether
[00:07:27.784]it's actually absolutely straight up
[00:07:30.183]or tilted one way or the other.
[00:07:32.757]Now if we turn to the topic of expression of aggression.
[00:07:35.712]Societies vary markedly in the degree
[00:07:37.433]to which adults express anger
[00:07:39.174]and act aggressively towards others.
[00:07:43.061]In farming communities, for example,
[00:07:45.047]it was suggested by Edgerton
[00:07:47.170]that farmers tend to hold their emotions close.
[00:07:51.630]They tend not to blow up or express their anger
[00:07:55.189]or indeed even happiness towards others.
[00:07:57.495]They want to have dependent relationships.
[00:08:00.884]But on the other hand, he found that pastoralists
[00:08:03.268]were more willing than farmers
[00:08:05.121]to express aggression openly.
[00:08:08.461]It's hard to tell what this is a consequence of,
[00:08:11.110]but it may the fact that in general
[00:08:13.635]pastoralists are much more war-like than farmers.
[00:08:19.045]This is just a kind of illustrated example
[00:08:20.918]of a very aggressive society, the Yanomamo,
[00:08:23.896]a group that I studied.
[00:08:24.791]And here we have two men facing off in a crowd,
[00:08:28.960]doing a chest pounding duel.
[00:08:32.125]The receiver of the blow stands with his chest out
[00:08:35.717]and the person who's gonna deliver the blow
[00:08:39.260]is all wound up and he's gonna strike
[00:08:41.534]in a ram blow across the heart.
[00:08:44.102]And this is in contrast to the kinda peaceful life
[00:08:46.736]we see among the Pygmy, a very relaxed kinda family life,
[00:08:51.410]children being cared for by men and women
[00:08:54.579]and a very kind of relaxed attitude.
[00:08:56.561]This is in direct, and what's also significant
[00:09:00.352]is that the Pygmy have very low levels of violence,
[00:09:03.036]where the Yanomamo have very high levels of violence.
[00:09:08.008]In the box on page 167,
[00:09:10.438]the question of gender differences in morality is asked.
[00:09:13.838]Are women more concerned with compassion,
[00:09:15.896]sensitivity to others, and affection?
[00:09:19.150]While men are more concerned with following rules
[00:09:21.604]and impartiality, as Gilligan suggests?
[00:09:25.644]There's some evidence for these differences,
[00:09:27.359]but even though men and women feel differently
[00:09:30.909]in these dimensions, there's no evidence
[00:09:33.418]that they seem to affect their moral behavior.
[00:09:39.176]Sometimes we want to focus on psychological
[00:09:41.328]explanations of cultural variation,
[00:09:43.832]that is do the psychology people
[00:09:46.564]somehow color and affect the nature of the culture?
[00:09:49.256]So psychological anthropologists are interested
[00:09:51.786]in the possible causes of psychological differences
[00:09:54.392]between societies, as well as the possible
[00:09:57.144]consequences of psychological variation.
[00:10:00.852]Again, some research has been done in this area,
[00:10:04.339]but it's really a very interesting question
[00:10:07.377]and we just have at this point
[00:10:08.843]some more tantalizing questions than good solid conclusion.
[00:10:14.064]One approach to, explanations of cultural variation
[00:10:18.651]stem from the work of Adam Kardiner,
[00:10:21.078]who suggested that cultural patterns
[00:10:23.110]influence personality development,
[00:10:25.131]and that the resulting personality
[00:10:26.584]characteristics influence culture.
[00:10:29.595]So we have primary institutions
[00:10:31.420]that have to do with how we adapt to the environment,
[00:10:34.535]how we procure our food.
[00:10:36.353]And then this leads to secondary institutions,
[00:10:40.098]which are social institutions,
[00:10:41.465]like family, marriage, and kinship,
[00:10:43.774]and trying to figure out how personality
[00:10:47.059]and psychology affect the structure
[00:10:50.691]of these institutions and vice versa.
[00:10:54.409]Other researchers have kind of taken Kardiner's
[00:10:57.101]approach to heart and look at the personality
[00:10:59.440]integration of culture, which refers to the possibility
[00:11:02.337]that an understanding of personality
[00:11:04.159]might help us explain connections
[00:11:06.710]between primary and secondary institutions.
[00:11:10.291]If you look at individuals as agents of cultural change,
[00:11:13.883]and here the focus is on how
[00:11:15.802]individuals can change cultures,
[00:11:18.314]ethnographers are focusing more explicitly now
[00:11:21.249]on how individual agency,
[00:11:24.004]that is the ability of individuals
[00:11:26.155]to act on their own and follow their own desires,
[00:11:29.465]may bring about cultural change,
[00:11:31.879]especially when groups of individuals
[00:11:35.224]work together to create change.

The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!

You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.

Comments

0 Comments

Chap 3 ANTH 212

Description

Searchable Transcript

Comments icon comment

Related Channels

Comments