Reading Comprehension in ASD: The Intersection of Language, Social Competence, and Reading

Christi Carnahan Author

09/19/2016 Added

378 Plays

Description

This webinar will discuss the following: Social communication, reading, and writing What is reading comprehension? Reading profiles in ASD Big ideas in reading comprehension

Searchable Transcript

Search:

[00:00:00.610]Good afternoon, I'm Christy Carnahan
[00:00:03.126]and I'm excited to be here today alongside my good friend
[00:00:06.511]and colleague, Pam Williamson.
[00:00:08.232]Pam's background is in the area of reading
[00:00:10.777]and special education.
[00:00:12.612]My background is in the area of special education
[00:00:16.435]and specifically, meeting the needs of individuals
[00:00:20.407]with significant communication, sensory
[00:00:22.778]and behavioral challenges.
[00:00:24.507]Today we're going to talk about our work
[00:00:27.175]which we've been connecting for the last 10 years or so.
[00:00:31.829]And really around the literacy needs
[00:00:37.365]of individuals with autism spectrum disorder.
[00:00:41.031]We are both passionate about meeting the needs
[00:00:44.005]of these individuals in the area of literacy
[00:00:47.442]and really building literacy, not only as a functional skill
[00:00:51.351]that's important in school, but as a life skill
[00:00:54.991]that is about communication in engaging and sharing
[00:01:01.982]and gaining information from others.
[00:01:07.596]We're excited to be here with you today
[00:01:09.892]and we look forward to hearing your questions
[00:01:11.415]at the end of the session.
[00:01:16.897]Today is the first in a two part series
[00:01:19.219]on literacy for learners with autism spectrum disorder.
[00:01:22.824]Before we begin, we would like to take a few minutes
[00:01:25.993]to discuss the lens with which
[00:01:27.883]we approach and view literacy.
[00:01:30.335]Literacy is not something for which an individual
[00:01:33.064]needs to be ready, rather, literacy refers to
[00:01:36.526]the shared interactions through which we gain or receive
[00:01:39.983]and share information.
[00:01:41.664]At its core, literacy is an essential part
[00:01:44.568]of the human experience.
[00:01:46.371]We believe that all individuals, and we mean all,
[00:01:49.874]no matter their perceived level of functioning
[00:01:52.992]are capable of engaging in literacy experiences.
[00:01:56.720]For the remainder of this section, we will discuss
[00:01:59.728]the social communication, reading and writing needs
[00:02:05.104]of individuals with autism spectrum disorder,
[00:02:08.673]specifically the inner section of cognition in autism
[00:02:12.894]and reading comprehension.
[00:02:17.138]We will discuss the specific aspects
[00:02:19.747]of reading comprehension and what it means
[00:02:22.084]to read with comprehension.
[00:02:23.834]We will then talk about reading profiles in ASD
[00:02:27.204]and lastly and with a brief introduction into some
[00:02:30.948]big ideas in teaching reading comprehension
[00:02:34.254]to individuals with autism spectrum disorder.
[00:02:39.312]As we mentioned,
[00:02:41.345]literacy is a uniquely social experience.
[00:02:44.637]Not only do we engage in social interactions with others
[00:02:47.799]through literacy, but through our social interactions
[00:02:50.528]we develop literacy skills.
[00:02:52.696]From just a few weeks of age,
[00:02:54.804]infants begin to engage in shared experiences with others.
[00:02:58.336]Through these shared experiences,
[00:03:00.419]they develop an understanding
[00:03:02.010]of complex communication exchanges
[00:03:04.164]and begin to understand how people direct their own
[00:03:07.429]and other's attention and behavior.
[00:03:10.181]One critical skill that develops early,
[00:03:13.290]is the ability to match the word someone uses
[00:03:16.085]with the referent or object to which the word refers.
[00:03:19.624]By coordinating our attention with an individual's words,
[00:03:23.265]we begin to develop sophisticated understandings
[00:03:25.946]of how things work and the language and vocabulary
[00:03:29.700]to describe many different things in our environment.
[00:03:33.383]When we share our attention with others,
[00:03:35.855]we also come to understand how conversations
[00:03:38.969]and shared interactions work.
[00:03:41.124]Think of a young child, for example,
[00:03:43.613]who hears an airplane.
[00:03:45.321]The child often stops or pauses, looks at an adult,
[00:03:49.410]looks to the sky while pointing
[00:03:52.053]and then shifts their gaze back and forth.
[00:03:55.790]This sets the stage for sharing nuance turn taking
[00:04:00.010]and eventually, sophisticated conversations.
[00:04:04.062]These social exchanges provide lots of opportunity
[00:04:07.963]to practice directing our attention,
[00:04:11.025]shifting between one activity or topic and another,
[00:04:15.163]making and executing plans
[00:04:17.357]and self-monitoring our own behavior.
[00:04:20.396]A complex set of skills often described
[00:04:23.489]as executive function.
[00:04:25.883]Essentially, when children jointly engage
[00:04:28.815]with others, they are developing critical skills
[00:04:31.949]for social communication and conventional literacy
[00:04:34.658]or reading and writing.
[00:04:36.362]At its heart, however, autism is marked by differences
[00:04:40.292]in social communication and to an extent,
[00:04:43.008]executive function.
[00:04:44.618]Both which are likely linked
[00:04:46.605]to how they direct their attention.
[00:04:49.042]Let's talk for a minute about the differences
[00:04:51.694]individuals with ASD experience in each of these areas.
[00:04:57.535]First, in the area of language,
[00:05:00.124]individuals may experience is different
[00:05:03.365]in how they learn words.
[00:05:06.799]Difficulty understanding multiple meanings of words
[00:05:09.693]and interpreting figurative language.
[00:05:12.569]Some students with autism may learn nouns before words,
[00:05:16.356]such as ball before throw and also have difficulty
[00:05:19.484]assigning more than one meaning to an individual word.
[00:05:23.435]Once a student learns the meaning of a word
[00:05:27.529]to mean something specific, he may forever know the word
[00:05:30.990]to only represent that one meaning.
[00:05:33.630]For example, if a student learns the word foot
[00:05:36.449]to mean a body part, he may have difficulty also assigning
[00:05:40.013]the word additional meaning such as a measurement
[00:05:43.269]or 12 inches or using the word in a phrase such as
[00:05:47.369]the foot of the bed.
[00:05:48.855]Individuals with ASD may also have difficulty interpreting
[00:05:52.686]and using figurative language such as idioms and similes
[00:05:56.404]and needs someone to provide specific and direct
[00:05:59.918]or discreet instruction in the meaning of each of these,
[00:06:03.880]of very specific kind phrases
[00:06:06.495]and these different figures of speech.
[00:06:09.596]Language is directly related
[00:06:11.662]to reading comprehension on several levels.
[00:06:14.527]In order to understand a text,
[00:06:16.669]and individual must not be only be able
[00:06:19.299]to decode the words on the page
[00:06:21.232]but also understand the meaning of those words
[00:06:23.862]which is essential.
[00:06:25.386]When individuals begin to read and write,
[00:06:28.395]their language skills form the base
[00:06:30.534]of what they will understand.
[00:06:32.600]Eventually, and importantly however,
[00:06:35.123]students' understanding in knowledge
[00:06:37.694]grows through their reading and writing.
[00:06:40.218]Essentially, the shift from using their knowledge
[00:06:44.195]to read and write, to using reading and writing
[00:06:47.358]to expand their vocabulary and conceptual knowledge.
[00:06:54.689]In addition to language,
[00:06:56.589]individuals with autism also demonstrate differences
[00:06:59.588]in the area of executive function
[00:07:01.711]that impact her reading comprehension.
[00:07:04.272]These learners often have difficulty knowing
[00:07:07.153]where to direct their attention,
[00:07:09.071]when or how to shift from one topic or activity to another
[00:07:13.076]in monitoring their on-task behavior,
[00:07:15.990]These attention setting and shifting differences
[00:07:19.420]and difficulty self-monitoring, all combine
[00:07:22.599]with language differences increase the complexity
[00:07:25.936]of learning challenges many individuals face
[00:07:28.939]both academically and socially.
[00:07:31.464]Specifically when reading, our executive function skills
[00:07:35.419]allow us to direct our attention to the text at hand.
[00:07:38.709]Use cues such as the title and picture to make predictions
[00:07:42.542]and set our purpose and then to monitor both our attention
[00:07:46.816]and understanding as we read.
[00:07:51.542]If you've ever had to stop reading to go back
[00:07:54.736]and read again because you realize you read
[00:07:57.492]several sentences or even paragraphs without attending,
[00:08:00.595]you've experienced your executive functions skills at work.
[00:08:04.722]We previously mentioned the social communication differences
[00:08:08.936]individuals with ASD encounter.
[00:08:11.597]These are often discussed under the umbrella term,
[00:08:15.284]"a theory of mind."
[00:08:16.850]Theory of mind, refers to a understanding
[00:08:19.646]that we all have different perspectives
[00:08:21.814]and our perspectives drive our behavior.
[00:08:24.740]In the past few years, (clears throat)
[00:08:28.552]the discussion regarding the role
[00:08:30.123]of theory of mind in Autism has shifted.
[00:08:33.101]Traditionally, individuals with ASD were described
[00:08:36.495]as not understanding different perspectives.
[00:08:39.274]However, it's becoming clear that these individuals
[00:08:43.077]with autism have different levels of theory of mind
[00:08:46.675]and that their individual language
[00:08:48.800]and attentional differences influence these skills.
[00:08:52.391]To say it another way, autism is a spectrum
[00:08:55.630]and it's likely, theory of mind skills
[00:08:58.570]vary across the spectrum.
[00:09:01.035]Recently, there has been discussion that both language
[00:09:04.317]and executive function skills interact with theory of mind
[00:09:08.174]to influence both social skills and reading comprehension
[00:09:12.563]for individuals with ASD.
[00:09:15.550]Our hypothesis is, yes and yes.
[00:09:19.140]There is likely an interaction,
[00:09:21.079]but the degree of the influence and the kind of influence
[00:09:24.449]likely vary from person to person.
[00:09:27.272]This is a lot of information,
[00:09:29.650]and it can be really complicated,
[00:09:32.122]so to summarize, early joint attention sets the stage
[00:09:36.224]and supports the development of both
[00:09:38.697]early executive function and vocabulary skills.
[00:09:42.196]These executive function and vocabulary skills
[00:09:45.289]are directly related to social communication
[00:09:48.084]or theory of mind and reading comprehension.
[00:09:51.755]Thus, the language and vocabulary differences
[00:09:55.041]combined with social communication
[00:09:57.046]and/or perspective taking differences
[00:09:59.155]all influence how an individual with autism
[00:10:01.579]will comprehend written text.
[00:10:03.798]Moving from decoding words on a page
[00:10:06.422]to actually understanding what we read
[00:10:08.868]required a sophisticated interaction
[00:10:11.235]between knowing the words, what the words mean,
[00:10:14.014]understanding perspectives of the writer or character
[00:10:17.367]and managing our own attention
[00:10:19.622]which are all complex processings.
[00:10:22.387]Especially for readers with ASD.
[00:10:24.915]On the next slide, we're going to begin talking in detail
[00:10:28.625]about what it means to really read with comprehension.
[00:10:36.426]Reading comprehension is about more
[00:10:39.324]than decoding words on a page.
[00:10:41.645]When we read, we read for meaning
[00:10:44.221]which involves decoding the words,
[00:10:46.392]understanding their meaning
[00:10:48.107]and activating relevant background knowledge.
[00:10:51.033]To put it another way, when we read,
[00:10:53.950]we take our understanding of the words on the page
[00:10:57.032]and integrate it with what we already know
[00:10:59.891]about the topic or our existing experiences.
[00:11:04.595]This information then either
[00:11:06.789]affirms our current understanding
[00:11:09.156]or helps us to develop new knowledge.
[00:11:11.793]Let's take a minute to look a bit deeper at this process.
[00:11:15.887]We view reading from a theoretical model termed
[00:11:19.572]as the construction integration model.
[00:11:22.600]In this model, there are two levels to comprehension
[00:11:26.485]including first understanding the words on the page
[00:11:29.846]and then integrating this understanding with what you know,
[00:11:33.773]making inferences and incorporating
[00:11:36.525]your social understanding.
[00:11:38.346]The first level of understanding is called the Text Base.
[00:11:42.247]When we use the term, construct an accurate text base,
[00:11:46.103]we mean that an individual actually understands the words
[00:11:50.275]written on the page.
[00:11:52.782]For example, if we read, the girl went to the mall,
[00:11:56.718]she bought shoes there.
[00:11:58.660]The text base refers to the actually word such as
[00:12:02.578]girl, went, mall and shoes.
[00:12:06.175]However, to develop a deep understanding,
[00:12:09.256]we have to activate our knowledge related to shopping,
[00:12:12.573]malls and purchasing.
[00:12:14.392]We bring both our understanding of the words together
[00:12:18.293]with our knowledge of these key concepts
[00:12:20.978]to make inferences that vary in complexity.
[00:12:23.991]For example, we infer that girl and she are the same.
[00:12:28.345]And that mall and there are the same.
[00:12:31.241]On a much deeper level, we use our understanding
[00:12:34.722]of the words and concepts to make inferences
[00:12:37.957]that a mall is a place where you can shop
[00:12:40.648]and thus, the girl bought shoes at the mall.
[00:12:44.145]Even though the author does not ever explicitly
[00:12:47.974]make this direct statement.
[00:12:51.551]In addition to understanding the words
[00:12:54.675]and using background knowledge,
[00:12:57.000]our social skills influence our comprehension.
[00:13:00.478]Our social skills help us recognize the feelings
[00:13:04.264]and perspective of characters and inform our understanding
[00:13:07.982]of our text.
[00:13:09.412]Together, our language, social and executive function skills
[00:13:13.614]all influence how we comprehend a story.
[00:13:21.871]Let's now return to our example,
[00:13:24.856]the girl went to the mall, she bought shoes there.
[00:13:27.572]But add a few additional lines.
[00:13:29.473]She called her friend with excitement,
[00:13:31.116]they are both having trouble waiting until Friday.
[00:13:34.289]We draw on our social understanding to understand
[00:13:37.572]that someone might be happy to have new shoes
[00:13:40.378]and want to share this with a friend.
[00:13:42.630]Then integrating our understanding of the words on the page
[00:13:45.650]our knowledge of the girls' perspective
[00:13:48.332]and our own experiences about buying shoes
[00:13:51.826]for a special occasion, we make a prediction.
[00:13:55.283]They have a special event on Friday night
[00:13:58.197]and are really looking forward to it.
[00:14:02.689]Well, social skills, executive function and language
[00:14:05.630]and vocabulary are all important to this comprehension.
[00:14:09.590]It may be helpful to know that students
[00:14:12.492]with stronger vocabulary and language skills
[00:14:14.825]will often have better or deeper comprehension.
[00:14:18.607]Let's bring it all together.
[00:14:21.645]Students with autism often have significant differences
[00:14:24.920]in language and vocabulary skills,
[00:14:27.190]how they understand the perspectives of others,
[00:14:30.101]and their to activate and integrate
[00:14:32.766]relevant background knowledge while reading.
[00:14:35.829]This is especially true in the realities
[00:14:38.408]of our daily classroom lives when environments are busy,
[00:14:42.088]distractions are plentiful and many things compete
[00:14:45.504]for our attention.
[00:14:46.907]So when language demands are high, text is complex
[00:14:50.635]and situations are dynamic,
[00:14:52.638]such as our typical classroom settings,
[00:14:54.781]students with autism who otherwise appear to have
[00:14:57.607]high language, theory of mind or executive function skills,
[00:15:01.189]often demonstrate significant challenges
[00:15:03.876]with reading comprehension.
[00:15:05.862]To say it another way, though individual students
[00:15:09.417]may have strong skills in some or all of these areas,
[00:15:12.860]when we present them with complex reading assignments
[00:15:16.004]in our busy classrooms, they may need a great deal
[00:15:21.182]of support to be successful.
[00:15:23.561]About five years ago, we started studying
[00:15:26.776]how individuals with autism approach
[00:15:29.159]and comprehend written text.
[00:15:31.319]On the next slides, we'll take a look at these profiles
[00:15:34.956]beginning to emerge.
[00:15:38.441]You won't be surprised to hear
[00:15:40.668]that how individuals with autism approach text
[00:15:43.619]varies across a continuum.
[00:15:46.444]Some individuals whom we refer to as strategic comprehenders
[00:15:50.558]use strategies that are often described
[00:15:53.331]as good reader behaviors while reading.
[00:15:56.422]These behaviors include strategies such as connecting
[00:15:59.859]to previous experiences
[00:16:01.760]and questioning the text while reading.
[00:16:04.857]For example, while reading a text about Halloween,
[00:16:08.743]a student we know, vocalized the question,
[00:16:11.301]"I wonder how long ago this story actually means."
[00:16:14.899]The student who falls in the strategic profile
[00:16:18.370]often develop and accurate understanding of the words
[00:16:22.045]on the page and integrate their background knowledge.
[00:16:25.896]So, we say they have developed an accurate situation model
[00:16:30.162]or overall understanding of the text.
[00:16:34.183]However, the special interest these learners have
[00:16:37.989]may overshadow or distract them from comprehending the text.
[00:16:42.106]For example, the same student we just described
[00:16:45.513]often linked the stories he read
[00:16:47.987]to his special interests, the Titanic.
[00:16:50.876]He made connections between the text and Titanic,
[00:16:54.744]that while they were plausible, also distracted him
[00:16:58.675]from thinking about comprehending the text.
[00:17:03.144]For these students, it is important to focus on activating
[00:17:06.915]relevant background knowledge
[00:17:08.890]while directing their attention to apply comprehension
[00:17:12.296]strategies in the context of the text.
[00:17:17.611]Students who tend towards the text bound profile,
[00:17:20.578]are those learners who overly focus on the words on the page
[00:17:24.552]without activating or integrating any background knowledge.
[00:17:29.820]They tend to be learners who repeat the last word they hear,
[00:17:33.573]specific phrases from a sentence
[00:17:36.532]or even repeat back exact words from the question,
[00:17:41.558]often without actually answering the question.
[00:17:45.424]For these learners, it is essential to support them
[00:17:49.011]in thinking about what they know
[00:17:50.979]before beginning instruction.
[00:17:54.140]This not only helps them prepare to integrate
[00:17:56.919]their existing knowledge and experiences
[00:17:59.391]but also elicits language related to the topic.
[00:18:03.300]By activating both conceptual knowledge
[00:18:06.461]and the related language,
[00:18:09.047]it is possible students will make more connections,
[00:18:12.984]demonstrate deeper understanding,
[00:18:15.570]and be able to share these connections
[00:18:18.374]and understanding with others to demonstrate comprehension.
[00:18:23.632]When working with students who appear to be text bound,
[00:18:27.037]you might use visuals such as pictures or photographs,
[00:18:31.474]written reminders, or a combination
[00:18:34.405]to begin talking about the related conceptual knowledge.
[00:18:39.722]Then, while reading, you may need to literally show them
[00:18:43.981]the connections by referring to the pictures
[00:18:47.386]and describing the connections.
[00:18:50.748]On the other side of the continuum, however,
[00:18:54.285]are learners who tend towards the imaginative.
[00:18:58.221]They often overemphasize or focus on their prior knowledge
[00:19:02.313]and experiences to such and extent that they can turn
[00:19:06.695]any text into a related story.
[00:19:09.977]Often, these students answer questions
[00:19:12.457]based on their special interest area or previous experiences
[00:19:16.603]rather than what is actually in the text.
[00:19:21.251]For these students, it is essential to continually
[00:19:24.284]direct them back to the text.
[00:19:27.078]You might talk about their prior knowledge and experiences
[00:19:30.620]before beginning to read but then give them a list
[00:19:33.477]in writing, pictures or a combination
[00:19:36.177]of things that are related and can be used
[00:19:38.842]for connections and those that are not related and
[00:19:41.916]that are going to be the we-can-talk-about-it-later list.
[00:19:48.130]As students read, you may need to even say,
[00:19:51.511]"That's not in the text,
[00:19:53.401]we're not talking about that right now."
[00:19:56.422]For teachers with lots of experience teaching reading,
[00:19:59.997]this can feel uncomfortable.
[00:20:01.994]We want students to make connections.
[00:20:04.503]But it's important to remember that for students
[00:20:08.082]who tent towards the imaginative,
[00:20:10.555]these connections are distracting and actually decrease
[00:20:14.543]students' learning and comprehension.
[00:20:17.560]Let's take a minute now to begin thinking about
[00:20:20.923]some of the students you know.
[00:20:24.676]Chose and individual,
[00:20:26.486]a young boy or a girl from your classroom
[00:20:29.667]and go ahead and write his or her name down
[00:20:32.514]on a piece of paper.
[00:20:39.771]Now that you've identified a learner,
[00:20:42.607]let's start by asking you to answer this question.
[00:20:46.714]Which profile might this student fall into?
[00:20:51.419]Think about that.
[00:20:52.688]Think about what you know about each of the profiles
[00:20:55.241]for just a minute, then identify the profile
[00:20:58.333]with which this student might closely align.
[00:21:04.004]Add that profile under the student's name on your page.
[00:21:12.285]Now, an even deeper question.
[00:21:16.152]What is your evidence that that student
[00:21:18.303]might fall into that profile?
[00:21:20.954]I'm going to pause here for just a minute
[00:21:23.278]and ask you to write down some specific details
[00:21:27.945]or data that support why you added,
[00:21:32.105]why you believe that student falls into that profile.
[00:21:53.400]As you're writing, try to recall some specific examples.
[00:21:59.748]Add those examples to your sheet.
[00:22:34.363]Now think instructionally.
[00:22:37.585]What does that student need you to do?
[00:22:41.367]Is this a learner who needs access
[00:22:43.185]to more background knowledge and related vocabulary?
[00:22:47.324]Is this a kiddo who really has a good deal
[00:22:50.387]of relevant background knowledge but might need help
[00:22:53.593]applying that as he or she applies a specific
[00:22:58.114]reading comprehension strategy?
[00:23:01.902]Is this a learner who needs you to glue them to the text?
[00:23:06.775]Who might get too far off without you constantly saying,
[00:23:10.922]we're only talking about what's in the text?
[00:23:15.642]Make yourself some notes about the specific strategy
[00:23:19.589]or approach you might need to apply with this learner.
[00:23:25.037]I'll give you another minute to think that through.
[00:24:14.787]You have about 20 seconds left,
[00:24:17.297]so please take a minute to wrap up your thoughts.
[00:24:34.436]Now, before we move on,
[00:24:39.586]let's just do a brief summary.
[00:24:42.581]We started by talking about some of the factors
[00:24:44.976]that make up the cognitive profile that we see
[00:24:48.589]in many individuals with autism.
[00:24:51.260]We talked about the role of early engagement,
[00:24:53.901]enjoying attention.
[00:24:55.312]We talked about executive function, theory of mind,
[00:24:59.073]and other social competence.
[00:25:05.183]And we talked about those in the context
[00:25:08.129]of social communication.
[00:25:10.331]We also discussed the process of reading comprehension
[00:25:13.442]that requires us to both know the words on the page
[00:25:16.977]and activate our background knowledge
[00:25:19.482]so that we can develop an accurate situation model
[00:25:23.139]or overall understanding of the text.
[00:25:26.729]Then, we talked about the different reading profiles,
[00:25:30.126]including the strategic, the text bound and the imaginative.
[00:25:35.751]And we briefly discussed ways you might tailor
[00:25:38.745]your instruction to help students either
[00:25:41.019]increase their level of background knowledge,
[00:25:43.578]more closely focus on the text,
[00:25:46.215]or apply what they know in the context of the reading
[00:25:50.211]comprehensions strategies they're already using.
[00:25:55.713]Let's now shift our focus briefly
[00:25:58.365]to begin thinking about some big ideas
[00:26:01.373]in reading instruction that will support comprehension
[00:26:04.689]and hopefully also the ongoing the development of language
[00:26:09.845]and vocabulary and social communication skills.
[00:26:16.412]Given the complexities of reading comprehension
[00:26:19.434]for learners with autism, especially given the critical role
[00:26:23.218]of language, social communication and cognition
[00:26:26.609]and executive function and the fact that differences
[00:26:29.970]in each of these areas are essentially markers of autism,
[00:26:33.923]it isn't surprising that supporting reading comprehension
[00:26:38.025]for learners with autism can be challenging.
[00:26:41.377]However, despite these challenges,
[00:26:43.858]the work of supporting reading comprehension
[00:26:46.497]is both fun and rewarding.
[00:26:48.637]We've seen literacy instruction and more specifically,
[00:26:52.021]instruction in the area of reading comprehension,
[00:26:55.275]literally change lives.
[00:26:58.228]Remember, when you're addressing the literacy needs
[00:27:01.518]of individuals with autism, you aren't just preparing them
[00:27:04.968]to do well in school, instead, you're trying to make
[00:27:08.137]a significant impact on the quality of the lives.
[00:27:11.916]Perhaps the most important thing you hear
[00:27:14.300]from this entire session, is that individuals with autism
[00:27:17.838]need literacy and need quality literacy instruction
[00:27:21.669]every day no matter their perceived level of functioning.
[00:27:26.691]So, we mean all learners,
[00:27:28.818]even those with the most challenging communication,
[00:27:32.884]sensory or behavioral differences must have
[00:27:36.290]quality literacy instruction every single day.
[00:27:42.080]I'd like to take a minute to tell you a story
[00:27:44.431]about a young man I worked with just this week.
[00:27:47.574]His name is Paul and he is 19 years old.
[00:27:50.351]Paul has significant communication and sensory challenges.
[00:27:54.401]He's been moved from school to school
[00:27:56.729]but finally settled in a classroom
[00:27:58.740]where teachers care about and want to support him.
[00:28:01.734]However, because of how Paul presents,
[00:28:04.792]it is often hard to see how much he's actually capable of.
[00:28:09.677]He's a big guy and his physical looks
[00:28:12.307]can be a bit intimidating, to say the least.
[00:28:15.610]He walks around his environment humming and singing songs
[00:28:19.361]though it's difficult to actually understand
[00:28:22.055]any words he is saying.
[00:28:23.910]Though I've known Paul for a while,
[00:28:26.243]his teacher mentioned this week that he likes to watch
[00:28:29.110]Meet The Press on the web.
[00:28:31.061]Hearing this set me into motion.
[00:28:33.393]I couldn't help myself.
[00:28:35.103]I Googled several different election websites,
[00:28:38.222]found a YouTube video about the election
[00:28:40.930]and selected a recent Meet The Press episode
[00:28:43.910]about the current candidates.
[00:28:46.086]Then, I sat down with Paul to work.
[00:28:48.514]Keep in mind, my materials weren't pretty, at all.
[00:28:53.541]I literally spent 10 minutes
[00:28:55.552]getting things together, that's it.
[00:28:57.886]I used torn pieces of paper for my vocabulary.
[00:29:01.078]A marker and dry-erase board to write our schedule
[00:29:04.756]and had a stack of paper next to me
[00:29:07.259]for any choices I might ask.
[00:29:10.296]When I sat down with Paul, the classroom was loud.
[00:29:14.101]People were transitioning from lunch,
[00:29:15.947]one student was singing in the background.
[00:29:18.281]I honestly, almost abandoned the lesson,
[00:29:20.789]thinking there is no way this guy is going to focus
[00:29:23.642]on these materials in this setting right now.
[00:29:27.327]But I didn't want to walk away so fast,
[00:29:30.584]so I started the lesson with a brief YouTube video.
[00:29:34.318]It took a few minutes but then Paul really focused.
[00:29:37.957]After the video, I introduced some election words.
[00:29:40.924]I wrote the words on a piece of paper
[00:29:43.156]and then had the matching definitions on another.
[00:29:46.597]So, I told Paul, I'm going to ask you what each
[00:29:50.150]of these words means so that I don't insult you
[00:29:53.454]by teaching yo8u something you already know.
[00:29:57.587]Guess what, when I presented him with a definition
[00:30:00.497]and three choices for which the word matched the definition,
[00:30:03.954]he already knew all of them.
[00:30:06.491]Here's the thing, I wouldn't have known
[00:30:09.545]that he knew them all if I didn't change
[00:30:11.704]the way I presented the materials.
[00:30:13.851]I read the definition, then wrote three choices
[00:30:16.809]on a piece of paper. I then held the paper
[00:30:19.422]above Paul's line of vision.
[00:30:21.354]Imagine someone rolling their eyes,
[00:30:23.461]at the top of the roll is where I held the paper.
[00:30:26.812]If I'd sat those materials on the table,
[00:30:29.059]Paul wouldn't have even had made a choice.
[00:30:33.783]After talking about election related vocabulary,
[00:30:37.293]we switched to the Meet The Press video.
[00:30:40.403]We watched the for a few minutes,
[00:30:42.624]stopping every so often for me to ask a question.
[00:30:45.445]We followed the same process using print materials
[00:30:49.159]that I read aloud to Paul from various websites.
[00:30:52.245]Guess what, Paul answered all
[00:30:54.518]of the factual questions correctly, 100%.
[00:30:59.107]He struggled with the questions that required an inference
[00:31:02.451]or weren't tied directly to what was stated.
[00:31:05.611]But this gave me something to target.
[00:31:07.848]You might find it humorous to hear that I asked Paul twice
[00:31:11.475]who he would vote for, if he was given the chance.
[00:31:14.541]He selected the same name twice,
[00:31:16.648]though I'll keep his personal political views quiet.
[00:31:23.756]Here's the thing, Paul is paying attention,
[00:31:27.880]listening to the materials and is actually comprehending.
[00:31:31.822]Instructional targets seriously needed to change for Paul.
[00:31:36.513]We aren't talking about basic identification anymore,
[00:31:39.927]he needs access to quality materials
[00:31:42.158]that represent sophisticated content
[00:31:44.848]presented in a way in which he can share
[00:31:47.614]what he actually understands.
[00:31:49.934]At the heart of this story is an important message,
[00:31:53.197]many, if not most, individuals with autism
[00:31:56.435]are similar to Paul.
[00:31:58.943]They can absolutely access materials and already comprehend.
[00:32:03.045]They just need us to find a way
[00:32:05.702]for them share and communicate.
[00:32:08.350]On this slide and the next,
[00:32:10.445]we're going to talk about some critical first steps
[00:32:12.599]in creating an environment that will support
[00:32:14.984]an individual like Paul
[00:32:16.687]in communicating their understanding.
[00:32:23.657]When we think about reading comprehension instruction,
[00:32:26.563]we want to start by considering the 27
[00:32:29.509]evidence-based practices for teaching students with autism
[00:32:33.331]that are detailed by
[00:32:34.942]The National Professional Development Center on ASD.
[00:32:38.878]The critical evidence-based approaches
[00:32:41.264]for structuring your reading and other literacy instruction
[00:32:44.851]include task analytic instruction, visual schedules,
[00:32:48.796]reinforcement, and systematic prompting.
[00:32:52.881]You can find detailed information
[00:32:54.884]about teach of these approaches on the website on the slide.
[00:32:59.568]You'll notice that these are not specific to reading.
[00:33:02.999]It is important to remember that evidence-based practices
[00:33:05.895]and evidence-based practice are not the same thing.
[00:33:09.686]Thus, when implementing any evidence-based practice,
[00:33:14.725]you must consider the evidence while also considering
[00:33:17.607]what you know about the individual and the environment.
[00:33:24.938]When evidence-based practice is used as a verb,
[00:33:28.025]it means that we identify and by that I mean,
[00:33:31.631]when we talk about our teaching in an evidence-based way.
[00:33:35.721]It means that we identify the practices
[00:33:38.840]with the most research support for an individual
[00:33:41.992]with similar demographics such as age
[00:33:44.310]to the one we're serving.
[00:33:46.180]We then implement the practice, collecting data
[00:33:49.340]on our fidelity of implementation which means,
[00:33:52.312]did we implement it the way we're supposed to
[00:33:54.480]on a consistent basis and then
[00:33:56.509]on the individual's progress or behavior.
[00:33:59.755]Are we making the necessary gains over time?
[00:34:03.030]If not, we ask questions such as,
[00:34:05.546]did we do it the right way?
[00:34:07.663]Did we target the right skill?
[00:34:09.753]Do we need to teach something else or something additional?
[00:34:13.165]Did we present it in a way the individual can actually use?
[00:34:17.620]Please notice, that almost all of these questions
[00:34:20.832]go back to our or the team's behavior
[00:34:23.818]rather than the individual's.
[00:34:26.231]Currently, there aren't any evidence-based practices
[00:34:30.114]for teaching reading.
[00:34:32.420]This means that you use the existing evidence-based
[00:34:35.489]practices to structure your instruction in the environment
[00:34:38.746]and you turn the head to the research-based practices
[00:34:42.333]in reading that are emerging.
[00:34:45.381]Some of these research-based practices include,
[00:34:47.931]cognitive strategy instruction, grouping approaches
[00:34:51.363]and using explicit instruction to teach targeted skill.
[00:34:55.104]There is emerging work that suggests
[00:34:57.656]one of the most valuable strategies falls under the category
[00:35:01.350]of cognitive strategy instruction.
[00:35:04.108]It is the use of graphic organizers.
[00:35:06.914]We believe graphic organizers are so important
[00:35:10.259]because they support students with autism
[00:35:12.862]in organizing information in their brains
[00:35:15.314]and then systematically teach the students
[00:35:18.761]the language they need to talk about the content.
[00:35:25.194]In addition to incorporating evidence-based practices
[00:35:28.318]and research-based practices,
[00:35:30.174]another critical point is building
[00:35:32.211]on student's special interest in activating
[00:35:34.240]relevant background knowledge.
[00:35:36.139]When we mentioned using an individual's special interest
[00:35:39.851]as the basis for instruction, we often hear a great deal
[00:35:43.638]of groans and see some eye-rolling.
[00:35:48.018]After all, most of us hear about these special interest
[00:35:52.148]from our students all day long.
[00:35:54.714]And even spend a good deal of time trying to get learners
[00:35:57.492]to stop talking about these topics.
[00:36:00.113]However, using an individual's special interest
[00:36:03.291]will actually help you teach reading.
[00:36:05.711]Students are most engaged
[00:36:07.409]when discussing their special interest.
[00:36:09.546]We promise, there is no evidence to suggest
[00:36:12.515]that incorporating an interest into your instruction
[00:36:15.754]will make the interest more intense.
[00:36:18.734]In fact, what you'll find is that these interests
[00:36:21.287]are the best tools for teaching new or challenging material.
[00:36:24.952]You'll see an increase in both the efficiency
[00:36:28.214]and the effectiveness of your instruction.
[00:36:30.776]So, to briefly summarize so far,
[00:36:33.433]we've talked about the need to incorporate
[00:36:36.916]evidence-based practices,
[00:36:38.849]research-based practices,
[00:36:40.898]and lean heavily on the special interest
[00:36:43.998]or motivating topics of the students you teach
[00:36:47.412]who have autism.
[00:36:50.656]Let's finish this conversation
[00:36:52.553]by briefly talking about the need
[00:36:54.356]for a comprehensive approach to instruction.
[00:36:57.168]Perhaps most importantly, it is essential that we approach
[00:37:00.747]our vocabulary, reading and writing
[00:37:03.308]from an integrated perspective.
[00:37:05.905]When we think about instruction,
[00:37:07.705]we can not view vocabulary as isolated
[00:37:10.283]from our reading and writing.
[00:37:12.701]Or reading isolated from writing
[00:37:15.334]and vocabulary or writing as isolated
[00:37:18.413]from vocabulary or reading.
[00:37:20.525]Think back to Paul's lesson,
[00:37:22.449]vocabulary was an integral piece.
[00:37:24.861]In fact, it was the foundation which circles us back
[00:37:28.308]to one of the first ideas on this slide.
[00:37:31.278]All learners must have quality instruction
[00:37:34.421]in the areas of vocabulary, reading and writing,
[00:37:37.895]every single day.
[00:37:41.105]Teaching students with autism to decode words
[00:37:43.948]is far easier than teaching them to understand the meaning
[00:37:47.178]but not nearly as important.
[00:37:49.282]So we must focus our instruction on the much more complex
[00:37:52.443]but important skills of teaching meaning.
[00:37:55.406]Additionally, it is really important to remember
[00:37:58.288]that reading and writing are opposite sides
[00:38:00.753]of the same coin.
[00:38:01.995]When we teach students to read,
[00:38:03.616]they also need to learn to write.
[00:38:06.114]As they develop in one they'll grow in another.
[00:38:08.711]Reading and writing have reciprocal relationship.
[00:38:11.898]We read about what we write
[00:38:13.761]and we write about what we read.
[00:38:15.934]And in the midst or context of both of those,
[00:38:18.767]we're using and learning new vocabulary.
[00:38:25.879]Now that we've discussed some big ideas
[00:38:28.626]to consider as you approach your instruction,
[00:38:31.171]we'd like to take a few minutes to talk
[00:38:33.113]about important components of daily instruction
[00:38:36.026]and your thinking about how you can manage these components.
[00:38:40.053]First, it is essential that we read every day.
[00:38:43.308]This means that students are engaged in reading materials
[00:38:46.583]they select and that the teacher selects each day.
[00:38:50.002]Additionally, it is important students read to themselves,
[00:38:53.242]read to others and listen to others read.
[00:38:56.551]This may require some creative thinking and planning.
[00:39:00.278]For a student who doesn't yet know how to read,
[00:39:03.762]or for whom we're unsure what they can actually read,
[00:39:07.681]we might first systematically teach them how to use books
[00:39:11.373]by incorporating evidence-based practices
[00:39:14.142]such as video models and systematic prompting.
[00:39:17.468]We can also incorporate online books
[00:39:19.924]such as those available from Storyline Online
[00:39:23.242]or Tumble Books to augment the read to self time
[00:39:26.048]during the day.
[00:39:27.946]There are also a variety of strategies for reading aloud
[00:39:31.229]to students across the gray bands.
[00:39:33.371]For individuals with autism,
[00:39:35.197]it is important to choose approaches that emphasize meaning
[00:39:39.080]and support the development of language and vocabulary
[00:39:42.369]which brings us back again to emphasizing the importance
[00:39:46.187]of studying words in context.
[00:39:48.541]Going back to Paul, I now know he understands
[00:39:51.929]basic election vocabulary.
[00:39:54.134]However, the Meet The Press segment
[00:39:56.577]was about transparency in the context of the election.
[00:39:59.859]Paul didn't understand the meaning of the word transparent
[00:40:03.261]and it wasn't explicitly taught in the news clip.
[00:40:06.434]So, this provides the perfect example of how we might teach
[00:40:10.048]complex vocabulary in a very contextualized format.
[00:40:15.151]Lastly, and yep, we're saying it again,
[00:40:18.345]writing is an essential aspect of supporting comprehension
[00:40:22.108]for learners with Autism.
[00:40:23.928]By having students read and write about the same topic,
[00:40:27.098]especially their special interest,
[00:40:29.127]we deepen their comprehension by increasing their engagement
[00:40:33.078]and their attention in learning.
[00:40:36.242]To summarize, we started our session by talking
[00:40:39.152]about the specific cognitive factors
[00:40:41.572]that influence comprehension.
[00:40:43.653]These include early joint engagement and attention
[00:40:47.498]which influences both social cognition, communication,
[00:40:51.539]and vocabulary, our executive function skills
[00:40:55.180]and our vocabulary and oral language knowledge.
[00:41:00.494]It's likely, that differences in each of these areas
[00:41:03.532]will influence comprehension for learners with ASD
[00:41:06.928]and support the development
[00:41:08.861]of the emerging reader profiles in autism.
[00:41:13.988]Understanding about where
[00:41:16.044]on the emerging reading profile continuum,
[00:41:19.495]or as I called it earlier, simply,
[00:41:22.315]the reading profile continuum,
[00:41:24.773]is a critical aspect of building reading comprehension
[00:41:28.891]for your learners.
[00:41:31.234]When you know where they fall,
[00:41:32.873]you can tailor your instruction
[00:41:35.030]to meet their individual needs.
[00:41:37.137]Finally, we ended by discussing some big ideas
[00:41:40.700]related to the importance of quality literacy instruction
[00:41:44.401]for all learners.
[00:41:45.628]Remember, an integrated approach in which students
[00:41:48.866]read, write and study words every single day
[00:41:52.818]is essential for all learners.
[00:41:55.704]Now, in the second webinar, you'll hear lots more
[00:41:59.020]about a framework for instruction to help you move forward
[00:42:02.618]with your individual learners.
[00:42:04.689]As you prepare for the next session,
[00:42:06.780]you might consider gathering some information
[00:42:09.001]about the needs of your students and about where
[00:42:11.836]or which profile they fit.
[00:42:15.218]This will prepare you or help you
[00:42:17.680]to get the most from the second webinar.
[00:42:21.564]We hope this session was valuable
[00:42:24.159]and we look forward to talking with you in webinar two.

The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!

You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.

Comments

0 Comments

Reading Comprehension in ASD: The Intersection of Language, Social Competence, and Reading

Description

Searchable Transcript

Comments icon comment

Related Channels

Comments