Nebraska Legislature - Special Committee - Climate Change Seminar - Animal Science Research Initiatives

Dr. Galen Erickson Author

06/08/2016 Added

202 Plays

Description

Seminar on Climate Change for the Climate Change Seminar for Elected Officials of the Nebraska Legislature - Animal Science Research Initiatives

Searchable Transcript

Search:

[00:00:01.788]So beef cattle are pretty important
[00:00:04.752]to the state of Nebraska
[00:00:06.104]and so I feel blessed to be here
[00:00:07.857]at the University of Nebraska
[00:00:08.963]and beef's a major priority area for us
[00:00:10.832]in terms of research.
[00:00:13.913]In some respects we're interested
[00:00:15.319]in decreasing what's produced by cattle naturally,
[00:00:20.945]quantifying what's produced in our normal systems
[00:00:24.390]and then figuring out ways to increase methane
[00:00:28.755]but using it from manure and bio-gas generation.
[00:00:32.300]So I'm gonna briefly discuss that
[00:00:34.660]but always with pictures
[00:00:36.556]so you don't have to worry to much.
[00:00:38.589](audience laughing)
[00:00:39.769]We've tried some innovative ways.
[00:00:41.794]My background's in nutrition
[00:00:44.169]so I'm interested in how we feed cattle
[00:00:46.335]on managed nutrients that they consume and excrete better,
[00:00:49.513]that's really my interest area.
[00:00:51.918]So I joke with people, I'm a cattle dietitian,
[00:00:54.390]most people know what dietitians are.
[00:00:55.937](audience laughing)
[00:00:57.524]So we have tremendous research facilities
[00:00:59.398]as part of the university,
[00:01:00.792]obviously those are off-campus.
[00:01:02.452]So we've been figuring out ways
[00:01:03.528]so that when cattle stick their head in these gates
[00:01:05.682]they can only open up one
[00:01:07.105]cause they gotta key,
[00:01:08.446]so we get to prevent which ones,
[00:01:10.551]or control which ones they have access to.
[00:01:13.310]When they stick their head in there
[00:01:14.734]it's an enclosed space,
[00:01:16.305]turn on the pumps and we fill these little bags
[00:01:18.458]with breath that they're respiring
[00:01:20.818]and that's one way to measure methane.
[00:01:23.022]It's not great, it's a pretty crude way
[00:01:25.231]but it worked pretty well.
[00:01:27.095]The reason that's better though
[00:01:28.156]is this is one of the more common ways,
[00:01:30.231]which is you put cattle literally
[00:01:31.557]in a, they call it a head-box,
[00:01:33.808]there's feed and water in there,
[00:01:35.305]he's eating and then you measure him
[00:01:36.976]throughout the whole day
[00:01:38.393]with how much oxygen's coming in
[00:01:40.724]and how much CO2 and methane's going out.
[00:01:43.691]That's great but you can imagine cattle
[00:01:45.582]don't really like being in this little trough, right?
[00:01:48.750]So they don't do quite normal
[00:01:50.591]and you can only measure them for a couple days.
[00:01:53.310]So now along with the University of California
[00:01:56.955]and Michigan State, they're the only three places
[00:01:59.412]where we've developed a room
[00:02:01.988]where we put groups of animals in there,
[00:02:04.681]measure air coming in
[00:02:06.242]and then CO2 and methane going out.
[00:02:10.657]There's a sensor by these fans
[00:02:12.853]so that you can measure a group of 10 to 15 or 20 animals
[00:02:16.929]in a more quote unquote normal environment.
[00:02:20.980]We've been part of a large methane focus grant
[00:02:23.975]to decrease how methane cattle are naturally producing.
[00:02:28.106]Cattle are naturally producing that methane
[00:02:30.192]because of the bacterial process
[00:02:32.120]that's in their digestive system.
[00:02:34.194]So it is a natural process, unfortunately,
[00:02:36.835]whenever it's natural it's kind of hard to manipulate,
[00:02:41.271]so we're trying.
[00:02:42.931]As part of that grant though,
[00:02:44.267]it was an integrated grant,
[00:02:45.661]so I have an extension appointment
[00:02:47.917]and we just had a methane conference
[00:02:50.105]a couple weeks ago.
[00:02:51.556]And focused on it for beef producers
[00:02:53.532]on here are things that have been tried
[00:02:55.636]that you could do differently
[00:02:57.032]to decrease methane production by cattle.
[00:02:59.667]There aren't many good ways yet,
[00:03:01.858]so we don't have a lot of good options.
[00:03:04.292]Part of that grant we did a survey
[00:03:05.859]of producers in the state of Nebraska
[00:03:07.402]and I guess I would make a comment,
[00:03:09.679]I get the impression especially from the earlier surveys
[00:03:12.348]that crop producers are particularly more open
[00:03:15.580]to discussing climate change
[00:03:17.397]than maybe beef producers are.
[00:03:19.420]Our response from beef producers surveys
[00:03:24.184]was almost perfectly bi-modal,
[00:03:27.860]meaning about half the producers
[00:03:29.708]thought we were crazy for exploring it
[00:03:31.531]and about half thought it was the greatest thing ever,
[00:03:34.080]does that make sense?
[00:03:35.292](audience laughing)
[00:03:36.174]That probably means we're about right,
[00:03:37.849]right if half of them ...
[00:03:41.032]But you know why I think that,
[00:03:42.616]so I'm bringing this up just as a side note,
[00:03:44.166]I think many beef producers are a little sensitive
[00:03:46.017]to climate discussions only because beef get implicated
[00:03:50.167]heavily as a problem, not a solution.
[00:03:54.017]In the U.S. they account for about 4%
[00:03:56.327]of total greenhouse gas emissions.
[00:03:58.125]Globally it's higher, but in our U.S. systems
[00:04:00.582]it's not that high,
[00:04:01.804]but beef producers feel like they're getting beat on some.
[00:04:06.454]Like any good extension project
[00:04:08.502]our information's available online
[00:04:11.181]for producers and others.
[00:04:14.844]Second area I want to discuss
[00:04:16.970]is maybe what else is normal
[00:04:18.949]about our beef production system?
[00:04:22.107]Everybody hopefully appreciates
[00:04:24.058]that we have a lot of cattle in Nebraska.
[00:04:26.400]We finish at any one time,
[00:04:28.420]we have about 2 1/2 million head of cattle on feed,
[00:04:31.005]we finish about 5 million head.
[00:04:33.462]We would be number one or two essentially close with Texas.
[00:04:37.699]It is the biggest component
[00:04:39.410]of ag revenue in the state of Nebraska.
[00:04:42.397]Obviously we're a big corn producer
[00:04:44.505]which helps support that feedlot industry
[00:04:46.438]and we're a big ethanol producer.
[00:04:48.157]My point is Nebraska's normal,
[00:04:51.065]from my perspective,
[00:04:52.502]normal ag production system
[00:04:54.047]is a large ethanol complex,
[00:04:55.578]a large corn complex
[00:04:56.958]and a large beef complex
[00:04:58.576]which are quite frankly closely tied.
[00:05:00.907]Now why does that matter?
[00:05:02.357]I'm gonna get to that.
[00:05:03.776]That matters because one of the benefits
[00:05:06.159]for beef cattle in Nebraska
[00:05:07.949]is actually having an ethanol industry.
[00:05:11.703]And it's gonna come back
[00:05:12.913]to relate to greenhouse gas in just a second.
[00:05:15.305]This graph though is from '08 to last summer
[00:05:19.243]and this line right here
[00:05:21.271]says that if all those dots run that line
[00:05:24.445]that means producers would buy distillers grains,
[00:05:27.892]this by-product from ethanol plants
[00:05:29.689]at exactly the same price as corn.
[00:05:32.378]So notice that in the black is dry,
[00:05:35.184]the blue is modified and the red is wet,
[00:05:37.763]just three different kinds of distillers
[00:05:39.451]that many of these ethanol plants
[00:05:40.804]produce across the state.
[00:05:43.984]Notice that many times these prices
[00:05:46.495]that the producers are buying distillers grains at
[00:05:48.607]is cheaper than corn.
[00:05:51.147]The red line is from our research
[00:05:53.078]and what we think the wet stuff's worth.
[00:05:56.062]The blue line's what we think the modified's worth,
[00:06:00.026]so what's my point?
[00:06:02.757]Producers are buying it here
[00:06:04.883]and it's worth this,
[00:06:06.358]it makes 'em 50 to $70 more per head
[00:06:09.332]on a steer which is a lot of money.
[00:06:12.381]It's a big deal for our beef producers in the state.
[00:06:15.516]So what?
[00:06:16.706]Now here's how it relates.
[00:06:19.278]You don't have to worry too much about the two lines.
[00:06:21.294]This line is what we modeled,
[00:06:23.326]the other line is what we measured.
[00:06:25.491]This is the percent reduction in greenhouse gas emissions
[00:06:29.206]from a corn, ethanol, cattle system in Nebraska,
[00:06:34.227]relative to gasoline.
[00:06:36.340]So my point is that if you are a ethanol plant
[00:06:39.404]and a beef producer and a corn farmer in Iowa,
[00:06:42.262]which is where I grew up so I can pick on them,
[00:06:46.096]you have to do this.
[00:06:47.479]So your complex, you reduce greenhouse gas emissions
[00:06:50.202]by about 45%, which is great,
[00:06:52.880]relative to gasoline.
[00:06:54.657]If you're in Nebraska and you have a lot of cattle,
[00:06:56.991]right next door to the ethanol plant
[00:06:59.084]and you're feeding wet distillers grains
[00:07:00.808]you reduce greenhouse gas emissions
[00:07:02.640]from Nebraska's complex by roughly 60%.
[00:07:08.254]So having cattle and ethanol co-located
[00:07:10.372]is a pretty good thing
[00:07:12.130]from an overall ag system perspective.
[00:07:14.318]Why is that?
[00:07:17.046]Main reason for this difference
[00:07:18.579]is cause ethanol plants have to put in energy
[00:07:21.423]and therefore produce,
[00:07:23.399]to make dry distillers grains,
[00:07:25.899]if an ethanol plant--
[00:07:27.246]Go ahead.
[00:07:28.079]My question is why does it reduce
[00:07:29.447]the greenhouse gas emissions?
[00:07:30.882]Even more than dry, or more than gasoline?
[00:07:33.315]I'm not worried about the wet versus dry,
[00:07:34.931]I'm just wondering why does using distillers grains
[00:07:38.024]reduce the greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline?
[00:07:42.140]That's what I keep hearing you saying.
[00:07:44.182]Yes, that's based primarily on work done 10 years ago
[00:07:46.733]by Ken Casman and Adam Liska
[00:07:49.491]and it's been documented that if you burn gasoline
[00:07:52.843]versus taking corn, growing the corn,
[00:07:55.866]making it into ethanol
[00:07:57.367]and then burning ethanol in your vehicle,
[00:07:59.463]this is renewable, this one's not
[00:08:01.457]and so it reduces how much carbon emissions
[00:08:03.522]you have relative to just the ethanol corn complex.
[00:08:08.386]My excitement wasn't that though,
[00:08:09.828]my excitement is that you have cattle
[00:08:12.322]and you can make it and use the wet stuff
[00:08:14.676]that's a benefit, but yes, it is good no matter what.
[00:08:21.260]Okay last thing then I guess to discuss
[00:08:23.610]something that we're trying
[00:08:25.506]which is really not, not common
[00:08:28.460]and may not ever be adopted
[00:08:29.951]but we're trying it.
[00:08:31.609]This is what's commonly called,
[00:08:33.328]remember this was Nebraska before,
[00:08:35.301]corn, ethanol plant, cattle,
[00:08:38.314]now if you add in a digester
[00:08:41.478]for the manure on the cattle
[00:08:43.405]it's what's commonly called a closed-loop
[00:08:45.475]so now you can produce bio-gas from the manure.
[00:08:48.246]That's a closed-loop system.
[00:08:50.894]What we're also trying
[00:08:53.273]is taking it another step further,
[00:08:55.542]so we're calling it a super-loop
[00:08:57.533]instead of a closed loop,
[00:08:59.445]and putting algae into this system
[00:09:01.927]so actually you digest manure,
[00:09:04.083]produce bio-gas to burn
[00:09:06.775]so you can make manure into methane
[00:09:08.957]and then recycle some of those nutrients further
[00:09:11.336]to produce algae
[00:09:12.758]which may have promise in the future, may not.
[00:09:16.563]We've done a lot of research
[00:09:18.019]supported by the Nebraska Center for Energy Sciences.
[00:09:20.837]This picture I think's telling,
[00:09:22.601]this is good old manure-water,
[00:09:24.714]looks nice right, it's brown.
[00:09:26.884]This is the clear one behind it
[00:09:30.303]is what you would normally raise the algae on,
[00:09:33.172]after six days this one looks green
[00:09:35.130]and this one still looks like dirty water,
[00:09:37.459]by day 21 there's no difference.
[00:09:39.701]My point is algae can grow well
[00:09:42.064]even on digested manure
[00:09:43.938]so that's why we're thinking about
[00:09:45.129]trying to make algae fit into this Nebraska system.
[00:09:49.188]From funding from the Environmental Trust
[00:09:52.349]as well as from the Energy Sciences Center
[00:09:54.735]we have a little larger scale ponds
[00:09:57.566]up at Mead at our Ag Research and Development Center
[00:10:01.277]trying to test that theory.
[00:10:03.690]With that I would take any questions or comments.

The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!

You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.

Comments

0 Comments

Nebraska Legislature - Special Committee - Climate Change Seminar - Animal Science Research Initiatives

Description

Searchable Transcript

Comments icon comment

Related Channels

Comments