Durham Keynote: Pleasure and Danger
University Communications
Author
03/15/2016
Added
150
Plays
Description
Meenakshi Gigi Durham, professor and collegiate scholar in the Department of Gender, Women's and Sexuality Studies at Iowa State University presents "Pleasure and Danger: Sex, Violence, and Ethics in the Age of Digital Media."
Searchable Transcript
Toggle between list and paragraph view.
- [00:00:00.000](applause)
- [00:00:03.229]Thanks so much.
- [00:00:04.888]I really appreciate you all inviting me here
- [00:00:06.607]to speak to you tonight.
- [00:00:08.867]I'm so intrigued by the name of this conference.
- [00:00:11.807]Sexuality and Gender in the Digital Age No Limits.
- [00:00:16.085]It's interesting, and perhaps even ironic
- [00:00:18.265]that I was asked to keynote this conference
- [00:00:20.424]as my work to a large extent,
- [00:00:22.484]actually, explores limits
- [00:00:24.822]the way societies and cultures
- [00:00:27.062]attempt to enforce limits
- [00:00:28.582]on those very categories, sexuality and gender.
- [00:00:31.962]Even using them in the singular implies a limit.
- [00:00:35.282]We should really say gender is sexualities, right?
- [00:00:38.922]Plural, wide-ranging, multifarious,
- [00:00:42.182]and sort of infinite.
- [00:00:45.021]In theory, sex and gender are limitless.
- [00:00:48.320]In reality, people,
- [00:00:51.185]especially women,
- [00:00:52.852]but also other marginalized groups,
- [00:00:56.580]sexual minorities, and other people
- [00:01:00.272]of color face limits at every turn.
- [00:01:03.472]A limit is a marker, it's a boundary,
- [00:01:05.832]it's a line in the sand,
- [00:01:07.652]but if we play a word association game,
- [00:01:09.412]and I say the word limits
- [00:01:10.972]what's the first thing that comes to mind?
- [00:01:20.350]What?
- [00:01:21.750]I said speed limits.
- [00:01:24.128]Oh, speed limits, right, right, right, okay.
- [00:01:26.228]Other words?
- [00:01:28.186]Boundaries.
- [00:01:30.306]Boundaries, okay, yeah.
- [00:01:35.344]Sorry, what?
- [00:01:36.182]Calculus.
- [00:01:37.222]Calculus, oh right, right.
- [00:01:38.997]Right, of course, you have to believe
- [00:01:40.697]in limits to do calculus.
- [00:01:43.277]Parameters.
- [00:01:45.837]Parameters, okay.
- [00:01:48.794]The word that comes to mind
- [00:01:49.754]for me is testing, limit testing.
- [00:01:53.491]I feel like every limit is to be tested.
- [00:01:55.672]Every boundary has to be broken.
- [00:01:57.791]Lines in the sand are meant to be crossed.
- [00:02:00.951]What's the old bumper sticker quote?
- [00:02:02.911]"Well-behaved women seldom make history."
- [00:02:06.149]That's the thing that you see all over the place.
- [00:02:08.749]Feminists are notorious limit testers,
- [00:02:10.589]and good for us, right?
- [00:02:12.629]That brings us to the notion of no limits
- [00:02:15.529]the enticing subtitle that at this conference
- [00:02:18.349]underpins, in particular, the idea of
- [00:02:20.649]sexualities and genders in the digital age.
- [00:02:23.480]This is not a new idea.
- [00:02:25.320]You're all probably familiar with that
- [00:02:26.600]old New Yorker cartoon, right?
- [00:02:27.957]"On the Internet nobody knows you're a dog,"
- [00:02:29.657]and its variations.
- [00:02:31.177]The idea here in this cartoon was that
- [00:02:33.417]you were free to be whoever
- [00:02:34.457]you wanted to be online.
- [00:02:36.117]That is, no one needed to know
- [00:02:37.436]who you were in real life.
- [00:02:39.356]Everything that might have restricted you
- [00:02:41.236]in your real life,
- [00:02:42.716]your looks, your age, your gender,
- [00:02:44.596]your class, your family,
- [00:02:46.656]you're presumed sexual orientation,
- [00:02:48.836]your religious community,
- [00:02:50.156]or as in this dog's case your non-human category
- [00:02:53.376]could be freely and totally shed online.
- [00:02:56.054]There were apparently no limits,
- [00:02:58.574]and, indeed, especially in the early ages
- [00:03:00.754]of the Internet of Internet exploration
- [00:03:03.490]people wrote about online sexualities,
- [00:03:05.490]and genders in exactly this way.
- [00:03:07.590]Sherry Turkle, for example,
- [00:03:09.650]used the metaphor of
- [00:03:14.466]seduction when she wrote about it
- [00:03:16.502]in Life on the Screen,
- [00:03:18.042]and she mused "Love, passion, infatuation,
- [00:03:20.922]"what we feel for another person
- [00:03:22.942]"teaches us about ourselves.
- [00:03:24.461]"If we explore these feelings,
- [00:03:26.001]"we can learn what we are drawn to,
- [00:03:27.821]"what we are missing, and what we need.
- [00:03:29.761]"The analysis of computational seduction
- [00:03:32.101]"offers similar promise.
- [00:03:33.781]"Online, people are swept up by experiences
- [00:03:36.241]"that enable them to explore
- [00:03:37.801]"previously unexamined aspects of their sexuality,
- [00:03:40.441]"or that challenge their ideas
- [00:03:41.941]"about a unitary self.
- [00:03:43.621]"In simulation, identity can be fluid and multiple,
- [00:03:46.681]"a signifier no longer clearly points to
- [00:03:49.401]"a thing that is signified,
- [00:03:50.801]"and understanding is less likely to
- [00:03:52.541]"proceed through analysis
- [00:03:54.021]"than by navigation through virtual space."
- [00:03:58.079]Thus, Cleo Odzer,
- [00:04:00.193]in her book Virtual Spaces
- [00:04:02.513]confessed "Posing as a man
- [00:04:04.833]"I had sex with a woman.
- [00:04:06.513]"Posing as a gay man I had sex with a man.
- [00:04:09.193]"Posing as a man I had sex with a man
- [00:04:11.233]"who was posing as a woman.
- [00:04:13.293]"I had all sorts of sex
- [00:04:14.433]"in every new way I could think of."
- [00:04:16.373]There's glee in Odzer's account of her
- [00:04:18.612]sexual morphing online,
- [00:04:20.551]and this excitement in cybersex's potential
- [00:04:22.751]for modes of experimentation
- [00:04:24.691]coupled with anonymity
- [00:04:26.511]a lifting of the moral and social constraints
- [00:04:28.591]of one's real life
- [00:04:30.091]the opportunity to explore fantastic options
- [00:04:32.731]accounts for the seductions of the screen.
- [00:04:35.751]Online sexual activity or cybersex,
- [00:04:38.191]and I'm gonna use those two terms synonymously
- [00:04:41.791]even though there's some debate about
- [00:04:44.091]the difference between them,
- [00:04:45.631]and their exact definitions,
- [00:04:46.931]but for now cybersex is online
- [00:04:48.570]sexual activity in this talk.
- [00:04:50.830]It's motivated by a quest for erotic pleasure,
- [00:04:53.087]and it's fueled by accessibility,
- [00:04:55.867]affordability, and anonymity sometimes called
- [00:04:58.487]the triple A engine of the Internet.
- [00:05:00.827]Of course, anonymity can be misleading.
- [00:05:05.606]Perhaps it doesn't really matter
- [00:05:07.446]if they're both enjoying themselves.
- [00:05:10.724]I do want to acknowledge that cybersex
- [00:05:12.463]affords intense pleasure to some extent.
- [00:05:15.343]We're all seduced by the screen
- [00:05:17.063]even if we don't engage in online sexual activity,
- [00:05:19.862]but sexuality like every other
- [00:05:21.922]aspect of social life is deeply imbricated
- [00:05:24.782]by technology and techniques,
- [00:05:26.902]and to some extent it always has been.
- [00:05:29.782]Technologies fill our life-worlds.
- [00:05:31.880]There are factors in virtually
- [00:05:33.040]every realm of human existence,
- [00:05:34.940]and they're central to the formation
- [00:05:36.240]of gender and sexuality,
- [00:05:37.580]and contemporary society.
- [00:05:39.938]Recent scholarship in the emerging field
- [00:05:42.478]of soma techniques calls attention to the fact
- [00:05:44.996]that the body and the technology
- [00:05:46.656]are always already mutually interdependent
- [00:05:50.136]woven through each other.
- [00:05:52.116]While a vast array of technology is from
- [00:05:54.276]the vibrator to gender reassignment surgeries
- [00:05:56.716]are engaged in the production
- [00:05:58.616]of genders and sexualities
- [00:06:00.376]many are strategically deployed to enforce
- [00:06:02.556]dominant meanings about
- [00:06:03.895]gender and sexuality
- [00:06:05.375]while others have the potential to disrupt them.
- [00:06:08.075]Media technologies tend to delineate
- [00:06:10.055]ideal bodies for each socially defined
- [00:06:12.195]gender category,
- [00:06:13.555]and regulate as well as capitalize on
- [00:06:15.475]the practices for achieving them.
- [00:06:17.895]Certain soma technologies,
- [00:06:19.435]breast augmentation, or rhinoplasty for example,
- [00:06:22.855]are pointedly designed to help human bodies
- [00:06:25.275]mimic technologically generated,
- [00:06:27.555]and highly binarized media ideals,
- [00:06:30.233]so get the sexiest body ever
- [00:06:33.153]commands the magazine cover,
- [00:06:34.871]and hard abs, more sex, hotter sex
- [00:06:37.811]as they portray women
- [00:06:39.511]bursting out of bustiers, and short shorts,
- [00:06:42.211]or men with bulging biceps,
- [00:06:44.110]and rippling stomach muscles,
- [00:06:45.970]and we've all seen them.
- [00:06:47.350]They're all like this.
- [00:06:48.370]Flat belly, tight tush, lean legs,
- [00:06:51.030]and, of course, this leads to mind blowing sex.
- [00:06:54.865]Let's go back to that guy.
- [00:06:58.344]Or this one, like super hero abs
- [00:07:00.524]which gives her the sex of her dreams somehow.
- [00:07:07.103]These kinds of bodies as we know
- [00:07:08.603]cannot be attained without technologies,
- [00:07:11.123]plastic surgeries for breast implants,
- [00:07:13.643]or pec implants as in the case of this guy.
- [00:07:16.383]Pharmacological technologies, steroids,
- [00:07:18.880]hormone treatments, diet aids,
- [00:07:20.960]consumer technologies, ellipticals,
- [00:07:23.580]weight machines, and so on,
- [00:07:25.620]yet, the easy move toward
- [00:07:27.780]a technologically determined body
- [00:07:29.660]would be simplistic.
- [00:07:30.980]Technologies don't spontaneously self-generate.
- [00:07:33.600]They are developed and created
- [00:07:34.980]by human inventiveness.
- [00:07:36.840]As the historian Rosalind Williams points out
- [00:07:39.279]"Technological determinism is a non-issue
- [00:07:41.559]"because there are no technological forces
- [00:07:43.617]"separate from social ones.
- [00:07:45.617]"The real question to ask then is not
- [00:07:48.177]"is technological determinism true,
- [00:07:50.397]"but what are the historical forces
- [00:07:52.497]"shaping the construction
- [00:07:53.937]"of the technological world?
- [00:07:56.037]"Technologies of the body operate
- [00:07:58.257]"within dynamic matrices of culture,
- [00:08:00.676]"temporality, politics, and economics.
- [00:08:03.216]"They can be seen as a consequence
- [00:08:05.056]"of the ethos of an era
- [00:08:06.556]"as well as a factor in shaping it,
- [00:08:08.276]"and they must be understood as historicized
- [00:08:13.735]"because body technologies and their utility
- [00:08:16.394]"like all technologies change with the times."
- [00:08:19.034]I'm just gonna turn this guy off for a second
- [00:08:23.113]as much as you might like to look at him.
- [00:08:27.053]In other words, they are profoundly
- [00:08:28.390]engaged with human evolution.
- [00:08:30.130]All technologies have the capacity
- [00:08:31.710]to alter our time or space,
- [00:08:33.590]perception, location, identity, mobility,
- [00:08:35.990]power, possibility, technologies of the body
- [00:08:39.110]by interacting with our very flesh,
- [00:08:41.530]our cytoplasm, our corpuscles,
- [00:08:43.549]our flesh and bones make radical
- [00:08:45.849]interventions into our very reality,
- [00:08:47.989]our sense of being in the world.
- [00:08:50.809]The body self is constituted
- [00:08:53.049]in relation to cultural imaginaries.
- [00:08:55.868]Those ready made symbols through which
- [00:08:57.668]we make sense of social bodies,
- [00:08:59.388]and which determine in part their value,
- [00:09:01.646]their status, and what will be deemed
- [00:09:03.806]their appropriate treatment.
- [00:09:05.846]Global circuits of transnational media
- [00:09:08.386]are powerful agents of these cultural imaginaries
- [00:09:10.866]producing and distributing
- [00:09:12.686]millions of images every second
- [00:09:14.786]via satellite and wireless networks,
- [00:09:17.246]high efficiency video coding,
- [00:09:19.246]cable systems, fiber optics,
- [00:09:21.446]Cloud computing, and other means,
- [00:09:23.726]and sexuality is a vital part of this system.
- [00:09:26.886]Increasingly, the interactive,
- [00:09:28.626]and "DIY" features of digital technologies
- [00:09:31.342]are being used to represent,
- [00:09:32.702]and circulate sexual desires.
- [00:09:34.962]Teenagers engage in sexting,
- [00:09:36.802]sex tapes are uploaded to the Internet.
- [00:09:39.362]People engage in chat
- [00:09:40.602]that simulates sex online.
- [00:09:42.442]Cyber-porn is a multi-million dollar industry,
- [00:09:45.201]and sex trafficking flows
- [00:09:46.921]via transnational digital networks.
- [00:09:49.361]Desire is channeled through technology
- [00:09:51.681]in the contemporary era.
- [00:09:53.381]Images forge intimate bonds between partners,
- [00:09:56.181]but they also go viral
- [00:09:58.061]establishing sexual identities,
- [00:09:59.841]reputations, and proclivities
- [00:10:02.081]thus cellphones, tablets,
- [00:10:04.120]and other digital technologies
- [00:10:05.720]can be understood as "desiring machines"
- [00:10:08.240]to quote Deleuze and Guattari,
- [00:10:10.039]"channeling flows of desire and corporeal signs
- [00:10:12.757]"through their circuits to reinscribe
- [00:10:14.937]"sexual subject positions in line with
- [00:10:16.977]"the larger logics of the day."
- [00:10:18.897]As the feminist physicist Karen Barad points out
- [00:10:21.456]existence is not an individual affair.
- [00:10:23.876]Individuals emerge through and part
- [00:10:26.136]of their entangled intra-relating.
- [00:10:29.013]Mark Hanson argues for a deep correlation
- [00:10:31.453]between embodiment and virtuality
- [00:10:34.333]pointing out that new media technologies,
- [00:10:36.351]especially, those constituting our virtual reality
- [00:10:39.171]engage bodily sensations
- [00:10:41.289]in ways that give rise to ontological states.
- [00:10:44.067]He notes that biological embodiment
- [00:10:46.127]within cultural experience is crucial
- [00:10:48.547]to the development of body schemas,
- [00:10:50.687]our understandings of our bodies,
- [00:10:52.527]and also to our subject positions,
- [00:10:54.427]our understandings of who we are,
- [00:10:55.927]our sense of self.
- [00:10:59.106]In this approach he engages
- [00:11:00.486]a philosophical tradition that
- [00:11:01.806]not only construes the body
- [00:11:03.666]as socially and culturally constructed
- [00:11:06.066]structured malleable historicized,
- [00:11:09.123]but recognizes subjectivity
- [00:11:10.801]as constituted through the body.
- [00:11:12.820]Subjectivity and corporeality
- [00:11:15.060]are thus mutually implicated,
- [00:11:16.519]and generated in relation to social formations.
- [00:11:18.999]I want to use the word subjectivity.
- [00:11:20.799]I mean the sense of self, the subject, the self,
- [00:11:23.699]how we think of ourselves,
- [00:11:26.139]the "person" behind the eye.
- [00:11:31.037]Subjectivity and corporeality
- [00:11:33.557]are mutually implicated,
- [00:11:35.557]and they're always generated in relation
- [00:11:37.397]to larger social formations.
- [00:11:39.377]All these cultural images.
- [00:11:40.757]All the cultural discourses and narratives
- [00:11:43.377]that we hear around us
- [00:11:44.537]about what bodies should look like,
- [00:11:46.537]how they should operate,
- [00:11:47.837]how they should practice,
- [00:11:50.377]so these post-structuralist concepts of corporeality
- [00:11:53.937]open up ways of considering
- [00:11:55.677]the complex and dynamic operations
- [00:11:57.477]of power, embodiment, and sexualities
- [00:12:00.197]in an era of transnational media.
- [00:12:02.476]Feminist science and technology studies,
- [00:12:04.455]and the more recent discipline
- [00:12:05.815]of soma techniques have explored
- [00:12:07.435]technologies constitutive role
- [00:12:09.435]in gendered power relations.
- [00:12:11.252]As Judy Wajcman argues
- [00:12:12.712]understanding technology as
- [00:12:14.491]a social apparatus, a culture,
- [00:12:16.651]or material semiotic practice
- [00:12:18.471]enables us to understand how
- [00:12:20.371]our relationship to technology
- [00:12:22.111]is integral to the constitution of subjectivity
- [00:12:24.431]for both sexes.
- [00:12:26.731]Wajcman points out that feminist perspectives
- [00:12:29.068]recognize technology and society
- [00:12:31.028]as involved in a fluid relationship
- [00:12:33.248]of mutual shaping.
- [00:12:35.028]On her account gender relations
- [00:12:37.028]can be thought of as materialized in technology,
- [00:12:39.847]and masculinity and femininity
- [00:12:41.827]in turn acquire their meaning,
- [00:12:43.587]and character through their enrollment,
- [00:12:45.647]and embeddedness in working machines.
- [00:12:48.667]Wajcman's analysis is rooted
- [00:12:50.246]in a gender binarism,
- [00:12:51.846]but drawing on the insides of
- [00:12:53.265]soma techniques it's clear that
- [00:12:54.825]a whole range of gender, sexualities,
- [00:12:57.105]and categories of bodies and identities
- [00:12:59.502]are similarly mobilized,
- [00:13:01.602]so in the contemporary moment
- [00:13:03.302]let's think about working machines,
- [00:13:05.822]the working machines that construe our bodies.
- [00:13:08.162]I think the ones that we know and use the best
- [00:13:10.522]are the various media technologies,
- [00:13:12.882]the media communication technologies
- [00:13:14.702]that permeate our environments.
- [00:13:17.022]In every contemporary society
- [00:13:18.702]people interact with the media,
- [00:13:20.742]and these interactions are, of course,
- [00:13:22.582]shaped and complicated by
- [00:13:24.982]the locations in which they occur,
- [00:13:26.722]impacted and configured by histories,
- [00:13:28.862]geographies, material circumstances,
- [00:13:30.842]cultures, and other factors.
- [00:13:32.702]Fundamental to media theory
- [00:13:34.122]is the recognition that all communication media
- [00:13:36.702]are both technological and cultural,
- [00:13:38.982]and the very term the media
- [00:13:41.602]spans a vast range of forms and functions,
- [00:13:44.482]so we can't just sort of lump
- [00:13:46.782]the media together as one thing.
- [00:13:48.622]We know that cellphones
- [00:13:50.002]are very different from television
- [00:13:51.601]which is sort of fading away
- [00:13:53.081]in terms of its social presence,
- [00:13:54.561]very different from cinema,
- [00:13:56.121]very different from the Internet,
- [00:13:58.481]or Facebook, social media,
- [00:14:00.161]so we can't just sort of lump
- [00:14:01.661]all the media together,
- [00:14:02.561]yet, despite all these specificities and differences
- [00:14:05.741]as Roger Silverstone reflects
- [00:14:07.721]it's possible to consider the media
- [00:14:09.301]as a complex system,
- [00:14:11.001]and all these technologies
- [00:14:12.221]are sort of interrelated.
- [00:14:13.821]He thinks of it as a space that is increasingly
- [00:14:16.701]mutually referential,
- [00:14:20.139]and reinforcive,
- [00:14:21.759]and increasingly integrated into
- [00:14:23.299]the fabric of everyday life.
- [00:14:25.279]"The media are becoming environmental," he says.
- [00:14:28.219]More and more the media
- [00:14:29.619]constitute our environments
- [00:14:30.999]in ways that are taken for granted,
- [00:14:32.719]and pretty much imperceptible,
- [00:14:34.399]so from electronic billboards,
- [00:14:35.878]to closed-circuit cameras
- [00:14:37.338]which I'm sure are in this room.
- [00:14:39.718]The video camera that's
- [00:14:41.817]recording me at the moment, cellphones.
- [00:14:44.896]Media comprise elements of daily life.
- [00:14:47.196]We don't even really think about them anymore,
- [00:14:49.116]and as electronic media increasingly
- [00:14:51.156]saturate our everyday spaces with images
- [00:14:53.556]of other places, and other imagined,
- [00:14:55.796]or real orders of space
- [00:14:57.536]it's evermore difficult to tell
- [00:14:59.176]a story of social space
- [00:15:00.736]without also telling a story of media,
- [00:15:02.896]and vice versa.
- [00:15:05.116]Our engagements with the media are
- [00:15:07.096]perhaps the most veiled of our relationships.
- [00:15:09.716]We dismiss them sometimes as guilty pleasures,
- [00:15:12.175]or distractions.
- [00:15:13.775]We publicly deny that they have any
- [00:15:16.375]import or impact on our lives.
- [00:15:18.475]We acknowledge that yeah,
- [00:15:19.855]maybe other people are affected by
- [00:15:22.175]the seductions of the cellphone,
- [00:15:23.973]or the iPad, or whatever,
- [00:15:26.693]but we invariably see ourselves as
- [00:15:28.753]active and decisive managers
- [00:15:30.513]of our media consumption.
- [00:15:32.073]We baulk at spending any time,
- [00:15:34.413]or serious thought
- [00:15:35.692]on our interactions with the media
- [00:15:37.792]yet we live in an era where the media
- [00:15:40.052]pervade our existences.
- [00:15:42.192]This is most true of western societies,
- [00:15:44.192]those of the global north,
- [00:15:45.672]but it's increasingly becoming typical
- [00:15:47.532]in the global south, or the "Third World."
- [00:15:51.172]As Hanson has noted,
- [00:15:52.852]"Technology affects our experience
- [00:15:54.510]"first and foremost through its
- [00:15:55.789]"infrastructural role.
- [00:15:57.529]"Effectively, technology structure our life-worlds."
- [00:16:00.369]If we acknowledge this
- [00:16:02.029]then we're faced with two choices.
- [00:16:03.789]We can accept and ignore
- [00:16:05.029]the media and culture industries
- [00:16:06.489]as aspects of a taken for granted environment,
- [00:16:08.668]or we can radically rethink their function
- [00:16:11.088]as cultural, historical structures
- [00:16:13.328]that work along with such power formations
- [00:16:15.867]as phallocentrism and heteronormativity
- [00:16:18.887]as defining symbolic institutions
- [00:16:21.186]that make specific interventions
- [00:16:22.886]into the body, sex, gender desire matrix
- [00:16:25.605]re-articulating these concepts in ways
- [00:16:28.005]that impinge upon our imaginations
- [00:16:30.105]of these key vectors of intimacy and identity.
- [00:16:33.505]No longer then do we premise our understanding
- [00:16:36.645]of personhood or subjectivity
- [00:16:38.905]on a Cartesian dualism
- [00:16:40.504]between the mind and body.
- [00:16:42.244]Instead we recognize the fluid,
- [00:16:44.104]and continuous synergies that
- [00:16:45.524]constitute the self as well as the social.
- [00:16:47.884]In fact, our embrace of body transformations
- [00:16:50.744]appear to be predicated in
- [00:16:52.624]a rather sophisticated understanding
- [00:16:54.104]that bodies are not fixed or stable or natural,
- [00:16:58.211]but this recognition stands at an
- [00:17:00.101]uneasy tension with a concept of the self
- [00:17:02.561]which is a contradictory and paradoxical one
- [00:17:05.099]where the self is regarded as
- [00:17:06.859]simultaneously split off from,
- [00:17:09.299]and also closely aligned with the body,
- [00:17:11.679]so, I think, we're still kind of grappling with this idea
- [00:17:14.499]that ourselves are separate from our bodies,
- [00:17:17.039]but at the same time in some circumstances
- [00:17:19.719]we see the self as kind of enmeshed with the body.
- [00:17:23.098]So, for example, people engaging in online sex
- [00:17:26.158]seem to recognize that
- [00:17:27.578]a transformation into a virtual self
- [00:17:29.718]is the conduit for physical pleasure,
- [00:17:31.958]so even though it's all happening virtually,
- [00:17:34.258]and it's kind of through the mind
- [00:17:35.818]the body is reacting,
- [00:17:37.198]and so there really is no distinction there
- [00:17:38.638]between self and body.
- [00:17:40.817]On Shannon McCray's interpretation
- [00:17:42.657]"When intense erotic union is accomplished
- [00:17:45.536]"in a kind of void in which bodies
- [00:17:47.756]"are simultaneously, acutely imagined,
- [00:17:50.176]"vividly felt, and utterly absent
- [00:17:52.476]"the resultant sense of seizure,
- [00:17:54.756]"of scattering of self loss can be experienced
- [00:17:57.515]"as a violent mingling of pleasure and pain.
- [00:18:00.935]"The intensity of pleasure results from
- [00:18:03.195]"the kind of sustained dislocation
- [00:18:05.275]"required when your body is entirely real,
- [00:18:07.815]"and entirely imagined at the same time."
- [00:18:10.855]So this juncture or disjuncture of self and body
- [00:18:14.195]is also evident in the narratives of people
- [00:18:16.435]who undergo actual physical transformations
- [00:18:19.455]using biomedical technologies.
- [00:18:21.875]"I'm happy about who I am, finally,"
- [00:18:24.754]reported Rachel Love-Fraser
- [00:18:26.574]after undergoing seven surgical procedures
- [00:18:29.114]on the FOX reality TV makeover show, The Swan.
- [00:18:32.413]Do you guys remember
- [00:18:33.473]The Swan from the 1990's?
- [00:18:35.492]"It's made such a difference
- [00:18:36.772]"in the way I feel about myself,"
- [00:18:38.372]enthused Marnie Rygiewicz,
- [00:18:40.252]a contestant on The Swan
- [00:18:41.472]after multiple surgeries depicted on air.
- [00:18:44.432]"I think I'd have a more fulfilling life
- [00:18:46.552]"if I looked better," mused schoolteacher
- [00:18:48.692]Mary Ellen Smith at a casting call for the show.
- [00:18:51.450]For these women the self
- [00:18:53.569]is predicated on the body.
- [00:18:55.789]Self and body are mutually dependent variables,
- [00:18:58.449]and technological interventions
- [00:19:00.189]into the body can release the real me
- [00:19:02.627]trapped inside the unwanted,
- [00:19:04.547]unattractive corporeal shell,
- [00:19:06.687]so there's an existential rift between
- [00:19:08.867]the body and the self that's healed
- [00:19:10.607]through plastic surgery,
- [00:19:12.327]and the women come to understand
- [00:19:13.727]their preoperative body is accidental,
- [00:19:15.687]and their current, more normative appearance
- [00:19:18.067]is a more accurate indicator
- [00:19:19.446]of who they really are.
- [00:19:21.526]This version of the body is
- [00:19:22.786]a representation of the self.
- [00:19:24.086]It's also present in some transsexual narratives,
- [00:19:26.626]and among people undergoing
- [00:19:28.086]sex reassignment surgeries.
- [00:19:29.946]In the past this has involved
- [00:19:31.286]a feeling of being trapped in the wrong body,
- [00:19:33.466]or being somehow out of
- [00:19:34.886]alignment with one's body,
- [00:19:37.585]although, reconfigured transgender bodies
- [00:19:40.745]as Sandy Stone has pointed out
- [00:19:42.845]have immeasurable progressive potential
- [00:19:45.505]disrupting traditional gender binaries,
- [00:19:48.005]and inserting new narratives
- [00:19:49.545]of the body's subject with radically
- [00:19:51.225]different histories of coming into being
- [00:19:53.245]into our social consciousness,
- [00:19:55.565]yet, the conventions of the contemporary
- [00:19:57.625]makeover culture valorize the notion that
- [00:20:00.504]valid selfhood is attained through transformations.
- [00:20:04.104]Makeovers intervened with class,
- [00:20:06.144]race, and gender inflicted improvements
- [00:20:09.004]that gain at legitimacy by speaking
- [00:20:11.244]through the idiom of identity
- [00:20:12.824]such that successful selfhood is attained
- [00:20:15.244]through the manipulation of the body
- [00:20:16.763]toward normative ideals.
- [00:20:18.983]The makeover phenomenon tells a story
- [00:20:21.043]of coherent and stable subject positions
- [00:20:23.361]located and expressed through
- [00:20:25.401]the made-over body
- [00:20:26.961]before our bodies quite often lack valid me-ness,
- [00:20:29.736]and after bodies mark the zone
- [00:20:32.116]of celebrated selfhood where subjects
- [00:20:33.915]rejoice "I'm me now!"
- [00:20:36.455]The notion of a mismatch between
- [00:20:38.695]body and subjects suggests an
- [00:20:40.294]organic or intrinsic misalignment
- [00:20:42.794]yet any interrogation of such incongruities
- [00:20:45.312]points to culturally constructed logics
- [00:20:48.092]as their source and sight.
- [00:20:49.951]Without the imposition of a cultural logic
- [00:20:52.811]of physical normalcy or even perfection
- [00:20:56.211]there would be no sense of a slippage
- [00:20:57.730]between self and body.
- [00:20:59.169]No need to take corrective action.
- [00:21:01.189]As Judith Butler following Foucault
- [00:21:03.289]has emphasized "Bodies only appear, only endure,
- [00:21:06.469]"only live within the productive constraints
- [00:21:09.749]"of certain highly gendered regulatory schemas."
- [00:21:13.469]Perhaps you remember the Greek myth
- [00:21:15.929]of Pygmalion the sculptor who crafted
- [00:21:18.249]the perfect statue of a woman,
- [00:21:20.329]and then prayed to the goddess Aphrodite
- [00:21:22.488]to bring her to life
- [00:21:23.868]which she did to his joy.
- [00:21:25.968]The Pygmalion dream is that of the male artist,
- [00:21:28.708]a visionary who acquires the power to realize,
- [00:21:31.468]indeed to reify his image of a perfect woman,
- [00:21:34.768]the embodiment of an ideal sexual partner.
- [00:21:38.428]In the myth Pygmalion claims to have
- [00:21:41.028]produced through art a beauty superior
- [00:21:43.388]to anything created by nature.
- [00:21:45.468]The image is purely corporeal.
- [00:21:47.328]"He's a sculptor, a plastic artist"
- [00:21:49.668]as Bernard Baars puts it,
- [00:21:51.704]"so his creation is material carved out of ivory
- [00:21:54.043]"an inanimate body without a spirit or soul,
- [00:21:56.803]"yet, the latter are projected by the creator
- [00:21:59.062]"onto his creation
- [00:22:00.602]"the physical determines,
- [00:22:02.182]"and defines the spiritual."
- [00:22:04.462]No longer working with ivory
- [00:22:06.462]modern day Pygmalions apply their artistry,
- [00:22:08.862]and vision to create perfect women
- [00:22:10.902]through a variety of sophisticated technologies
- [00:22:13.462]that are revolutionizing the sexual landscape.
- [00:22:17.921]Although, Playboy recently decided
- [00:22:20.041]not to show nude women anymore,
- [00:22:21.841]I don't know if you guys heard about that,
- [00:22:23.221]but just a few years back it actually
- [00:22:25.561]featured computer generated images
- [00:22:27.341]of women taking representations
- [00:22:29.201]of perfect bodies a step beyond
- [00:22:31.061]the routinely, digitally manipulated
- [00:22:33.499]photoshopped images common to
- [00:22:35.778]the contemporary publishing world.
- [00:22:38.018]Adult video games starring
- [00:22:39.432]nubile computer generated women
- [00:22:41.234]in sexual situations
- [00:22:42.752]are produced many by male programmers,
- [00:22:44.632]and artists for male audiences,
- [00:22:47.052]so as I just mentioned there are these
- [00:22:49.392]computer generated women
- [00:22:51.512]as in Grand Theft Auto that most of
- [00:22:54.887]the game designers are men,
- [00:22:57.452]and most of the intended audiences
- [00:23:00.601]are male, although, of course,
- [00:23:01.903]this is changing these days.
- [00:23:04.861]I'm gonna hope this link works,
- [00:23:06.581]but there was an Italian entrepreneur
- [00:23:10.001]named Franz Cerami who hosts
- [00:23:11.881]the Miss Digital World beauty pagent
- [00:23:15.219]where computer generated women
- [00:23:17.659]compete for the title.
- [00:23:19.958]The goal of the contest is to create
- [00:23:21.378]a contemporary ideal of beauty
- [00:23:23.178]through virtual reality.
- [00:23:25.218]I'll just show you a few moments of this.
- [00:23:35.618]You don't really even need sound for it.
- [00:23:37.378]You can see these images,
- [00:23:38.938]and they're all completely
- [00:23:44.077]computer generated.
- [00:23:46.256]Also, perhaps, you're familiar with this woman.
- [00:23:49.384]Dr. Frank Ryan was
- [00:23:50.756]the svengali like plastic surgeon
- [00:23:52.656]behind the transformation of Heidi Montag
- [00:23:55.556]whose notorious surgical adaptations
- [00:23:57.716]have included several breast augmentations
- [00:23:59.816]that reportedly produced triple D cup,
- [00:24:02.276]and then G cup sized breasts,
- [00:24:04.835]more than one rhinoplasty, liposuctions,
- [00:24:06.894]otoplasty or ear pinning,
- [00:24:08.614]and a variety of other cosmetic procedures.
- [00:24:10.634]She is said to have undergone
- [00:24:11.794]as many as 10 surgeries in a single day.
- [00:24:14.214]Following these operations
- [00:24:15.974]Montag posed for Playboy,
- [00:24:18.214]and starred in a sex video that was
- [00:24:19.693]widely circulated on the Internet.
- [00:24:22.013]Men, of course, are not always
- [00:24:24.033]the actual instigators or masterminds
- [00:24:26.051]behind such body remodeling
- [00:24:27.731]as Sandra Lee Bartky reminds us.
- [00:24:29.911]"The technologies of femininity
- [00:24:31.589]"are taken up and practiced by women.
- [00:24:33.809]"All women have internalized
- [00:24:35.369]"patriarchal standards of body acceptability.
- [00:24:38.027]"The fact that these female sexual ideals
- [00:24:40.607]"are cyborg creations,
- [00:24:42.447]"a fiction of technology and biology
- [00:24:44.746]"Franken-Babes of the sort,
- [00:24:46.866]"is not a hindrance to their appeal.
- [00:24:48.946]"In fact, the artifice at work seems to boost
- [00:24:51.181]"their desirability as they exemplify
- [00:24:53.461]"physical proportions and qualities
- [00:24:55.060]"that no unedited human woman could approach.
- [00:24:57.740]"The resultant cyborg bodies are then
- [00:24:59.920]"circulated via technologies of distribution
- [00:25:02.220]"that involve wireless global
- [00:25:04.019]"circuits of transmission.
- [00:25:05.679]"Technology intersects with the desirable,
- [00:25:07.819]"and desiring body at multiple points,
- [00:25:09.819]"and these processes are reflected
- [00:25:11.899]"in individual lives where people use
- [00:25:14.139]"digital imaging technologies
- [00:25:15.619]"to alter their own body images,
- [00:25:17.379]"and distribute them to friends
- [00:25:18.939]"via cellphones, social media, and the web."
- [00:25:22.898]Marcia Ochoa's ethnographic studies
- [00:25:24.958]in Venezuela reveal the parallel
- [00:25:26.838]self-modifications of transformistas,
- [00:25:29.338]transgender women and cisgender
- [00:25:31.438]beauty pageant contestants
- [00:25:33.458]noting the way that both modes of femininity
- [00:25:35.538]are achieved through similar practices
- [00:25:37.158]of cosmetic surgery, body modification,
- [00:25:39.478]makeup, and performativity,
- [00:25:41.058]and produced in citational relationship
- [00:25:43.397]to the same mediated ideals
- [00:25:45.057]of feminine beauty as she writes:
- [00:25:47.497]"Transformistas, like other Venezuelan women,"
- [00:25:50.597]and this is a transformista woman,
- [00:25:53.297]"assemble their notions of femininity
- [00:25:55.037]"from their bodies, their environments,
- [00:25:56.957]"the expectations placed on them
- [00:25:58.575]"by their communities.
- [00:25:59.975]"Their own ideas about the currency
- [00:26:01.675]"of specific forms of femininity,
- [00:26:03.635]"mass media, and the material forms
- [00:26:06.015]"of production available for the project
- [00:26:07.995]"of accomplishing femininity."
- [00:26:10.755]She situates her findings in
- [00:26:12.355]the Venezuelan context,
- [00:26:13.855]but the reach of global media
- [00:26:15.255]impacts and homogenizes ideals
- [00:26:17.575]of femininity and sexuality almost everywhere.
- [00:26:20.355]Modifying and imaging one's body
- [00:26:22.855]is now unremarkable.
- [00:26:24.454]Our understanding of our corporeality
- [00:26:25.934]is as firmly rooted in the notion
- [00:26:27.854]of bodies as cultural plastic,
- [00:26:30.154]mutable, and transmissible,
- [00:26:32.332]but as Susan Bordo has pointed out
- [00:26:34.731]"There are hidden philosophical currents
- [00:26:36.531]"lurking behind the notions of
- [00:26:38.189]"liberty, renewal, and self-determination
- [00:26:41.009]"invoked by this view.
- [00:26:42.769]"People are indeed increasingly free
- [00:26:44.589]"to physically or virtually sculpt
- [00:26:46.449]"their own bodies to fit the ideals,"
- [00:26:48.449]yet, as Bordo argues
- [00:26:50.287]"It's crucial not to lose sight
- [00:26:51.727]"of the normalizing power of cultural images,
- [00:26:54.586]"and the continuing social realities
- [00:26:56.526]"of dominance and subordination at work
- [00:26:58.566]"in these physical transformations."
- [00:27:00.606]She draws attention to the social directives
- [00:27:02.826]that drive such transformations.
- [00:27:04.946]Directives that reinforce hierarchies
- [00:27:07.046]of race, ethnicity, class, and gender
- [00:27:09.126]under an ingenuous post-modern rhetoric
- [00:27:12.946]of diversity and empowerment,
- [00:27:14.885]directives that are most often transmitted
- [00:27:16.785]via the mass media.
- [00:27:18.865]The ideals are not only
- [00:27:20.025]distributed via the media
- [00:27:21.344]they are media fabrications
- [00:27:22.844]partly, if not wholly, constructed by
- [00:27:25.044]digital imaging and other technologies.
- [00:27:27.404]For women a mediated standard
- [00:27:29.104]of the culturally desirable body
- [00:27:30.944]inevitably thin, yet voluptuous,
- [00:27:33.844]tending toward the Aryan fantasy
- [00:27:36.104]of the blue-eyed blonde
- [00:27:37.504]underpins and motivates
- [00:27:39.484]the creation of both virtual ...
- [00:27:44.602]The fantasy of a blue-eyed blonde
- [00:27:46.982]underpins and motivates the creation
- [00:27:48.701]of both virtual and flesh and blood
- [00:27:50.461]female physiques.
- [00:27:52.281]Power is thus infused into
- [00:27:53.641]our corporeal reshapings.
- [00:27:55.401]The technologies of physical transformation
- [00:27:57.441]intersect with the technologies
- [00:27:58.960]of communication to forge a complex
- [00:28:01.097]rack-and-pinion system of body politics.
- [00:28:04.227]In the contemporary world body schemas
- [00:28:07.057]are made real, reified through
- [00:28:08.954]visual representation and popular culture
- [00:28:10.974]in the mass media.
- [00:28:12.374]Body ideals are displayed, flaunted,
- [00:28:14.454]promoted, and iconized via cinematic,
- [00:28:17.134]and televisual print and online text
- [00:28:19.332]that not only reinscribe gender categories,
- [00:28:21.512]but forge symbolic linkages
- [00:28:23.312]among bodies, gender, and sexual identities
- [00:28:25.772]through a signifying economy of
- [00:28:27.632]visual and verbal codes.
- [00:28:29.372]In the text of popular media
- [00:28:31.192]gender categories are binary,
- [00:28:33.031]and sexuality is firmly intertwined
- [00:28:35.791]with achieving specific physical ideals.
- [00:28:38.271]These physical ideals have racialized
- [00:28:41.131]as well as gendered components.
- [00:28:43.110]Media sign systems naturalize and normalize
- [00:28:45.630]these regulatory schemas
- [00:28:47.730]turning them into common sense
- [00:28:49.670]while masking the ideological imperatives
- [00:28:51.710]at work in their design.
- [00:28:53.330]These imperatives are reflected,
- [00:28:54.830]and reinscribed in the images
- [00:28:56.330]transmitted by individuals
- [00:28:57.810]through social media sites and phone networks.
- [00:29:02.008]Many people
- [00:29:05.266]find pleasure, or seek pleasure through
- [00:29:07.726]these technological activities
- [00:29:09.386]be they cyber sexual practices,
- [00:29:11.046]or body reshaping surgeries.
- [00:29:13.185]When teenagers sext, for example,
- [00:29:15.365]they do not see the practice as problematic.
- [00:29:17.885]They understand sexting to be something
- [00:29:19.965]like love letters used to be,
- [00:29:21.505]an intimate exchange between lovers.
- [00:29:23.584]They even understand sexting as safe sex
- [00:29:26.164]in an era where they've been bludgeoned
- [00:29:27.984]with abstinence only messages
- [00:29:29.764]from the time they were young.
- [00:29:31.644]It's true, too, that there are for example
- [00:29:33.504]LGBTQ communities online
- [00:29:35.884]where people can find support,
- [00:29:37.564]and validation for non-normative
- [00:29:39.464]sexual orientations
- [00:29:40.924]just as there are body positive websites
- [00:29:43.304]that seek to challenge restrictive,
- [00:29:45.104]mainstream ideals of sexuality,
- [00:29:47.723]but we must remember that
- [00:29:49.343]Foucault understood sex to take shape
- [00:29:51.283]via spirals of power and pleasure.
- [00:29:53.483]He writes that the centralization of power,
- [00:29:55.923]and the gain of pleasure,
- [00:29:57.783]and we cannot only think
- [00:29:59.060]about genders and sexualities
- [00:30:00.500]in the digital era in relation to pleasure alone.
- [00:30:03.358]We must always heed the Foucauldian premise
- [00:30:05.718]that pleasure and power are mutually implicated,
- [00:30:08.858]the mobility and diffusion of modern power
- [00:30:11.518]proliferates and circumscribes pleasures.
- [00:30:14.238]As an example I'll refer briefly to
- [00:30:16.398]a recent New York Times magazine article
- [00:30:18.538]about a child who was the victim of
- [00:30:20.418]cyber pornography at the hands of her own father.
- [00:30:26.197]It's true that pleasure
- [00:30:27.277]was involved in this incident.
- [00:30:31.415]The pleasure of the father
- [00:30:32.975]who repeatedly recorded himself
- [00:30:34.415]raping his 10-year-old child,
- [00:30:37.275]making her smile at the camera,
- [00:30:39.013]and perform as though
- [00:30:40.033]she were enjoying it,
- [00:30:41.573]and the pleasure of the viewers
- [00:30:42.773]who downloaded and bought his imagery,
- [00:30:44.953]but, of course, the child was not
- [00:30:46.893]experiencing pleasure.
- [00:30:48.593]She was brutalized and exploited,
- [00:30:50.653]and as this story explains,
- [00:30:52.293]although she is grown,
- [00:30:53.432]and no longer in that situation
- [00:30:55.252]working to recover her life
- [00:30:56.892]the images are still out there.
- [00:30:59.952]In the quickest analysis of power and pleasure
- [00:31:02.731]she was powerless because of her age,
- [00:31:05.151]her situation, her gender,
- [00:31:07.271]and her relationship with her father.
- [00:31:09.251]She is powerless to control the images.
- [00:31:11.451]His power resulted in his pleasure,
- [00:31:13.891]and his financial gain,
- [00:31:15.591]and he's still at large.
- [00:31:23.111]The legal scholar Madeleine Mercedes Plasencia
- [00:31:25.727]points out that
- [00:31:26.665]"The Internet has in many ways increased
- [00:31:28.287]"physical risks to children,
- [00:31:29.925]"especially, in non First World settings."
- [00:31:32.705]She points out that
- [00:31:33.825]"Online networks facilitate the sexual abuse
- [00:31:36.285]"of minors internationally,
- [00:31:38.125]"and as we know the children of
- [00:31:39.545]"the global south are much more vulnerable
- [00:31:41.504]"to exploitation via child prostitution,
- [00:31:44.024]"sex trafficking, and pornography."
- [00:31:46.184]The anthropologist Heather Montgomery
- [00:31:48.004]conducted detailed ethnographic work
- [00:31:50.204]in a community in Thailand
- [00:31:51.643]where most of the children
- [00:31:52.683]including very young ones
- [00:31:54.403]from four years old and up
- [00:31:56.023]were engaged in prostitution
- [00:31:57.523]with foreign tourists.
- [00:31:59.143]Importantly, she notes that
- [00:32:00.602]"The commercial, sexual exploitation of children
- [00:32:02.622]"does not exist in a vacuum.
- [00:32:04.762]"The material specificities which arise
- [00:32:06.982]"from Thailand's position,
- [00:32:08.742]"and globalized political and economic relations
- [00:32:11.041]"perpetuate the sexual exploitation."
- [00:32:14.101]To me this point is crucial.
- [00:32:16.541]If we begin to think about pleasure
- [00:32:18.341]in relation to power,
- [00:32:20.261]and we recognize that sometimes
- [00:32:22.521]the pleasures of the more powerful
- [00:32:24.821]create tremendous danger
- [00:32:26.761]for the less powerful
- [00:32:28.261]we need a rubric or a heuristic
- [00:32:30.441]to assess the ethics of pleasure and danger
- [00:32:33.021]in relation to genders and sexualities
- [00:32:34.981]in a digital era.
- [00:32:36.661]I believe the heuristic rests on
- [00:32:38.881]two related concepts.
- [00:32:40.581]Embodied vulnerability,
- [00:32:42.681]and the politics of location.
- [00:32:45.121]The more seasoned feminist scholars
- [00:32:46.841]here today will know that the latter term,
- [00:32:48.481]the politics of location
- [00:32:50.161]is a term that is not new.
- [00:32:51.900]Adrienne Rich introduced
- [00:32:53.420]the idea 20 years ago.
- [00:32:55.138]We must recognize that cybersex
- [00:32:56.877]has material impacts
- [00:32:59.177]that virtual sexual practices
- [00:33:00.797]are connected with real world bodies
- [00:33:03.377]in a form of Machinic suture.
- [00:33:05.777]As the film scholar Linda Williams notes,
- [00:33:07.677]"Apparatus of sexuality
- [00:33:09.557]"wrap around the body,
- [00:33:10.637]"and it's sexual organs to produce
- [00:33:12.137]"different kinds of pleasure,
- [00:33:13.637]"and relations of alliance,
- [00:33:15.677]"so we must attend to the material context
- [00:33:18.117]"of material bodies when we assess
- [00:33:20.357]"the ethical implications of genders,
- [00:33:22.357]"and sexualities in the digital era.
- [00:33:24.537]"Although it's an accelerating idea
- [00:33:26.377]"to contemplate digital media
- [00:33:28.095]"as having no limits,
- [00:33:29.455]"especially, in relation to pleasure,
- [00:33:31.395]"as scholars we must be mindful
- [00:33:33.515]"of embodiment and its entailments."
- [00:33:36.015]In her book Precarious Life in the Frame of War
- [00:33:38.755]Judith Butler argues that
- [00:33:40.314]"We need a new bodily anthology,
- [00:33:42.813]"one that applies the rethinking of precariousness,
- [00:33:45.712]"vulnerability, indurability,
- [00:33:48.209]"interdependency, exposure."
- [00:33:50.969]Her recognition of life as precarious
- [00:33:52.988]is a call for ethics, feminist ethics.
- [00:33:56.148]The ethics of care also bring into view
- [00:33:58.806]the recognition that vulnerability
- [00:34:01.006]precipitates relationships that are
- [00:34:03.206]progressive, reparative
- [00:34:04.718]in their moral underpinnings.
- [00:34:06.618]When we think of digital media
- [00:34:08.058]we must understand it to encompass
- [00:34:09.638]sex positive connections and communities
- [00:34:12.398]as well as the realities of sexual exploitation,
- [00:34:16.078]cyber-stalking, revenge porn,
- [00:34:18.838]and other gendered and sexed terrors.
- [00:34:21.811]So as we've spent the day considering
- [00:34:24.588]a variety of aspects of this ever-changing,
- [00:34:27.228]still uncharted, and probably
- [00:34:29.467]unchartable new media environment
- [00:34:31.607]I hope these frameworks offer ways
- [00:34:33.707]to work out a position that recognizes
- [00:34:35.487]our virtual landscapes as contested terrains
- [00:34:38.567]where pleasures and dangers
- [00:34:40.467]interact and intersect
- [00:34:42.187]and where our understandings of these processes
- [00:34:44.545]can lead to real world changes
- [00:34:46.325]that ensure social justice and sexual safety.
- [00:34:50.085]Thank you so much for your time today.
- [00:34:53.864](applause)
- [00:35:03.004]I'll be glad to answer questions,
- [00:35:04.364]or if you have comments,
- [00:35:06.124]or thoughts about any of this.
- [00:35:08.822]When you were describing plastic surgery
- [00:35:10.281]I couldn't help but think of the culture
- [00:35:11.841]of our generation getting tattoos
- [00:35:13.681]in order to claim their bodies,
- [00:35:15.361]and I was wondering how you felt about that
- [00:35:17.161]in this world where we're perfecting our bodies
- [00:35:20.237]is that still the same damages
- [00:35:22.977]of the biological modification,
- [00:35:25.455]or the cyber babe that you were describing,
- [00:35:27.655]and how is it different?
- [00:35:28.795]That's a really interesting question.
- [00:35:31.135]I don't actually see it in quite the same way,
- [00:35:33.995]although, certainly tattoos are a certain trend.
- [00:35:36.215]I mean, we do have to look at them as being,
- [00:35:37.715]you know, sort of they've been fashionable
- [00:35:39.555]for the last, I don't know, 10 years or so,
- [00:35:41.790]whereas, like previous generations
- [00:35:43.706]tattoos were always seen as something
- [00:35:45.346]that only sailors and bikers got,
- [00:35:48.305]so there was certainly a class aspect to them.
- [00:35:51.335]There's a historical moment in which
- [00:35:53.785]tattoos have become popular,
- [00:35:55.782]and a way to convey a narrative,
- [00:35:58.862]but in that spirit I think there's
- [00:36:01.542]a lot of agency in tattooing,
- [00:36:03.202]and people usually get tattoos
- [00:36:04.481]because the symbols are meaningful to them.
- [00:36:08.240]I think in that sense there's an
- [00:36:10.100]individual level of tattooing,
- [00:36:11.840]and there's a personal connection to them
- [00:36:13.480]that's not quite the same as
- [00:36:15.280]the enforced mode of body modification
- [00:36:17.360]that Heidi Montag went through for example.
- [00:36:20.059]But would you say that
- [00:36:21.179]body modification can have that same effect?
- [00:36:23.879]Should you be getting a procedure
- [00:36:26.458]that was meaningful to you?
- [00:36:28.538]I guess my question is
- [00:36:30.078]you can't cancel out all of it,
- [00:36:32.237]so where do we draw the line?
- [00:36:34.137]That's a really interesting,
- [00:36:36.717]and challenging question for me.
- [00:36:39.897]When I think about the kinds of
- [00:36:41.877]plastic surgeries that I routinely see
- [00:36:45.092]they do conform to certain,
- [00:36:47.212]especially, racial hierarchies,
- [00:36:49.296]and also to a particular type of
- [00:36:52.332]"emphasized femininity" to use
- [00:36:54.492]Robert Connell's term.
- [00:36:56.569]Generally, it's in the direction of larger breasts.
- [00:37:00.252]Generally, it's in the direction of liposuction
- [00:37:02.469]to make the body thinner.
- [00:37:04.089]Generally, it's in the direction of
- [00:37:05.809]skin tanning and hair bleaching.
- [00:37:07.489]So there's a certain directive that
- [00:37:09.589]actually reinforces racial,
- [00:37:11.589]and gendered power structures.
- [00:37:14.049]I don't think tattoos operate
- [00:37:15.909]in quite the same way.
- [00:37:17.669]I think examining them in light
- [00:37:20.089]of whether they are reinforcing those
- [00:37:22.688]same social hierarchies is maybe one way
- [00:37:24.788]to think of them differently.
- [00:37:27.947]Thank you for the very interesting talk.
- [00:37:31.866]I cannot remember what state
- [00:37:33.406]this was about, specifically,
- [00:37:34.626]but I read an article recently about a state,
- [00:37:36.523]I believe, someone introduced legislation.
- [00:37:38.883]I don't believe it was passed yet
- [00:37:40.143]that would decriminalize
- [00:37:42.503]sexting behavior between minors,
- [00:37:45.023]and so I'm wondering about your thoughts
- [00:37:47.083]on the criminal rules and regulations,
- [00:37:50.383]and the state authority
- [00:37:53.401]to try and regulate and negotiate,
- [00:37:57.021]and how we do that outside of the shoulds,
- [00:38:00.176]but, also, the legal side of things.
- [00:38:02.236]This is a huge, complicated question.
- [00:38:05.126]I'm not a lawyer so, actually, I can't speak
- [00:38:07.655]with authority about the legal aspects of it,
- [00:38:10.110]but certainly there's a lot of debate about
- [00:38:12.230]the use of child pornography statutes
- [00:38:14.550]to prosecute kids who are sexting.
- [00:38:16.990]Some states have changed it so that
- [00:38:19.470]if the children are close in age
- [00:38:21.890]then they're not prosecuted
- [00:38:24.410]under those same statutes,
- [00:38:25.710]but I think we need to think a whole lot more.
- [00:38:27.889]These issues are still being debated.
- [00:38:30.229]I think one way to do it,
- [00:38:32.109]and one reason, actually,
- [00:38:33.269]that I'm thinking about this in ethical terms
- [00:38:35.249]in relation to embody vulnerability
- [00:38:38.329]I think that heuristic is actually one way
- [00:38:40.087]we can get at sexting
- [00:38:42.506]because sexting when kids do it
- [00:38:45.386]among each other between
- [00:38:48.084]two minor children
- [00:38:51.362]all the research indicates that
- [00:38:52.662]they think of it as something intimate,
- [00:38:54.542]something that's just happening
- [00:38:55.658]between two people,
- [00:38:56.778]and because of their developmental stage
- [00:38:58.498]they actually don't think about
- [00:38:59.818]the implications when it's circulated
- [00:39:01.558]more widely than that.
- [00:39:05.456]I think one of the ways that
- [00:39:06.936]we have to think about it is
- [00:39:08.356]what happens when sexting
- [00:39:10.516]moves into the broader arena
- [00:39:12.956]where it is then accessed by adults and so on.
- [00:39:15.596]I think we have to think about it legally
- [00:39:18.276]much more carefully,
- [00:39:19.336]and with a lot more nuance
- [00:39:20.816]than we're doing right now
- [00:39:22.116]by simply imposing child ponography
- [00:39:25.595]prosecution against these kids.
- [00:39:30.515]Okay, so first off, thank you.
- [00:39:32.675]I think that your presentation was wonderful,
- [00:39:34.715]and I think that especially your presentation
- [00:39:38.335]was both interesting, relevant,
- [00:39:40.815]and intersectional in a true sense,
- [00:39:44.555]in a true genuine sense,
- [00:39:46.255]so I appreciate that,
- [00:39:48.214]especially, when we talk about
- [00:39:49.574]trans issues which is close to my heart.
- [00:39:51.773]So you talk about transsexuality,
- [00:39:54.033]and, normally, I wouldn't like that word,
- [00:39:57.111]but, I think, in this particular instance
- [00:39:58.571]when you're talking about
- [00:39:59.849]body modification it's appropriate.
- [00:40:06.707]Do you think that all body modifications
- [00:40:08.947]that are sought by transgender indiviuals
- [00:40:12.267]are inherently like
- [00:40:16.225]re-inscribed in those ideals or not
- [00:40:19.225]because, personally, I don't think so,
- [00:40:21.045]but I'm just curious
- [00:40:22.145]because you talk about inscribing vulnerability.
- [00:40:25.263]I'm, actually, so glad you asked
- [00:40:26.744]because I think it would be easy
- [00:40:27.702]to make that assumption that I thought that,
- [00:40:29.319]but I actually don't.
- [00:40:30.579]I'm actually extremely grateful to
- [00:40:31.999]the people who undergo
- [00:40:34.497]transsexual surgeries
- [00:40:37.117]because they're revealing what
- [00:40:39.617]a construction those ideals of femininity are,
- [00:40:42.277]and so they're bringing to light
- [00:40:43.897]the fact that these are completely
- [00:40:46.097]sort of artificial social creations
- [00:40:48.497]that can be achieved by anyone, really,
- [00:40:51.577]so I love that, and I also love what
- [00:40:54.015]Sandy Stone said that
- [00:40:57.930]the transsexual genders, if I can say that,
- [00:41:01.190]are bringing into the world
- [00:41:04.589]a completely different notion of gender
- [00:41:07.449]with different origins,
- [00:41:09.269]and they're really disrupting our binaries,
- [00:41:11.029]and our sort of emphasized femininity,
- [00:41:13.169]and hegemonic masculinity
- [00:41:14.629]in ways that I think are wonderful.
- [00:41:16.027]Cool, thank you.
- [00:41:17.869]I hoped that in the process of
- [00:41:19.907]walking to the mic I would turn
- [00:41:21.187]my comment into a question.
- [00:41:23.147]I think it's still a comment,
- [00:41:25.247]but this is really fascinating to me.
- [00:41:29.565]I'm a cultural historian.
- [00:41:30.925]I work on the early 19th Century,
- [00:41:32.544]and I'm always thinking about
- [00:41:33.501]the problems of how you figure out
- [00:41:35.321]what are the different cultural texts
- [00:41:37.481]that need to be in play
- [00:41:39.541]to sort of solve a problem, right?
- [00:41:42.041]And so when you talked about
- [00:41:43.901]for us today media is really
- [00:41:45.961]the environment in which we live
- [00:41:48.381]that seems to me that it creates
- [00:41:51.061]a host of real methodological problems
- [00:41:53.939]for thinking about projects that
- [00:41:55.796]involve reading particular cultural texts
- [00:41:58.096]because there are always these, like,
- [00:42:00.236]Internet battles about is this a feminist,
- [00:42:03.271]you know, movie, like is Frozen feminist,
- [00:42:05.371]is it not feminist?
- [00:42:06.791]We know that there's this kind of barrier
- [00:42:10.191]that we always come to in that framing,
- [00:42:12.811]but that what you described
- [00:42:15.471]is a really interesting way of trying to
- [00:42:17.990]create a different angle for starting
- [00:42:20.610]to re-frame how we think about those problems.
- [00:42:23.807]So, anyway, thank you for that.
- [00:42:27.781]I'm glad you said that
- [00:42:29.327]because that's exactly
- [00:42:30.579]kind of how I was coming to it
- [00:42:32.139]because we do reach those impasses, right?
- [00:42:34.859]I actually went to a presentation
- [00:42:36.878]last night on feminist art,
- [00:42:38.638]and that same argument surfaced.
- [00:42:40.758]What is feminist art?
- [00:42:41.958]How do you define feminist art?
- [00:42:43.278]Is it feminist if the artist
- [00:42:45.036]identifies herself as a feminist,
- [00:42:46.636]and what if she doesn't?
- [00:42:47.596]So it went on like that.
- [00:42:49.514]It's the same thing like we come into
- [00:42:51.034]these sort of pitched battles around sex work,
- [00:42:53.334]and issues of consent
- [00:42:55.054]which are extremely tricky,
- [00:42:56.854]and so what is the feminist position?
- [00:42:58.774]There are arguments on both sides
- [00:43:00.274]when people are thinking,
- [00:43:01.694]so I want to intervene with this idea
- [00:43:04.134]of embodied vulnerability.
- [00:43:07.284]What is the vulnerability of the people involved?
- [00:43:09.852]What are the power of relations at stake?
- [00:43:14.089]How can we think about
- [00:43:15.409]precarity or precariousness
- [00:43:17.629]which also allows us
- [00:43:20.487]to think about those politics of location.
- [00:43:23.047]The class positions,
- [00:43:25.544]the geopolitical positions,
- [00:43:28.564]things like that that might put people
- [00:43:30.744]in certain circumstances where
- [00:43:33.244]certain types of sexual practices,
- [00:43:35.824]certain types of sexual exploitation
- [00:43:37.964]are almost inevitable,
- [00:43:39.304]and they are sometimes read as choices
- [00:43:41.943]because there are no alternatives.
- [00:43:44.283]It's true that that's a way
- [00:43:46.143]to gain resources when there are no others,
- [00:43:48.423]but I think if we can introduce that
- [00:43:50.743]into the framework of our thinking
- [00:43:52.683]maybe making those sorts of changes,
- [00:43:54.923]the material changes, the socioeconomic changes
- [00:43:57.642]then that would allow for us
- [00:44:01.082]to really consider agency in a different way.
- [00:44:07.180]Earlier when you were talking about,
- [00:44:10.056]I guess, embodied vulnerability,
- [00:44:12.116]and child pornography,
- [00:44:14.376]and the ways that people can be exploited
- [00:44:18.654]via technology,
- [00:44:20.909]especially, now since the sex industry is becoming
- [00:44:23.269]like so, I guess, globalized in a way,
- [00:44:26.765]and it's become really expanded,
- [00:44:28.685]especially, since it's way easier
- [00:44:30.103]for people to travel back and forth.
- [00:44:32.763]Do you think that with technology
- [00:44:34.819]there are ways to make the sex industry
- [00:44:38.039]safer for the people involved,
- [00:44:40.439]or is there a way for the sex industry
- [00:44:43.399]to become empowering
- [00:44:45.019]as opposed to exploitative?
- [00:44:47.536]I think there are empowering aspects
- [00:44:49.735]of online sexuality,
- [00:44:51.075]and, I think, I mentioned a few of them.
- [00:44:52.795]I mean, certainly there are like
- [00:44:54.414]LGBTQ communities where people
- [00:44:55.854]can find support and validation
- [00:44:57.294]for sexual orientations
- [00:45:00.291]that might be marginalized,
- [00:45:01.491]or persecuted in their real lives,
- [00:45:06.389]so there are ways in which,
- [00:45:07.829]I think, it is empowering,
- [00:45:08.869]and, certainly, as far as truly consensual sex
- [00:45:11.708]between adults goes, I mean,
- [00:45:13.248]I'm a complete libertarian as far as that goes
- [00:45:15.408]if nobody is getting hurt, right?
- [00:45:18.943]There are those other circumstances
- [00:45:21.363]that we have to consider,
- [00:45:22.823]and those are the places in which
- [00:45:24.563]there's sexual violence happens,
- [00:45:26.703]and we all understand that sex
- [00:45:29.463]can be extremely dangerous.
- [00:45:30.903]Online sex and real world sex as well,
- [00:45:33.423]but cyber stalking, and you know,
- [00:45:35.423]sort of revenge pornography,
- [00:45:36.943]and the kinds of things that are happening online
- [00:45:38.823]are impacting people materially
- [00:45:40.903]in very, very terrible ways.
- [00:45:44.281]Again, I want to sort of introduce that idea
- [00:45:46.381]of thinking about the material vulnerability
- [00:45:49.360]of the people engaging in those practices,
- [00:45:51.860]and the factors that
- [00:45:55.076]lend themselves to, or create those vulnerabilities.
- [00:45:57.896]If we can address those factors
- [00:45:59.176]then maybe we can find a way
- [00:46:00.496]to make online sex empowering and safe.
- [00:46:03.450]Thanks again to
- [00:46:04.550]Dr. Durham for that talk.
- [00:46:05.930]Thank you.
- [00:46:07.077](applause)
The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!
You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.
Log in to post comments
Embed
Copy the following code into your page
HTML
<div style="padding-top: 56.25%; overflow: hidden; position:relative; -webkit-box-flex: 1; flex-grow: 1;"> <iframe style="bottom: 0; left: 0; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; border: 0; height: 100%; width: 100%;" src="https://mediahub.unl.edu/media/5272?format=iframe&autoplay=0" title="Video Player: Durham Keynote: Pleasure and Danger" allowfullscreen ></iframe> </div>
Comments
0 Comments