Changing Conceptions of Kindergarten Literacy Learning: Q&A Session with Elfreida "Freddy" Hiebert
TLTE
Author
11/20/2014
Added
218
Plays
Description
2014 Helen Kelly Symposium for Excellence in Education:
Changing Conceptions of Kindergarten Literacy Learning
Question and Answer Session
Elfreida "Freddy" Hiebert
Searchable Transcript
Toggle between list and paragraph view.
- [00:00:00.139](relaxed music)
- [00:00:14.804]What a fantastic resource textproject.org is.
- [00:00:20.531]If you have not gone to that website,
- [00:00:22.896]please do,
- [00:00:24.496]because there are so many resouces for teachers
- [00:00:27.685]and for children on it.
- [00:00:32.100]All right, okay. Are you ready?
- [00:00:34.266]All right, Freddy.
- [00:00:37.115]Why did the researchers you cite
- [00:00:39.430]say that kindergarten has been dumbed down?
- [00:00:50.714]So the first slide that I started with, right?
- [00:00:55.930]I don't think I'm gonna go all the way back there.
- [00:00:58.671]The first slide I started with was the common core.
- [00:01:05.926]Why did the people who wrote the common core
- [00:01:09.182]say that K through 12
- [00:01:11.475]had been dumbed down?
- [00:01:13.480]If you've been in a school
- [00:01:18.192]in the last 10 years,
- [00:01:20.144]you knew that that wasn't the case for K.
- [00:01:22.704]It logically wasn't possible,
- [00:01:24.752]because until No Child Left Behind,
- [00:01:26.746]there were no books for kids in kindergarten.
- [00:01:30.117]Why did they say that?
- [00:01:32.773]I think it was
- [00:01:38.141]a provocative stance.
- [00:01:40.199]They had three studies--
- [00:01:43.456]First of all, it wasn't true
- [00:01:45.297]all the way through sixth grade.
- [00:01:48.592]So the data that they were using,
- [00:01:53.917]for first grade they actually based it on
- [00:01:56.694]the Dick and Jane books,
- [00:01:58.347]on Jeanne Chall's 1967 analysis.
- [00:02:01.899]Why did those people do it?
- [00:02:03.403]Well, just like Mussolini, they got the report in on time.
- [00:02:08.459]I mean, to their credit, they did it in a year.
- [00:02:11.552]And I guess there was lots of not fact checking.
- [00:02:14.090]I think they wanted to tell a story.
- [00:02:16.672]There were some industry reasons
- [00:02:21.142]why this story was cool,
- [00:02:23.252]to say that the texts had been dumbed down,
- [00:02:25.546]and I think they believed it.
- [00:02:31.401]I don't think they needed data,
- [00:02:32.820]I think they believed it.
- [00:02:35.241]Now, in terms of the Closens statement,
- [00:02:38.430]Closens was using the 1998
- [00:02:41.855]early childhood longitudinal data
- [00:02:44.266]and those data were gathered before
- [00:02:47.743]No Child Left Behind.
- [00:02:49.514]And basically what she was saying is,
- [00:02:51.380]you know how I showed that every copyright,
- [00:02:54.036]they just kept adding on more stuff?
- [00:02:56.564]She was saying that when the schools use
- [00:03:00.459]the letter naming,
- [00:03:03.969]and the letter sound matching,
- [00:03:05.744]and the kids already know it,
- [00:03:06.981]that's a waste of their time.
- [00:03:08.655]And I would completely agree with that.
- [00:03:10.906]But to come out in 2013 with a statement that
- [00:03:15.462]kindergarten is too easy,
- [00:03:17.700]or to let that interpretation be made of your research,
- [00:03:21.849]they're actually saying it needs to be more advanced.
- [00:03:24.611]That, to me, again is one of these issues of
- [00:03:28.836]what are the consequences
- [00:03:32.921]of the research that we do?
- [00:03:36.067]I think as researchers we have to think of that.
- [00:03:39.662]So if this comes out
- [00:03:44.792]and it could be misinterpreted,
- [00:03:46.591]how can I stop those misinterpretations?
- [00:03:54.407]So the Closens one,
- [00:03:55.938]I mean we can actually validate that with the next,
- [00:03:58.742]the 2010, whether, in fact,
- [00:04:01.729]the kids have gotten smarter
- [00:04:03.841]as a result of more stuff in preschool.
- [00:04:05.876]I hope that all of you don't think that...
- [00:04:09.205]You know, I'm looking for a really rich
- [00:04:10.794]kindergarten experience.
- [00:04:12.213]I think we had the model in 1990.
- [00:04:18.210]I think we had it.
- [00:04:20.940]I think it was great.
- [00:04:26.343]One of the things we've been talking about
- [00:04:28.021]at some of the tables is also
- [00:04:29.322]the consequences for teachers,
- [00:04:31.412]of having to teach some of this.
- [00:04:35.071]And that's hard, to teach these little kids,
- [00:04:40.309]to recite this stuff that doesn't
- [00:04:43.305]make a lot of sense.
- [00:04:48.675]Just a question from me.
- [00:04:50.175]When you're talking about teachers,
- [00:04:53.651]and you're thinking about teachers,
- [00:04:56.083]do you find that there is
- [00:04:59.805]some misinterpretation of what's being asked,
- [00:05:06.278]in some ways, from the original policy
- [00:05:10.919]or the original suggestions
- [00:05:13.479]to how it filters down to teachers in the schools?
- [00:05:20.615]I think kindergarten teachers
- [00:05:22.972]have been one of the last bastions
- [00:05:25.191]of child centered-ness.
- [00:05:31.526]And what I see, in the state of California at least...
- [00:05:35.760]I mean, one of the good things about coming from California,
- [00:05:38.416]and about the whole state,
- [00:05:39.718]one of the reasons we have California,
- [00:05:41.381]is because they can do a lot of this stuff
- [00:05:43.579]and you can watch them do it.
- [00:05:45.272]You can watch them do it and then decide not to do that.
- [00:05:47.440](audience laughs)
- [00:05:48.869]You know, so they're always a case study
- [00:05:50.490]in maybe we shouldn't do it that way.
- [00:05:52.985]But what I see is a lot of retirements
- [00:05:55.747]of kindergarten teachers,
- [00:05:57.840]long time, very good kindergarten teachers.
- [00:06:00.036]Maybe it was time.
- [00:06:01.380]But I'm not seeing the misinterpretations were the teachers.
- [00:06:05.316]I'm seeing the misinterpretations
- [00:06:07.636]with the administrators,
- [00:06:11.860]I'm seeing the misinterpretations with
- [00:06:14.889]the people who are concerned about test scores.
- [00:06:17.769]I'm not seeing it with teachers.
- [00:06:19.251]I think the teachers have held out as long as they can,
- [00:06:22.099]and I've sat with kindergarten teachers
- [00:06:24.659]who've described what it's like not to be able to
- [00:06:29.356]have kids do some of the art and some of the conversations
- [00:06:33.325]and some of the play acting that they used to be able to do.
- [00:06:38.220]Now, Marjorie just left, and she--
- [00:06:40.603]No, I'm right here.
- [00:06:41.788]She's here.
- [00:06:42.684]Why don't you tell about that study
- [00:06:44.447]that you just found today.
- [00:06:45.947]Some of us get a little exchange,
- [00:06:49.851]the little exchange notes,
- [00:06:51.824]and some of you read this study about kindergarten.
- [00:06:55.173]So Caroline, do you want to tell what it said.
- [00:06:57.776]Well, I think it said that at kindergarten,
- [00:06:59.844]that all our focus is only on outcomes
- [00:07:01.882]and not on learning.
- [00:07:03.952]There was also how they spent their time,
- [00:07:07.344]and they spent more time on
- [00:07:10.414]direct instruction and reading...
- [00:07:12.647]Spent more time on direct instruction and reading
- [00:07:15.813]than everything else combined.
- [00:07:18.575]And less than ten percent of the time
- [00:07:20.675]was spent on science, math, social studies,
- [00:07:23.396]health, physical activity.
- [00:07:26.039]So we really are seeing a kindergarten curriculum
- [00:07:30.061]that used to be a whole child focused curriculum,
- [00:07:33.543]And this was a study of children from,
- [00:07:36.697]it was over, like, a seven year period.
- [00:07:39.640]Did I get this right, for those of you who saw that?
- [00:07:43.340]Yeah.
- [00:07:50.828]What do you think of the Montessori approach
- [00:07:52.599]to teaching reading?
- [00:07:54.444]I believe that it involves writing to read.
- [00:08:00.951]So the Montessori approach...
- [00:08:07.733]I think it's great, the question is who gets it, right?
- [00:08:11.553]I mean, in my community...
- [00:08:16.267]I think the notion of kids
- [00:08:18.282]doing a lot of hands on activities...
- [00:08:21.312]I mean, if you think about it,
- [00:08:23.199]the alphabet is one of the most abstract
- [00:08:26.004]notions little kids encounter.
- [00:08:31.124]Then the next abstract thing they encounter,
- [00:08:33.129]and I'm gonna come back to describing that a little bit,
- [00:08:35.508]the next abstract thing they encounter
- [00:08:37.503]are the high frequency words.
- [00:08:39.891]So for those of you who aren't in literacy,
- [00:08:42.698]a guy made his name, his name was Ed Dolch,
- [00:08:47.208]and he made his name by putting
- [00:08:50.174]together a list of the most frequent words.
- [00:08:55.517]So about 25 words in English
- [00:08:59.378]account for 33 percent of the words you read.
- [00:09:02.388]Somebody figured that out around 1920,
- [00:09:06.568]and then Ed Dolch took those 25 words
- [00:09:09.745]and then added some more.
- [00:09:11.080]And then now,
- [00:09:12.786]that's typically what kids get
- [00:09:15.816]after they learn the alphabet,
- [00:09:17.094]so when you saw that one slide with the sight words,
- [00:09:18.822]that's what they were talking about.
- [00:09:20.327]Well, it turns out that "the"
- [00:09:22.555]accounts for seven percent of the words in written English,
- [00:09:27.218]for the texts all of us read, too.
- [00:09:31.280]I've always thought that I should've copywritten them.
- [00:09:33.285](audience laughs)
- [00:09:34.683]I would still be doing this.
- [00:09:36.345]But think about the word "the".
- [00:09:40.538]First of all, it has an irregular sound for the T-H,
- [00:09:47.811]and it also has an irregular sound for E.
- [00:09:51.427]Now, turn to your partner, to somebody next to you,
- [00:09:53.924]and define it.
- [00:09:55.406]Not use it, but define "the".
- [00:09:58.500](audience laughs)
- [00:10:00.589]And then the word "a" and "of".
- [00:10:02.659]You know?
- [00:10:04.556]I mean, first of all, they don't teach you
- [00:10:07.278]about the alphabet very well,
- [00:10:08.919]about the letter sound system,
- [00:10:10.734]and they're really abstract, weird words.
- [00:10:13.676]So anything you can do
- [00:10:17.410]to get kids hands on, in terms of sorting words,
- [00:10:20.272]writing words, writing with magnetic letters,
- [00:10:23.501]knowing why you have books,
- [00:10:27.009]knowing why you would want to find things out from books.
- [00:10:33.452]And see, the place that I do my work is where
- [00:10:35.702]99 percent of the kids are the children of farm workers.
- [00:10:41.900]And they are so amenable, when they're five years old,
- [00:10:46.230]to doing what these people ask them to do.
- [00:10:50.538]And I'll tell you, we've got
- [00:10:51.456]the biggest gang problem on the planet
- [00:10:52.971]in fifth grade.
- [00:10:55.573]But you know, those little guys,
- [00:10:57.162]I mean, yeah, they're starting to...
- [00:10:58.687](imitates child speaking)
- [00:11:02.506]I mean, in their language, if they're Spanish speaking,
- [00:11:06.101]they have very few single syllable words.
- [00:11:12.991]Turns out they've got a lot of these really great words
- [00:11:15.711]that help you with literary and scientific text.
- [00:11:19.774]Like, they don't use a word like "bug",
- [00:11:21.577]they use "insecto".
- [00:11:26.702]So what I've been doing is just trying to
- [00:11:29.758]find things that are highly concrete
- [00:11:31.976]and that you want know about,
- [00:11:33.127]like cats, and dogs, and elephants, and snails,
- [00:11:36.018]and firetrucks.
- [00:11:39.143]Those are things that you want to learn about,
- [00:11:41.053]and that's really concrete.
- [00:11:43.047]But "the"? Not so much.
- [00:11:46.641]So Montessori, anything that we can do
- [00:11:48.913]to do some of the movement.
- [00:11:51.580]But in my community, the kids that get Montessori...
- [00:11:54.631]I mean, when Maria Montessori,
- [00:11:57.222]she developed the program for the children of the poor.
- [00:12:00.476]That's not how it's working out right now.
- [00:12:07.184]This kind of tags along with what you were just saying.
- [00:12:11.003]There's a nutrition benchmark
- [00:12:13.296]for child case studies,
- [00:12:16.794]and it says, "Teach children about food through books."
- [00:12:23.175]Do you think that increasing familiarity
- [00:12:25.722]with different kinds of foods in that way
- [00:12:28.346]will help children be more likely to try it?
- [00:12:32.281]What do you recommend about materials to use?
- [00:12:35.652]Would it be, like, ham?
- [00:12:37.038](audience laughs)
- [00:12:46.032]I could give you almost any topic,
- [00:12:49.869]with some content, and find you some interesting books,
- [00:12:52.931]and we could get kids interested in it.
- [00:12:55.416]So I think highly of the value of good books
- [00:12:59.459]to be an educational source,
- [00:13:03.809]if I'm understanding the question right.
- [00:13:07.340]Is this stuff that we're giving them now
- [00:13:09.900]that kind of diet?
- [00:13:12.610]What would one of those books look like?
- [00:13:14.593]Cake is not good. Cake is bad.
- [00:13:18.252]I mean, I'm trying to write a book right now
- [00:13:20.855]in my mind of what you would tell them not to do.
- [00:13:27.398]Bob ate chips. Bob is dead.
- [00:13:31.201]I don't...
- [00:13:32.171](audience laughing)
- [00:13:39.754]Chips are bad. No, Bob, no.
- [00:13:44.309]I think we could come up with a series.
- [00:13:46.111]Each table make another one of these.
- [00:13:48.468]We could probably have a best seller,
- [00:13:50.646]and we could probably go out to
- [00:13:52.224]a local school district and sell it as common...
- [00:13:55.317]Well, not common core in Nebraska,
- [00:13:57.268]but common core compliant.
- [00:14:02.259]I'm gonna ask a question that,
- [00:14:04.660]I don't know if Guy is still here or not,
- [00:14:06.269]but Guy and I have been
- [00:14:07.977]very interested in, in the last few years,
- [00:14:11.956]and that's the integration of technology.
- [00:14:15.689]But you hear pros and cons about
- [00:14:20.040]using technology with very young children.
- [00:14:23.367]What do you think about that for
- [00:14:25.767]getting them involved in all sorts of literacy?
- [00:14:30.482]Okay, so the question about technology...
- [00:14:35.710]My husband shared with me that on the charts...
- [00:14:39.665]We're Canadians, eh. Watch a lot of hockey.
- [00:14:43.773]So that on the charts the Rosetta Stone has now gone into
- [00:14:48.017]some kind of little exercise for kids and literacy.
- [00:14:56.239]So the one set of books that I showed you,
- [00:14:58.258]we give books,
- [00:14:59.600]those are all ebooks,
- [00:15:01.627]and all of the books that I create are ebooks.
- [00:15:04.378]I don't know the research in this area.
- [00:15:11.487]There are a lot of reports coming out.
- [00:15:14.907]I would also say that there are just some really stupid
- [00:15:18.681]little exercises that really poor parents...
- [00:15:21.998]You know, because a lot of poor families now have mobiles,
- [00:15:25.177]mobile phones, and they're really selling to those families
- [00:15:29.273]some really stupid little exercises.
- [00:15:32.835]I mean, I try to change the world one kid at a time,
- [00:15:35.355]you know, like in airports and grocery stores,
- [00:15:38.199]but I don't think I'm gonna get around to all of them.
- [00:15:41.947]So I'm just saying, to me it's an issue
- [00:15:45.221]of what the technology is doing.
- [00:15:48.240]And what I see is there's a lot of marketing, a lot,
- [00:15:52.506]to places like Costco,
- [00:15:56.544]for some really...
- [00:15:59.917]Things that are a waste of money.
- [00:16:03.515]But can some things be good?
- [00:16:05.040]I mean, obviously we think that they are.
- [00:16:06.746]You can have a lot of these books
- [00:16:08.101]on ebooks and so on.
- [00:16:13.104]But that's not my area.
- [00:16:14.788]You guys know more about that than I do.
- [00:16:19.994]Are there some more questions?
- [00:16:22.106]Did all the tables ask me questions?
- [00:16:25.539]Did you all have... Is this it?
- [00:16:27.897]We didn't get a card for every table,
- [00:16:30.307]so if that's what your question was.
- [00:16:32.805]Anybody want to raise their hand and ask me something?
- [00:16:36.712]Sam?
- [00:16:37.436]So can you help us distinguish,
- [00:16:39.922]and you know where I am in this,
- [00:16:42.097]but can you help us distinguish between
- [00:16:43.741]essentially dumbed down kindergarten curriculum
- [00:16:46.214]and intellectually challenging, rigorous curriculum
- [00:16:50.950]that doesn't fall over into
- [00:16:55.612]curriculum that is really inappropriate.
- [00:17:00.434]As you've been critical in terms of (mumbles).
- [00:17:03.419]Well, I don't know how explicit I was
- [00:17:05.594]through this process.
- [00:17:07.196]So there was a group of us,
- [00:17:09.690]in the late '70s through the '80s,
- [00:17:13.754]who really raised a lot of questions
- [00:17:17.657]about what we thought was
- [00:17:19.877]intellectually impoverished kindergarten.
- [00:17:24.590]Where kids were doing these these little exercises
- [00:17:27.857]like the N how many times in front of "nail",
- [00:17:31.311]and ticking off little pictures and so on.
- [00:17:37.147]I think literacy is much more than that,
- [00:17:43.023]and I think we had a model,
- [00:17:44.985]and I think it was actually a fairly fleshed out
- [00:17:48.301]and appropriate model
- [00:17:50.776]at the end of the '80s,
- [00:17:52.364]that was starting to enter into various programs.
- [00:17:57.761]And I think the presence of big books was important to that.
- [00:18:01.783]I think what happened in the Texas, California, Florida
- [00:18:06.903]textbook adoptions in 1993,
- [00:18:11.426]2000, and then No Child Left Behind,
- [00:18:13.696]which modelled what had happened in Texas,
- [00:18:16.011]I think that all that work got disintegrated.
- [00:18:21.237]So I think we have a model
- [00:18:23.416]of kids doing a lot of
- [00:18:25.525]tracking print in interesting little books
- [00:18:29.099]having to do with content around science,
- [00:18:32.331]social studies, mathematics.
- [00:18:35.434]I mean, from my perspective, if kids
- [00:18:38.400]don't come to understand that a text
- [00:18:41.205]is where you get information...
- [00:18:44.414]Our information as human beings
- [00:18:46.974]is stored in texts.
- [00:18:48.681]That's why the literacy is so important,
- [00:18:51.423]and you have to come at it through
- [00:18:54.153]projects, inquiry, discussions,
- [00:18:58.217]and books help you with that process.
- [00:19:02.930]So I think we have a model.
- [00:19:04.916]I think there are some good models of curriculum.
- [00:19:12.690]I think that I'm not going on a tangent here,
- [00:19:17.489]a rant about No Child Left Behind.
- [00:19:20.101]I think there were some good parts to it.
- [00:19:22.607]I think where the problem came is that
- [00:19:25.083]it was assumed that it started in kindergarten,
- [00:19:29.658]and it was a very direct, didactic model.
- [00:19:34.309]That's where the issue is, and to me,
- [00:19:36.441]Sam, it's neither challenging
- [00:19:39.471]or appropriate.
- [00:19:41.859]The stuff that I've been showing you
- [00:19:43.161]with the decodable model.
- [00:19:47.352]Some of the new things that have
- [00:19:48.547]come in with the common core,
- [00:19:50.031]like the big books around social studies and science,
- [00:19:52.184]I think that's good,
- [00:19:54.115]and the little books related to that.
- [00:19:56.345]Again, Caroline raised the point today,
- [00:19:58.456]Caroline Baxter, if some of you don't know her,
- [00:20:01.858]about whether the standard are aspirational
- [00:20:05.282]or mandatory.
- [00:20:07.853]What's our view?
- [00:20:09.436]Are we viewing it that a kid has to know
- [00:20:12.300]these almost 100 high frequency words,
- [00:20:14.903]and there's something wrong with the kid,
- [00:20:16.428]not the curriculum, if they don't?
- [00:20:19.532]And to me, it's a matter of incredible exposure.
- [00:20:22.358]I've watched some very smart
- [00:20:26.017]children in my acquaintance
- [00:20:28.267]who have had so many books,
- [00:20:34.362]including lots of little books,
- [00:20:36.747]lots of good models, lots of opportunities to write,
- [00:20:41.132]and I haven't seen any of those kids
- [00:20:44.267]learn to read as early five year olds.
- [00:20:50.336]Now, I'm not saying that they can't
- [00:20:52.086]and that some don't.
- [00:20:53.471]I mean, I did a dissertation, in Wisconsin,
- [00:20:55.839]where I found a three year old who could barely talk
- [00:20:58.239]who had been taught to read.
- [00:21:00.075]The guy could barely describe what the words were,
- [00:21:02.302]but he was reading them,
- [00:21:04.436]and his parent were so proud.
- [00:21:06.227]You know, I think I could start a whole industry
- [00:21:09.492]just getting first class tickets on planes
- [00:21:12.947]sitting beside young parents,
- [00:21:16.286]and when they describe their 19 month old
- [00:21:19.126]can do such and such with letters,
- [00:21:21.315]and all I would say is, "And they can't read yet?"
- [00:21:24.953]And I would start a whole consulting business right there.
- [00:21:28.078]I think it's become kind of so fashionable,
- [00:21:30.743]like, "Look at my three year old, they can do this."
- [00:21:34.275]And that's great for those kids,
- [00:21:36.301]so I'm talking about these other guys.
- [00:21:38.723]And I think it's possible, I think
- [00:21:42.945]every American child can read well
- [00:21:45.633]by the middle of second grade.
- [00:21:50.550]But some of them are gonna come at that
- [00:21:52.129]very different times,
- [00:21:53.537]and so I'll just have to see a lot of it
- [00:21:55.362]to understand why they're doing it.
- [00:21:57.579]And right now what we're doing is,
- [00:21:58.817]you get one book, and then we throw in this
- [00:22:02.006]Bob and ham stuff, and then
- [00:22:04.053]you're kinda going...
- [00:22:07.007]But hey, the lady said to do it, I'm gonna try.
- [00:22:11.126]So to me, it isn't challenging or appropriate,
- [00:22:14.336]is what I'm trying to say.
- [00:22:15.615]And Sam, the thing that just troubles me
- [00:22:22.456]is, other than this talk,
- [00:22:25.066]and an article you wrote in a blog,
- [00:22:27.956]and one that I wrote in a blog,
- [00:22:29.440]I haven't heard people asking
- [00:22:31.689]how this all happened so fast.
- [00:22:35.860]I mean, what we're seeing now
- [00:22:37.343]with the common core materials is
- [00:22:39.657]there's another spike.
- [00:22:41.832]Another what?
- [00:22:42.847]Another spike in expectations.
- [00:22:45.203]And I'm not hearing, at my professional conferences,
- [00:22:48.328]people holding up their hands and saying,
- [00:22:50.836]"This can't go on."
- [00:22:56.521]I mean, all we're gonna do is we're gonna make
- [00:22:59.794]more kids into problem readers earlier.
- [00:23:04.828]But some of you in this room know more about
- [00:23:07.772]things like this than I do, in terms of policy.
- [00:23:09.864]I hope I'm wrong.
- [00:23:13.382]But keep remembering, I'm in California,
- [00:23:16.210]and we're always off the mark first,
- [00:23:18.033]and it's not what I'm seeing.
- [00:23:20.390]Yes?
- [00:23:21.510]Given your opinions on expectations
- [00:23:24.806]that have been put on kindergarten children,
- [00:23:29.692]and some of the data that has reinforced that,
- [00:23:33.715]what are your thoughts about
- [00:23:35.774]those who would be interested
- [00:23:38.611]in more universal preschool,
- [00:23:40.221]or expanding Head Start and those kind of programs?
- [00:23:50.419]So I'm all for giving every single child
- [00:23:54.642]the experiences I saw today in, uh....
- [00:23:57.116]Keep telling me the name of it was (mumbles)
- [00:23:59.665](audience members call out inaudibly)
- [00:24:01.149]I mean, I get chills.
- [00:24:06.406]Wonderful.
- [00:24:09.149]I want kids to have that.
- [00:24:11.953]I guess my big question is
- [00:24:13.553]is that what's gonna happen?
- [00:24:17.520]You know, what I worry about is that
- [00:24:21.157]when we get test results back
- [00:24:24.016]in states like Florida and New York and California,
- [00:24:27.453]from the common core tests,
- [00:24:30.234]and the test results are gonna be with
- [00:24:31.823]third, fourth, and fifth graders,
- [00:24:33.243]not with kindergarten, first graders...
- [00:24:36.778]The problems never were with kindergarten, first grade.
- [00:24:39.586]We actually did a fairly good job with No Child Left Behind
- [00:24:42.413]in making some modest gain.
- [00:24:47.852]But I'm just afraid that
- [00:24:49.953]it's just gonna keep going down.
- [00:24:55.330]I mean, I want good stuff for all the kids.
- [00:25:00.022]Somebody was just describing to me
- [00:25:01.590]a program for two year olds.
- [00:25:03.724]That was just absolutely delightful.
- [00:25:08.949]But what I don't want
- [00:25:10.464]is somebody starting to think like,
- [00:25:12.928]"Well, it worked for my kid."
- [00:25:15.782]You know? "It worked for me,
- [00:25:18.776]"and look at me."
- [00:25:23.287]You have to understand, you know,
- [00:25:25.762]that if you walk into some place...
- [00:25:28.365]You know, I'm never going to be an Olympic skier.
- [00:25:31.512]I've been on skis once.
- [00:25:34.219]I can go over the list of things I will never do,
- [00:25:38.497]but I can tell you some things that I do,
- [00:25:41.186]and I've put in my 10,000 hours in different areas.
- [00:25:45.569]And some of these little guys
- [00:25:47.649]haven't even put in an hour with literacy,
- [00:25:50.348]and we're shoving this stuff down their throat.
- [00:25:53.943]And I worry an incredible amount
- [00:25:58.720]about...
- [00:26:01.824]The first question was why the K to 12 dumbing down?
- [00:26:06.357]Why the dumbing down all together?
- [00:26:09.077]Well, what a great message, you know?
- [00:26:10.719]Who wouldn't stand for more challenge?
- [00:26:12.800]Americans, we need more challenge.
- [00:26:15.401]I just worry, you know?
- [00:26:21.472]Test results don't look good,
- [00:26:23.689]you just push it down the little guys more,
- [00:26:27.785]and I think we're gonna pay for it.
- [00:26:30.857]I think that's what we're seeing in the middle school.
- [00:26:35.124]They're not enrolled, they're not engaged.
- [00:26:41.949]But if Sam and Caroline
- [00:26:45.298]can be in charge of all the
- [00:26:49.340]preschool, then I'm for it.
- [00:26:53.500]And maybe you can do a model like that in the state.
- [00:26:57.286]And that's actually why I spent
- [00:26:59.357]weeks thinking about this,
- [00:27:02.119]because I think you can here,
- [00:27:05.713]and you can show what could happen with kids
- [00:27:08.231]when they have those opportunities.
- [00:27:12.661]Because it actually turns out that that gain
- [00:27:14.866]that Closens talks about in the article,
- [00:27:17.449]a half a standard deviation,
- [00:27:18.952]by the end of first grade, you didn't make any difference.
- [00:27:24.039]But what if you could show an enormous difference
- [00:27:27.613]of these kids doing all these cool science books, you know?
- [00:27:35.720]I think you can do it here, you know?
- [00:27:37.872]You've got the infrastructure to do it.
- [00:27:41.426]That's why I actually said I would do this.
- [00:27:44.443]I know I depress some of the undergraduates.
- [00:27:46.354]Some of them are crying, but...
- [00:27:47.676](audience laughing)
- [00:27:51.429]Maybe the Kelleys think,
- [00:27:52.390]"I don't know about this symposium idea any more."
- [00:27:54.683](audience laughing)
- [00:27:56.208]But I actually think you can do it here.
- [00:28:01.424]And, see, I think, in terms of all these things
- [00:28:03.727]we think about young children, nutrition, whatever,
- [00:28:06.629]I think when their first institutional experience in school
- [00:28:10.692]is one of, essentially, being bullied,
- [00:28:15.844]I think that that's wrong.
- [00:28:19.044]And I think you guys have got a chance.
- [00:28:22.575]If there's some way I could be part of it and help,
- [00:28:24.571]I would like to.
- [00:28:25.625]And we know what to do.
- [00:28:27.577]We've done it.
- [00:28:31.256]You know?
- [00:28:32.206]And the name of the school that I can never remember,
- [00:28:34.606]they're doing it.
- [00:28:35.886](laughs)
- [00:28:38.767]I'm the daughter of a minister,
- [00:28:40.515]you all know that, right?
- [00:28:42.061]And the first thing I could do when I was
- [00:28:45.029]a little kid was do an altar call.
- [00:28:47.586]I've been to so many revival services.
- [00:28:50.125]But then they told me I couldn't be a minister in my church,
- [00:28:52.483]so I found something... I found (mumbles).
- [00:28:55.607](audience laughs)
- [00:28:56.646]Did you have a question?
- [00:28:57.819]What does that mean internationally?
- [00:28:59.751]Are we experiencing the same titles
- [00:29:02.000]in Germany, in England, and Poland?
- [00:29:05.297](mumbles)
- [00:29:07.525]No, actually,
- [00:29:11.145]Finland's a case study of a country...
- [00:29:15.124]Keep remembering that the orthography of a country
- [00:29:18.452]makes a difference, right?
- [00:29:21.683]And also the level of diversity in a country
- [00:29:25.428]makes a difference.
- [00:29:27.742]But I have to say that,
- [00:29:29.760]being a Canadian originally,
- [00:29:33.375]from the deep south of Canada, by the way.
- [00:29:36.392]Most Canadians are from the deep south,
- [00:29:39.175]if you think about it.
- [00:29:40.274]Just think about it a little bit.
- [00:29:41.415](audience laughs)
- [00:29:44.776]Canada does not do this.
- [00:29:47.634]And they do consistently better than we do
- [00:29:50.077]in areas that are matched for diversity, okay?
- [00:29:54.407]Like British Columbia, certain parts of...
- [00:29:56.977]They take provinces of Canada and compare it
- [00:29:59.506]to different American states.
- [00:30:02.769]Germany and Poland
- [00:30:05.191]increased their status on the last
- [00:30:07.771]international comparison,
- [00:30:09.595]and it wasn't by pushing down.
- [00:30:16.097]And the German orthography, that's pretty hard.
- [00:30:18.884]One of the things about our English orthography
- [00:30:21.444]is we have two linguistic sources
- [00:30:25.913]make up English.
- [00:30:28.695]So we started out as a Germanic language.
- [00:30:32.087]So words that you just saw on these little...
- [00:30:35.096]Id and it and all those,
- [00:30:37.473]those are from the German layer of English,
- [00:30:41.164]and then in 1066 the Normans invaded England
- [00:30:43.925]and they brought them French,
- [00:30:46.400]and so then we have a whole Romance system.
- [00:30:49.941]And that's what the little Spanish guys
- [00:30:51.627]come to school good at,
- [00:30:53.941]which we don't ever tell them.
- [00:30:56.117]We forgot.
- [00:30:59.935]I mean, our system is a little bit more complex
- [00:31:03.060]than some, and I think one of the reasons we get nervous,
- [00:31:06.208]but this pushing down, you know,
- [00:31:09.162]Great Britain, no.
- [00:31:13.086]The European countries aren't doing it.
- [00:31:15.338]Maybe in China, I don't know.
- [00:31:17.790]That one I don't know.
- [00:31:18.911]Guy's gonna go there in a couple weeks
- [00:31:21.512]and Guy will be our informant.
- [00:31:26.413]I mean, we keep pushing down, and like I said
- [00:31:29.054]the thing that we see in international comparisons
- [00:31:31.570]is you can't tell from the fourth grade average
- [00:31:34.311]who starts early,
- [00:31:36.574]but you can tell from the size of the standard deviation.
- [00:31:40.915]Yes?
- [00:31:43.154]So you kind of talked a little bit about
- [00:31:45.511]the sorting and norming that happens in schools,
- [00:31:47.763]and the homogenization and these high frequency words.
- [00:31:50.834]But when I think about, like, a Freirean approach,
- [00:31:53.456]what are the words that are meaningful to you?
- [00:31:55.975]How do we use this also have a social justice layer
- [00:32:00.241]that's associated with it?
- [00:32:05.724]Well, in the work that I showed you that we were...
- [00:32:09.743]And this is probably about it, right?
- [00:32:11.760]Because I think it looks like,
- [00:32:14.542]I can always tell the glossy eyes.
- [00:32:19.682]One of the things with some of the
- [00:32:22.062]technology we have now, like fMRIs,
- [00:32:25.625]we've learned a lot about how people learn vocubulary,
- [00:32:30.190]and from my view,
- [00:32:33.325]in American reading instruction,
- [00:32:35.235]we went from Dick and Jane,
- [00:32:37.410]and that was based completely on
- [00:32:39.758]those 25 to 100 most frequent words, right?
- [00:32:43.683]The theory was, of a guy named Thorndike
- [00:32:47.052]and then his student Gray,
- [00:32:48.760]if we could teach those words that you see the most,
- [00:32:52.237]then you'll learn to read.
- [00:32:55.510]The problem is about 40 percent of those first 100
- [00:32:59.329]have variant vowels,
- [00:33:01.035]and about 60 percent of them
- [00:33:02.785]are just really boring words,
- [00:33:07.657]that are really uninteresting to kids.
- [00:33:09.449]Which is why Dick and Jane were so uninteresting.
- [00:33:14.185]So then we go to this completely decodable perspective where
- [00:33:18.718]if you've been taught that, you can learn that.
- [00:33:22.674]One of the things we haven't done very well
- [00:33:24.787]is to look at what are some core ideas
- [00:33:26.867]that kids like to know about,
- [00:33:29.031]and in terms of the fMRI work,
- [00:33:32.284]what kinds of words do kids really learn quickly?
- [00:33:36.913]And it turns out human beings learn concrete words the best
- [00:33:40.614]and the fastest, and remember them.
- [00:33:43.761]So, for example, if I teach you T-A-T,
- [00:33:49.477]you know, like, with crocheting or whatever,
- [00:33:51.323]and "that", and "bat",
- [00:33:54.311]and "sat". and "cat",
- [00:33:56.729]the kid will remember "cat" first.
- [00:33:59.503]That's the word they'll know.
- [00:34:01.905]We've never really done a good job of that.
- [00:34:05.008]And in those little books that I was showing you
- [00:34:07.225]up there that I've made available for free,
- [00:34:09.114]that's what we do.
- [00:34:10.863]We pick the most highly concrete, interesting words for kids
- [00:34:15.290]that also have some regularity.
- [00:34:19.811]Okay?
- [00:34:20.683]So I don't want to leave you in tears,
- [00:34:24.661]I think there's an incredible opportunity
- [00:34:27.732]here in the state of Nebraska,
- [00:34:29.502]and I hope that we get to see some of that
- [00:34:32.510]come to fruition.
- [00:34:33.727]Thank you.
- [00:34:34.698](audience applauds)
- [00:34:41.022]Thank you, Freddy,
- [00:34:42.751]on behalf of all of us.
- [00:34:45.822]A simulating presentation.
- [00:34:47.709]I hope that the conversation continues,
- [00:34:49.841]with what you've learnt here today,
- [00:34:52.360]and thoughts that you've had, that you might take some notes
- [00:34:55.243]and continue the conversation,
- [00:34:57.531]and hope to be able to make a change.
- [00:35:00.251]I want to thank again
- [00:35:03.505]our benefactor, our donor,
- [00:35:05.775]Helen Kelly.
- [00:35:07.243]As well, of course, this would not have been possible had
- [00:35:10.273]Helen not had the vision
- [00:35:13.013]to be able to fund these kinds of events,
- [00:35:16.724]to bring speakers like Freddy Hiebert
- [00:35:19.477]in to talk to us about these ideas,
- [00:35:22.804]but also her great generosity.
- [00:35:25.524]So Helen, thank you so very, very much.
- [00:35:27.839](audience applauds)
- [00:35:34.916]On behalf of the Department of Childhood and Family Studies
- [00:35:37.578]and the College of Education and Human Sciences,
- [00:35:40.831]we do want to give you something
- [00:35:44.115]that you can take with you.
- [00:35:47.997]You're gonna need some help carrying that out.
- [00:35:50.110](audience laughs)
- [00:35:52.651]But thank you so very much.
- [00:35:54.706](audience applauds)
- [00:36:00.124]I hope you're all inspired,
- [00:36:01.512]because learning is just so fascinating.
- [00:36:04.615]And having had a mother who was a teacher who told me
- [00:36:07.423]that if you don't make it fun, they don't learn,
- [00:36:09.660]and then I taught seniors when I was 21
- [00:36:12.443]in English literature courses,
- [00:36:14.513]so I had my grill test.
- [00:36:18.715]But I really appreciate the interest that you all have,
- [00:36:21.585]and hope this really helps inspire
- [00:36:24.329]all the things you can do with kids.
- [00:36:26.779]Thank you.
- [00:36:27.920](audience applauds)
- [00:36:30.618](relaxing music)
The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!
You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.
Log in to post comments
Embed
Copy the following code into your page
HTML
<div style="padding-top: 56.25%; overflow: hidden; position:relative; -webkit-box-flex: 1; flex-grow: 1;"> <iframe style="bottom: 0; left: 0; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; border: 0; height: 100%; width: 100%;" src="https://mediahub.unl.edu/media/4039?format=iframe&autoplay=0" title="Video Player: Changing Conceptions of Kindergarten Literacy Learning: Q&A Session with Elfreida "Freddy" Hiebert" allowfullscreen ></iframe> </div>
Comments
0 Comments