Changing Conceptions of Kindergarten Literacy Learning: Elfreida "Freddy" Hiebert
TLTE
Author
11/20/2014
Added
189
Plays
Description
2014 Helen Kelly Symposium for Excellence in Education:
Changing Conceptions of Kindergarten Literacy Learning
Elfreida "Freddy" Hiebert
Searchable Transcript
Toggle between list and paragraph view.
- [00:00:00.427](light guitar music)
- [00:00:14.430]Get your attention and welcome you to
- [00:00:16.829]Helen Kelley Symposium for Excellence in Education.
- [00:00:22.919]I'm Richard Bischoff, I'm the department chair
- [00:00:25.276]of Childbirth and Family Studies
- [00:00:27.719]and I'm grateful that you all braved the weather
- [00:00:30.726]to come to this event.
- [00:00:33.787]I'm confident that you will be richly rewarded.
- [00:00:37.894]Marjorie Kostelnik, the dean of the
- [00:00:39.622]College of Education and Human Sciences
- [00:00:42.427]will say just a few words about our donor Helen Kelley
- [00:00:46.469]and then I'll introduce our speaker.
- [00:00:54.917]Well, good afternoon.
- [00:00:56.805]This is going to be a wonderful way
- [00:00:58.597]to end a very cold and breezy day.
- [00:01:01.946]I am sure that by the end of this session
- [00:01:04.687]you will feel warm of heart and stimulated of brain.
- [00:01:08.879]Now, I am very pleased to tell you something
- [00:01:11.844]about the person who is responsible for
- [00:01:14.990]our getting together, and that is Helen Kelley.
- [00:01:18.894]Now, you know, I introduce a lot of people
- [00:01:22.670]and very often we read, read or we describe
- [00:01:26.830]all of the different things that they've done.
- [00:01:29.497]And Helen Kelley certainly has a very esteemed resume.
- [00:01:35.832]She's a graduate of UNL, she has her certification
- [00:01:40.525]in Secondary Education.
- [00:01:43.052]She worked as a literacy and language teacher,
- [00:01:47.115]an English teacher in the Westside schools,
- [00:01:50.870]but she is someone, who beyond, I mean,
- [00:01:53.409]she's done a lot of things.
- [00:01:55.009]She's been on her school board, she's been on the
- [00:01:57.473]National School Board Association,
- [00:02:01.473]and she has done a lot of work and service in the community.
- [00:02:06.432]But one of the things that strikes me, Helen, when I look
- [00:02:09.825]at all of the different things that you've done,
- [00:02:12.651]is this is a person who appreciates learning,
- [00:02:16.694]and a person who wants to share that learning
- [00:02:19.904]with people around her.
- [00:02:22.891]You know, you have touched the lives of students
- [00:02:26.848]at every level of education, from the very smallest
- [00:02:32.095]ones through elementary and secondary.
- [00:02:36.458]Some directly and some through the good works
- [00:02:40.745]that you have sponsored in your community.
- [00:02:44.340]Yeah, but you haven't left it there.
- [00:02:47.081]You've said, "You know, if you're an administrator
- [00:02:49.033]"you need to know something more about
- [00:02:51.517]"teaching and learning and have a deep grasp of that."
- [00:02:55.698]And you have helped academic faculty, also,
- [00:03:00.327]revisit those ideals.
- [00:03:04.114]So all the way from preschool to higher education.
- [00:03:09.245]That is a wonderful record of passion and a wonderful
- [00:03:14.429]mission to help people think about teaching and learning
- [00:03:19.634]in all of its facets and all of its populations.
- [00:03:24.081]So we are particularly pleased and proud to have you
- [00:03:28.977]and your family here for this
- [00:03:32.389]Helen Kelley Symposium.
- [00:03:35.462]Please join me in thanking our benefactor.
- [00:03:38.907](applause)
- [00:03:46.160]You are a great inspiration, and you have made
- [00:03:50.736]it possible for us to be inspired,
- [00:03:53.765]not only by your good works, but by the guests who have
- [00:03:57.828]come to the university over the past three years
- [00:04:02.263]and who have enlightened us in a whole variety of ways.
- [00:04:06.732]And today will be no exception, so thank you.
- [00:04:09.356]Rich?
- [00:04:14.273]It's my pleasure to introduce our speaker
- [00:04:16.736]Dr. Freddie Hiebert.
- [00:04:19.552]Dr. Hiebert is the president and CEO of
- [00:04:22.037]TextProject, a non-profit who provides
- [00:04:24.267]open-access resources to support higher reading levels,
- [00:04:28.661]and she's a research associate at the
- [00:04:30.836]University of California, Santa Cruz.
- [00:04:33.450]Dr. Hiebert received her PhD in Educational Psychology
- [00:04:36.713]from the University of Wisconsin, Madison.
- [00:04:39.487]She has worked in the field of early reading acquisition
- [00:04:42.282]for 45 years, first as a teacher's aide and teacher
- [00:04:45.673]of primary-level students in California
- [00:04:47.886]and subsequently as a teacher, educator and researcher
- [00:04:51.299]at the University of Kentucky,
- [00:04:52.942]University of Colorado, Boulder, University of Michigan,
- [00:04:56.732]and the University of California, Berkeley.
- [00:04:59.095]Her research addresses how fluency, vocabulary
- [00:05:02.913]and knowledge can be fostered through appropriate
- [00:05:05.591]use of texts.
- [00:05:07.383]Dr. Hiebert's research has been published in
- [00:05:10.732]numerous scholarly journals, she has authored or edited
- [00:05:13.898]10 books.
- [00:05:15.553]Through documents such as
- [00:05:17.183]"Becoming a Nation of Readers" and
- [00:05:18.454]"Every Child Reader,"
- [00:05:20.371]she has contributed to making research accessible
- [00:05:22.974]to educators.
- [00:05:24.841]Dr. Hiebert's model of accessible texts for beginning
- [00:05:27.795]and struggling readers has been used to develop
- [00:05:30.451]numerous reading programs that are widely used
- [00:05:33.193]in schools throughout the US.
- [00:05:35.678]Dr. Hiebert was the 2008 recipient of the
- [00:05:38.558]William S. Gray Citation of Merit,
- [00:05:41.203]which was awarded by the International Reading Association.
- [00:05:45.106]She is also a member of the Reading Hall of Fame,
- [00:05:47.944]a fellow of the American Educational Research Association,
- [00:05:51.485]and the 2013 recipient of the American Educational Research
- [00:05:55.282]Association's Research to Practice Interpretive Award.
- [00:06:00.166]Dr. Hiebert chaired an advisory group on early childhood
- [00:06:03.783]for the Common Core and serves on the
- [00:06:06.257]Item Quality Review panel of Smarter Balanced.
- [00:06:10.364]She has spoken and provided workshops throughout
- [00:06:12.987]Nebraska, I had an opportunity to be able to go to dinner
- [00:06:16.762]with her last night and thoroughly enjoyed our conversation.
- [00:06:19.430]I'm confident that you will enjoy her talk today.
- [00:06:22.310]Please welcome Dr. Hiebert.
- [00:06:24.229](applause)
- [00:06:30.831]Thank you so much, to the Kelleys
- [00:06:34.095]and to the University of Nebraska
- [00:06:37.573]for giving me this opportunity and really the
- [00:06:40.132]first opportunity since I finished graduate school
- [00:06:43.012]at Wisconsin to unabashedly wear red.
- [00:06:46.457](laughing)
- [00:06:48.943]So you all have heard the litany of universities
- [00:06:52.302]that I was at, so if you think about the
- [00:06:54.116]University of Colorado, Boulder and their attitudes
- [00:06:57.763]toward red, given Michigan and Ohio State,
- [00:07:01.678]and then Berkeley and Stanford, you'll get an idea
- [00:07:04.846]that this was very special for me to
- [00:07:07.576]return to my Wisconsin roots.
- [00:07:14.296]I thought a lot about what I could say
- [00:07:19.384]in a community that has been devoted to
- [00:07:23.002]early childhood in the way that this
- [00:07:26.021]College of Education has been.
- [00:07:29.541]Evidenced by this lectureship, also by the
- [00:07:34.351]Buffett Center that Sam Meisels
- [00:07:37.657]is the executive director of.
- [00:07:40.867]You've had a long history of a commitment
- [00:07:45.986]to young children and I'm
- [00:07:51.427]hopeful that some of the things I share with you
- [00:07:54.520]today aren't happening in Nebraska.
- [00:07:58.883]And I am sharing this with you with the hope
- [00:08:03.715]that leadership can help
- [00:08:08.966]maybe stem the flow
- [00:08:12.174]and also act as a resource
- [00:08:16.868]for alternative models to things that you're doing here.
- [00:08:21.295]So I want to give a couple caveats in starting out.
- [00:08:26.617]In talking about how kindergarten has been changing
- [00:08:30.541]over the last 15 or 20 years in particular,
- [00:08:34.819]I want to emphasize that I'm not talking about
- [00:08:39.756]Kathy Wilson's darling grandchildren, she just
- [00:08:43.437]showed me the products of their preschool today
- [00:08:48.312]and the things that Lila is writing at age four.
- [00:08:53.312]I'm talking about the 63%
- [00:08:56.351]of the kids here in Nebraska
- [00:08:59.787]that on the National Assessment of Educational Progress
- [00:09:02.643]in 2013, didn't reach the proficient mark in literacy.
- [00:09:09.416]I'm talking about the kids who depend on schools
- [00:09:13.373]to become highly literate.
- [00:09:15.645]That's who I'm dedicating this talk to.
- [00:09:18.823]I also recognize that I'm in a non-Common Core state
- [00:09:23.482]and I think that's becoming increasingly more
- [00:09:26.291]non-Common Core state, but you have not been
- [00:09:30.174]one of the original states, and so
- [00:09:34.301]saying some of the things that I'm gonna talk about,
- [00:09:37.469]I recognize that you might not yet have seen some of
- [00:09:42.525]the pressures that some of the other states are seeing,
- [00:09:47.015]but typically, as some of the very, very large states
- [00:09:50.322]in the nation go, so do some of the smaller states.
- [00:09:53.820]Unless you have a lot of courage, knowledge and commitment,
- [00:09:57.841]and that's what I'm speaking to today.
- [00:10:00.561]I also want to be clear that I'm going to talk about
- [00:10:02.822]materials and materials are only
- [00:10:08.405]make a difference, right, in the hands of teachers.
- [00:10:12.415]So we can give you a sense of what's been
- [00:10:15.477]happening nationally.
- [00:10:18.239]So, in talking about changing conceptions
- [00:10:22.164]about kindergarten, I start with this statement
- [00:10:26.996]from the Common Core, again recognizing that
- [00:10:31.188]this isn't something that you are dealing with
- [00:10:33.619]quite the same way as some of the other states,
- [00:10:36.425]but the statement was made and this has been
- [00:10:38.718]immensely influential in the last four years
- [00:10:42.312]across the country.
- [00:10:44.755]So, I understand actually, that a fairly large
- [00:10:46.770]school district that we might be standing in
- [00:10:49.554]just adopted Core reading program.
- [00:10:51.890]So if they did, it was Common Core aligned
- [00:10:54.876]and in doing that, it complies with this notion
- [00:10:58.343]that K through 12 texts have been trended downward
- [00:11:02.962]over the last 50 years.
- [00:11:05.276]And my talk today is really going to look at,
- [00:11:08.167]could that be true, has that really happened.
- [00:11:11.921]Because, for those of you who aren't directly
- [00:11:14.651]involved in the educational enterprise, when kids
- [00:11:17.840]started school in 2011, if you were reading in grade 4
- [00:11:23.386]the year before, you know the grade 4 texts,
- [00:11:27.429]the kids are now reading the grade 5 texts?
- [00:11:31.898]And the grade 5 kids are now reading the grade 6 texts.
- [00:11:35.536]At least the levels are designed in that way,
- [00:11:39.055]so text levels have been upped across the grades,
- [00:11:43.770]including kindergarten.
- [00:11:46.447]I also want to have, as a reference, this study
- [00:11:49.945]in Ed. Week, coming from one of our most prestigious
- [00:11:54.190]journals, American Educational Research Journal,
- [00:11:59.449]where the statement was made based on the
- [00:12:03.267]early childhood longitudinal study findings of 1998
- [00:12:07.662]that kids benefit from having more challenging content.
- [00:12:13.457]And we're not going to argue with that, but we're going
- [00:12:15.761]to ask, what's the content that is given when people
- [00:12:19.249]think you need to challenge kids more?
- [00:12:21.776]That's what I want to ask today.
- [00:12:24.123]Okay, so in Education Week's language, they just
- [00:12:27.803]declared kindergarten is too easy, and they
- [00:12:30.512]came away with that conclusion.
- [00:12:32.294]So what I'm saying is, the message that we're hearing is
- [00:12:35.216]the text in kindergarten has been dumbed-down,
- [00:12:38.576]and secondly, kindergarten is too easy.
- [00:12:41.402]So let's take a look.
- [00:12:42.821]So what I want to do today is, by the way,
- [00:12:45.829]the people on eBay who sell used books absolutely
- [00:12:49.178]love me, I've not gotten premier status because
- [00:12:52.676]I've ordered a lot of books to do this presentation.
- [00:12:56.292](laughing)
- [00:12:58.041]Okay, so let's look at the evolving expectations
- [00:13:01.230]of kindergarten.
- [00:13:02.233]So I'm gonna go over what Common Core was in 2010,
- [00:13:04.590]I'm gonna go back to 1960.
- [00:13:07.779]So, here we've got 1966, and I picked that kind of
- [00:13:10.926]intentionally because that's where I could get the copyright
- [00:13:14.296]but it also turned out that that's really when
- [00:13:16.515]I started in education.
- [00:13:18.669]So, I started being a teacher's aide in 1966
- [00:13:22.178]and this little book, Getting Ready to Read
- [00:13:26.018]from Houghton Mifflin first appeared in the
- [00:13:29.090]Houghton Mifflin program.
- [00:13:30.433]Before 1949, there were no kindergarten materials.
- [00:13:36.047]So if you think about 1949, I was sorta there,
- [00:13:40.154]but, you know the baby boomers are going to
- [00:13:42.575]start kindergarten or start school soon
- [00:13:45.049]and suddenly we have a component of the core
- [00:13:48.121]reading programs for kindergarten.
- [00:13:51.470]And what I've done, for all of the copyrights
- [00:13:54.404]that I'm going to take a look at today, is I've taken
- [00:13:57.305]the middle lesson from the program.
- [00:14:01.304]So in the middle of kindergarten, right about January,
- [00:14:04.419]this is what kindergartners in 1966 were doing.
- [00:14:09.779]This is what we were told has been dumbed-down.
- [00:14:13.096]This was 1966 and had gone on for about 25 years
- [00:14:17.725]because it started in about 1950.
- [00:14:22.194]So, my math is not a strong point today.
- [00:14:25.266]Okay, now in 1986, I actually did a study of all the
- [00:14:30.183]programs in kindergarten at that place, at that time.
- [00:14:34.503]I had just finished my PhD,
- [00:14:40.114]I couldn't figure out why there were absolutely
- [00:14:44.474]no books that kids held in their hand in kindergarten.
- [00:14:48.495]They were still doing these exercises,
- [00:14:51.823]so they were copying letters, they were matching sounds,
- [00:14:54.713]picking pictures out for sounds, that's what they were doing
- [00:14:59.076]and I published that in Early Childhood Research Quarterly.
- [00:15:02.223]Now, in 1986, the same program,
- [00:15:05.337]do you see how they actually modernized the
- [00:15:07.492]little book, right?
- [00:15:08.601]Same book, but it looks a little different.
- [00:15:10.798]So we've had it around now for about 22 years.
- [00:15:13.944]They also had a little book called Ready Steps
- [00:15:19.255]that was to precede this workbook that kids were getting.
- [00:15:24.290]So kids only got workbooks.
- [00:15:26.711]So in all of the programs that we looked at in 1986,
- [00:15:31.095]only workbooks, and here they still were getting letters,
- [00:15:35.522]tracing the letters and letter sounds,
- [00:15:37.836]but they also, now, got some comprehension activities.
- [00:15:41.655]So they actually got to sort pictures.
- [00:15:44.279]Okay, so that was new.
- [00:15:46.700]And then, they got to actually read some words.
- [00:15:51.574]In this program and most of the other programs
- [00:15:54.273]there were about 10 words that kids got to see.
- [00:15:58.518]And these pages were ones that were perforated
- [00:16:02.155]so the kids could actually take home some text to read.
- [00:16:05.995]But that's what life looked like in 1986
- [00:16:09.226]and this was across the board.
- [00:16:12.053]So, colleagues and I, in a movement which was called
- [00:16:14.655]Emergent Literacy, we asked a lot of questions about this.
- [00:16:19.306]Couldn't kids be involved with real books?
- [00:16:21.887]Couldn't there be big books?
- [00:16:23.956]Couldn't they do lots of writing?
- [00:16:26.249]Couldn't they move little cards around and make words?
- [00:16:29.812]Well, sometimes you should be careful what you wish for,
- [00:16:32.916]because that, in fact happened in 1989 and 1991
- [00:16:36.979]in a movement that came to be called Whole Language.
- [00:16:42.611]So, California and then Texas, and then followed by Florida
- [00:16:47.869]and then New York, so there you've got all the big
- [00:16:50.109]states, right?
- [00:16:51.688]They called for having a different perspective
- [00:16:56.061]in kindergarten.
- [00:16:58.012]So now, this book, that used to be the workbook,
- [00:17:03.431]is followed by another book that's actually a
- [00:17:07.783]little bit ramped up.
- [00:17:10.524]And we still have all the other activities you've just seen,
- [00:17:14.097]the comprehension activities and the letter-tracing
- [00:17:17.467]activities and the sound activities,
- [00:17:19.665]but you also have big books.
- [00:17:22.512]And they're very good big books.
- [00:17:25.147]So, at this point, in about 1989, big books enter the scene
- [00:17:30.661]and for some of you who are in businesses other
- [00:17:33.253]that the educational enterprise, that means an
- [00:17:36.144]enlarged book that the kindergarten teacher can read
- [00:17:38.927]and all the kids can participate as the teacher is
- [00:17:41.445]tracking the print and they're reading along,
- [00:17:44.313]or looking along, okay?
- [00:17:46.810]Keep remembering that these are five year old kids,
- [00:17:49.284]right, but this again, comes from the middle of the program.
- [00:17:52.249]Another thing that we see is, there's a little bit more
- [00:17:55.620]opportunity to actually participate.
- [00:17:58.329]So, in addition to the letter-naming activity,
- [00:18:02.243]now you've actually got a page where you can draw
- [00:18:05.070]pictures, or if you can actually write words,
- [00:18:09.539]you can write things that start with that letter.
- [00:18:13.709]So, these were the things we'd been writing about
- [00:18:15.981]in this movement called Emergent Literacy
- [00:18:18.946]and it actually turns out that this was a program
- [00:18:20.493]I was involved with, and at a very early point in my career,
- [00:18:24.962]I got to see these things come to fruition,
- [00:18:27.852]and we just were so excited.
- [00:18:30.231]We also had some inventive comprehension activities.
- [00:18:33.964]You know, where you would draw the ending of the
- [00:18:35.735]story rather that have to just pick it
- [00:18:37.985]as a multiple choice thing.
- [00:18:39.937]You could, in There's an Alligator Under My Bed,
- [00:18:43.275]actually draw some pictures of what make
- [00:18:45.185]the alligator big.
- [00:18:46.721]Okay, so we were really trying to be open-ended here.
- [00:18:50.080]And we gave kids a story book, so for that very first
- [00:18:54.827]kindergarten level you got a story book that
- [00:18:58.752]didn't have any words in it, so you could
- [00:19:01.578]re-tell the story.
- [00:19:03.978]Because pedagogically this is the kind of thing
- [00:19:06.250]we really wanted young children to be able to do.
- [00:19:09.482]But, in the second level of kindergarten,
- [00:19:12.586]you actually got little books that had stories
- [00:19:18.505]that were summaries of the stories your
- [00:19:21.652]teacher had read to you.
- [00:19:23.924]Now I want you to take a look, if you can see that,
- [00:19:25.651]the quality of the art.
- [00:19:27.497]It was very well done.
- [00:19:31.155]Now, one of the things that I learned about in my career
- [00:19:35.955]is you should always think about unintended consequences.
- [00:19:39.549]So, now the expectation is there that you can
- [00:19:41.746]put words for kindergarten kids to read.
- [00:19:46.354]And what happens in the interim, is that we
- [00:19:48.957]have the very first state by state comparison
- [00:19:53.724]of the National Assessment of Educational Progress.
- [00:19:57.159]And California doesn't come out very well,
- [00:20:00.742]and California had been the first state
- [00:20:03.281]to go in this direction.
- [00:20:05.692]And there were statements that were made,
- [00:20:07.825]that Whole Language was the reason California
- [00:20:10.694]didn't come out very well.
- [00:20:13.904]So, there were some responses, and one of them
- [00:20:19.408]was a set of books that were really institutionalized
- [00:20:25.221]in 2003, with No Child Left Behind.
- [00:20:29.562]So now think about kindergarten.
- [00:20:31.439]Everything I've shown you, except the really interesting
- [00:20:33.732]pictures in children's books, everything is still
- [00:20:36.591]in the program, but now we have something new.
- [00:20:41.615]You can't see this, but I'm gonna read it to you.
- [00:20:44.697]We have something new called decodable
- [00:20:47.812]and I want you to understand that the 2003
- [00:20:51.651]program, this is the middle lesson in kindergarten.
- [00:20:55.896]Now I don't know if it's aspirational, we only
- [00:20:58.318]think we should expose kids, but this is
- [00:21:00.653]what we're exposing kids to.
- [00:21:04.355]The book is called Pal Has Ham.
- [00:21:07.885]Bill has one big ham, Bill has one big pot.
- [00:21:12.962]Bill can fill the pot.
- [00:21:15.181]See the very big pot hiss.
- [00:21:18.284]Excuse me, I actually made a reading miscue there.
- [00:21:21.260]I added the word "very" and you might be asking
- [00:21:23.937]if I have dyslexia, we can talk about that later.
- [00:21:26.700](laughing)
- [00:21:28.150]Bill has ham.
- [00:21:29.697]Lil has ham.
- [00:21:31.276]Hal has a big ham.
- [00:21:33.942]Okay, so starting with 2003, this is the first time
- [00:21:38.517]this level of text appears.
- [00:21:41.419]The texts haven't been dumbed-down,
- [00:21:44.139]this is an incredible acceleration
- [00:21:47.061]and if you think, in my state,
- [00:21:51.680]of about a quarter of a million kids
- [00:21:56.212]coming to kindergarten who don't speak English
- [00:21:58.868]as a first language, trying to read that Lil has ham,
- [00:22:04.297]if you want to sit and listen to something
- [00:22:07.583]that's agonizing, go into a kindergarten classroom,
- [00:22:13.556]work with those kids attempting
- [00:22:15.059]to make sense of what this is.
- [00:22:17.822]Okay, oh and by the way, there's a follow-up.
- [00:22:20.467]This is about Bob, Bob hit it,
- [00:22:23.208]and I think you get the gist of these stories,
- [00:22:26.056]and then there's also, so starting in 2003
- [00:22:29.448]with No Child Left Behind, there are three
- [00:22:32.082]little books for every kindergarten lesson.
- [00:22:35.698]This third book teaches high-frequency words
- [00:22:39.314]like "the and "is" and "a," okay?
- [00:22:43.175]So that's 2003.
- [00:22:46.759]Okay, so that brings us to 2010
- [00:22:49.724]and the Common Core state standards.
- [00:22:52.422]And I'm gonna suggest that the revolution
- [00:22:56.529]in what's happened in kindergarten is so great
- [00:23:00.571]that no one even asked any questions
- [00:23:03.152]that the K-1 band was put together in the
- [00:23:06.619]Common Core state standard.
- [00:23:08.976]And a list of books was given for kindergarten
- [00:23:13.733]and first grade that didn't distinguish between
- [00:23:16.297]what should be at the beginning and
- [00:23:17.711]what should be at the end.
- [00:23:20.292]American teachers have been left not knowing
- [00:23:23.566]what kindergarten really is.
- [00:23:26.456]Now, the big difference with the Common Core
- [00:23:29.763]is that now we have informational texts.
- [00:23:33.219]And so when you go to the same program,
- [00:23:35.576]keep thinking, everything that we've gone before,
- [00:23:37.987]these are just some examples of what's on the
- [00:23:39.693]Common Core for K-1.
- [00:23:42.114]So it goes from having wordless books
- [00:23:45.282]to books with some pretty hard words,
- [00:23:47.458]but not that many of them,
- [00:23:49.549]to books that used to be in the
- [00:23:51.607]second grade curriculum.
- [00:23:55.494]Okay, so here we've got now the
- [00:23:56.977]Common Core Edition, this is 2014,
- [00:23:59.697]this is their brand new program.
- [00:24:01.712]Everything you saw before is still there,
- [00:24:05.392]but now we have a big book with science
- [00:24:09.125]and we have little books on top of the other
- [00:24:11.802]ones you saw, having to do with science.
- [00:24:15.204]And keep remembering, this is what kids
- [00:24:16.559]are gonna see in January, okay?
- [00:24:19.834]So, with respect to that first question,
- [00:24:23.919]have the texts been dumbed-down?
- [00:24:27.247]I don't know what those people were thinking.
- [00:24:29.743]Now, you heard that I was one of the advisers.
- [00:24:32.729]Just because you advise someone, doesn't mean
- [00:24:34.862]they always listen to you.
- [00:24:36.249](laughing)
- [00:24:37.667]I actually run a free consulting service for my
- [00:24:39.299]nephews and nieces, and it turns out
- [00:24:41.699]they very rarely take my free consulting.
- [00:24:44.685](laughing)
- [00:24:46.083]I also do a lot of free consulting for the airlines
- [00:24:49.357](laughing)
- [00:24:50.819]and I have yet to have any of them take my
- [00:24:52.834]very, very good ideas.
- [00:24:55.714]So yes, did I consult?
- [00:24:57.848]I did, but I can assure you that my consulting
- [00:25:02.871]seemed to fall on the same deaf ears as a lot
- [00:25:04.865]of my other really good ideas.
- [00:25:07.937]So, have texts been dumbed-down?
- [00:25:10.657]Well, that's what they looked like 50 years ago,
- [00:25:14.167]and that's what they look like now.
- [00:25:16.972]So the answer to the first piece of evidence,
- [00:25:19.596]I kept asking, when I was preparing this talk,
- [00:25:23.723]what could we look for in terms of evidence?
- [00:25:27.051]So this is one piece of evidence.
- [00:25:29.707]A second question is, do we have any evidence that
- [00:25:33.739]if you push down the expectations
- [00:25:37.728]to kindergarten,
- [00:25:40.021]or what if, when the Common Core results come out
- [00:25:44.511]and lots of the states haven't done very well,
- [00:25:48.084]we start saying, maybe we should start doing
- [00:25:50.378]some of this in preschool.
- [00:25:53.108]Do we have any evidence that the earlier you start,
- [00:25:58.388]the better you do?
- [00:26:01.129]And in fact, in the national assessments, the evidence
- [00:26:04.723]says that by fourth grade, when you look at average
- [00:26:08.563]scores of comparable nations, you can't tell
- [00:26:12.958]who started early and who started late.
- [00:26:16.573]But if you look at the standard deviation,
- [00:26:19.272]that is the index of the amount of variation
- [00:26:22.973]there is between kids, the standard deviation
- [00:26:26.770]is larger when you start out earlier.
- [00:26:30.300]In other words, you can actually
- [00:26:31.527]do things to increase the gap.
- [00:26:33.084]Now, I'm not saying that Lila shouldn't
- [00:26:36.540]have lots of great opportunities to write
- [00:26:40.380]and write and read and read and read
- [00:26:43.494]and to read all the books that kids want to read.
- [00:26:47.473]I'm asking about the demands on the kids
- [00:26:49.926]who aren't ready for some of this.
- [00:26:51.718]So the real question that I want to ask
- [00:26:53.670]today is, are the expectations for
- [00:26:56.656]task mastery, we could ask, is the content
- [00:27:01.125]that I've just shown you just something
- [00:27:03.173]that people think is nice?
- [00:27:05.353]We're gonna expose kids.
- [00:27:07.166]If you think back to our view of Emergent Literacy,
- [00:27:09.662]we just wanted to expose kids to big books.
- [00:27:12.137]We wanted them to have these little books
- [00:27:13.950]that they retold the stories in.
- [00:27:16.670]But now, these tasks are actually tested.
- [00:27:21.768]Not by statewide tests, but by
- [00:27:24.029]teacher-delivered tests.
- [00:27:25.939]So, the question is, the expectations for task mastery,
- [00:27:30.322]did they match the capacity of the majority of the kids?
- [00:27:33.394]Especially those in the bottom 66.
- [00:27:35.773]And I use 66 because that's the national number,
- [00:27:39.527]in Nebraska it's about 63%.
- [00:27:42.652]Well let's take a look at some data.
- [00:27:45.233]Is this seeable? I tell ya, using all this red,
- [00:27:49.820]after a while I just didn't know how much more to use,
- [00:27:52.870]you know, but I couldn't stop myself.
- [00:27:55.121](laughing)
- [00:27:57.073]I was so happy about it.
- [00:27:58.683]But, if we look at the early childhood longitudinal
- [00:28:01.968]study, so this was a study of kindergartners
- [00:28:07.269]who entered kindergarten in the fall of 1998,
- [00:28:10.992]and they actually followed them through high school
- [00:28:13.061]graduation, okay.
- [00:28:16.879]And one of the questions is, are kids coming
- [00:28:19.546]better prepared?
- [00:28:21.679]And right now, it looks like, on the 2010, so we've
- [00:28:27.023]just started another cohort of kids,
- [00:28:30.575]that they actually are doing just a tad bit better.
- [00:28:34.190]The kids in the fall of 2010 are getting 42%,
- [00:28:38.617]they've also increased the items, and I haven't been
- [00:28:41.710]able to get access to those items yet.
- [00:28:44.760]This is all pretty new, okay?
- [00:28:46.787]So I'll be able to tell you in a couple months
- [00:28:51.480]about whether, in fact, it's formal reading skills
- [00:28:55.746]that they got better at, okay?
- [00:28:58.445]But, if we look at, so this is the specific data
- [00:29:03.917]from 1998 for the kindergarten cohort.
- [00:29:10.540]So the first line, the black line is how the kids
- [00:29:12.854]did when they came into kindergarten.
- [00:29:15.638]Then the next line is how they did in spring,
- [00:29:18.518]and then the final, the third line in the set,
- [00:29:22.379]is how they did in first grade, okay?
- [00:29:27.296]So, you see that by the end of first grade,
- [00:29:30.059]the basic things like letter naming, letter sound matching,
- [00:29:33.536]initial consonants and final consonants, we've got that.
- [00:29:36.480]I want to have you take a look here,
- [00:29:39.797]at how they're doing on sight words.
- [00:29:42.815]So the sight words, that's like "the," "a," "of," "is,"
- [00:29:47.252]turns out, oh and by the way, you were needing
- [00:29:51.113]to read all of those words, right, in the text
- [00:29:53.502]that I was showing you.
- [00:29:55.433]It turns out only about 14% of the kids leaving
- [00:29:58.547]kindergarten in 1999 could actually read those words
- [00:30:04.030]to mastery and when we look at reading the text,
- [00:30:10.045]about 4% of them could actually read the text.
- [00:30:14.610]So what I'm suggesting here is that there's a big
- [00:30:17.640]mismatch between what we're asking kids to do
- [00:30:23.431]and what kids are actually capable of doing.
- [00:30:27.271]One of the questions I raise is,
- [00:30:30.279]are we potentially increasing the numbers
- [00:30:34.012]of students who could be relegated to interventions
- [00:30:40.092]very early on because they aren't meeting the standard
- [00:30:45.338]as soon as they come into kindergarten?
- [00:30:50.425]Now, this is the expectation, the words in red
- [00:30:54.094]are the high frequency words, and the words in gold
- [00:30:57.208]are decodable words.
- [00:30:59.054]So after we've got the Common Core state standards,
- [00:31:03.203]you see that, in terms of decodable words,
- [00:31:07.042]you need to know well over 250 at the end
- [00:31:09.944]of kindergarten and about, almost 100
- [00:31:12.994]high frequency words.
- [00:31:14.135]Let me tell you, if some of you aren't people
- [00:31:17.548]who teach a lot of kids to read,
- [00:31:19.618]if you can do that, you're pretty much set.
- [00:31:23.724]If you can do that, you're set.
- [00:31:25.772]We should be having 100% of our kids
- [00:31:28.332]reading very, very well if kids can actually do that.
- [00:31:32.861]So I wanted to show you here the mid-kindergarten
- [00:31:35.378]texts, and what we've been doing in our work,
- [00:31:39.783]these are some of the ones I read to you, right?
- [00:31:42.205]Hal and ham, so this is what we're asking kids
- [00:31:44.519]to read in the middle of kindergarten.
- [00:31:48.647]And from a huge database that we use, we're able
- [00:31:53.393]to predict what words kids at the 50th percentile can read.
- [00:32:00.645]And this is about how much they can read
- [00:32:02.821]at the beginning of first grade, of kind of like the
- [00:32:06.981]Bob and ham words, right?
- [00:32:11.609]This is what it looks like in winter,
- [00:32:15.362]and this is what it looks like in spring.
- [00:32:17.559]I'm saying that these kindergarten books,
- [00:32:24.244]that's a pretty high diet in relation to what kids
- [00:32:27.433]are actually able to do.
- [00:32:32.124]So, I haven't painted the most optimistic picture,
- [00:32:35.740]I've been raising questions here about
- [00:32:38.417]what we're asking kindergarten kids to do.
- [00:32:42.321]It actually turns out, in terms of the Common Core,
- [00:32:45.734]what we know is that you can get young kids
- [00:32:50.022]to learn some of this, you can push hard.
- [00:32:55.120]But where the real problems come is in about
- [00:32:57.541]fifth or sixth grade, when kids' level of engagement
- [00:33:01.050]seems to drop.
- [00:33:03.343]And in terms of our national patterns,
- [00:33:06.415]that really seems to be where some of the problems lie.
- [00:33:10.276]Now, I'm not suggesting here today,
- [00:33:12.718]that now that the horse is out of the barn,
- [00:33:15.759]that we pull back on what we're giving kids
- [00:33:20.110]in terms of books when they start school.
- [00:33:23.545]You remember my original commitment,
- [00:33:25.817]lots of invented spelling, lots of big books,
- [00:33:28.889]lots of opportunities to leaf through books.
- [00:33:32.973]But I'm gonna ask what might be some next steps
- [00:33:37.239]so we don't go down the slippery slope
- [00:33:39.533]too much more quickly.
- [00:33:41.218]I use that metaphor really wisely because
- [00:33:43.469]today I was a little worried about the slippery slopes,
- [00:33:46.402](laughing)
- [00:33:47.170]I mean not that there are that many slopes,
- [00:33:48.759]you know of course there are lots of hills,
- [00:33:50.338]but it was pretty icy.
- [00:33:53.228]Okay, in terms of next steps, I'm gonna call
- [00:33:55.884]on two things that I think are really appropriate
- [00:33:57.633]for a research community to think about.
- [00:34:01.228]Some of you are thinking that this woman is speaking
- [00:34:04.342]kind of a foreign language, but this is
- [00:34:06.998]what we deal with in beginning reading right now.
- [00:34:09.248]This is what kindergarten teachers are dealing with.
- [00:34:12.458]I'm saying that we need to debunk the
- [00:34:16.619]"lesson-to-print-match" model of these
- [00:34:18.891]little books like Bob and Pal and ham.
- [00:34:22.325]We need to actually take a look at those books
- [00:34:24.640]and I'm gonna tell you how they got built, okay?
- [00:34:27.690]Somebody had a good idea, and got it into policy
- [00:34:30.517]actually first in the state of Texas and then
- [00:34:32.319]California thought that would be really cool.
- [00:34:35.210]So, this is what the guidelines say
- [00:34:37.408]in California right now, and we're getting ready
- [00:34:39.733]for new books in California, but this is what it says.
- [00:34:43.403]Decodable means that at least 75% of the words
- [00:34:48.650]consist solely of previously taught sound-spelling patterns.
- [00:34:54.441]Okay, so if a pattern has been taught, then you can
- [00:34:57.994]have it appear in a book.
- [00:35:01.385]And 15-20% of the words can be previously taught
- [00:35:05.023]high frequency words and story words, okay?
- [00:35:08.724]So this is how it plays out.
- [00:35:11.038]In kindergarten, and this is the standing part
- [00:35:14.793]of the legislation in California,
- [00:35:17.128]kindergarten you have to have at least 35 of these books,
- [00:35:20.744]and take a look here, below, if it didn't take
- [00:35:25.053]in kindergarten, you get them up through grade eight.
- [00:35:29.852]You just keep giving kids the same diet of decodables.
- [00:35:32.797]So let's take a look at what decodable is.
- [00:35:35.965]So, on the left hand side is a book that's decodable
- [00:35:39.826]by lesson 16, which is what I was showing you.
- [00:35:43.505]So that means that all of those letters,
- [00:35:46.031]T, H, I, S, B, O, all of those letter-sound patterns
- [00:35:51.324]have been taught.
- [00:35:53.546]So that means, even if that letter-sound pattern,
- [00:35:57.567]the new letters in this book are H and L.
- [00:36:02.239]Kids have never seen those before in this program,
- [00:36:07.358]but here you see, if the book set, and I actually
- [00:36:11.966]wrote this one myself, it took me about three minutes,
- [00:36:15.401]which gives you some idea of how quickly some of
- [00:36:17.598]these books are written, and that they are really
- [00:36:20.318]not literary quality.
- [00:36:22.599]So this is Deb the hen, well Deb the hen,
- [00:36:25.788]you can't ever have in the program, because they
- [00:36:29.746]haven't been introduced to the letter E yet.
- [00:36:33.703]Now they've seen it in "the," but they haven't
- [00:36:37.138]had a lesson on it, and if you haven't had a lesson,
- [00:36:41.202]is this making any sense?
- [00:36:43.153]It's hard, okay Carolyn is saying it doesn't.
- [00:36:45.489]Okay so, what they're saying is that,
- [00:36:49.009]if a letter has been introduced, with its sound,
- [00:36:52.646]and kids have practiced it in one of those
- [00:36:54.460]worksheets, you can see a word, any word
- [00:36:57.585]with that letter in it, provided all the other
- [00:37:00.539]letters around it have also been taught.
- [00:37:05.008]But, for example, they haven't seen U and E yet,
- [00:37:08.859]so they can't see words like Jud and Jeb and Deb and hen.
- [00:37:14.874]That would be illegal, it wouldn't get counted
- [00:37:17.252]as a decodable text, and they wouldn't make the grade
- [00:37:20.329]in Texas and California and Florida.
- [00:37:25.812]Where did this come from?
- [00:37:28.052]Is there any evidence that a little kid only has
- [00:37:30.772]to see a pattern once to learn it?
- [00:37:35.506]And the answer is, there is absolutely none.
- [00:37:39.078]This was a lobby group that thought this
- [00:37:40.891]was a really good idea.
- [00:37:43.878]I just wanted to show you what it looks like
- [00:37:45.680]in other languages.
- [00:37:47.611]I thought this was interesting because,
- [00:37:49.851]see one of the other problems with these little books,
- [00:37:52.655]is it's really weird to see a lot of these little
- [00:37:54.843]three-letter words.
- [00:37:57.264]You know? It gets to be like tongue-twister.
- [00:38:04.187]So I looked to see what it would be like if you had
- [00:38:06.191]this text in Spanish, and you see how the
- [00:38:09.178]words have a lot of distinction and differentiation?
- [00:38:14.642]Now I also want to show you the two countries
- [00:38:16.328]that did particularly well in the international
- [00:38:20.402]assessment this past year.
- [00:38:22.461]This is what the books would look like in German.
- [00:38:26.357]And this is what they would look like in Finnish,
- [00:38:29.809]and I thought I also put Polish, but I guess I
- [00:38:32.604]hadn't pulled that out.
- [00:38:34.759]So, the point that I want to make here
- [00:38:37.895]is that this model was built on a study that claimed
- [00:38:43.292]that this had all been tested out,
- [00:38:47.110]but the texts in this study are very different.
- [00:38:50.747]Words have a lot of repetition in this program.
- [00:38:54.427]So all the words with the phonetically regular pattern
- [00:38:58.832]are repeated over and over again.
- [00:39:02.042]I think I've inspired a lot of people
- [00:39:03.653]to go and teach a kid to read.
- [00:39:06.234](laughing)
- [00:39:08.463]Either that or, class is over, the time for the
- [00:39:10.970]class is over, and we can go, okay.
- [00:39:14.564]I always think when people leave, they're going to
- [00:39:16.634]find a kid and make sure this doesn't happen.
- [00:39:23.223]Okay, so I'm also gonna suggest,
- [00:39:27.447]I know that for a couple of reading people in this room,
- [00:39:31.511]that what I just have talked about makes some sense,
- [00:39:34.413]I'm saying this is driving beginning reading
- [00:39:37.517]for a lot of young children, and if it isn't happening
- [00:39:40.876]here in Nebraska, just wait.
- [00:39:46.517]And I'm saying it's an incredibly horrendous
- [00:39:51.625]introduction to literacy, especially if your culture
- [00:39:57.386]is a different one than the mainstream.
- [00:40:00.479]And especially if you speak a language like Spanish.
- [00:40:05.087]Spanish functions very, very differently,
- [00:40:09.076]and doesn't, as you saw, doesn't have a lot of
- [00:40:13.545]those little short words.
- [00:40:18.668]You can actually get a sense here the distinction
- [00:40:20.802]and differentiation that you'd be able to have.
- [00:40:24.332]Words of different lengths, right?
- [00:40:26.241]Rather than words of all the same length.
- [00:40:30.976]Okay, I want to make one more point,
- [00:40:32.906]and that is, I don't think we have right now,
- [00:40:36.906]in our learning community, a sense of what
- [00:40:40.234]comes before what,
- [00:40:43.459]so in 1975 to 1986,
- [00:40:47.576]there was a really distinctive, there were some ideas,
- [00:40:52.376]right or wrong, there were some very distinctive
- [00:40:55.522]ideas of what preceded what,
- [00:41:00.439]in terms of learning to read.
- [00:41:03.671]And you didn't learn the letter L at the same time
- [00:41:08.503]you were expected to read about 15 different words.
- [00:41:13.281]Okay, there was a progression.
- [00:41:15.520]Now, the progression kind of looks like this.
- [00:41:19.116]Everything is kind of presented in a big blob.
- [00:41:23.862]And I'm saying that for those of us in this room
- [00:41:26.848]who are part of a research community,
- [00:41:30.080]I'm suggesting this is a critical thing
- [00:41:32.159]for us to be looking at.
- [00:41:35.157]For all of the millions of dollars that have been spent
- [00:41:37.354]on interventions in reading, billions of dollars,
- [00:41:40.896]I'm saying we're doing things that just don't make sense.
- [00:41:44.714]We're having kids learn the letter L at the same time
- [00:41:48.714]we're asking them to read a word like "one" or "seed."
- [00:41:52.692]And I'm suggesting that that is, just doesn't
- [00:41:56.617]make a whole lot of sense.
- [00:41:59.688]We need people to actually have good descriptions
- [00:42:03.710]of what is needed to learn particular
- [00:42:08.382]skills in the beginning reading sequence.
- [00:42:13.857]Boy, I think I maybe went a little too technical here,
- [00:42:16.780]but I had a lot of fun learning this stuff.
- [00:42:19.500](laughing)
- [00:42:22.710]And for those of you who did have the class
- [00:42:25.215]ended and you're still here, thank you,
- [00:42:27.584]for those of you who could have left,
- [00:42:29.279]thank you also.
- [00:42:30.965]But I want to just tell you a couple things
- [00:42:33.685]that's changed 'cause especially
- [00:42:36.874]if you taught reading some time ago,
- [00:42:39.455]you're kind of wondering, when did this all come about?
- [00:42:42.719]So something becomes fashionable,
- [00:42:45.065]and one of the things that we stopped doing
- [00:42:47.604]in reading, is we stopped believing that
- [00:42:50.366]repetition was important.
- [00:42:53.810]When we had Dick and Jane, some of you
- [00:42:55.644]remember Dick and Jane,
- [00:42:57.917]some of you don't know who Dick and Jane were.
- [00:43:00.317]Dick and Jane were a duo that 80% of the
- [00:43:03.484]baby boomers in North America learned to read with.
- [00:43:07.239]And they were very, very dysfunctional little family,
- [00:43:11.303](laughing)
- [00:43:12.337]because Dick and Jane actually had repetitive,
- [00:43:16.060]kind of a compulsive disorder,
- [00:43:18.310](laughing)
- [00:43:19.536]where they had to do everything a certain
- [00:43:21.563]number of times, so they would run, run, run, you know?
- [00:43:25.691]And then, actually, part of the baby boomer generation
- [00:43:28.838]actually would have songs that would go with that
- [00:43:31.216]like "Fun, Fun, Fun," like that.
- [00:43:33.445]But, in Dick and Jane they did things so many times
- [00:43:38.405]that Gene Shaw came out in 1967 and said,
- [00:43:41.999]"Enough already."
- [00:43:43.973]And then what do we do?
- [00:43:45.071]We throw the whole thing out.
- [00:43:47.162]And I'm suggesting that, now that we have these
- [00:43:49.540]huge databases that we can look at
- [00:43:52.463]of kids learning to read.
- [00:43:54.681]You know, computers have let us now look
- [00:43:56.430]at just huge, huge digital sets of texts
- [00:43:59.940]and kids' performances.
- [00:44:01.849]And what we've found, these are the prototypical
- [00:44:05.123]words that kids know in winter, spring, fall,
- [00:44:09.859]and then grade two.
- [00:44:12.099]And we are seeing an almost perfect relationship
- [00:44:16.440]with how many times those words appear in print.
- [00:44:19.714]In other words, the words that kids are learning,
- [00:44:23.554]so let me explain this again,
- [00:44:24.994]the words that kids are learning, are the words
- [00:44:28.962]that appear a lot in the text, not some of those
- [00:44:31.596]random words like "pal" and "ham" and "Lil."
- [00:44:35.884]In fact, we don't see the kids learning
- [00:44:38.870]a lot of those words at all.
- [00:44:41.334]Especially because a lot of them are very, very weird,
- [00:44:44.544]and very, very infrequent.
- [00:44:48.523]Okay, what you see here is very little repetition
- [00:44:53.515]of the words in texts, right?
- [00:44:57.280]And if you think about learning a language
- [00:44:59.435]without repetition, that's a pretty
- [00:45:02.336]difficult thing to do.
- [00:45:04.245]So I'm saying, one of the the things we need
- [00:45:05.727]to return to is some understanding of repetition
- [00:45:08.821]in learning to read.
- [00:45:10.773]It's not a popular concept.
- [00:45:12.863]Dick and Jane kind of made it very bad for us.
- [00:45:16.095]What I'm saying here is not very popular at all.
- [00:45:19.764]And I'm suggesting we've got to ask how much
- [00:45:23.276]kids need to see some of these patterns
- [00:45:25.697]before they can learn to read.
- [00:45:28.555]Here's an alternative in a set of little books
- [00:45:30.550]that I've developed.
- [00:45:32.117]Where, within the same book, there's lots
- [00:45:35.115]and lots of repetition of the same word.
- [00:45:39.221]They're learning about phonics,
- [00:45:40.864]but they're also getting to see these words
- [00:45:43.306]across stories, and also across the levels in the program.
- [00:45:49.973]Okay, so kids are getting to see these words a lot
- [00:45:53.205]in an intentional way.
- [00:45:55.028]This isn't Dick and Jane but it still has
- [00:45:58.527]a modicum of repetition
- [00:46:01.204]and I'm suggesting we need to understand
- [00:46:03.785]developmentally, what comes before what,
- [00:46:08.073]and we also need to know what you need to see often.
- [00:46:13.171]In an interesting way, not in a pedantic, repetitive,
- [00:46:18.696]Dick and Jane.
- [00:46:24.851]I have typed in all the Dick and Jane books,
- [00:46:27.368]I have got copies of all of them, and sometimes
- [00:46:30.482]I don't even know if I've typed the page yet, you know?
- [00:46:33.565]Because it all seems like it's the same one.
- [00:46:36.093]So that was a silly as the Pal had a bad ham,
- [00:46:40.028]but I'm saying there needs to be some balance,
- [00:46:43.057]some middle road that's based on better knowledge.
- [00:46:46.854]And I think we have it, but we've let some state
- [00:46:50.395]policies really run the way we've been going.
- [00:46:53.969]So, I want to end with showing you what I believe
- [00:46:58.576]kindergarten classrooms should look like.
- [00:47:02.150]So I haven't been suggesting, as people
- [00:47:07.109]from the Gesell Institute do,
- [00:47:09.978]that we can wait until seven for kids
- [00:47:11.109]to learn to read, that's not gonna happen.
- [00:47:13.935]You don't go backward,
- [00:47:17.146]but I think we need to move away from these
- [00:47:21.956]didactic, incredibly tedious
- [00:47:27.701]kinds of little books that kids have been looking at.
- [00:47:33.077]And we need to come to a center
- [00:47:35.860]where we're ensuring that kids get some sense
- [00:47:40.308]of the system.
- [00:47:42.953]And I know that Nebraska, you're doing that,
- [00:47:47.314]and it's a state where you have a lot of communication.
- [00:47:50.620]My friend Sam Meisels says he came today from a meeting
- [00:47:53.383]where all, what, 11 universities were there.
- [00:47:56.796]You're able to communicate and maybe this is a place
- [00:48:00.926]where we stop some of this silliness
- [00:48:03.892]that we've been seeing in early childhood, in literacy.
- [00:48:07.283]Because we have absolutely no evidence
- [00:48:10.537]that is going to make the difference for the kids
- [00:48:13.150]who need the difference made.
- [00:48:16.754]So, let me stop with some pictures of kids
- [00:48:19.905]having a lot of books read out loud to them, a lot.
- [00:48:26.544]Kids doing an enormous amount of writing,
- [00:48:30.970]I think writing is the primary way in which
- [00:48:32.741]you come into reading.
- [00:48:37.423]Kids doing a lot with sorting words.
- [00:48:41.422]I'm all for words, I'm all for the letters of the alphabet,
- [00:48:45.230]I'm all for beginning sounds, I like sounds a lot, but
- [00:48:49.379]we also want to bring words from their environments in.
- [00:48:52.867]I was in the most delightful four year old class today
- [00:48:55.714]here on campus, what those kids are getting to see,
- [00:49:00.535]the kids who depend on schools should be getting too,
- [00:49:04.045]and we shouldn't be panicked that they're not
- [00:49:06.594]gonna get it, and then start pushing some
- [00:49:08.461]of this stuff down.
- [00:49:11.042]I want them to do lots of word sorting, a lot of it.
- [00:49:16.162]I want them to see lots of little books.
- [00:49:19.191]Not being responsible for reading them,
- [00:49:21.441]but picking out some words that they
- [00:49:22.743]might be able to read.
- [00:49:24.630]I want them to see hundreds of little books.
- [00:49:28.022]And to ensure that, I've actually gotten
- [00:49:31.883]WeGiveBooks.org to take some of my old books,
- [00:49:36.619]that the publisher forgot to sell,
- [00:49:38.998](laughing)
- [00:49:39.872]and give them away.
- [00:49:41.866]So there's lots of little books there for kids
- [00:49:44.544]that have a pedagogical base to them.
- [00:49:48.832]And I want kids to learn about things
- [00:49:53.567]while they're seeing these little books.
- [00:49:57.482]I've written about 120 of these little books,
- [00:50:00.223]and they're on my website, all for open access,
- [00:50:02.995]free download, somewhere,
- [00:50:10.241]and I want kids to be inundated with these books.
- [00:50:14.961]Do you see how this is very different?
- [00:50:18.438]There's some repetition here.
- [00:50:20.465]There's something of interest, there's actually
- [00:50:21.990]something to learn.
- [00:50:24.144]You know, explain to me about Pal and that ham.
- [00:50:27.013]Actually, it looked to me like that dog had a bone,
- [00:50:31.237]not a real ham, you know?
- [00:50:33.466]So, that might really cause some problems.
- [00:50:35.748]Oh, by the way, you do intensive comprehension
- [00:50:38.405]activities with those books too, like the Pal had ham.
- [00:50:43.268]Kids like, why do you think Pal did that
- [00:50:45.230]and so on and so forth.
- [00:50:46.639]I'm saying I want them to have something of substance
- [00:50:49.891]and that's the commitment that I've made
- [00:50:51.492]at TextProject where we're generating material
- [00:50:55.492]like this and making it available.
- [00:50:58.137]And my hope is that for the kids of Nebraska,
- [00:51:02.542]they don't have to
- [00:51:07.622]deal with Pal and Bob,
- [00:51:10.981]whatever he hit, and Hal and a host of other books
- [00:51:16.133]all the way through eighth grade.
- [00:51:18.437]Keep thinking that that's what some of those
- [00:51:19.749]kids are seeing all the way through eighth grade.
- [00:51:22.746]To me, that's not what my vision of literacy is.
- [00:51:27.599]And I want to tell you thank you, for what it is
- [00:51:31.013]that you've been committed to in this state.
- [00:51:33.145]I think that there's an enormous amount of leadership
- [00:51:36.826]that's available here in terms of getting kids
- [00:51:42.127]on to the page and getting them to stay there,
- [00:51:45.294]because that's what we really want.
- [00:51:48.258]I also want kids to have a lot of
- [00:51:49.923]great children's literature.
- [00:51:51.352]We're in an amazing time of children's literature
- [00:51:54.979]and I provide a lot of examples of this.
- [00:51:58.840]We still have one of the last independent bookstores
- [00:52:01.464]standing in the country in Santa Cruz, California,
- [00:52:04.450]where I live.
- [00:52:05.730]You know Santa Cruz, where we have a lot of
- [00:52:07.767]individualistic people there, so you buy at the
- [00:52:12.535]bookstore and we have the best book buyer in the world
- [00:52:16.172]and she gives me ideas, and I put that on my website.
- [00:52:20.620]I want kids to have books about stuff that matters.
- [00:52:28.101]Poems old and new, lots of stories, fables and so on.
- [00:52:32.858]So that's my vision of literacy.
- [00:52:36.132]I look forward to continuing to interact with my colleagues
- [00:52:39.844]here in Nebraska as we
- [00:52:44.034]stay the course and map out for
- [00:52:48.419]kids the futures that they so desperately want.
- [00:52:52.003]Thank you.
- [00:52:53.401](applause)
- [00:52:55.288](light guitar music)
The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!
You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.
Log in to post comments
Embed
Copy the following code into your page
HTML
<div style="padding-top: 56.25%; overflow: hidden; position:relative; -webkit-box-flex: 1; flex-grow: 1;"> <iframe style="bottom: 0; left: 0; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; border: 0; height: 100%; width: 100%;" src="https://mediahub.unl.edu/media/4037?format=iframe&autoplay=0" title="Video Player: Changing Conceptions of Kindergarten Literacy Learning: Elfreida "Freddy" Hiebert" allowfullscreen ></iframe> </div>
Comments
0 Comments