RNA Interference for Insect Pest Management
Ana Maria Velez, Asst. Professor; Entomology Department UNL
Author
11/06/2023
Added
100
Plays
Description
RNA interference (RNAi) is a gene-silencing mechanism conserved across eukaryotic organisms. RNAi has been widely used as a research tool to study gene function. Over the past decade, RNAi has been investigated for agricultural applications, including managing plant insect pests. During this presentation, I will provide an overview of the current state of using RNAi for insect pest management.
Searchable Transcript
Toggle between list and paragraph view.
- [00:00:00.750]The following presentation
- [00:00:02.220]is part of the Agronomy and Horticulture Seminar series
- [00:00:05.790]at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln.
- [00:00:08.490]Good afternoon and welcome to the Department of Agronomy
- [00:00:11.040]and Horticulture Seminar series.
- [00:00:13.320]It is my pleasure to introduce Dr. Ana Maria Velez Arango.
- [00:00:17.520]Dr. Velez Arango received her Bachelor's of Science degree
- [00:00:20.460]from Pontificia Universidad Javeriana
- [00:00:23.790]and her MS in Entomology
- [00:00:25.260]from the National University of Columbia.
- [00:00:28.140]She received her PhD here
- [00:00:29.490]at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln in 2013
- [00:00:32.250]working on resistance to Cry1F in fall armyworms.
- [00:00:36.510]Dr. Velez Arango joined the Department of Entomology in 2013
- [00:00:40.230]as a postdoctoral researcher
- [00:00:42.210]and as a research assistant professor in 2016.
- [00:00:45.720]As of 2023,
- [00:00:47.310]Dr. Velez Arango serves as an associate professor
- [00:00:49.800]in the Department of Entomology
- [00:00:51.450]with research and teaching responsibilities.
- [00:00:54.210]Her work focuses on understanding how insects respond
- [00:00:56.940]and adapt to chemical stressors
- [00:00:58.560]and specifically on current and emerging technology
- [00:01:00.960]used for insect pest management
- [00:01:03.060]such as transgenic plants that express toxins
- [00:01:05.520]from bacillus thuringiensis, BT and RNA interference.
- [00:01:09.900]Her labs work consider these methods at the molecular,
- [00:01:12.750]organismal and population level.
- [00:01:15.570]Dr. Velez Arango has produced 29 peer reviewed articles
- [00:01:18.450]along with 10 invited reviews and book chapters.
- [00:01:21.090]She also owns six patents related to her work in RNAi.
- [00:01:25.170]Dr. Velez Arango received the DuPont Young Professor Award
- [00:01:28.260]in 2016
- [00:01:29.820]and was recognized
- [00:01:30.900]as distinguished Multicultural CASNR alumni in 2019.
- [00:01:35.010]Dr. Velez Arango will be presenting
- [00:01:36.480]on RNA Interference for Insect Pest Management.
- [00:01:39.720]Thank you Christian for the introduction.
- [00:01:41.790]Absolutely my pleasure.
- [00:01:43.277]I don't think, I think I got it here.
- [00:01:46.040]Okay before I start, I wanna thank Dr. Ashley Stengel
- [00:01:50.400]for inviting me to give this presentation.
- [00:01:53.430]And what I wanted to do with this presentation
- [00:01:55.710]is to make it basic enough
- [00:01:57.840]for those of you who don't have a molecular background
- [00:02:00.540]but give enough detail for those of you
- [00:02:02.310]that have a molecular background.
- [00:02:05.010]And also not a lot of time to present everything
- [00:02:08.340]that I have done with RNAi
- [00:02:10.140]so I'm just kind of showing a little bit
- [00:02:12.510]and I want to give you some history on this technology.
- [00:02:16.590]Before I start and I forget,
- [00:02:18.660]I wanna acknowledge the main people that has helped me
- [00:02:21.990]with this research.
- [00:02:23.250]Dr. Blair Siegfried who was the one
- [00:02:25.560]first that introduced me to this work.
- [00:02:28.230]Dr. Ken Narva that used to work in Dow AgroSciences,
- [00:02:31.560]now he works at Greenlight Biosciences
- [00:02:33.960]and he's still one of my biggest mentors
- [00:02:36.990]and Dr. Elaine Fishilevich,
- [00:02:38.580]who also was a big mentor on RNAi for me.
- [00:02:41.310]Now she works with the human component of
- [00:02:43.137]for RNAi therapeutics.
- [00:02:45.480]And then the work that I will present today
- [00:02:47.670]are from my students and postdocs.
- [00:02:49.590]So Mariana Sanchez, Matthew Welter, Dr. Molly Darlington
- [00:02:54.090]and Dr. Suresh Varsani
- [00:02:55.707]and then my collaborators from Bayer CropScience,
- [00:02:58.560]Dr. Will Moar and Chitvan Khajuria
- [00:03:01.260]and Kristopher Silver from Kansas State University.
- [00:03:07.457]A brief outline of what I will talk today.
- [00:03:09.240]First, I want talk to you about how RNAi was discovered,
- [00:03:13.350]some of the general applications
- [00:03:15.000]because it's not only used for pest management.
- [00:03:17.730]A RNAi for Insect Pest Management, so how it works,
- [00:03:21.210]some of the delivery strategies
- [00:03:22.860]and then just narrow down and focus on my work
- [00:03:25.470]on Western Corn Rootworm Management,
- [00:03:27.390]some history, trait identification, mode of action
- [00:03:30.660]and then field population susceptibility.
- [00:03:34.380]So in terms of the discovery,
- [00:03:36.060]it was discovered
- [00:03:38.370]like a lot of things in science by mistake.
- [00:03:41.820]So there was researchers in California
- [00:03:43.740]trying to produce petunia that were more purple
- [00:03:47.010]and what they find is that they were actually producing
- [00:03:50.760]flowers that were white
- [00:03:52.020]or like with these patterns with white.
- [00:03:55.560]They didn't know what was happening.
- [00:03:59.070]And then eventually, they start finding this in fungi
- [00:04:02.610]and then C. Elegans
- [00:04:04.500]and it was Andrew Fire and Craig Mello
- [00:04:07.200]that finally describe it in C. elegans
- [00:04:10.260]as a post-transcriptional gene silencing.
- [00:04:12.780]So instead of putting more of that messenger RNA
- [00:04:16.170]that will produce the purple,
- [00:04:17.910]so the messenger RNA like kind of like the COVID protein,
- [00:04:20.520]what they were actually getting is this
- [00:04:23.040]and I'll talk more a little bit of how that work
- [00:04:24.783]or a double stranded RNA.
- [00:04:26.880]And all of these work on the description of RNA interference
- [00:04:30.060]gave them the Nobel Prize in Physiology and Medicine
- [00:04:32.670]in 2006.
- [00:04:36.060]So when we talk about RNA, we need to go back
- [00:04:39.120]to the Central Dogma of Biology
- [00:04:41.370]and I think maybe the laser here will work.
- [00:04:44.370]Yeah, so we need to go back to the Central Dogma of Biology
- [00:04:48.480]where you have your DNA,
- [00:04:49.560]then the nucleus is transcribing to messenger RNA.
- [00:04:53.160]Then this messenger RNA is translated into a protein.
- [00:04:56.160]So basically what we do with RNA interference
- [00:04:58.560]is we degrade this messenger RNA
- [00:05:00.510]and there is no production of protein.
- [00:05:02.520]If you remember with the COVID vaccines,
- [00:05:05.280]we were introducing messenger RNA
- [00:05:07.500]to produce the spike proteins
- [00:05:09.210]to then generate the immunity.
- [00:05:11.460]In this case, we're actually eliminating
- [00:05:14.220]innate messenger RNAs.
- [00:05:20.220]So it is a post-transcriptional gene silencing mechanism
- [00:05:24.060]that is conserved across all eukaryotic organisms.
- [00:05:27.480]And then the mRNA degradation prevents
- [00:05:29.820]the formation of that protein
- [00:05:31.320]and we describe this as gene silencing.
- [00:05:35.400]So there is three different pathways of gene silencing
- [00:05:39.150]that we have studied:
- [00:05:40.410]the siRNA pathway, miRNA pathway and piRNA pathway.
- [00:05:45.300]All of these pathways are important
- [00:05:47.010]for gene regulation in our bodies.
- [00:05:49.890]But when we talk about the siRNA pathway,
- [00:05:52.830]that is the one that we use or we explore
- [00:05:54.870]for pest management
- [00:05:57.390]is also used or is triggered by exogenous
- [00:06:01.440]double stranded RNA or dsRNA.
- [00:06:03.420]And I will be referring to dsRNA a lot in this presentation
- [00:06:06.930]and this evolve as a defense mechanism
- [00:06:09.150]against nucleic acid
- [00:06:11.490]so like a transposable elements and viruses.
- [00:06:17.580]And as we get at the end of the presentation,
- [00:06:19.500]we'll get back to this
- [00:06:20.490]because it gets them more complicated than we thought.
- [00:06:23.160]So in terms of applications in general for research,
- [00:06:26.220]it has been used for a long time for functional genomics.
- [00:06:29.430]So just to do that genotype to phenotypes
- [00:06:32.640]to understand what is the roles of those genes.
- [00:06:35.400]For gene therapy is silencing of viruses
- [00:06:38.310]or genes associated with diseases.
- [00:06:40.830]So I mentioned Elaine Fishelevich.
- [00:06:42.870]She now works in a company that they are developing
- [00:06:46.170]new technology or a new therapy.
- [00:06:48.030]I think it's now in the market for rare genetic diseases.
- [00:06:52.860]And then in agriculture for control of pest and pathogens,
- [00:06:55.800]so insects, nematodes, fungi and viruses
- [00:06:58.860]for to improve plant nutrition
- [00:07:00.840]and therapeutic for bees for viruses and Varroa mites.
- [00:07:04.830]But for this talk, I'll mainly talk about insects.
- [00:07:10.620]So how it works for insects.
- [00:07:12.930]What we do is we knock down or silence those two terms
- [00:07:16.470]are used interchangeably.
- [00:07:18.960]Genes with double stranded RNA
- [00:07:21.300]and then this generates a lethal or a sublethal effect
- [00:07:24.180]that will be useful to control those insects best.
- [00:07:27.720]So what are the advantages of this new technology?
- [00:07:30.750]First is really sequences specific.
- [00:07:32.760]So when we're talking about managing insect pests,
- [00:07:35.820]it depends on the sequence.
- [00:07:37.590]So it will target a really specific gene species.
- [00:07:40.150]So it has high selectivity
- [00:07:42.240]and has low environmental persistence.
- [00:07:44.700]Those are two things that we are always looking for
- [00:07:47.820]when we're thinking in terms of insect pest management.
- [00:07:50.910]Disadvantages is that as we started exploring
- [00:07:54.240]more of this technology,
- [00:07:55.410]we find that there is variability
- [00:07:57.180]between different insects
- [00:07:58.530]so it doesn't work well in our insect species.
- [00:08:02.190]It's lower mortality.
- [00:08:03.780]So if you think of synthetic insecticides,
- [00:08:05.610]you can find mortality 24 to 48 hours.
- [00:08:08.310]Then we would move to BTs.
- [00:08:10.470]Mortality happens in around seven days.
- [00:08:13.050]With RNAi, it happens in 10 days.
- [00:08:15.030]They start feeling sick earlier
- [00:08:16.590]and slow the rate of consumption
- [00:08:19.200]but it takes about 10 days for them to die.
- [00:08:23.100]And then this is kind of like a...
- [00:08:27.570]we have higher selectivity
- [00:08:29.100]but we can target them less pest
- [00:08:31.020]with this specific technology.
- [00:08:35.280]Some of the delivery strategies that are being explored
- [00:08:39.120]will depend on the insect
- [00:08:40.770]and the efficiency for that specific insect.
- [00:08:43.590]I cannot go into a lot of detail.
- [00:08:45.150]This can be a whole new presentation.
- [00:08:47.910]But we define it in with these terms
- [00:08:50.250]so host-induced gene silencing or HIGS,
- [00:08:53.160]that will be in a transgenic plant
- [00:08:55.260]or it's also being explored in a genetically modified yeast
- [00:08:59.730]for mosquito control.
- [00:09:00.870]So they just put pellets in water
- [00:09:03.090]for controlling mosquito larva,
- [00:09:05.190]spray-induced gene silencing or SIGS,
- [00:09:07.950]virus-induced gene silencing or VIGS
- [00:09:10.800]and then trunk injections and root absorption.
- [00:09:13.920]And then the trunk injections and root absorptions,
- [00:09:17.460]those are more for insects that feed on sap like aphids.
- [00:09:22.050]But for this talk, I mainly talk about the transgenics
- [00:09:25.830]and the SIGS or spray-induced gene silencing.
- [00:09:33.030]So in terms of hosting those gene silencing,
- [00:09:35.370]the first report that this could be done was in 2007
- [00:09:39.630]and was in this paper in "Nature"
- [00:09:41.280]a biotechnology that is really famous
- [00:09:43.710]and they show that with Western corn rootworm,
- [00:09:45.780]they could express in corn this gene for the V-ATPase.
- [00:09:50.400]And then what happens that is more important
- [00:09:52.260]when we're thinking in terms of pest management
- [00:09:54.360]is that it reduced the damage of the insect.
- [00:09:56.850]And I'll go into a lot of more detail on
- [00:09:59.700]Western corn rootworm biology.
- [00:10:01.770]So that was the first demonstration of HIGS in 2007.
- [00:10:06.270]And then there is another product
- [00:10:09.600]and let's just go back there for a second.
- [00:10:12.420]And these two products that I'm going to talk
- [00:10:14.310]are the ones, those that are like either
- [00:10:16.980]recently in the market or will be soon in the market.
- [00:10:20.310]And I'll talk more about the HIGS
- [00:10:22.590]later in the presentation.
- [00:10:24.150]The other one is the spray-induced gene silencing.
- [00:10:27.480]This is being developed by GreenLight Biosciences
- [00:10:31.140]for Colorado potato beetle.
- [00:10:33.210]And this product really relevant to the presentation today
- [00:10:37.350]is open for EPA comments,
- [00:10:39.840]so from the public for regulatory approval.
- [00:10:42.780]So it will likely be in the market hopefully next year.
- [00:10:49.500]So something to think about in term of this
- [00:10:51.630]deliver strategies that originally when we was discovered,
- [00:10:55.440]everybody thought this is amazing.
- [00:10:57.240]We're going to solve all the pest management issues.
- [00:11:00.780]This looks awesome.
- [00:11:02.400]Then what we started to find is that it's,
- [00:11:04.250]it doesn't look as good.
- [00:11:06.090]We find that for Coleoptera or for beetles,
- [00:11:08.310]they are really, really susceptible.
- [00:11:10.050]We are still trying to understand
- [00:11:11.430]why they are so susceptible to it,
- [00:11:14.040]but then it's just really variable in other organisms.
- [00:11:18.030]Lepidoptera doesn't work at all in some species
- [00:11:23.490]and I can go into a whole presentation talking about that.
- [00:11:26.243]Hemiptera, Orthoptera, Diptera and Hymenoptera
- [00:11:30.570]is give and take, is really variable.
- [00:11:33.660]The other factors that could affect it is a species.
- [00:11:37.710]So even between different species, it might change.
- [00:11:40.590]Life stages.
- [00:11:42.450]They also vary in terms of susceptibility.
- [00:11:45.480]Tissues and even genes can have different effectiveness
- [00:11:49.560]between the species.
- [00:11:52.470]And when we think into SIGS
- [00:11:54.780]or the strain-induced gene silencing,
- [00:11:57.780]we need to take in the formulation and stability
- [00:12:01.980]in the environment
- [00:12:02.820]because we will have UV light, rain and microorganisms.
- [00:12:06.570]So for that, they are using a lot of different things
- [00:12:09.090]to stabilize those products
- [00:12:10.650]like bacterials, virus or yeast,
- [00:12:12.510]liposomes, peptides and polymers and nanoparticles.
- [00:12:16.140]This is an area of research that is growing
- [00:12:19.050]but also for HIGS or host-induced gene silencing,
- [00:12:23.370]we also need to think in terms of the internal
- [00:12:27.570]physiology of the insect
- [00:12:28.920]that might affect the effectiveness
- [00:12:30.570]of that double strand RNA.
- [00:12:31.980]So for example, in Hemiptera insects
- [00:12:34.080]that I mentioned earlier,
- [00:12:35.520]they have of RNAs or enzymes that can degrade
- [00:12:38.670]these double strand RNA
- [00:12:40.110]in their enzymes in the saliva.
- [00:12:41.880]So that's one of the reasons why it doesn't work that well.
- [00:12:44.610]And then in terms of for example in the mid gut,
- [00:12:47.040]Lepidoterans or all your caterpillars
- [00:12:50.130]have a lot of RNAs in their mid guts
- [00:12:52.800]that degrade that before it can be even uptaken.
- [00:13:01.500]So that was just a little bit of the wrap up
- [00:13:03.540]of how we're using it for insect pest management.
- [00:13:09.900]Now I would like to move into talking about
- [00:13:14.280]how we are using it for Western corn rootworm.
- [00:13:18.720]So just a little bit of history
- [00:13:20.610]for those of you that are maybe not familiar
- [00:13:23.130]with the Western corn rootworm.
- [00:13:25.110]The Western corn rootworm is the most important pest
- [00:13:27.960]of corn in the US corn belt.
- [00:13:30.510]The larvae damaged the root as you can see here.
- [00:13:33.003]This is a non-infested root, an infested root.
- [00:13:36.660]What happens is with high winds,
- [00:13:38.700]the plants lodges and then that affects the yield of corn.
- [00:13:43.379]This is now considered a $2 billion pest
- [00:13:46.680]in terms of the money that need to invest in inputs
- [00:13:50.910]and then yield losses.
- [00:13:53.280]And to make it even worse is a highly adaptable pest.
- [00:13:56.790]So these species has evolved resistance to
- [00:14:00.240]all the groups of synthetic insecticides, not everywhere
- [00:14:02.760]but in different places in the US.
- [00:14:05.100]Cultural techniques that I think that's amazing.
- [00:14:07.380]They figure out that in Illinois,
- [00:14:09.510]that they can lay eggs on soybeans
- [00:14:11.370]because next year is going to be corn
- [00:14:14.010]and then to transgenics, so the BT protein.
- [00:14:16.470]So they are just really highly adaptable.
- [00:14:18.540]We still don't understand why.
- [00:14:22.290]So because of that, we need new traits
- [00:14:24.630]for Western corn rootworm management.
- [00:14:28.410]In terms of transgenic crops for insect pest management,
- [00:14:31.350]we have the first generation.
- [00:14:33.120]That that first generation for rootworms came in 2003.
- [00:14:37.410]That was the Bacillus thuringiensis proteins.
- [00:14:41.340]The second generation really recent.
- [00:14:43.650]The first product was commercialized last year in 2022.
- [00:14:47.700]And then the third generations
- [00:14:49.590]are proteins from other sources like other types of bacteria
- [00:14:53.190]or even ferns
- [00:14:54.510]that are just in the pipeline of development.
- [00:15:01.770]So before I move into this,
- [00:15:03.600]for those of you that are not familiar
- [00:15:05.180]of how biotech products work or what is the pipeline
- [00:15:08.730]or how they are developed,
- [00:15:10.830]they are first discover.
- [00:15:12.090]So they check a lot of different traits,
- [00:15:14.130]see which ones are efficient.
- [00:15:15.870]Then from those pick a couple to explore more.
- [00:15:19.050]Then they do target characterization,
- [00:15:21.420]more into detail on how that will work
- [00:15:23.730]and maybe greenhouse experiments.
- [00:15:25.440]Eventually express it in plants planted in the field
- [00:15:28.950]and see how it will work in different environments.
- [00:15:31.830]Another big component is the ecological risk assessment
- [00:15:35.010]that has two components
- [00:15:36.900]and I want you to consider that for biotech traits,
- [00:15:39.630]these ecological risk assessment is way more stringent
- [00:15:42.810]than any of the synthetic pesticides or even biologicals.
- [00:15:47.460]And these two components are the effects
- [00:15:49.290]on non-target organisms including humans resistance.
- [00:15:52.440]And then eventually the product is released.
- [00:15:55.110]And during this process, we also study the mode of action
- [00:15:59.010]to both understand how could potentially affect
- [00:16:01.740]other organisms
- [00:16:03.120]and how resistance could evolve.
- [00:16:06.450]So I'm going to talk a little bit about that.
- [00:16:10.680]So just going back, I told you about 2007
- [00:16:13.980]where the first publication came up into the market,
- [00:16:17.220]into say that it will work against Western corn rootworm.
- [00:16:22.410]There was different genes that they tested
- [00:16:24.660]and they finally found that a really effective gene
- [00:16:27.330]is this gene, the DvSnf7.
- [00:16:30.870]This Snf7 gene is part of the endosomal
- [00:16:33.660]sorting complex pathway
- [00:16:35.940]and basically to put it in layman terms,
- [00:16:38.010]it helps the cell take all the garbage out.
- [00:16:41.070]So one interesting thing is that when you give these
- [00:16:43.050]for example to the rootworms adults
- [00:16:44.670]is that they start getting stinky as they starting to die
- [00:16:47.580]because their cells cannot longer
- [00:16:50.400]excrete all the things from their cells.
- [00:16:53.340]So this product is by Bayer CropScience
- [00:16:56.790]and is branded as a SmartStax PRO.
- [00:16:59.620]It has three different modes of action
- [00:17:02.280]that DvSnf7 double strand RNA
- [00:17:04.680]and then two different BT proteins
- [00:17:07.230]we do two different modes of actions.
- [00:17:09.450]We're stacking it with three modes of action
- [00:17:11.820]because as I mentioned, they're highly adaptable.
- [00:17:14.070]So this is a way that we can maybe delay
- [00:17:16.050]that resistance evolution.
- [00:17:18.120]This product was registered by EPA in 2017
- [00:17:22.200]and commercially released in 2022.
- [00:17:24.957]And you might wonder why the big gap
- [00:17:27.840]between that in part was COVID.
- [00:17:30.120]But the other part is that when they're going to release
- [00:17:32.520]any transgenic product,
- [00:17:33.930]it needs to be approved in other countries for export.
- [00:17:38.610]So it wasn't approved in China until 2021
- [00:17:41.907]and that was one of the reasons why
- [00:17:43.620]it wasn't commercial available until 2022.
- [00:17:49.230]There is another product by Corteva Agriscience
- [00:17:52.470]that express this gene, the SSJ1 or snakeskin.
- [00:17:56.760]This gene has a different,
- [00:17:58.080]completely different type of mode of action.
- [00:18:00.000]Is really important for the binding between cells.
- [00:18:04.230]So it just at the end you have like,
- [00:18:06.660]you see that they can get separated.
- [00:18:09.810]This is currently under regulatory revision.
- [00:18:19.080]And then an important part to explain,
- [00:18:21.330]I mentioned that ecological risk assessment.
- [00:18:23.820]So for transgenics, we have a really defined framework
- [00:18:28.860]for ecological risk assessment defined by the EPA.
- [00:18:32.460]As I say, more stringent than for any other products
- [00:18:35.190]for insect pest management
- [00:18:37.050]and how this work is that
- [00:18:39.300]or how it work initially for BTs is that you define
- [00:18:42.180]a problem where you talk about your protection goals.
- [00:18:45.870]Lower protection goals are usually maintained
- [00:18:48.390]different ecological functions like pollination,
- [00:18:50.790]predation and degradation of things in the soil.
- [00:18:53.550]And then what are the endpoints?
- [00:18:54.840]And by endpoints I mean mortality is going to affect
- [00:18:57.810]fertility or other endpoints for other organisms.
- [00:19:01.710]We eventually have to test those things
- [00:19:04.680]and we do it in a tier approach where we do a tier one
- [00:19:07.740]with a laboratory worst case scenario
- [00:19:09.870]with the highest dose possible
- [00:19:11.460]or like maybe 10 times higher than what you will express
- [00:19:14.370]in the field.
- [00:19:15.270]If you don't find effects here in the tier one,
- [00:19:17.700]is deemed safe and then approved for that specific organism.
- [00:19:22.650]We're going organism by organism.
- [00:19:24.780]If they find there is something there,
- [00:19:26.580]then they move to a tier two
- [00:19:28.050]where is an extended laboratory semi-field,
- [00:19:30.660]a more realistic dose to what they will encounter
- [00:19:32.850]in the field.
- [00:19:34.140]If they don't find anything else, they stop there.
- [00:19:37.260]But if they find something else of concern,
- [00:19:39.330]they move to a tier three
- [00:19:40.770]that is more a field approach.
- [00:19:42.210]Usually we don't get a lot into this piece.
- [00:19:46.020]Then you do analysis of exposure.
- [00:19:48.540]Are the organisms,
- [00:19:50.220]and we're talking a lot of different organisms,
- [00:19:52.440]going to even be exposed to this trait,
- [00:19:55.830]potential effects and then
- [00:19:57.660]the EPA takes the risk characterization
- [00:19:59.790]and defines if the product can be released.
- [00:20:02.160]So this one was the framework that we use for BTs.
- [00:20:05.010]We wanted to know if this will work for RNAi.
- [00:20:08.640]We found after years
- [00:20:10.050]that it will work for the same framework.
- [00:20:12.540]And it seems from a workshop that I recently was in DC,
- [00:20:16.140]that is going to work for the third generation
- [00:20:18.180]of transgenics too.
- [00:20:21.150]So just really briefly, I did some work
- [00:20:23.370]during my postdoc working on honeybees for this.
- [00:20:27.150]But this work here is for the DvSnf7
- [00:20:30.000]from Bayer CropScience.
- [00:20:32.220]Basically what they find super specific,
- [00:20:34.890]not a lot of effects on other organisms,
- [00:20:38.400]yes they find in Southern corn rootworms
- [00:20:40.405]but they have an 98.8 sequence identity
- [00:20:43.020]really closely related to species.
- [00:20:45.390]When we talk about BTs, you're affecting the same orders.
- [00:20:48.630]In this case, you're affecting maybe some organisms
- [00:20:51.990]from the same tribe.
- [00:20:53.880]So really getting to really a specific.
- [00:20:58.080]I forget that this one doesn't click.
- [00:21:02.760]And then for the ecological risk assessment
- [00:21:05.160]for the DvSnf7 using that EPA framework
- [00:21:07.980]that I explained earlier,
- [00:21:09.720]they did a really extensive testing where they check
- [00:21:13.320]multiple non-target organisms including predators,
- [00:21:16.650]parasitoids, pollinators, soil biota,
- [00:21:19.440]aquatic and terrestrial vertebrates
- [00:21:21.720]and then look at different endpoints,
- [00:21:23.640]so survival, growth, development, reproduction.
- [00:21:26.340]And they found that basically there was no adverse effect
- [00:21:29.340]at a or above the level of the
- [00:21:32.100]maximal expected environmental concentration.
- [00:21:35.400]Now going to, I don't have a slide on that,
- [00:21:37.470]but they also find that there is no effects on mammals.
- [00:21:40.020]Mammals and vertebrates in general
- [00:21:42.030]were used to degrade nucleic acids.
- [00:21:47.130]So now to finalize, I'll going to talk a little bit of
- [00:21:52.680]what has been done by my students.
- [00:21:55.680]And within this framework,
- [00:21:58.410]we have worked a little bit in trait discovery
- [00:22:01.290]and characterization, mode of action
- [00:22:03.870]and the ecological risk assessment in terms of resistance.
- [00:22:08.250]And what we're finding is we're opening like everything
- [00:22:10.680]more of a can of worms in a lot of cases.
- [00:22:15.000]So this one we, in terms of trait identification,
- [00:22:18.210]Mariana Sanchez, a Master's student,
- [00:22:20.310]we wanted to explore chemoreceptors
- [00:22:23.010]as a species-specific genes.
- [00:22:25.047]And in this case, it will be even more specific
- [00:22:27.930]that some of the other genes that have been explored
- [00:22:30.480]just because those genes are more
- [00:22:32.100]conserved between different species.
- [00:22:34.140]In this case, it will be genes that are really
- [00:22:37.080]species-specific.
- [00:22:38.580]So we wanted to explore these ones
- [00:22:41.700]and we look at different ones
- [00:22:43.890]but I'm only going to talk about gustatory receptors
- [00:22:46.500]or GR genes.
- [00:22:47.990]In rootworms, they have three different genes:
- [00:22:50.010]gr1, gr2, gr3.
- [00:22:51.810]And is thought that these genes are related
- [00:22:54.420]with the detection of CO2 by larva
- [00:22:57.330]that gets them into finding those roots in the soil
- [00:23:00.600]once they emerge.
- [00:23:05.100]So for this, we use a parental RNAi.
- [00:23:08.970]I did some of this work during my PhD,
- [00:23:11.760]is kind of different.
- [00:23:14.370]So in this case, we did the adult females feet
- [00:23:17.430]on the double strand RNA
- [00:23:19.410]and then we looked at the phenotype in the offspring.
- [00:23:22.830]Everything that I have been talking to this point,
- [00:23:25.140]we feed it to the larva or the adult
- [00:23:27.090]and they die or show the phenotype.
- [00:23:29.220]In this case, we're passing it to the next generation.
- [00:23:37.440]And by the way, this doesn't work in all organisms
- [00:23:40.440]this well.
- [00:23:42.990]So we explore those three different genes.
- [00:23:45.930]We find that with gr2, we can knock down or silence
- [00:23:50.100]the gene on the adults, on the eggs
- [00:23:53.280]and even on the larva we saw some effects.
- [00:23:56.580]We also from these larva tested on these behavioral chambers
- [00:24:01.530]where we have CO2 and water.
- [00:24:04.620]The CO2 was basically carbonated water and normal water.
- [00:24:08.310]And we find that actually those larva
- [00:24:10.470]were not able to find the CO2.
- [00:24:13.350]So if they have the receptor,
- [00:24:14.820]they are able to find the CO2 like if it was the root.
- [00:24:18.060]If that receptor is knocked down or silenced,
- [00:24:20.670]then you will find that they will not be able to find
- [00:24:23.427]the CO2.
- [00:24:25.200]Eventually, we didn't continue exploring this idea.
- [00:24:28.140]Really good to understand gene function
- [00:24:30.510]but it was really variable.
- [00:24:32.070]It will be really hard to produce that in a plant
- [00:24:34.900]or in a sprayable.
- [00:24:37.350]So one of the things that happens
- [00:24:38.670]when you're working in these kind of things,
- [00:24:40.110]you might be in some of the work that I did
- [00:24:42.240]during my postdoc.
- [00:24:43.320]We even expressed things on plants
- [00:24:45.690]in collaboration with the other sciences
- [00:24:47.580]but it, the plant didn't express enough to
- [00:24:49.710]be able to take it to market.
- [00:24:53.010]Then the other piece is the mode of action,
- [00:24:55.470]really complicated mode of action
- [00:24:58.740]and we have been working for years trying to
- [00:25:00.930]figure out how it works.
- [00:25:02.310]It doesn't work the same in all organisms
- [00:25:04.320]and what we have learned from C. elegans
- [00:25:06.480]cannot necessarily move into insects.
- [00:25:10.470]So I divide, I like, we like to divide the mode of action
- [00:25:13.350]in three places.
- [00:25:14.340]One, uptake.
- [00:25:15.240]So how is that double strand RNA
- [00:25:17.220]getting uptake in the mid gut of the insect
- [00:25:19.470]because everything that they are getting is through feeding.
- [00:25:22.800]The double strand RNA
- [00:25:23.940]just because of the physical, chemical properties
- [00:25:25.980]couldn't get through the cuticle of the insect.
- [00:25:29.040]The other piece is the processing
- [00:25:30.600]that eventually generates that silencing
- [00:25:34.110]and then how it moves from cell to cell.
- [00:25:37.200]From our experiments with parental RNAi,
- [00:25:39.600]we know it's moving from the gut to the ovaries.
- [00:25:42.000]We really don't understand why.
- [00:25:43.740]So that's kind of like the three steps.
- [00:25:45.600]Each one of those steps have multiple genes
- [00:25:48.390]that are in both.
- [00:25:50.790]So Molly, Dr. Molly Darlington during her PhD work
- [00:25:55.350]on trying to understand some of the puzzle pieces
- [00:25:59.070]for the uptake.
- [00:26:00.480]During my postdoc, I found DCR2 and then,
- [00:26:05.160]oh it's not here.
- [00:26:06.120]DCN argano-2, those two important proteins in the processing
- [00:26:10.710]that are part of that.
- [00:26:12.720]So for uptake, not going to go into a lot of detail.
- [00:26:17.310]There was a lot of work from Molly
- [00:26:19.650]but she wanted to evaluate the different routes
- [00:26:22.050]of cellular uptake using pharmacological inhibitors.
- [00:26:25.826]RNAi of RNAi, that's not a typo.
- [00:26:28.770]That's a technique that we use that we knock down the genes
- [00:26:31.470]that we want to study
- [00:26:32.430]and then check the gene involved in the RNAi.
- [00:26:37.350]And if you want more details
- [00:26:39.240]or understand that a little bit better,
- [00:26:40.710]you can ask me later.
- [00:26:42.240]And then microscopy.
- [00:26:43.350]So we have different ways that we can take cellular uptake.
- [00:26:47.550]We can have phagocytosis, pinocytosis and receptor mediated.
- [00:26:52.020]So she wanted to explore different genes involved
- [00:26:54.300]in each one of these
- [00:26:55.920]to better understand how it's getting inside.
- [00:26:58.050]We already had an idea
- [00:26:59.340]that if maybe clattering dependent endocytosis
- [00:27:02.940]will play a role but the effect wasn't clear.
- [00:27:05.370]So we had a suspicion that maybe
- [00:27:07.350]other pathways could be involved.
- [00:27:11.040]So just really sure because I cannot go into detail.
- [00:27:14.460]We find that only evidence is still
- [00:27:16.530]for the clathrin independent endocytosis
- [00:27:18.683]still seems that maybe other pathways could be involved
- [00:27:21.990]but we didn't have really strong evidence.
- [00:27:24.780]But she did this beautiful experiment
- [00:27:27.420]with confocal microscopy
- [00:27:29.310]where she gave them this pharmacological inhibitor
- [00:27:32.670]dextran sulfate.
- [00:27:33.930]This dextran sulfate is important for scavenger receptors.
- [00:27:39.030]She labeled her double strand RNA for Snf7 with Alexa Fluor
- [00:27:43.740]so its that,
- [00:27:46.650]that red that you see.
- [00:27:48.570]So in here you can see the control, the dsRNA
- [00:27:51.180]and you can see that that red is being uptaken by the cells.
- [00:27:54.330]These ones are inside guts.
- [00:27:56.790]And then when you do the Dextran Sulfate
- [00:27:58.920]plus the double strand RNA,
- [00:28:01.530]you don't see any red.
- [00:28:02.850]So that show us really evidently that
- [00:28:05.670]scavenger C receptors are definitely involved
- [00:28:08.370]in the uptake of a double strand RNA in rootworms
- [00:28:11.910]and gave us further evidence
- [00:28:13.890]that clathrin-dependent endocytosis plays a role
- [00:28:18.150]in Western corn rootworm uptake of double strand RNA.
- [00:28:22.080]The other part that we're exploring,
- [00:28:24.240]as I say I explored this part for the processing
- [00:28:26.580]during my postdoc,
- [00:28:28.410]we're trying to understand how it's moved from cell to cell.
- [00:28:31.140]We have a hypothesis that is due by, done by exosomes.
- [00:28:37.170]So Dr Suresh Varsani, my postdoc,
- [00:28:39.870]is currently working on this project.
- [00:28:42.330]We also want to explore if these exosomes
- [00:28:44.880]could potentially be used
- [00:28:46.290]or if we give the double strand RNA coated in exosomes,
- [00:28:49.830]if that could be used to target a recalcitrant species.
- [00:28:56.970]That said with mode of actions, that's a really dense work
- [00:29:00.780]that I didn't wanna go into a lot of detail.
- [00:29:03.360]Now let's talk more about the field susceptibility
- [00:29:05.730]that is more applicable for like
- [00:29:07.650]the application of this technology.
- [00:29:10.770]When you work with plant-incorporated protectants,
- [00:29:13.500]that's how we call any transgenics,
- [00:29:15.810]we need to worry about resistance.
- [00:29:17.580]Why, because when you think in terms
- [00:29:19.350]of synthetic insecticides,
- [00:29:20.700]you're only applying that insecticide
- [00:29:22.320]when you see the pressure of the insect.
- [00:29:24.570]In this case, that trait is expressed all the time.
- [00:29:28.260]So the likelihood of the organism to adapt to resistance
- [00:29:31.830]is even higher.
- [00:29:33.900]The other part that is important that we have learned
- [00:29:36.270]and I can talk with if any of us is interested,
- [00:29:38.730]I can tell you more, is the high dose.
- [00:29:41.070]We know that this trait is not expressed in a high dose.
- [00:29:44.790]So the likelihood of evolving resistance is higher
- [00:29:47.400]and that's why the SmartStax Pro product
- [00:29:50.100]has two different proteins from BT
- [00:29:52.530]with two different mode of actions
- [00:29:53.880]plus the DvSnf7 double strand RNA.
- [00:29:57.120]So because of this, the EPA requires
- [00:29:59.880]insect resistance management or initially in the early days
- [00:30:03.780]of be of plant-incorporated protectants,
- [00:30:06.540]it was those only this insect resistance management.
- [00:30:09.780]But later on, they also require that they need to use
- [00:30:14.370]both traits.
- [00:30:15.990]And I can, I could give a whole lecture on this,
- [00:30:18.237]not going to go in a lot of details.
- [00:30:20.490]The other thing that is different is that RNAi
- [00:30:23.030]is also active in adults.
- [00:30:25.170]With BTs, they only work on larva.
- [00:30:27.210]The adults can need any other tissue,
- [00:30:29.820]not going to have any effect.
- [00:30:31.920]In the adults, in with RNAi,
- [00:30:34.815]it will have an effect on the adults.
- [00:30:36.510]So the likelihood of potential resistance might be higher.
- [00:30:40.650]And we also wanted to explore that idea,
- [00:30:43.080]well if it works in the adults,
- [00:30:45.270]anybody that has worked with rootworms,
- [00:30:47.250]they over winter,
- [00:30:48.330]so you need to collect the adults this year.
- [00:30:51.030]Let them over winter and you're not going to be able
- [00:30:53.280]to test anything until next spring.
- [00:30:55.590]So we wanted to test if maybe doing assays with the adults
- [00:30:59.430]will be equivalent to what you find
- [00:31:01.350]in terms of susceptibility with the larva.
- [00:31:05.220]And that's the work that I'm going to describe in a second.
- [00:31:08.040]But then also in 2018, Bayer CropScience
- [00:31:11.370]showed that they could develop a resistant colony
- [00:31:14.880]from insects collected in the field.
- [00:31:17.640]So they did multiple generations of selection
- [00:31:21.630]and they find out that they could generate a colony
- [00:31:23.970]that it was higher than 130 times more resistant
- [00:31:27.540]to the double strand RNA for DvSnf7.
- [00:31:30.210]They started to look a little bit in the mechanism
- [00:31:33.510]and like how it will work.
- [00:31:35.370]As you can see here, this is DvSnf7.
- [00:31:38.580]Red is the susceptible, blue is the resistant.
- [00:31:43.350]It was resistant to a lot of other different
- [00:31:46.350]double strand RNAs.
- [00:31:48.060]So not good because if it evolves resistance to one trait,
- [00:31:51.300]it will evolve resistance to all double stranded RNAs.
- [00:31:54.630]So that kind of killed some of the excitement
- [00:31:57.000]of people working with RNAi.
- [00:31:59.430]And yeah, as you can see, similar to what Molly showed
- [00:32:02.130]with the uptake with the inhibitor,
- [00:32:05.490]that's what they found with the resistance,
- [00:32:06.870]that there is no uptake.
- [00:32:09.000]I think in here you just cannot see it
- [00:32:11.520]but the control, you can see the red there.
- [00:32:14.160]So anyway, the mechanism is due to uptake
- [00:32:18.210]of the double strand RNA.
- [00:32:19.980]Bayer CropScience, they probably already know the mechanism.
- [00:32:22.830]Haven't published yet.
- [00:32:23.880]We're waiting for
- [00:32:24.930]for that publication to come out
- [00:32:26.580]to understand more of details on that.
- [00:32:29.790]So as part of what I mentioned,
- [00:32:31.530]we wanted to stress if we can use the adults
- [00:32:33.570]but also have a a better understanding of
- [00:32:35.880]how field populations will be susceptible
- [00:32:38.700]to double strand RNA.
- [00:32:40.920]So we collaborated with Bayer CropScience
- [00:32:44.154]and my student Matthew Welter, this work,
- [00:32:47.040]we had populations from Nebraska, from Iowa,
- [00:32:51.060]from South Dakota and Minnesota.
- [00:32:53.160]Two different susceptible controls:
- [00:32:55.260]crop characteristics that is a commensurable vendor,
- [00:32:58.020]Bayer CropScience and then others.
- [00:33:00.450]Bayer CropScience RNAi resistant strain
- [00:33:04.080]and then a Cry3Bb1 resistant.
- [00:33:06.810]Cry3Bb1 again is a BT protein.
- [00:33:11.610]So it's not going to go in a lot of detail.
- [00:33:14.040]You can see that there is a lot of diversity
- [00:33:16.620]in the susceptibility.
- [00:33:19.560]The only one that I want you to notice here, the resistant,
- [00:33:22.530]you can't even plot it there
- [00:33:23.700]because you can't get a little concentration.
- [00:33:26.940]For this population, you can see it's not a mistake.
- [00:33:29.580]The F is up here.
- [00:33:31.380]Leigh, Nebraska,
- [00:33:32.550]those larva relatively not that susceptible.
- [00:33:36.420]Interesting there, a lot of the field testing
- [00:33:38.730]was done in Leigh, Nebraska of the
- [00:33:40.650]of this product.
- [00:33:45.480]Then with the adult susceptibility,
- [00:33:47.220]like everything in science,
- [00:33:48.420]you think that everything is going to work beautiful
- [00:33:51.000]but it didn't.
- [00:33:52.050]We find out there is a lot of variability
- [00:33:54.360]actually in the adults.
- [00:33:56.190]So we had to do more assays and understand
- [00:33:58.500]that for the control population,
- [00:34:00.630]you can see there is a lot of variability
- [00:34:02.580]between the ages of the insects in terms of susceptibility
- [00:34:05.850]and then when you move into females and males,
- [00:34:08.610]it's also really different.
- [00:34:11.580]We still don't understand the biological mechanism
- [00:34:14.190]of this happen.
- [00:34:15.023]So make the testing more challenging
- [00:34:17.610]and we had to H-synchronize the insects
- [00:34:20.490]to be able to do the testing.
- [00:34:23.040]And in terms of the adult susceptibility,
- [00:34:25.200]again a lot of variability but interestingly enough,
- [00:34:29.610]the susceptibility didn't correlate
- [00:34:31.440]with the larval susceptibility.
- [00:34:33.780]We still don't understand why.
- [00:34:35.010]So the original idea that we could use adults
- [00:34:38.310]to monitor for resistance will not work.
- [00:34:42.330]But we understood or learned a lot about in general,
- [00:34:45.660]how larva and adults are susceptible in the field.
- [00:34:50.490]We wanted to further explore these.
- [00:34:54.600]So Molly did another study where we wanted to correlate
- [00:34:58.200]this in terms of gene function
- [00:35:01.110]or the gene expression.
- [00:35:03.270]So she did in 2020, collections of those adult rootworms,
- [00:35:08.310]tested susceptibility in both larva and adult
- [00:35:11.400]and did a gene expression analysis of some target genes.
- [00:35:18.300]And what she found out is that
- [00:35:22.050]in terms of not going to go in a lot of details here
- [00:35:26.100]is that there is genes that overlap between larvae and adult
- [00:35:31.800]and then some that are more overexpressed in adult
- [00:35:35.580]or on larva that that might explain why
- [00:35:38.400]is that differential gene expression between the larvae
- [00:35:41.040]and the adults
- [00:35:43.140]or the differential susceptibility.
- [00:35:46.140]Something that was interesting
- [00:35:47.700]is that we will not looking for toll receptor genes.
- [00:35:50.340]Toll receptor genes are more related with immune response,
- [00:35:54.120]not with any of the RNAi pathways.
- [00:35:57.810]We still don't know the linkage
- [00:35:59.220]and it's something that we would like to explore
- [00:36:01.110]a little bit more.
- [00:36:02.940]And we find this new gene hen1
- [00:36:05.880]that has never been described before.
- [00:36:09.210]In terms by population effect for larvae and adults,
- [00:36:12.450]again a lot of different overlapping genes
- [00:36:15.390]and these gene are genes that I was showing you.
- [00:36:17.640]The mode of action, I show you a couple of genes.
- [00:36:20.400]A lot of those genes are correlated differences
- [00:36:23.790]between adult and larva.
- [00:36:26.160]Again, we have for larva some of those toll receptor genes
- [00:36:30.660]that are present.
- [00:36:34.380]So, we originally thought that we were only working
- [00:36:36.900]with the siRNA pathway
- [00:36:38.910]but now we're finding that a lot of those genes
- [00:36:40.980]and there is crosstalk between the pathways
- [00:36:43.740]and it got more complicated than we thought.
- [00:36:46.710]And you have also these toll receptor genes
- [00:36:49.410]that are potentially related with immunity.
- [00:36:52.710]So just something to think about for us
- [00:36:56.520]in how that will affect susceptibility in the field.
- [00:37:00.000]For the next step that will happen here,
- [00:37:01.980]we really wanna start understanding
- [00:37:04.380]how resistance will evolve in the
- [00:37:06.600]in the field.
- [00:37:10.080]So just some and I'll finish really early
- [00:37:13.260]take home messages.
- [00:37:15.150]RNAi highly specific tool for pest management.
- [00:37:19.620]Had to do a really, a short overview.
- [00:37:23.040]Didn't went into a lot of detail
- [00:37:24.450]but I'm happy to answer any question.
- [00:37:26.460]First transgenic product
- [00:37:27.810]for Western corn rootworm management
- [00:37:29.550]was first commercially available in 2022.
- [00:37:31.980]So really recent.
- [00:37:33.270]We had only been I guess two years in the market.
- [00:37:37.050]The first spray for Colorado potato beetle
- [00:37:39.360]is in open process for public comment by EPA.
- [00:37:44.250]If anybody's interested, send me an email
- [00:37:46.980]and you wanna comment, I can send you the link for that.
- [00:37:50.190]In terms of ecological risk assessment,
- [00:37:52.500]like any type of insecticide that we're going to apply,
- [00:37:56.700]there is a risk of resistance
- [00:37:58.590]and we need to concern,
- [00:37:59.670]be concerned of how we are going to protect this technology.
- [00:38:02.400]In terms of effects on non-target organisms,
- [00:38:05.340]the effects are minimal
- [00:38:06.870]and even less than when we talk about BTs for example.
- [00:38:11.610]And one big challenge that we have
- [00:38:13.290]is the communication with the public.
- [00:38:15.600]I remember a couple of years ago
- [00:38:17.130]talking with Vice-Chancellor Mike Bain,
- [00:38:19.530]that he mentioned that they did a survey in Nebraska
- [00:38:23.310]and they mentioned that 60% of the population
- [00:38:25.830]think that you shouldn't need DNA.
- [00:38:27.840]So if we are starting from that background
- [00:38:29.520]even in agricultural state
- [00:38:32.190]that we have even a high use of transgenics,
- [00:38:35.490]that will be a
- [00:38:37.033]a really big challenge when you have a double strand RNA
- [00:38:40.035]or RNA in the world.
- [00:38:43.621]And with that, I will be happy to answer any questions.
- [00:38:49.221]My understanding is RNAi was or
- [00:38:51.300]or that process double strand RNA was how viruses
- [00:38:54.630]have in plants and potentially causing effect
- [00:38:57.300]of shutting down.
- [00:38:58.830]That was a way of the plant protecting itself
- [00:39:00.750]or whatever organism
- [00:39:02.790]that was trying to defend itself.
- [00:39:03.900]So if you have resistance to RNAi,
- [00:39:06.000]it seems broad across several genes,
- [00:39:08.970]are those resistant populations
- [00:39:11.100]potentially even more susceptible to viruses?
- [00:39:14.190]Has any work been done on it?
- [00:39:15.750]That's a great question that we would like to answer
- [00:39:18.090]and it's also that I would like
- [00:39:20.610]that I curious.
- [00:39:22.320]So okay, two things.
- [00:39:23.460]First, viruses are not great at controlling rootworms.
- [00:39:28.650]So there is not a lot of viruses that kill rootworms.
- [00:39:32.820]For what reason I don't know if in the soil is harder
- [00:39:35.520]and a plant pathologist can correct me if that's the case.
- [00:39:39.420]Two, I have the same question
- [00:39:41.220]but also how potentially the
- [00:39:44.730]like maybe populations that have different exposure
- [00:39:47.130]to different viruses
- [00:39:48.390]or higher loads of viruses
- [00:39:50.220]might make them even develop that resistance faster or not
- [00:39:53.280]or more susceptible.
- [00:39:54.113]We really don't know the correlation.
- [00:39:56.010]We know there was a study on honeybees
- [00:39:57.870]but what they did is that they injected double strand RNA
- [00:40:01.230]to the bees
- [00:40:02.460]and then gave them a virus.
- [00:40:03.960]And actually what they that
- [00:40:05.340]that they did was that make the honeybees more resistant
- [00:40:09.360]to the virus.
- [00:40:10.530]It's like you prompt the RNAi machinery,
- [00:40:13.710]make them more
- [00:40:16.470]how do you say, more tolerant to the virus.
- [00:40:18.720]So we still don't even understand what is that correlation
- [00:40:21.390]with a viral exposure
- [00:40:22.950]and then your exposure to double strand RNA.
- [00:40:25.250]So that's a great question that we still have
- [00:40:27.330]not answered in terms of resistance
- [00:40:29.010]and also for non-target organisms.
- [00:40:37.350]That was a very nice presentation.
- [00:40:39.090]I enjoyed all your visuals.
- [00:40:40.830]Oh thank you.
- [00:40:42.150]I have to tell you that a lot of it went way over my head
- [00:40:45.450]but nonetheless, it was very interesting.
- [00:40:47.670]My question is
- [00:40:49.200]in a recent article in "Nebraska Farmer" came out this week,
- [00:40:53.310]talked about a Bayer product with proteins and BT and
- [00:40:59.790]can you tell us more about that?
- [00:41:02.100]Yep. So that one is this product actually.
- [00:41:11.610]So it's this Bayer product SmartStax Pro
- [00:41:14.730]that has the three modes of action.
- [00:41:16.320]So it has that DvSnf7 that was strand RNA
- [00:41:19.860]plus the two BT proteins cry2bt1 and Cry34/35.
- [00:41:25.560]In theory, all of them or no,
- [00:41:27.210]we know that all of those three,
- [00:41:28.890]they have different modes of action.
- [00:41:30.450]So that's what we're hoping
- [00:41:32.340]that it will help delay resistance.
- [00:41:35.250]One issue there is that it's already,
- [00:41:37.620]we have already certain populations in Nebraska
- [00:41:40.500]that already have resistance to Cry2bt1
- [00:41:43.107]and some of them have even resistance to Cry2bt1
- [00:41:46.174]and Cry34/35.
- [00:41:47.880]But those populations are the ones that we're more
- [00:41:50.820]concerned about
- [00:41:51.930]that they will also evolve resistance to DvSnf7.
- [00:41:56.640]And what about...
- [00:41:59.340]how many you, how many hybrids are...
- [00:42:01.470]That's okay.
- [00:42:02.303]How many hybrids or what company's license this?
- [00:42:06.353]This is just Bayer. Right now just Bayer.
- [00:42:10.050]Yeah and I think that a cortellis is coming with a new trait
- [00:42:13.830]but it will have the same DvSnf7.
- [00:42:16.710]So it will have a genetics from Corteva but it's not,
- [00:42:20.490]I don't think it is
- [00:42:21.720]Bob do you know or Jeff?
- [00:42:23.670]I don't think it's out yet but it will have the same traits.
- [00:42:26.760]But for right now the only one that is out in the market
- [00:42:29.190]and the only genetics is from Bayer.
- [00:42:33.950]Okay.
- [00:42:38.670]Question from the...
- [00:42:40.350]from online.
- [00:42:44.100]There was an early concern about the uptake of 24
- [00:42:47.640]to 24 base pair RNA eye molecules by insects.
- [00:42:51.540]Apparently insects can only uptake larger,
- [00:42:53.580]about 70 base pair duplexes.
- [00:42:55.740]Hmm.
- [00:42:56.573]Early works use chloroplast expression
- [00:42:58.350]to generate the larger duplexes.
- [00:42:59.613]It is still a concern and that's from Mitra.
- [00:43:03.960]Yep. So that's a great question, Dr. Mitra.
- [00:43:08.190]Yes, we find that 2120, so let's go back to this here
- [00:43:17.103]in the mode of action.
- [00:43:18.270]So what happened is like that double strand RNA is long.
- [00:43:21.000]So what we give the insect is 240 or 150 base pairs.
- [00:43:26.460]Then it gets, it gets inside.
- [00:43:27.990]It is sharp in little place in little small interference RNA
- [00:43:31.680]that are 21 to 25 base pairs
- [00:43:34.260]and that's actually what generates the silencing.
- [00:43:37.920]So at some point, we thought okay we can give them
- [00:43:39.810]a bunch of 21 base pairs.
- [00:43:41.490]We find out that for rootworms specifically,
- [00:43:44.340]they don't take it.
- [00:43:45.173]They need to take at least 60 base pairs
- [00:43:47.130]will the only thing that will be uptaken by the cell.
- [00:43:49.890]If you give them a 25, 21 to 24 base pairs,
- [00:43:53.490]will not be uptaken by the cells.
- [00:43:54.990]So will not have an effect.
- [00:43:57.000]Why we don't, we still don't know.
- [00:43:59.190]It might be related to those receptors
- [00:44:01.560]that they have a length limit to be uptaken.
- [00:44:05.577]And just a caveat there, this is
- [00:44:08.280]we have only proved that for rootworms.
- [00:44:10.230]They haven't been tested this for other insects,
- [00:44:14.250]not that it has been published.
- [00:44:16.470]A lot of this work that is
- [00:44:18.090]gets makes it challenge is that companies do a lot of work
- [00:44:20.640]but sometimes they don't publish.
- [00:44:22.230]So you might ask the question
- [00:44:23.400]and then they say oh yeah we did that
- [00:44:24.660]but we never publish it.
- [00:44:26.040]So not publishable yet.
- [00:44:28.860]So yeah, we need to incorporate those
- [00:44:31.830]longer double strand RNAs.
- [00:44:33.600]In terms of the chloroplast insertion,
- [00:44:37.380]they have found the product from Corteva
- [00:44:39.690]actually is not producing the chloroplast.
- [00:44:41.970]So somehow, still those longer sequences
- [00:44:45.630]are getting inside the insect
- [00:44:48.420]but for other traits or for other organisms,
- [00:44:51.120]they're trying to express more in the chloroplast
- [00:44:53.910]and for those of you who don't understand,
- [00:44:55.350]so the plant also has that RNAi machinery.
- [00:44:58.560]So if you produce a sequence,
- [00:45:00.420]then the RNAi machinery from the plant will chop it.
- [00:45:03.150]So the Amanda will get into the insect
- [00:45:05.010]will not be as much.
- [00:45:06.720]If you express it on the chloroplast,
- [00:45:08.610]you're kind of protecting it from the rest of the plant
- [00:45:11.370]and you're being
- [00:45:13.230]or ensuring that you're getting that longer
- [00:45:15.420]sequence into the insect.
- [00:45:17.460]So still, the chloroplast expression
- [00:45:20.100]will make it more effective.
- [00:45:29.100]Thank you for this very interesting presentation.
- [00:45:31.710]I do have one practical question.
- [00:45:33.480]Do you have any information on the adoption rate
- [00:45:35.520]of the product that was commercialized
- [00:45:38.100]and are there any new concerns on the rise
- [00:45:41.430]since the product went commercial?
- [00:45:44.070]Not so.
- [00:45:44.903]We don't really.
- [00:45:45.736]I know that in 2022, it wasn't really available
- [00:45:48.990]but I don't know in terms of adoption.
- [00:45:50.700]I think that will,
- [00:45:51.630]we will learn more of that later on.
- [00:45:54.390]Jeff? Yeah.
- [00:45:56.220]I will ask maybe more to the people that work with farmers.
- [00:46:01.740]In terms of concerns,
- [00:46:02.940]so far we haven't heard anything.
- [00:46:07.080]A lot of times what happened unfortunately with companies
- [00:46:10.110]is that there is a concern and they don't talk about it.
- [00:46:13.410]Maybe a couple of years later
- [00:46:15.660]or maybe sometimes an extension,
- [00:46:17.760]a person at the university hears about it
- [00:46:19.620]and then that's when we are aware of it.
- [00:46:22.110]So so far, we just have had a two seasons.
- [00:46:24.840]I know that in 2022, the adoption wasn't great
- [00:46:28.410]because they just take it out.
- [00:46:30.300]Biggest adoption interior would be this year
- [00:46:32.850]but we still don't have the numbers.
- [00:46:34.830]So I'm also curious to see what's going to happen
- [00:46:37.230]if we're going to have any concerns.
- [00:46:40.260]Okay, thank you very much for your
- [00:46:41.670]Yeah, thank you. Answer.
- [00:46:48.687]Okay, any further questions?
- [00:46:53.711]We'll finish or we...
- [00:46:54.991]I got one.
- [00:46:58.620]Thank you for your presentation.
- [00:46:59.670]Maybe this is also for you or for the ones in the room
- [00:47:03.420]that have more contact with farmers.
- [00:47:05.100]And so this last technology that they mentioned
- [00:47:06.930]that was released is in terms of management from the farmers
- [00:47:10.080]points of view to protect let's say the technology.
- [00:47:12.870]There's some constraints.
- [00:47:14.520]What is for this specific technology
- [00:47:16.530]if you comment on that?
- [00:47:18.060]So let's step back to BT.
- [00:47:20.520]So a bit like I mentioned, the insect resistant management,
- [00:47:24.540]like the main thing is that we need to have a refuge
- [00:47:27.120]right there.
- [00:47:28.020]So the refuge means that you need to plant plants
- [00:47:30.780]that are not expressing that trait.
- [00:47:33.540]That way you have susceptible insects
- [00:47:35.640]that then will mate with those resistance insects
- [00:47:38.730]and from a lot of assumptions that we originally had,
- [00:47:41.430]then you will dilute it.
- [00:47:42.990]We're finding that those assumptions don't always meet
- [00:47:45.450]like everything in biology.
- [00:47:47.670]So then, that's why we need to do the high dose.
- [00:47:52.800]Also at some point, there was no farmer compliance
- [00:47:55.650]because originally, they just get a bag
- [00:47:57.330]and they need to do a strips or like put it in the borders.
- [00:48:01.230]Obviously farmers don't, those will get damaged.
- [00:48:03.690]They didn't employ it so they employed or apply something
- [00:48:06.720]called refuge in a bag
- [00:48:08.220]where they give you a bag
- [00:48:09.270]where it has the refuge there.
- [00:48:10.980]And the refuge for example here in the Midwest,
- [00:48:13.170]they completely different from Texas for example.
- [00:48:16.500]Anyway, so we use the same strategies so far.
- [00:48:19.500]So they still need to apply the refuge in a bag
- [00:48:22.080]and form rootworms.
- [00:48:23.340]Farmers also need to ensure
- [00:48:25.020]that they are using IPM strategies
- [00:48:27.720]and I think that's just harder to determine
- [00:48:31.080]if the farmers are using the IPM.
- [00:48:32.880]That's the recommendation from EPA.
- [00:48:35.520]But I don't think no one can enforce
- [00:48:37.800]if they are using both the...
- [00:48:39.810]if they're using IPM.
- [00:48:41.130]So enforce in a way, they sell the bags
- [00:48:43.410]already with the refuge in the bags,
- [00:48:45.270]so the percentage of seeds
- [00:48:47.070]that are not expressing the trait.
- [00:48:50.550]Yeah.
- [00:48:56.347]Did in the process of identifying resistance,
- [00:48:59.010]did they indicate any fitness costs
- [00:49:01.110]associated with the resistance to RNAi or is anybody?
- [00:49:04.080]It doesn't seem to have a fitness
- [00:49:05.550]like everything in rootworms.
- [00:49:06.597]Was that a expectation?
- [00:49:09.030]With rootworms, yes.
- [00:49:10.380]Like I don't know why they're so hardy
- [00:49:11.790]that a lot of the things that they end up
- [00:49:14.190]revolve in resistance.
- [00:49:16.440]We don't find a lot of fitness costs.
- [00:49:18.330]I sometime wonder if we don't,
- [00:49:20.190]we maybe are measuring some fitness that they have
- [00:49:22.800]but we're not measuring them.
- [00:49:24.510]But yeah, rootworms just seem to be hardy at everything.
- [00:49:38.160]I don't really come from a molecular background.
- [00:49:41.010]So I really have a question that might
- [00:49:43.140]not be the brightest one,
- [00:49:44.070]but I'm really concerned about the
- [00:49:46.980]gene flow from crop to the wild relatives.
- [00:49:49.980]Is that like, is that a real concern?
- [00:49:52.260]Can that happen and what would be the implications of that?
- [00:49:55.737]So that would be the same concern that we will have
- [00:49:57.660]with the BT traits.
- [00:50:00.090]And I think maybe you guys are more familiar
- [00:50:02.790]or maybe Bob, you're more familiar with that.
- [00:50:05.280]There was not a lot of concerns in terms of the
- [00:50:08.090]of the gene flow, but I don't remember.
- [00:50:10.620]So like those are studies from the '90s.
- [00:50:14.040]So like if there were like in some ways,
- [00:50:15.960]the EPA assumes that things that were tested in the past
- [00:50:19.080]for BTs will apply for things currently.
- [00:50:22.470]But there is, but that's like from all the,
- [00:50:25.605]in the, in a public sense,
- [00:50:26.910]that's kind of like the biggest concern
- [00:50:28.740]that you will renew, reduce gene
- [00:50:33.317]and not even inserting the genes
- [00:50:34.680]but just reducing the gene variability in closest relatives.
- [00:50:40.080]But there's no wild relatives of corn
- [00:50:42.750]In Nebraska.
- [00:50:43.583]So it is like it will be more of a...
- [00:50:44.490]Oh yeah, in New Mexico, grass stuff like that.
- [00:50:51.220]But I will say in other places, if you were,
- [00:50:53.640]so this technology is more relevant
- [00:50:55.200]for the US Midwest for rootworms.
- [00:50:57.810]If they are going to use it in another place
- [00:50:59.766]where there is a concern with gene flow,
- [00:51:02.040]then the regulatory agencies of that country
- [00:51:04.710]will require more testing in terms of that.
- [00:51:07.560]So that's part of like what happens
- [00:51:09.180]with a lot of the products that going to Asia for example,
- [00:51:12.390]that they need to do.
- [00:51:13.740]Like companies will need to do more testing
- [00:51:15.600]to demonstrate that the gene flow or like the likelihood
- [00:51:18.030]of gene flow will be low.
- [00:51:20.040]So that's part of the, that ecological risk assessment.
- [00:51:22.800]That will be a species of concern for example.
- [00:51:26.130]Yeah.
- [00:51:29.340]Sure.
- [00:51:32.850]My question is very practical I guess
- [00:51:35.310]in that your evaluations,
- [00:51:38.190]I'll say sort of stop at the laboratory or
- [00:51:41.010]or maybe some field studies,
- [00:51:43.410]but when it gets to Bayer or a farmer,
- [00:51:47.460]that yield monitor is their yardstick
- [00:51:52.020]and so what are the chances of making a
- [00:51:57.240]an overinterpretation or underestimation
- [00:52:00.600]based on other factors that affect yield?
- [00:52:06.358]That's How do you,
- [00:52:07.191]How do you deal with that?
- [00:52:08.190]That's a great question
- [00:52:09.540]and that just goes then to Bob and Justin (laughs) and Jeff
- [00:52:13.950]that I will be concerned but yeah,
- [00:52:15.540]there is always a concern of like how that will affect.
- [00:52:18.360]I know that companies, what they do a lot
- [00:52:20.490]is test these products
- [00:52:21.780]at different environmental conditions.
- [00:52:24.420]So just to be sure that they will perform the same way
- [00:52:27.990]no matter if you have drought or other things.
- [00:52:30.810]There is other, there was a PhD student too, not in my lab,
- [00:52:34.500]that did more testing with different farmers
- [00:52:36.630]and they look at field histories
- [00:52:39.600]and looking at yields too.
- [00:52:41.160]I don't recall all what he necessarily found
- [00:52:45.270]but those are things that actually companies
- [00:52:47.700]are concerned and test too.
- [00:52:50.560]I, in my case, I just work up to the greenhouse
- [00:52:53.730]and maybe bring the insects here
- [00:52:55.557]and then give it to other people to deal with it.
- [00:53:00.390]Impact shield enough, they're probably not likely
- [00:53:03.480]to continue to grow it
- [00:53:04.590]unless they have the concern always the yield loss.
- [00:53:11.880]But for I, what I understand in terms of yields
- [00:53:13.950]is as competitive to any of their other hybrids
- [00:53:16.500]that they currently have.
- [00:53:21.030]In terms of the trait characterization,
- [00:53:22.800]that's a big part that they need to do
- [00:53:24.660]because sometimes they can insert traits
- [00:53:28.320]that might decrease the yield of the product.
- [00:53:41.295]Thank you.
- [00:53:42.128]I'd like to thank you for a very interesting presentation.
- [00:53:44.160]I very much enjoyed it
- [00:53:45.240]and we appreciate you taking the time
- [00:53:47.010]to come and be a part of this seminar series.
- [00:53:49.350]Thank you very much. Thank you.
- [00:53:50.593](audience claps)
The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!
You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.
Log in to post comments
Embed
Copy the following code into your page
HTML
<div style="padding-top: 56.25%; overflow: hidden; position:relative; -webkit-box-flex: 1; flex-grow: 1;"> <iframe style="bottom: 0; left: 0; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; border: 0; height: 100%; width: 100%;" src="https://mediahub.unl.edu/media/21546?format=iframe&autoplay=0" title="Video Player: RNA Interference for Insect Pest Management" allowfullscreen ></iframe> </div>
Comments
0 Comments