Faculty Interview Guy Trainin-UNL
Brad Severa
Author
10/05/2022
Added
12
Plays
Description
OER Faculty Seed Grant interview with Guy Trainin.
Searchable Transcript
Toggle between list and paragraph view.
- [00:00:05.450]All right, so in our case, we're really looking at
- [00:00:08.507]the whole program, trying to move into OER,
- [00:00:11.647]and that's a process, but really what's driving the decision
- [00:00:16.970]to move onto OER is at heart of the social justice.
- [00:00:20.230]And it's a weird way to think about technology,
- [00:00:22.560]but I often think about technology
- [00:00:24.330]from a social justice perspective.
- [00:00:26.805]OER allows more access to our materials
- [00:00:29.684]with no additional cost to anybody who's there.
- [00:00:33.730]But there's a second layer that we think about,
- [00:00:37.240]and that is because we are in teacher education,
- [00:00:40.310]everything we do helps our students, primarily,
- [00:00:44.340]but it also models for them what we want them to do
- [00:00:47.230]in the classroom, so we think about OER as an opportunity
- [00:00:50.140]to model how K-12 classrooms that they're going to be
- [00:00:54.162]teachers in, can work in the same way, so they can rely
- [00:00:56.928]on OER to deliver curriculum,
- [00:01:00.610]making the cost for their districts,
- [00:01:03.190]and accessibility for their students considerably better.
- [00:01:06.860]So it works on both of those levels,
- [00:01:09.320]and so the big umbrella is social justice,
- [00:01:12.728]and in there we're thinking about how do we model
- [00:01:16.604]excellent teaching practices, and we're considering
- [00:01:19.960]the price and the impact on our students,
- [00:01:21.707]and the access to multiple media, because this is
- [00:01:26.410]the opportunity that we have to expose our students
- [00:01:30.130]not just to text, but to text with interactive items,
- [00:01:33.880]with video, with audio, and I know that there are
- [00:01:36.650]paid versions of that, but again,
- [00:01:38.967]the ability to have control over that is really important.
- [00:01:43.520]The last piece, and I think that is really important,
- [00:01:45.282]is that it gives instructors more control over material,
- [00:01:48.840]because when you decide to adapt a textbook,
- [00:01:51.320]unless you wrote it yourself, it's going to not work
- [00:01:54.070]100% for what you're doing, and so you start having
- [00:01:57.000]to make compromises.
- [00:01:58.670]If you make too many compromises and you tell your students,
- [00:02:01.140]we're gonna ask you to buy this book, it's $120, or 400,
- [00:02:05.140]and we're gonna use only chapters four, eight, and 12,
- [00:02:09.580]students feel that they have spent their money,
- [00:02:12.600]and they're not getting their money back.
- [00:02:15.290]And that may or may not be true, but it means that I'm,
- [00:02:20.030]as an instructor, kind of pushed to adapt more of that book,
- [00:02:23.380]even if I don't love it, whereas if I'm deciding on
- [00:02:27.410]exactly what to include, and I have the freedom to
- [00:02:29.476]pick pieces, or to adapt even a whole book, but it's free,
- [00:02:34.000]and it's electronic, it does give me the freedom to use
- [00:02:37.590]only what I really want to use,
- [00:02:39.200]and avoid the things I don't want to use.
- [00:02:46.000]Well, when we think about converting our courses to OER,
- [00:02:50.830]because we're doing it as a program,
- [00:02:52.580]we have additional steps.
- [00:02:54.090]So the first thing we do is we approach our instructors
- [00:02:57.330]and say, are you interested, this is the direction
- [00:02:59.960]we're moving, we're thinking about social justice.
- [00:03:02.220]So we talk about the why first, and the opportunity second.
- [00:03:06.760]Then we try to identify what they're using now.
- [00:03:10.140]A lot of our instructors, because we have an LMS,
- [00:03:13.070]really use a variety of resources that are beyond
- [00:03:15.970]just using a textbook, so the transition is
- [00:03:17.900]a little bit easier, I think.
- [00:03:19.420]And the first thing we try to identify is, is there
- [00:03:23.810]a textbook that is OER that is available out there.
- [00:03:29.910]We have found very, very few of those out there that have
- [00:03:33.910]enough quality that are worth it.
- [00:03:35.680]If we have that, that that's what we use,
- [00:03:37.990]and we use the creative commons license to play with
- [00:03:44.900]the structure, add, subtract, and not adapt it just as-is,
- [00:03:49.340]but to try to stay as close as possible.
- [00:03:51.320]That is the easiest, least amount of friction.
- [00:03:54.508]The advantage is, it's easy.
- [00:03:57.110]The disadvantage is, it doesn't have as much impact on
- [00:03:59.700]pedagogy as the second option, and the second option
- [00:04:02.900]has happened more often.
- [00:04:04.677]And that is that we go back and look at,
- [00:04:08.690]what is the content you want to deliver,
- [00:04:10.480]and then find resources that are available
- [00:04:13.590]through the library, so journal articles that are aimed at
- [00:04:16.370]practitioners, sometimes they are aimed at researchers,
- [00:04:20.599]videos that are available out there, other resources,
- [00:04:25.170]guides, teaching guides, PDFs that are available and
- [00:04:30.809]free to use, and we stitch them together into classes.
- [00:04:34.980]So the idea there is that we are creating
- [00:04:38.070]a collection of resources where the instructor's job
- [00:04:43.095]stops being explaining the book, and the intent behind it,
- [00:04:48.210]or whatever the textbook is, and becomes more the person
- [00:04:52.670]who helps our students connect the dots between
- [00:04:56.160]the different resources, and this is where
- [00:04:58.280]pedagogy really changes for us.
- [00:05:00.316]Your pedagogy, as the instructor, becomes
- [00:05:03.219]I'm the person that helps you understand how this video
- [00:05:06.357]and this text and this piece that we pulled
- [00:05:08.806]with the lesson plan fit together into a cohesive whole.
- [00:05:14.320]And that is a really useful exercise
- [00:05:18.270]because it does have a real impact on pedagogy.
- [00:05:20.940]Now, we'd rather there was less friction and we'd find
- [00:05:23.630]a lot more things that are available freely, just because
- [00:05:28.220]we're dealing with teacher education.
- [00:05:29.790]Teacher education is one of those areas that is taught
- [00:05:33.600]in almost every American university.
- [00:05:35.300]There's a very robust textbook industry, and therefore,
- [00:05:38.510]there are a lot less free resources that exist as textbooks,
- [00:05:42.300]so we go to that second level, but the advantage is,
- [00:05:45.070]because it's a rich area, there are a lot of free resources
- [00:05:48.650]available out there, or resources that are available freely
- [00:05:52.840]to our students because they have free access to the library
- [00:05:56.140]and all of its resources, so we can make all of those
- [00:05:59.510]connections fairly easily.
- [00:06:05.008]All right, so student feedback had been
- [00:06:08.640]overwhelmingly positive for a variety of reasons.
- [00:06:12.800]So first of all, students are very happy
- [00:06:14.320]they don't have to buy a book.
- [00:06:15.410]That's always a positive.
- [00:06:17.320]That will probably go away as they will have
- [00:06:21.370]more and more classes without OER,
- [00:06:23.900]they won't have something to compare it to.
- [00:06:25.890]So that's something that is hopefully short-lived,
- [00:06:30.030]because we will go to OER on scale.
- [00:06:32.713]The second thing that they loved is the variety of resources
- [00:06:36.420]and especially the media, and I know that
- [00:06:39.716]my students especially, even when there were media packets
- [00:06:43.120]that they had to pay extra for, or came as part of the book,
- [00:06:45.717]they would often not use them, because if you tear
- [00:06:49.340]that piece at the end of the book that has the code,
- [00:06:51.486]the book will not be bought back.
- [00:06:53.780]They like selling their textbooks back, so even though
- [00:06:56.170]they told me they have watched, they haven't, actually.
- [00:06:59.020]This allows them to partake of everything that we have,
- [00:07:03.270]and that's been powerful.
- [00:07:04.720]I've had actually the reverse experience.
- [00:07:06.640]I've had a course that was on OER,
- [00:07:08.620]and then we decided to adapt a book,
- [00:07:10.880]for a variety of reasons, and the students' reaction
- [00:07:13.480]was fairly negative, so it was interesting what happens
- [00:07:16.062]when you try to go back.
- [00:07:17.450]And it's not the same students.
- [00:07:18.500]They haven't experienced the OER in this class,
- [00:07:20.800]but they were definitely,
- [00:07:21.810]why did we have to buy this textbook?
- [00:07:25.340]And as somebody who looks at a lot of course evaluation,
- [00:07:28.600]that's one of the concerns that students have, repeatedly.
- [00:07:32.020]Why did we get this?
- [00:07:33.090]And so the counter argument to that is, and they noted,
- [00:07:36.487]we love the fact that these resources were available,
- [00:07:40.380]we could download them, we could take it with us into
- [00:07:44.680]the future, because we do know that most of our students,
- [00:07:47.600]most of the books they buy, run to sell them back,
- [00:07:51.860]whether we like it or not, so that's part of the reality.
- [00:07:59.697]What hasn't worked?
- [00:08:00.920]As a program, the move is slow.
- [00:08:06.110]When we get new instructors, we have to bring them on board
- [00:08:09.880]and share the resources with them.
- [00:08:12.000]And they do have academic freedom to decide they're going in
- [00:08:14.760]a different direction, so that's one challenge.
- [00:08:16.537]And there are some areas where there aren't
- [00:08:19.780]really excellent resources.
- [00:08:21.490]So in what I teach, traditionally, in teaching reading
- [00:08:24.670]and writing at the elementary school,
- [00:08:26.120]there's a huge amount of resource out there.
- [00:08:28.460]There are areas where it's harder to get those, or harder
- [00:08:31.600]to get those for free, and math is one of those examples.
- [00:08:35.100]So we have, in very specific areas, great difficulty
- [00:08:38.744]in creating OER, and that's going to simply be
- [00:08:41.714]a longer process.
- [00:08:43.510]So it's not that we're not gonna get there,
- [00:08:45.090]but it will take a longer sifting, authoring,
- [00:08:50.357]and making choices.
- [00:08:57.790]So if you're thinking about it, you're at the right place.
- [00:09:03.270]You need to think about it as a design process,
- [00:09:06.960]so you've got to create an original.
- [00:09:11.280]Spend some time thinking about it,
- [00:09:12.760]consulting with others, and then just iterate.
- [00:09:15.340]The first iteration will not be perfect,
- [00:09:17.640]like anything else we design, so don't wait too long.
- [00:09:22.660]Take a semester to plan or a summer to plan,
- [00:09:25.070]collect the resources you want, go for it, get feedback,
- [00:09:28.460]and get better.
- [00:09:29.580]One of the things that I think is really important is
- [00:09:32.480]getting almost weekly feedback from students.
- [00:09:35.880]What did you like, what didn't you like?
- [00:09:37.740]What worked for you, what didn't work for you?
- [00:09:39.750]And I've done that in a course I taught.
- [00:09:42.700]We're doing that as a program, trying to get the feedback
- [00:09:45.280]in real time from students who are first doing it.
- [00:09:48.830]And again, for us, it is about, we're teaching you about
- [00:09:55.530]designing education, and part of designing education
- [00:09:59.620]is knowing how students are receiving it.
- [00:10:01.550]So you're doing it for the first time, it's the first
- [00:10:03.520]situation, we're gonna ask you for your opinion every week.
- [00:10:10.240]That is an excellent question.
- [00:10:11.810]I don't know if I was surprised.
- [00:10:14.020]Early on, I was surprised that some students felt,
- [00:10:24.530]how would I say this, I think
- [00:10:26.120]some students have felt that they miss the traditional book.
- [00:10:31.080]Some students, when we give them an option of a digital book
- [00:10:33.930]or a physical book, buy a physical book.
- [00:10:36.090]They feel that it's harder to take notes.
- [00:10:39.030]Those are real issues that I think are
- [00:10:42.400]important to think about.
- [00:10:45.230]They don't jump on the electronic side of things
- [00:10:48.250]quite as happily as most people assume
- [00:10:50.290]because they are a digital generation.
- [00:10:52.540]But part of it is also that our students are and were
- [00:10:59.040]excellent students, and they know how to work with textbooks
- [00:11:02.760]and with paper products, and they were always successful.
- [00:11:07.690]So they are a little bit suspicious when you change things
- [00:11:10.610]and the more successful they were in the past, the more
- [00:11:13.870]likely they are to resist it at least a little bit.
- [00:11:17.528]But after a while, and now with kids who are going to school
- [00:11:21.550]with, whether they're open educational resources or not,
- [00:11:24.610]with digital resources, that resistance is less and less,
- [00:11:29.990]and so with time, I believe that most of that would go away.
- [00:11:37.200]I think that OER is an opportunity to redesign courses.
- [00:11:42.220]OER is an opportunity to reconsider pedagogy and really
- [00:11:47.290]take that opportunity to use the fact that we do have
- [00:11:50.420]learning management systems to store all of
- [00:11:52.460]this information, and we do have a world where
- [00:11:56.110]a lot of information is available for free,
- [00:11:59.240]or somewhat for free, and it's available to students
- [00:12:03.910]through our other resources, especially library resources,
- [00:12:06.680]and all our participation in OER, and so we don't have to go
- [00:12:10.670]to the physical book, with the cost that comes with it,
- [00:12:14.800]and that is really a powerful moment,
- [00:12:18.913]pedagogically and from the social justice angle as well.
- [00:12:27.430]The main thing that we see in course evaluations,
- [00:12:31.090]the main difference, is when students are asked about
- [00:12:37.330]what didn't work for you, what are the critiques that
- [00:12:39.730]you have about this class, often in text-based classes,
- [00:12:43.600]they complain about the textbook,
- [00:12:45.240]about the amount of reading, sometimes, and about the cost.
- [00:12:51.490]And again, and I talked about this before,
- [00:12:53.610]but about the fact that they were asked to buy
- [00:12:56.440]this very expensive book, and then they used it only
- [00:12:58.870]occasionally, or only in the first four weeks.
- [00:13:01.670]And once we start using open educational resources,
- [00:13:05.760]especially if they're delivered through
- [00:13:07.560]a learning management system,
- [00:13:10.840]then most of these complaints go away.
- [00:13:13.490]They still complain about too much reading,
- [00:13:14.920]because too much reading is part of the deal,
- [00:13:18.100]I think it's part of going to college in some ways,
- [00:13:21.080]but they don't complain about the purchase.
- [00:13:25.200]They don't complain about resources that they only use
- [00:13:28.250]occasionally because they see their value, and they see
- [00:13:32.657]the value at the point of contact, and when you're not
- [00:13:35.900]paying that extra cost, it gets easier.
- [00:13:43.090]So at the program level,
- [00:13:44.870]the challenge is always to convince people to join.
- [00:13:48.300]The instructional challenge in the classroom is that
- [00:13:51.800]now you have to work with your students on sense-making,
- [00:13:55.620]on how do you connect the dots,
- [00:13:58.830]how do you help students understand that
- [00:14:00.730]these four different pieces that you included in this week,
- [00:14:03.640]I include a video about how you teach guided reading,
- [00:14:05.910]I include an article about guided reading,
- [00:14:08.240]and a short article from a practitioner journal
- [00:14:13.640]about asking questions.
- [00:14:15.660]So now my job in class is not to explain what you
- [00:14:19.620]didn't understand, but actually to say here is how
- [00:14:23.030]it all fits together, and is applicable to what you will do
- [00:14:26.343]when you get to work with kids.
- [00:14:29.170]So the job of the instructor really changes.
- [00:14:36.930]So this is a hard question.
- [00:14:38.710]I don't know that we see significant changes
- [00:14:41.930]in class performance.
- [00:14:43.500]The piece that is most helpful to our students
- [00:14:47.660]is actually the use of media.
- [00:14:49.010]Because we are a professional program, we're training them
- [00:14:51.410]for something that happens in the real world with a job,
- [00:14:54.870]it's not just an academic pursuit, the videos really help
- [00:14:59.060]see another version of reality.
- [00:15:00.990]So our students spend a lot of time in classrooms,
- [00:15:03.750]watching a specific teacher working with kids.
- [00:15:06.350]But they see only one version of reality, and when we
- [00:15:09.410]move to OER and included a substantial amount of video,
- [00:15:12.517]it helped expose them to other ways
- [00:15:16.240]that the same practices can be enacted,
- [00:15:18.220]or maybe practices they don't see in classrooms.
- [00:15:21.100]So for example,
- [00:15:24.620]there's a practice called literature circles.
- [00:15:27.640]You don't see it in all grades,
- [00:15:28.870]you don't see it in all classrooms.
- [00:15:30.550]Some places use it, some places use it not effectively.
- [00:15:33.910]We can use the videos to show really good examples,
- [00:15:37.190]or examples of how it works in a fourth grade classroom.
- [00:15:39.860]If you're right now with a teacher
- [00:15:41.180]in a kindergarten classroom,
- [00:15:42.240]even if they're using version of that,
- [00:15:43.850]it's nothing like a fourth or a sixth grade classroom.
- [00:15:47.040]So it allows to expand the variety of things that they
- [00:15:51.170]can experience, and contextualizing in a way that
- [00:15:53.720]a textbook, no matter how good it is, just can't.
- [00:16:02.530]Yes, so the things that changes is first, you have to think
- [00:16:08.540]about design, so you're redesigning your class in some ways,
- [00:16:11.330]especially in the years you start transferring,
- [00:16:13.850]and the fact that it's this jigsaw of resources
- [00:16:17.250]in most of our cases allows us to change, to keep tinkering
- [00:16:21.550]with content, without changing the structure of the class.
- [00:16:26.840]So that really changed the way
- [00:16:28.520]we keep redesigning our classes.
- [00:16:30.500]It doesn't require us to go scratch everything
- [00:16:32.850]and choose a new book and then adapt a new book.
- [00:16:35.550]It doesn't matter that the publisher has changed
- [00:16:38.310]page numbers, which they do on a regular basis
- [00:16:41.589]to make sure we buy the newest edition.
- [00:16:44.130]And so it frees us, from that perspective,
- [00:16:46.450]to redesign on the go, without having to just
- [00:16:50.170]get to the point where we're saying
- [00:16:51.350]we're not using this book anymore.
- [00:16:52.860]Then the adoption of a new textbook
- [00:16:55.340]becomes a real challenge.
- [00:16:56.910]So that's the first thing.
- [00:16:57.743]The second thing is it really changed
- [00:16:59.040]my role as an instructor.
- [00:17:00.490]That's part of an evolution.
- [00:17:02.160]I don't think it happens the day you adapt it, but it does
- [00:17:04.586]help you think about your instruction in different ways.
- [00:17:12.550]At the risk of fighting with Nike, just do it.
- [00:17:16.060]Ha!
- [00:17:17.445]Right?
- [00:17:18.278](laughter)
- [00:17:19.920]Anyway, I think that the most important thing is,
- [00:17:23.440]if you're thinking about it, just try it.
- [00:17:25.340]You can always go back to a textbook.
- [00:17:27.140]There's nothing that says that this is a one way street.
- [00:17:29.886]Find the resources, do the design work, and just try it.
- [00:17:34.710]I find it empowering for most instructors,
- [00:17:37.330]so I think it'll work.
The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!
You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.
Log in to post comments
Embed
Copy the following code into your page
HTML
<div style="padding-top: 56.25%; overflow: hidden; position:relative; -webkit-box-flex: 1; flex-grow: 1;"> <iframe style="bottom: 0; left: 0; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; border: 0; height: 100%; width: 100%;" src="https://mediahub.unl.edu/media/19929?format=iframe&autoplay=0" title="Video Player: Faculty Interview Guy Trainin-UNL" allowfullscreen ></iframe> </div>
Comments
0 Comments