Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs)
Brendan Bunker
Author
08/31/2022
Added
29
Plays
Description
Top Recommendations Series For Food Processors
Searchable Transcript
Toggle between list and paragraph view.
- [00:00:01.465]The implementation
- [00:00:02.298]of variable frequency drives or VFDs
- [00:00:05.010]and motor-driven processes is a popular recommendation.
- [00:00:08.550]However, whether this recommendation
- [00:00:10.320]is reasonable is not always clear cut.
- [00:00:13.470]In this video, I will discuss what a VFD is,
- [00:00:16.410]what situations justify the use of VFDs,
- [00:00:19.620]as well as some alternatives that may be considered
- [00:00:21.690]when a VFD is not the ideal choice.
- [00:00:24.000]A VFD is a device used to control
- [00:00:26.310]the rotational speed of motor-driven equipment.
- [00:00:29.790]VFDs are particularly advantageous
- [00:00:32.310]when a motor regularly runs at less
- [00:00:34.200]than its full operating load.
- [00:00:36.570]The added control that a VFD provides
- [00:00:38.970]allows us extra energy to be conserved,
- [00:00:41.790]which translates to cost reductions.
- [00:00:44.460]These energy savings depend heavily on application,
- [00:00:47.160]but sometimes there can be other cost driven incentives.
- [00:00:50.580]For example, many utilities offer rebates
- [00:00:53.700]between 16 and $150 per horsepower
- [00:00:57.360]for the installation of VFDs.
- [00:00:59.670]Facilities often see returns on this investment
- [00:01:02.370]in three to five years on a case by case basis.
- [00:01:05.730]These incentives typically apply
- [00:01:07.320]to VFDs added to existing equipment,
- [00:01:10.050]as is most common for VFD implementation.
- [00:01:12.990]VFDs can be used with motors
- [00:01:14.910]and many different applications,
- [00:01:16.590]but the choice to use them is strongly reliant
- [00:01:18.900]on the type of load that the motor is driving.
- [00:01:21.630]A motor with a variable torque load for instance
- [00:01:23.918]is a prime candidate for a VFD,
- [00:01:26.070]because the motor's torque decreases
- [00:01:28.230]with the square speed.
- [00:01:29.850]Fans, blowers and centrifugal pumps
- [00:01:32.100]are examples of variable torque loads.
- [00:01:34.590]In one case, it was recommended
- [00:01:36.480]that an ethanol plant install VFDs
- [00:01:39.060]on T100 horsepower pumps as an alternative
- [00:01:42.210]to throttling the pumps with control valves.
- [00:01:44.819]This change would save $13,300 in annual energy costs
- [00:01:49.350]with a payback period of approximately 3.5 years.
- [00:01:52.920]Conversely, VFDs may also be recommended
- [00:01:55.950]for motors with constant torque loads.
- [00:01:58.470]As opposed to variable torque loads,
- [00:02:00.570]the torque of these motors
- [00:02:01.800]is not proportional to speed.
- [00:02:03.900]Belts and conveyors are two examples
- [00:02:06.060]of these kinds of loads.
- [00:02:07.860]In another case, the implementation of VFDs
- [00:02:10.200]was recommended in a grain drying facility,
- [00:02:12.870]because the powering of two horizontal conveyors
- [00:02:15.180]by 20 horsepower motors was found to be more effective
- [00:02:18.540]when running at 80% power.
- [00:02:20.580]The proposed change would save the facility $1,600
- [00:02:24.360]on energy annually,
- [00:02:25.590]with a payback period of approximately 2.9 years.
- [00:02:36.150]While these benefits can be attractive,
- [00:02:38.340]the implementation of VFDs is not justifiable on every case.
- [00:02:42.840]There are many factors that influence
- [00:02:44.430]whether using a VFD is the appropriate choice.
- [00:02:47.730]For example, if a luster degree of freedom is required
- [00:02:50.670]in terms of process control,
- [00:02:52.680]other alternatives may be more effective.
- [00:02:55.410]Using multiple pieces of equipment
- [00:02:57.120]in series may act as an inexpensive alternative
- [00:02:59.910]to variable frequency drives.
- [00:03:02.220]Using a series of blowers to aerate
- [00:03:04.080]a stream of waste water provides the freedom
- [00:03:06.450]to turn on the appropriate number of motors
- [00:03:08.580]and adjust the air discharge as necessary.
- [00:03:13.050]It may also be possible to make mechanical adjustments
- [00:03:15.930]to equipment to change their operating parameters.
- [00:03:19.170]Changing a transmission ratio or trimming an impeller
- [00:03:22.290]could be a more cost effective option,
- [00:03:24.660]depending on the type of equipment.
- [00:03:26.940]In general, VFDs are not suited for low speed
- [00:03:30.120]or high load operations.
- [00:03:32.460]Excessively lowering a motor speed
- [00:03:34.560]can cause it to overheat
- [00:03:35.940]due to decreased cooling within the motor.
- [00:03:39.180]This graph illustrates the limitations
- [00:03:41.130]of operating a VFD controlled motor.
- [00:03:43.980]Instead of using a VFD for a motor running at lower speeds,
- [00:03:47.880]it may make more sense to downsize.
- [00:03:50.730]Furthermore, it is important to consider
- [00:03:52.680]how reducing a motor speed may impact its performance,
- [00:03:56.310]as pumping speed may impact other process parameters,
- [00:03:59.490]including fluid head.
- [00:04:02.820]An alternative technology to VFDs worth considering
- [00:04:06.180]is an Eddy current drive.
- [00:04:08.340]They provide similar control of VFDs,
- [00:04:10.560]but can offer a longer operating life
- [00:04:12.600]and lower maintenance costs.
- [00:04:14.670]The difference is that while a VFD
- [00:04:16.350]uses AC to DC voltage conversion,
- [00:04:19.320]high frequency sampling
- [00:04:21.060]in a powerful inverter to alter the speed of an AC motor,
- [00:04:24.900]an Eddy current drive consists
- [00:04:26.430]of a constant speed AC induction motor
- [00:04:29.490]and a magnetic clutch speed driven
- [00:04:31.380]by a small analog or digital controller.
- [00:04:34.830]The clutch uses an Eddy current coupling
- [00:04:37.260]to vary the speed of an attached output shaft.
- [00:04:40.350]These kinds of drives are used primarily
- [00:04:42.630]in constant torque applications.
- [00:04:46.080]Finally, newer, intelligent motors
- [00:04:48.390]with proprietary operating systems
- [00:04:50.520]are also becoming popular alternatives to VFDs.
- [00:04:54.420]They offer remarkable efficiencies
- [00:04:56.340]and dramatically reduce energy usage.
- [00:04:59.040]The careful inspection of the costs
- [00:05:01.110]and benefits of using these technologies
- [00:05:03.330]should be conducted.
- [00:05:04.950]A food processing plant,
- [00:05:06.450]when deciding between implementing third party motors
- [00:05:09.180]and continuing to use VFDs,
- [00:05:11.520]was advised not to install new motors
- [00:05:13.830]because of the large capital cost.
- [00:05:16.140]The reduction in energy usage
- [00:05:17.760]did not outweigh the cost of implementation in this case.
- [00:05:21.360]In general, it is crucial to understand
- [00:05:23.580]how a motor is being used to determine whether a VFD
- [00:05:27.000]or any of the other discussed alternatives are feasible.
- [00:05:30.390]Obtaining data that describes the duty cycle
- [00:05:32.790]of a given piece of equipment can help provide clarity.
- [00:05:36.390]Every application is different,
- [00:05:38.100]so thorough consideration of every option
- [00:05:40.230]is necessary when making a recommendation.
The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!
You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.
Log in to post comments
Embed
Copy the following code into your page
HTML
<div style="padding-top: 56.25%; overflow: hidden; position:relative; -webkit-box-flex: 1; flex-grow: 1;"> <iframe style="bottom: 0; left: 0; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; border: 0; height: 100%; width: 100%;" src="https://mediahub.unl.edu/media/19799?format=iframe&autoplay=0" title="Video Player: Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs)" allowfullscreen ></iframe> </div>
Comments
0 Comments