CollectionTalk: Los Angeles Spring
Sheldon Museum of Art
Author
03/04/2022
Added
107
Plays
Description
Sheldon Museum of Art’s CollectionTalk on February 24, 2022, featured a discussion with Toby Jurovics and Mark Ruwedel about “Los Angeles Spring,” a series of photographs by Robert Adams. Toby Jurovics is founding director of the Barry Lopez Foundation for Art & Environment in Santa Fe, New Mexico. Mark Ruwedel is an artist who has photographed American deserts and other remote locations for more than twenty-five years.
Searchable Transcript
Toggle between list and paragraph view.
- [00:00:08.813]And thank you all for being here.
- [00:00:10.090]I'm Laura Reznicek, and I'm delighted to welcome you
- [00:00:13.300]to Sheldon Museum of Art's. Great.
- [00:00:15.312]Collectiontalk event tonight
- [00:00:17.240]with Toby Jurovics and Mark Ruwedel.
- [00:00:20.250]Before we get started,
- [00:00:21.210]I want to extend a couple notes of appreciation.
- [00:00:24.820]The first is to those of you here tonight
- [00:00:26.740]who are Sheldon members, your support
- [00:00:29.360]makes this event possible and events like this.
- [00:00:33.335]And it also helps keep the museum running day to day.
- [00:00:35.700]So thank you very much for your membership support.
- [00:00:39.400]I do wanna invite you to two upcoming collectiontalk events.
- [00:00:44.210]On March 24th, we're going to be having a conversation
- [00:00:47.370]with artist Mel Chin, and on April 28th,
- [00:00:51.690]artist Amanda Ross-Ho.
- [00:00:53.710]Sheldon has recent acquisitions from each of these artists
- [00:00:57.240]and we expect these will be very dynamic conversations.
- [00:01:01.940]So please look into those.
- [00:01:04.850]The conversation tonight focuses on "Los Angeles Spring"
- [00:01:08.710]a series of photographs by Robert Adams.
- [00:01:11.610]Two images from the suite are recent acquisitions
- [00:01:14.390]that are currently on view at Sheldon
- [00:01:16.660]in the exhibition "Photography from the Collection."
- [00:01:20.190]And I'd like to thank those exhibition sponsors,
- [00:01:23.390]Nebraska Arts Council, Nebraska Cultural Endowment,
- [00:01:26.260]and Sheldon Art Association.
- [00:01:29.460]We would love for you to engage with tonight's guests
- [00:01:32.520]and the conversation between the two of them.
- [00:01:35.360]So while you will be muted at the beginning,
- [00:01:37.840]please use the chat box to type questions or comments
- [00:01:41.690]as we go along.
- [00:01:43.160]And then there will be some time at the end
- [00:01:45.130]for you to unmute yourself and ask questions directly.
- [00:01:49.600]And now I'm gonna turn it over to Wally Mason,
- [00:01:52.230]Sheldon's Director and Chief Curator
- [00:01:54.320]who will introduce Mark and Toby.
- [00:01:57.670]Good evening, everyone.
- [00:01:59.010]It's my pleasure to be able to sit tonight
- [00:02:02.340]with two people that I think the world of.
- [00:02:06.180]And it's perfect that the subject matter
- [00:02:10.720]for the the evening is Robert Adams' photographs.
- [00:02:15.570]Aaron, can we go one more slide?
- [00:02:17.770]It's appropriate because two of the works
- [00:02:22.850]that we're going to talk about tonight
- [00:02:25.160]are recent acquisitions.
- [00:02:26.700]And in this case, it's the two bottom ones
- [00:02:28.850]from the series "Los Angeles Springs."
- [00:02:32.330]The two top images are here
- [00:02:36.870]solely because we had made a commitment
- [00:02:39.180]to Robert Adams' work back as early as 1977.
- [00:02:46.330]And these are two from the series, "The New West."
- [00:02:49.040]They are, I don't know.
- [00:02:52.210]Of course you'd expect me to say
- [00:02:53.800]that these are my favorite "New West" pictures,
- [00:02:56.680]and the two below, the recent acquisitions,
- [00:03:01.040]are two of my favorite,
- [00:03:02.900]if not the favorite images from "Los Angeles Spring."
- [00:03:06.790]But when the museum in October of '21
- [00:03:11.170]was thinking about acquiring
- [00:03:13.190]the two photographs in the bottom,
- [00:03:16.460]the first person I called was Toby Jurovics
- [00:03:19.510]because I not only trust his eye,
- [00:03:21.890]but he's an expert on landscape photography,
- [00:03:24.840]landscape photography in the west, and Robert Adams.
- [00:03:28.470]So it seems appropriate, or maybe it's comeuppance
- [00:03:31.630]that he advised me to go forward and acquire these pictures.
- [00:03:36.150]And now he's been placed in the situation tonight
- [00:03:39.070]to have to talk about them.
- [00:03:40.770]So with that said,
- [00:03:42.770]let me just briefly introduce both individuals.
- [00:03:46.700]Toby Jurovics is the Founding Director
- [00:03:48.910]of the Barry Lopez Foundation for Art & Environment
- [00:03:52.160]in Santa Fe, New Mexico.
- [00:03:54.000]He was the Chief Curator and Curator of American Western Art
- [00:03:58.400]at Jocelyn Art Museum from 2011 to 2020.
- [00:04:03.390]Prior to this, he was a Curator of Photography
- [00:04:05.910]at Smithsonian American Art Museum
- [00:04:08.900]and Princeton University Art Museum.
- [00:04:11.850]An expert on 19th and 20th century
- [00:04:14.270]American landscape photography,
- [00:04:16.380]he has curated over 50 monographic and group exhibitions
- [00:04:19.790]of photography, painting, works on paper, and new media.
- [00:04:24.310]And published on Thomas Joshua Cooper, Steve Fitch,
- [00:04:28.380]John Gossage, Timothy H. O'Sullivan,
- [00:04:31.560]and the New Topographics.
- [00:04:34.250]Mr. Jurovics holds a BA in Art History and English
- [00:04:38.210]from the University of North Carolina Chapel Hill
- [00:04:41.270]and an MA in Art History from University of Delaware.
- [00:04:45.520]Joining him tonight is Mark Ruwedel.
- [00:04:48.260]Mark Ruwedel is a photographer
- [00:04:50.050]who resides in Long Beach, California.
- [00:04:53.710]I seem to want to collect his work at each museum
- [00:04:58.130]where I work, and the Sheldon's no different.
- [00:05:02.370]We own 20 works by Mark Ruwedel.
- [00:05:05.320]And as part of the exhibition,
- [00:05:08.480]what you saw in the previous slide,
- [00:05:12.570]we have 12 works up from his series,
- [00:05:14.487]"Westward the Course of Empire."
- [00:05:17.400]Mark Ruwedel received his MFA from Concordia University
- [00:05:20.900]in Montreal in 1983.
- [00:05:23.450]He taught there from 1984 to 2001, and he recently retired
- [00:05:28.910]and is now Professor Emeritus
- [00:05:31.080]at California State University Long Beach.
- [00:05:34.600]He received major grants from the
- [00:05:36.060]Canada Council for the Arts in 1999 and 2001.
- [00:05:40.760]And in 2014 he was awarded a Guggenheim Fellowship
- [00:05:45.630]and the Scotiabank Photography Award.
- [00:05:49.670]He is represented in such coveted collections
- [00:05:52.700]as the J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles County Art Museum,
- [00:05:56.430]Metropolitan Museum of Art, BL Art Gallery, Tate Modern,
- [00:06:02.800]pretty much every art museum that makes a difference
- [00:06:07.260]whether it's on this continent or others.
- [00:06:10.950]Again, 12 of his pictures are up currently
- [00:06:14.620]and it's my pleasure to hand the program over
- [00:06:17.720]to Toby and Mark.
- [00:06:19.670]And we'll hope that you'll have questions during the event
- [00:06:24.860]or after they complete.
- [00:06:28.110]Thank you, and Toby and Mark, it's yours.
- [00:06:31.960]Okay.
- [00:06:33.320]Well, thanks for that very generous introduction,
- [00:06:37.290]and welcome everybody.
- [00:06:41.790]When Wally reached out to me couple months ago
- [00:06:47.170]about these two pictures, and he said, you know,
- [00:06:50.750]we talked about them a bit.
- [00:06:52.094]And he said, well, which one should I buy?
- [00:06:53.280]And I said, you should buy both of them.
- [00:06:56.520]And he listened to me, and let's actually,
- [00:07:01.610]let's go back to that, to the previous slide there
- [00:07:04.340]so we can talk about those a bit in context.
- [00:07:09.880]And Mark asked me just to introduce a little bit
- [00:07:14.390]about our relationships with Mr. Adams.
- [00:07:20.610]That was so formal with Bob.
- [00:07:24.420]You know, I've known him a little over 20, 25 years,
- [00:07:31.240]and I grew up in Los Angeles.
- [00:07:34.830]And those two pictures, "Redlands" 1983
- [00:07:40.980]and "Highland, California" were made the year
- [00:07:42.930]I graduated from high school.
- [00:07:44.750]And when I look at them, I mean,
- [00:07:46.950]they're incredibly comforting to me
- [00:07:48.600]because that's exactly what the sky
- [00:07:51.360]in the San Fernando Valley looked like
- [00:07:53.650]throughout my entire childhood.
- [00:08:00.900]But at the same time,
- [00:08:02.400]the sort of work that the photographs
- [00:08:05.170]that I was raised on, sort of culturally,
- [00:08:08.020]were very different.
- [00:08:08.853]They were worked by Ansel Adams.
- [00:08:11.430]And, you know, like every kid in California,
- [00:08:12.730]I grew up going to the mountains,
- [00:08:14.210]and, you know, you buy the big coffee table books,
- [00:08:16.650]and you're looking at these, you know,
- [00:08:18.820]the sort of mountain glory pictures,
- [00:08:21.280]and Bob's work suddenly something very different.
- [00:08:24.310]And that photograph on the top right there,
- [00:08:30.157]"Pikes Peak, Colorado Springs," 1970.
- [00:08:33.680]I think that sums up as well as any single image
- [00:08:38.900]what this great shift in landscape photography was
- [00:08:43.720]primarily driven by Robert Adams, Lewis Baltz, Frank Gohlke,
- [00:08:48.620]and this group of photographers that we know
- [00:08:50.240]as the New Topographics.
- [00:08:52.810]And this was named after an exhibition in 1975,
- [00:08:56.910]but I had an exhibition of Bob's work up,
- [00:09:02.923]it would be late '90s when I was working at Princeton.
- [00:09:05.470]And I came in, you know, kind of after lunch
- [00:09:08.950]and listened to people walking around
- [00:09:11.420]and what they were thinking of the show.
- [00:09:13.330]And this person said, if he just moved to the right,
- [00:09:15.800]the house would've been out of the way,
- [00:09:17.400]and he could have taken a picture of the mountain.
- [00:09:20.040]And, you know, sort of that's when I thought I have,
- [00:09:23.382]you know, I have failed.
- [00:09:25.620]But what's great about this, you know,
- [00:09:26.977]"Pike's Peak" is this sort of,
- [00:09:30.390]in the sort of Western narrative, this historic landmark,
- [00:09:33.680]and he's got it practically obscured
- [00:09:35.940]by the gas station and the Frontier sign,
- [00:09:39.020]which is sort of truncated to suggest like, you know,
- [00:09:41.770]the west ends now.
- [00:09:46.000]And it's, you know, sort of the last thing you'd want to,
- [00:09:48.360]the last thing you'd want to look at,
- [00:09:51.282]but what he does with this and something
- [00:09:52.930]that he continues in the "LA Spring" pictures
- [00:09:55.050]is you have this really spectacularly beautiful light
- [00:09:58.830]in all of his prints.
- [00:10:00.300]And so you've got this glow
- [00:10:01.740]coming from the fluorescent lights over the pumps,
- [00:10:04.690]and then the sun going down behind the mountain,
- [00:10:06.560]and kind of filling the sky almost like a luminous painting.
- [00:10:10.440]And so what you see in Bob's work,
- [00:10:12.550]is this kind of constant tension
- [00:10:14.930]between these very difficult subjects
- [00:10:17.700]and how the work is sort of physically made.
- [00:10:21.240]And I'll let Mark maybe talk about that a little more.
- [00:10:24.390]Mark and I met, I just took a look at this, back in 1999.
- [00:10:31.047]And Mark is one of, I'll just embarrass him here,
- [00:10:35.510]one of the most important
- [00:10:39.220]contemporary American landscape photographers
- [00:10:41.260]and somebody whose work really manages
- [00:10:42.910]to sort of bridge this conversation
- [00:10:44.590]between the 19th and the 21st century.
- [00:10:47.880]And in the work, we wanna show
- [00:10:53.050]the installation here of one of the grids of Mark's work.
- [00:11:01.900]This is actually the work that
- [00:11:03.020]how we first got to know each other.
- [00:11:04.540]This is from the series, "Westward the Course of Empire,"
- [00:11:07.660]and these are all photographs
- [00:11:09.860]of railroad cuts from the 19th century.
- [00:11:13.037]And the track has subsequently
- [00:11:14.570]been pulled up and away from them,
- [00:11:17.220]but you have these sort of very graphic, topographic forms.
- [00:11:24.650]They relate to the way that Timothy O'Sullivan
- [00:11:26.610]made photographs in the 19th century,
- [00:11:29.150]but really about this tension
- [00:11:30.440]between the built and the natural environment.
- [00:11:33.070]And, you know, one of the things that really appealed to me
- [00:11:38.140]about Mark's work is that he is, and it's very, you know,
- [00:11:41.820]it's hard to see on a PowerPoint, but Mark prints in a way
- [00:11:45.460]that I think is very close to Bob's.
- [00:11:47.890]In that in terms of that kind of the expressiveness
- [00:11:49.840]and the warmth of his prints,
- [00:11:53.810]and Mark, maybe I'll let you talk a little bit about,
- [00:11:58.050]start with this series and about how you kinda
- [00:12:00.300]first came to know Bob.
- [00:12:03.760]Okay, yeah, so I'll go back quite a ways.
- [00:12:09.480]I mean, I tried to piece this together and, you know,
- [00:12:11.960]looking backwards that I didn't study photography
- [00:12:16.010]formally there, I was a painting student,
- [00:12:19.840]but there was two photo classes,
- [00:12:21.760]which is where I first got interested in.
- [00:12:23.890]There was a, somewhere in there
- [00:12:25.270]was a lecture about new documentary photography.
- [00:12:28.220]And this was a class that only had maybe two or three,
- [00:12:32.070]sort of theoretical or historical lectures
- [00:12:34.170]in the entire semester, but there was a couple pictures
- [00:12:36.860]from Bob and Lewis Baltz,
- [00:12:39.727]and I of course completely forgot about them.
- [00:12:41.870]But as a graduate student,
- [00:12:43.120]I started making pictures along the St. Lawrence River.
- [00:12:45.440]And some of my colleagues would say,
- [00:12:47.600]oh, that's New Topographics work.
- [00:12:49.600]And so that's when I started learning,
- [00:12:51.640]I was prompted to learn about this stuff.
- [00:12:53.320]So I had sort of maybe subconsciously absorbed the lesson,
- [00:12:59.020]or at least a lesson of Baltz, Adams, and company.
- [00:13:05.910]If we jump ahead, I also want to say
- [00:13:08.350]that I've known Robert Adams almost as long as,
- [00:13:11.490]or maybe even longer than Toby.
- [00:13:13.440]We met through a mutual friend and I visited him
- [00:13:17.243]when he lived in Colorado and later in Oregon,
- [00:13:23.110]he graciously wrote one or two letters of reference
- [00:13:29.062]for when I applied unsuccessfully
- [00:13:30.820]for the Guggenheim a couple times.
- [00:13:34.142]And so that's, you know, so I, and in fact,
- [00:13:36.180]we talked on the phone last week
- [00:13:37.720]about something somewhat trivial, but fun to talk about.
- [00:13:41.770]This series, what Toby didn't say,
- [00:13:46.120]and of course you can't see it of course, in the slide form
- [00:13:49.340]is that each of these mounted prints
- [00:13:51.550]has the name of the railroad.
- [00:13:52.980]In this case, Colorado Springs and Cripple Creek
- [00:13:56.140]printed on the mount, hand printed in pencil.
- [00:13:58.950]And that was a really important component of this work,
- [00:14:02.690]'cause I wanted to allude to the kind of,
- [00:14:05.530]this tremendous economic engine of imperialism
- [00:14:09.970]that just, you know, drove west in all directions,
- [00:14:14.490]in the United States and Canada as well.
- [00:14:17.440]And so that was an interest of mine,
- [00:14:19.690]as was this idea of earth work.
- [00:14:23.450]'Cause I, you know, some of my early heroes as artists
- [00:14:27.150]were people like Michael Heizer and Robert Smithson.
- [00:14:30.240]In fact, my first photographs of the railroad cuts
- [00:14:32.510]were actually made for a completely different project.
- [00:14:34.720]But when I made the prints back in Montreal,
- [00:14:38.330]they reminded me of photographs I had made
- [00:14:40.200]of Heizer's "Double Negative."
- [00:14:41.560]And that started me thinking about this,
- [00:14:43.520]as well as this kinda, you know, there's also the,
- [00:14:46.470]obviously this influence of the German components
- [00:14:49.900]of the Topographics work,
- [00:14:51.160]which would Bernd and Hilla Becher
- [00:14:52.830]and their gridded displays of industrial forms
- [00:14:57.100]mostly in Europe, but also in the United States,
- [00:14:58.970]so there's that.
- [00:15:01.070]And just for folks that haven't seen it,
- [00:15:03.810]Michael Heizer's "Double Negative," it's sort of a sculpture
- [00:15:06.910]cut into sort of opposite sides of a mesa.
- [00:15:10.310]And he basically used the bulldozer to make a road cut
- [00:15:13.890]with perfectly vertical sides,
- [00:15:17.410]sort of facing each other across this, you know,
- [00:15:20.810]across this chasm.
- [00:15:22.580]And it's one of the really great
- [00:15:25.350]contemporary sculptural works in the west.
- [00:15:28.290]So that in, you know, in a kind of comparison
- [00:15:31.600]with "Spiral Jetty" of kind of that importance.
- [00:15:35.830]Yeah.
- [00:15:36.972]But again, that kind of tension
- [00:15:39.860]between the natural landscape and something industrial
- [00:15:43.370]or if you wanna put it in, you know, Imperial that way.
- [00:15:47.160]Yeah, in fact, when I first showed some of these pictures
- [00:15:50.386]to friends and colleagues and that,
- [00:15:53.230]there was a kind of
- [00:15:55.190]it wasn't that clear. Oh, sorry.
- [00:15:56.690]Oh, thank you, that's perfect.
- [00:16:00.550]The funny thing about this, the "Double Negative,"
- [00:16:03.110]now I'm going off track here, but that's okay.
- [00:16:05.730]Is that, you know, I had a kinda really cocky
- [00:16:08.170]graduate student once who said,
- [00:16:10.265]you know, oh Michael Heizer,
- [00:16:11.270]that's all about aerial photography.
- [00:16:12.970]I said, well, that's 'cause you'd never been there.
- [00:16:14.890]You know, and this stuff is really about, you know,
- [00:16:19.330]phenomenal, it's phenomenologically a base.
- [00:16:23.420]To really understand the work, you have to stand in that cut
- [00:16:26.980]and you look across this great abyss,
- [00:16:29.020]and what you're looking at is basically
- [00:16:31.220]a mirror image of where you're standing,
- [00:16:32.610]except you're not there.
- [00:16:34.290]And when you go into the cut, of course,
- [00:16:36.660]you're going through time in reverse through all the strata,
- [00:16:39.480]you know, that's visible in the sides of the cut,
- [00:16:43.170]regardless, so where was I?
- [00:16:47.550]Yeah, so this idea that of, you know,
- [00:16:49.263]when I started making these cut pictures,
- [00:16:51.640]it wasn't clear to some people that
- [00:16:54.410]it was a technological intervention in the Earth.
- [00:16:59.070]It wasn't a natural phenomenon and that.
- [00:17:01.167]And that kinda really intrigued me.
- [00:17:03.020]And I think those kinds of, those kinds of paradoxes
- [00:17:08.240]that have always interested me in my work,
- [00:17:12.420]not more so than in my recent work on Los Angeles,
- [00:17:15.387]and landscapes in Los Angeles.
- [00:17:17.830]I wanted to say one thing about my experience
- [00:17:20.360]of "Los Angeles Spring" in particular, in that, you know,
- [00:17:26.310]once I sort of discovered the work of Adams
- [00:17:29.560]and other like-minded photographers of that generation,
- [00:17:32.600]I got really excited and interested in them.
- [00:17:35.190]And that actually led me back to learn more about, you know,
- [00:17:38.990]people like Timothy O'Sullivan and so on.
- [00:17:42.530]One of my favorite bodies of work by Adams
- [00:17:45.310]was in fact "Los Angeles Spring."
- [00:17:47.240]But of course I only knew it through the Aperture book.
- [00:17:51.950]And then there was a day in,
- [00:17:55.480]I was in New York, I don't even remember why,
- [00:17:57.960]and I just randomly went into a bunch of galleries.
- [00:18:01.589]And one of them had two bodies of work by Robert Adams,
- [00:18:03.600]and one of them was "Los Angeles Spring."
- [00:18:05.710]And up to that point, my understanding of those pictures
- [00:18:10.240]was pretty much structural,
- [00:18:12.930]but it turned out to be because of really bad reproduction.
- [00:18:16.950]And when I saw the prints,
- [00:18:17.970]I realized that they were really incredibly atmospheric.
- [00:18:21.900]And of course, Bob was photographing
- [00:18:24.540]in sort of the glory days of Los Angeles smog.
- [00:18:27.760]I mean, it's actually the, I mean,
- [00:18:28.970]it's one of the only places in America
- [00:18:30.350]where the air has gotten better in the last couple decades.
- [00:18:35.000]But so that was really, I also seem,
- [00:18:39.850]I also think, I know Bob's, you know,
- [00:18:41.760]he's a very careful technician and that,
- [00:18:44.360]and this is probably just my bias,
- [00:18:46.470]but I think it's his most wonderfully printed work as well.
- [00:18:51.190]I mean, it just appeals to, the kind of warmthness
- [00:18:54.430]and the attention,
- [00:18:55.976]because unlike the earlier work, which we just saw,
- [00:18:58.400]those two pictures of, it's very atmospheric.
- [00:19:02.510]You know, Los Angeles doesn't have that brittle,
- [00:19:06.360]high country sky that he photographed
- [00:19:08.820]earlier in his career in Colorado.
- [00:19:11.310]And even his work across the US in Nebraska,
- [00:19:15.310]for example, along the Platte,
- [00:19:18.610]this is a very different kind of light.
- [00:19:20.810]And the first couple years when I,
- [00:19:23.880]I moved to Los Angeles or Long Beach in 2002,
- [00:19:29.586]and I was still photographing a lot in the desert.
- [00:19:32.300]So I'd get up in the morning and drive east
- [00:19:34.580]off and on the Interstate 10.
- [00:19:37.020]And the, you know, as the morning fogs lifted and that
- [00:19:40.610]it was sometimes like driving through Bob's work.
- [00:19:47.855]Well since we have. Well, and.
- [00:19:48.740]Go ahead.
- [00:19:49.895]I was gonna say something about that,
- [00:19:52.159]but wanted to defer to you as the printer,
- [00:19:57.070]but I completely agree that that it's, you know, to me,
- [00:20:00.820]this is when sort of Bob hit his peak
- [00:20:03.310]as a a photographic printer.
- [00:20:05.400]And one of the, you know,
- [00:20:06.760]just to kind of put things in context,
- [00:20:10.660]those early photographs we were looking at from Colorado,
- [00:20:15.320]those were about six by six inches square.
- [00:20:19.660]And when, you know, the "LA Spring" prints are 16 by 20.
- [00:20:25.970]And in the, you know, when they were made in the early 80s,
- [00:20:29.710]that was a big photograph.
- [00:20:33.300]You know, this idea of this sort of four by, you know,
- [00:20:36.020]four by six foot print,
- [00:20:38.810]didn't come along until really until the end of that decade.
- [00:20:42.980]And to me looking at them, I mean,
- [00:20:46.610]I felt like he understood that in order to get
- [00:20:49.010]that kind of expressiveness from it,
- [00:20:50.580]he had to be making a bigger, you know,
- [00:20:53.840]he kind of needed more real estate on the page,
- [00:20:57.550]but you can see what you pointed to that shift
- [00:21:00.580]between the cool and the warm toned paper.
- [00:21:03.910]And it was like that Portriga was just made to,
- [00:21:06.560]kind of it was made to photograph smog.
- [00:21:10.400]And it reminds me of something
- [00:21:12.220]that there was an interview with Louis Baltz,
- [00:21:16.160]who again, photographed in the early seventies
- [00:21:20.186]in Los Angeles at the same time Bob was working.
- [00:21:25.100]And he said, you know, people look at my work and they say,
- [00:21:28.697]you know, basically why is he photographing junk?
- [00:21:32.350]And then they, you know, if they realize
- [00:21:34.860]they look at how beautiful the print is, and they think,
- [00:21:37.170]well, if you went to that kind of effort
- [00:21:40.400]to make it this beautiful,
- [00:21:42.120]or to make an object this beautiful,
- [00:21:43.520]there must be something worth caring about in the picture.
- [00:21:47.730]And I think that Bob, you know,
- [00:21:51.100]works in exactly the same way.
- [00:21:53.540]And that idea, I think he would almost,
- [00:21:55.940]I don't know if it's exact kind of word he would use,
- [00:21:57.880]but it's a way to sort of honor what the subject is.
- [00:22:01.980]And, you know, I think that just speaking
- [00:22:06.790]from the sort of curatorial perspective, you know,
- [00:22:10.690]doing an installation with that work in it,
- [00:22:13.599]and it was the same show I mentioned where this, you know,
- [00:22:15.130]the person walks in and said, oh, he just needs to get the,
- [00:22:17.778]you know, house out of the way.
- [00:22:18.950]There was one wall of "LA Spring" prints.
- [00:22:21.320]And that's what everybody gravitated towards.
- [00:22:24.460]That they were that, even though, you know,
- [00:22:26.870]they're not exactly, I mean,
- [00:22:28.230]there's nothing romantic at all about them.
- [00:22:30.780]There's something about the way he's printing
- [00:22:33.230]that was tremendously effective in that.
- [00:22:36.240]And I think it's that sort of bringing that
- [00:22:38.332]kind of emotional quality to the work.
- [00:22:43.050]You know, I mean, when we put this PowerPoint together
- [00:22:45.960]for this, when I sort of edited or amended it,
- [00:22:50.440]I just somewhat randomly chose
- [00:22:53.460]eight or 10 of my own recent landscapes in Los Angeles,
- [00:22:57.010]but then I inserted them
- [00:22:59.070]in different parts of the Robert Adams sequence.
- [00:23:02.860]And it was kind of, it was kind of interesting,
- [00:23:05.520]I think not, I mean, not consciously,
- [00:23:08.520]but in some ways his work haunts my work.
- [00:23:11.910]There's some, you know, even like locations and that.
- [00:23:15.560]I've photographed a lot in the same areas that,
- [00:23:19.703]you know, not literally the same spot, but the same say,
- [00:23:22.780]you know, Inland Empire areas and that.
- [00:23:25.937]And of course, there was one thing I wanted to point out
- [00:23:27.980]that I think as somebody who lives here, and Toby,
- [00:23:30.780]you might find this amusing as well,
- [00:23:32.260]the work's called "Los Angeles Spring,"
- [00:23:35.510]but almost none of those photographs
- [00:23:37.370]were made in Los Angeles.
- [00:23:39.860]Right.
- [00:23:40.693]You know, they're all made in Redlands, Rialto, Fontana,
- [00:23:45.081]and then weirdly two in Long Beach.
- [00:23:47.390]You know, so.
- [00:23:49.010]Yeah, yeah.
- [00:23:49.843]And one in Westchester, and I recently asked him,
- [00:23:53.660]like, how on Earth did you end up in Westchester?
- [00:23:56.810]He ignored that question, so we still don't know.
- [00:24:00.600]And he, you know, anyway,
- [00:24:04.000]and so I chose these pictures of mine that in fact,
- [00:24:07.440]I had some sort of relationship, not to his picture,
- [00:24:11.780]but maybe to his travels or his journey.
- [00:24:14.970]Like I know there's pictures
- [00:24:16.590]in his project of the Santa Ana Wash, for example,
- [00:24:19.990]we just saw one of that paint-splattered boulder.
- [00:24:24.260]My interest in the Santa Ana Wash
- [00:24:27.480]was because there had been a fire there
- [00:24:30.070]and I've become a, that's sort of like a sort of thematic
- [00:24:33.815]in my own epic photographic
- [00:24:38.100]sort of exploration of the Los Angeles Basin,
- [00:24:40.610]is 'cause fire, I mean,
- [00:24:43.080]fire is both something that's, you know,
- [00:24:45.170]part of the ecology of this part of the world.
- [00:24:47.580]But of course, you know,
- [00:24:48.640]every year they get the fire season,
- [00:24:51.300]I think quotation marks gets longer
- [00:24:53.417]and the fires get bigger.
- [00:24:55.433]And so there's, again, there's that kind of,
- [00:25:00.750]I don't know if paradox
- [00:25:02.260]is the most accurate way of saying it, but you know,
- [00:25:05.560]something that is both sort of natural
- [00:25:09.000]and completely altered by human activity in that,
- [00:25:14.917]in a not very pleasant manner, so.
- [00:25:20.450]Oh, I think.
- [00:25:22.347]It's easy when we talk about Robert Adams
- [00:25:25.390]that to kind of get into this
- [00:25:26.720]really depressing spiral of doom.
- [00:25:30.070]Well, I was about to say that the difference
- [00:25:32.520]between the work is maybe that we're, you know,
- [00:25:36.360]we're sort of 40 years closer to the apocalypse now.
- [00:25:41.779]And I'll just read this, I had this quote here
- [00:25:47.930]and this is something that, so, you know,
- [00:25:50.660]after Bob had made those little square pictures in Colorado,
- [00:25:55.720]he said that, he said, you know,
- [00:25:58.650]he kind of lost his way in the suburbs
- [00:26:00.640]and he wanted to go out
- [00:26:01.710]and rediscover the sort of land forms of the west.
- [00:26:04.150]And what had informed, you know, his predecessors
- [00:26:08.410]both as photographers and his family.
- [00:26:11.540]And he ended up getting a little depressed by it.
- [00:26:15.660]So here's what he writes, he said,
- [00:26:18.737]"where else has a region of more than a million square miles
- [00:26:22.020]been so damaged in so short a time.
- [00:26:25.470]We catch ourselves thinking in the bitterness
- [00:26:27.530]that can accompany the unexpected sound
- [00:26:29.760]of an aluminum can bending underfoot,
- [00:26:32.580]that it would've been merciful if Columbus had been wrong
- [00:26:35.430]and the world flat with an edge from which to fall,
- [00:26:38.910]rather than a circular cage that returns us to our mistakes.
- [00:26:42.730]The geography seems hopeless."
- [00:26:47.300]Well, thanks for that Toby.
- [00:26:49.663]Right, yeah, and now in person, Bob's a very cheery guy,
- [00:26:53.180]so it's not, but I think that, you know, to me,
- [00:26:58.100]and I've not talked about him,
- [00:27:00.630]talked to him about this directly,
- [00:27:01.910]but the project had been working on right before this
- [00:27:06.380]was called "From the Missouri West,"
- [00:27:08.470]and then immediately afterwards, it's "Los Angeles Spring."
- [00:27:11.207]And it seems to me like he hit the coast,
- [00:27:13.750]and he just, you know, he suddenly began to concentrate
- [00:27:16.610]on these photographs, and they're made
- [00:27:20.160]with the bigger camera that he'd been using.
- [00:27:21.960]And again, we mentioned that these were larger prints,
- [00:27:24.010]but I think he saw this as,
- [00:27:30.280]I won't say, you know, not quite apocalyptic
- [00:27:33.350]because I think at least 40 years ago, Bob always had,
- [00:27:39.207]there was always some kind of hope
- [00:27:40.300]buried underneath all of these pictures.
- [00:27:43.616]And he does tend to, you know,
- [00:27:44.560]he does kind of talk about things in these rather,
- [00:27:49.600]I think biblical is a fair way to put it, kind of terms,
- [00:27:53.980]but when he talks about the individual images,
- [00:27:56.590]he always brings up that idea of,
- [00:27:58.230]where, you know, you've got this,
- [00:27:59.817]the sort of bottom half of the picture is really grim,
- [00:28:02.310]but you have all this incredible light in the top half.
- [00:28:04.550]And he was really trying to balance that sense.
- [00:28:09.260]And I think, you know, give you the possibility
- [00:28:11.890]of hope or redemption.
- [00:28:14.060]I've gotta say, you know,
- [00:28:14.893]when I first saw this recent work of Mark's
- [00:28:17.340]and I think I sent you an email that said, you know,
- [00:28:19.740]congratulations, you've, you know, made, you know,
- [00:28:22.760]made "Los Angeles Spring," look like a, you know,
- [00:28:25.310]a cheery holiday card.
- [00:28:32.370]Well, I made, actually, I jokingly told this to Bob,
- [00:28:38.300]and with the idea that it would never be public,
- [00:28:42.030]but I'm gonna say it anyway.
- [00:28:44.396]I jokingly referred to my project as "Los Angeles Autumn."
- [00:28:50.549]And, you know, the thing is I didn't,
- [00:28:55.040]I've been working on this cycle of landscape photographs
- [00:28:58.820]of Los Angeles Basin for about five, six years now.
- [00:29:01.647]And I didn't set out to address his work in any way,
- [00:29:05.090]but that work is, you know, one of the histories
- [00:29:09.438]that I carry with me when I go to photograph, you know,
- [00:29:13.070]if we go back to the railroad there's different particulars,
- [00:29:16.010]but it's the same idea is that my knowledge of a place
- [00:29:19.630]includes the previous art made about the place and that.
- [00:29:23.297]And so I can't unlearn this stuff when I'm photographing,
- [00:29:28.740]and it's probably later in choosing images to print and,
- [00:29:32.530]you know, sequencing and all that other
- [00:29:33.930]kinda post photographing activity
- [00:29:38.510]is when I see these things, you know, like this picture,
- [00:29:42.340]I mean, this is another one of my favorites.
- [00:29:43.890]He does this kind of amazing sort of line of trees
- [00:29:46.960]in that work, you know, many times over,
- [00:29:50.830]but I've photographed quite a bit in San Timoteo Canyon
- [00:29:54.590]in the last couple years, well there you go.
- [00:29:58.720]But you know, he's looking down on it, of course,
- [00:30:01.220]I'm kind of down at the bottom there.
- [00:30:04.010]It's just the really, it's one of those, that road,
- [00:30:08.690]you know, it leads from the orchard country
- [00:30:11.300]of say Redlands, Rialto, Loma Linda, et cetera,
- [00:30:14.270]not Rialto, but Highland, excuse me, it leads to the desert.
- [00:30:18.090]So it's this, the road itself
- [00:30:21.480]sort of exemplifies this kinda transition
- [00:30:23.770]from basin to desert that I'm really interested in.
- [00:30:29.500]Joan Didion referred to those, that the Inland Empire,
- [00:30:33.100]as you know, haunted by the Mojave.
- [00:30:36.390]She had the kind of haunted, right,
- [00:30:39.000]I mean, she got the desert wrong.
- [00:30:40.490]It's the Lower Colorado, not the Mojave
- [00:30:42.570]that haunts the Inland Empire,
- [00:30:44.130]but nonetheless, and, you know,
- [00:30:46.970]I've been photographing a lot in the orchard country,
- [00:30:52.350]these orchards are being bulldozed, you know,
- [00:30:54.400]pretty much faster than I can photograph them.
- [00:30:56.697]And in their place are these giant,
- [00:30:59.050]sort of mile long warehouses, I mean, just, I mean,
- [00:31:03.080]it's amazing how much storage
- [00:31:04.560]we need for all this stuff being made.
- [00:31:06.356]And, you know, it's of course this kinda horrible feeling
- [00:31:10.930]that, you know, the orchard landscape's
- [00:31:14.000]disappearing under the bulldozer.
- [00:31:16.400]But last winter, I read this book "Trees of Paradise"
- [00:31:18.980]and the orchard industry itself is a kind of,
- [00:31:21.640]was an ecological nightmare, you know?
- [00:31:24.400]So again, there's that kind of, you know, we long,
- [00:31:28.120]and all these beautiful trees, the eucalyptus and that,
- [00:31:30.640]which is an invasive plant from Australia and New Zealand,
- [00:31:34.352]you know, what are you gonna do?
- [00:31:36.660]I'm surprised that there are any orchards left.
- [00:31:42.270]And I, you know, I'm sure that
- [00:31:43.740]most people listening have seen Chinatown.
- [00:31:48.110]And, you know, that was really the story of, you know,
- [00:31:50.290]what happened in the San Fernando Valley.
- [00:31:52.610]And they brought all this water, you know,
- [00:31:54.281]down from the Owens Valley
- [00:31:55.740]and suddenly they planted orchards.
- [00:31:58.210]And then in the fifties, they bulldozed them
- [00:32:00.710]and put up, you know, tract homes.
- [00:32:03.750]Like where you grew up.
- [00:32:05.021]Yeah, but, you know,
- [00:32:06.530]we had one orange tree and one grapefruit tree, you know,
- [00:32:12.210]on either side of the driveway.
- [00:32:13.900]So, you know, they left a little bit around
- [00:32:16.210]to kind of remind you of that.
- [00:32:18.060]But the thing that, I guess neither of us mentioned is that,
- [00:32:23.523]you know, Bob was born in New Jersey,
- [00:32:24.850]but he spent most of his childhood in California.
- [00:32:27.344]He went to graduate school in Redlands.
- [00:32:32.030]Yes.
- [00:32:33.170]And, you know, he has a, Bob had a PhD in English
- [00:32:38.920]and he said, you know, he returned to Colorado after that.
- [00:32:42.200]And that's when he saw all of this
- [00:32:43.740]kind of suburban development happening
- [00:32:45.270]along the front range of the Rocky Mountains.
- [00:32:48.750]And then he goes back to California after that.
- [00:32:51.800]And what he, that kind of last bit of, you know,
- [00:32:57.240]what he says here, "Southern California is
- [00:33:01.900]by the reports of those who lived there
- [00:33:03.720]at the turn of the century, beautiful."
- [00:33:05.910]And he goes on and talking about, you know,
- [00:33:07.500]the ornamental cypress and eucalyptus, and you know, now,
- [00:33:11.127]and it gets grim again.
- [00:33:12.830]Now, all we know is that, you know, we are judged.
- [00:33:16.510]But it was like, he'd seen two different landscapes
- [00:33:18.900]that he'd lived in destroyed within this very short,
- [00:33:22.400]you know, within this kind of decade.
- [00:33:25.647]And I mean, again, I think about
- [00:33:29.720]that kind of agricultural landscape of the valley
- [00:33:33.550]is something that was certainly gone by the sixties.
- [00:33:37.040]So I'm surprised that there are even any orchards left.
- [00:33:40.410]Yeah, we wanna pause for one second
- [00:33:44.350]and ask a Zoom question.
- [00:33:45.959]Are people seeing me when I speak, because I'm not.
- [00:33:50.690]Can Aaron, Aaron or somebody?
- [00:33:52.290]Yes, we can see you.
- [00:33:54.140]Okay, okay, I just,
- [00:33:55.043]because I thought this is really weird.
- [00:33:56.900]I don't, and, you know, I was wondering if I could,
- [00:33:58.720]you know, pick my nose or something, but I guess not, okay.
- [00:34:01.770]You can, but we'll see you.
- [00:34:03.524](laughs) Okay, okay.
- [00:34:05.669]The orchard thing is really fascinating,
- [00:34:09.510]'cause it turns, you know, in this book I read,
- [00:34:13.260]there was a period when the use of smudge pots to,
- [00:34:18.310]you know, to combat the frost in the winter,
- [00:34:23.005]it created so much smoke
- [00:34:24.820]that it closed Los Angeles Harbor occasionally.
- [00:34:28.330]I mean, so this is, you know,
- [00:34:29.900]that's like worse than a, you know,
- [00:34:31.710]thousands of diesel trucks,
- [00:34:33.030]which occasionally sort of cast a pall over where I live
- [00:34:36.560]coming out of the same harbor.
- [00:34:39.590]So there's nothing really benign about the citrus industry.
- [00:34:43.129]But and, Toby, there are in fact still producing orchards.
- [00:34:47.960]It's just fewer, fewer, and fewer.
- [00:34:49.740]And I mean, I still, there's this little,
- [00:34:52.820]the last town before you go up into the mountains,
- [00:34:56.160]sort of east of Redlands is a little place called Mentone
- [00:34:59.907]and there's still really healthy looking orchards there.
- [00:35:04.480]In fact, I always stop and buy a big bag of oranges
- [00:35:06.790]when I'm out photographing that way.
- [00:35:08.080]But I mean, I'm interested
- [00:35:15.509]in that really short space
- [00:35:17.220]between the healthy orchard and the warehouse.
- [00:35:21.150]And I guess, you know, I think that one of the things
- [00:35:24.265]that Bob Adams said that really stuck for me,
- [00:35:28.430]and I don't remember where or when he said this or why,
- [00:35:31.500]but he said, we want from photographs,
- [00:35:34.010]so we want the daily news,
- [00:35:35.860]but we also want history and prophecy,
- [00:35:39.270]and that, I think sums up a lot of what I'm asking
- [00:35:43.570]of my own work, you know, the daily news,
- [00:35:46.740]but prophecy as well, and maybe metaphor thrown in,
- [00:35:49.680]if I can be a little presumptuous.
- [00:35:52.570]This is a, this particular picture is a remnant wetland.
- [00:35:56.340]And if people are trying to put all this stuff together
- [00:36:00.210]in some sort of coherency,
- [00:36:03.380]I'm gonna really briefly sketch out the project, my project,
- [00:36:07.200]which is called "Los Angeles Landscapes of Four Ecologies,"
- [00:36:10.640]which is a nod to an architectural history of Los Angeles
- [00:36:14.070]by the British critic, Reyner Banham.
- [00:36:17.350]Which he wrote a really important book
- [00:36:19.420]called "Architecture of Four Ecologies."
- [00:36:22.120]So in brief, the four parts of my project
- [00:36:28.240]are the river systems within the Los Angeles Basin.
- [00:36:32.010]And I heard on the radio not too long ago,
- [00:36:34.980]that one in four Angelinos don't even know
- [00:36:36.780]there is a river in Los Angeles, but in fact there is.
- [00:36:40.680]And in fact it's the river, Los Angeles River
- [00:36:43.700]is why Los Angeles is where it is,
- [00:36:45.340]which is kind of interesting in and of itself.
- [00:36:47.270]Part two is the coastal regions,
- [00:36:49.980]which includes remnant wetlands and so on, like that,
- [00:36:55.330]that's from part one, the river.
- [00:36:57.060]Part three are the hills and the canyons,
- [00:37:00.690]which bisect the basin.
- [00:37:02.470]In part four, I've sort of already discussed briefly,
- [00:37:06.080]which is this kinda haunted by the desert,
- [00:37:10.250]to paraphrase Joan Didion.
- [00:37:12.760]This transition zone from what is basically
- [00:37:15.070]a Mediterranean climate of the basin
- [00:37:16.870]to the harsher climate of the desert
- [00:37:18.980]and the orchard sort of fits right on that border.
- [00:37:24.400]And this bring the, I mean,
- [00:37:25.800]I'm not gonna speculate as to why, but to my knowledge,
- [00:37:28.520]Robert Adams never made a color picture in his life.
- [00:37:31.390]So, back to you, Toby.
- [00:37:34.070]I don't get, only on his iPhone.
- [00:37:37.540]Does he have an iPhone?
- [00:37:39.057]No, no.
- [00:37:40.250]No. I didn't think so, he such a Luddite.
- [00:37:42.308]He has a landline.
- [00:37:46.210]I mean, just thinking about the LA River,
- [00:37:48.470]and I think everybody has seen it without realizing,
- [00:37:51.950]and it's where, you know.
- [00:37:52.950]Without water in it, too.
- [00:37:54.183]They use it for car chases because it's been paved.
- [00:37:58.330]There's this really terrific, do you guys know
- [00:38:00.790]the 1950s science fiction movie "Them,"
- [00:38:03.130]which is where the giant ants attack Los Angeles?
- [00:38:05.720]Do you know that Toby?
- [00:38:06.870]it's really terrific. I haven't seen it, no.
- [00:38:08.541]Okay, so the real,
- [00:38:11.330]the big climax is in in fact,
- [00:38:13.290]the concrete basin of the Los Angeles River,
- [00:38:15.590]the concrete chute, if you will,
- [00:38:18.300]but they're trying to, the police and the army,
- [00:38:22.180]they're interviewing this drunk who lives in the river,
- [00:38:28.060]he's in the hospital, 'cause he's been attacked
- [00:38:29.670]by one of these giant ants
- [00:38:31.460]and in the middle of his delirium,
- [00:38:33.250]he says, "I've seen it with water in it."
- [00:38:38.390]So, meaning the river.
- [00:38:40.910]Before we wrap up, I wanted, could we go back to that,
- [00:38:46.200]there's a print of Bob's there, "La Loma Hills, " it's,
- [00:39:01.590]we're getting there.
- [00:39:03.130]There we go.
- [00:39:04.520]Oops, we just shot past it.
- [00:39:06.911]Ooh, oh I see oh.
- [00:39:12.720]One more.
- [00:39:14.740]There we go.
- [00:39:16.190]So one thing that I think that you and Bob both do
- [00:39:21.070]is kind of pull the 19th century forward into your work.
- [00:39:27.236]And now that I realize we can pull things up on Google,
- [00:39:32.860]Aaron, if you could Google
- [00:39:34.630]Timothy O'Sullivan Karnak, K-A-R-N-A-K.
- [00:39:40.600]You know, we're all pretty familiar with,
- [00:39:47.660]well, now you know, there are all kinds of books
- [00:39:50.220]on all kinds of 19th century American photographers.
- [00:39:53.120]And you can, that first,
- [00:39:57.220]that picture in the upper left corner.
- [00:40:01.540]You know, you can find anything online in two seconds
- [00:40:04.800]and there are books for everything,
- [00:40:06.720]and in the '70s and '80s, when Bob was starting,
- [00:40:10.190]very little was published.
- [00:40:12.380]You certainly, you know, if you would,
- [00:40:17.780]you'd have to go find a book in the library,
- [00:40:21.420]that kind of thing.
- [00:40:22.253]And O'Sullivan hadn't really been paid much attention to
- [00:40:26.070]since the 1870s, and it was our colleague Edward Ranney,
- [00:40:30.467]and he used that phrase to me, he said,
- [00:40:32.150]Bob pulled a O'Sullivan forward for the rest of us.
- [00:40:34.520]And what it is is he went to the Denver Public Library
- [00:40:37.690]and he found a box of prints.
- [00:40:40.460]And, you know, and I think,
- [00:40:43.210]it wasn't matted or anything like that.
- [00:40:44.690]They were just sort of thrown into this,
- [00:40:46.810]you know, cardboard box.
- [00:40:48.870]And Bob was the first person, I think in terms
- [00:40:51.290]of at least who photographers read,
- [00:40:52.540]who really wrote about O'Sullivan's work.
- [00:40:56.350]And one of the things that that O'Sullivan does a lot
- [00:41:00.140]is this, you can see in this image here
- [00:41:01.710]where he tilts the camera
- [00:41:03.460]to give you this sort of sense of instability.
- [00:41:05.740]So if you, you know,
- [00:41:06.573]you follow that ridge line down towards the horizon,
- [00:41:10.050]and then you realize that everything
- [00:41:11.640]kind of flips back in the other direction,
- [00:41:15.160]and O'Sullivan was doing it to sort of promote this idea
- [00:41:20.735]about catastrophism, which was the survey leader,
- [00:41:24.660]Geographic Survey Leader, Clarence King
- [00:41:26.350]believed that the world was sort of formed by these huge,
- [00:41:29.190]you know, eruptions of volcanic action and things like that.
- [00:41:31.880]And then everything calmed down for 10,000 years,
- [00:41:33.820]and it all blew up again.
- [00:41:35.510]And so he's making these pictures
- [00:41:36.940]that show this kind of instability.
- [00:41:39.130]And I've always been kind of surprised
- [00:41:41.850]that Bob does that too.
- [00:41:42.960]So going back to that previous image
- [00:41:46.010]where all of a sudden he flips the, you know,
- [00:41:48.796]and he kind of turns the camera on its side
- [00:41:51.700]and you get that same sort of sense
- [00:41:55.550]where here's the edge of the,
- [00:41:56.980]you see the edge of the, it's not really a cliff there,
- [00:42:01.460]but you know, on the left hand side
- [00:42:04.060]and then that whole horizon is bent, is kind of bent over.
- [00:42:08.640]And I don't know if you agree or disagree with that,
- [00:42:11.640]but it seems like he's really using
- [00:42:13.350]these kind of 19th century formal cues.
- [00:42:17.260]I have no idea what he's thinking about, but you know,
- [00:42:21.500]the evidence is in the pictures, you know?
- [00:42:26.020]I was gonna respond with an anecdote that, you know,
- [00:42:30.660]thinking about that,
- [00:42:31.990]every time I look at the book "Los Angeles Spring,"
- [00:42:34.650]and in fact there's a much better printed,
- [00:42:36.400]newer version of it available now.
- [00:42:38.020]But I think about, you know, these tilted horizon pictures,
- [00:42:42.300]and when I was photographing in the Verdugo Mountains
- [00:42:46.032]above Burbank after the fires,
- [00:42:51.040]I actually tried this and it was unacceptable to me.
- [00:42:55.388](both laughing)
- [00:42:56.721]I mean, not his pictures, but I just,
- [00:43:00.376]I couldn't abide by it.
- [00:43:02.550]I needed to have, 'cause for me,
- [00:43:06.140]that tilt in my picture, not his,
- [00:43:10.490]that tilt became the kinda meaning of the picture
- [00:43:14.170]rather than the light and the burnt land.
- [00:43:17.930]That sort of overrode
- [00:43:20.460]the material stuff I was photographing.
- [00:43:22.740]So, but I mean,
- [00:43:25.274]I look at these pictures and I get it, but I prefer,
- [00:43:30.950]like one of, the second of the two pictures
- [00:43:33.630]that the Sheldon just acquired is my favorite picture
- [00:43:37.210]in that entire body of work.
- [00:43:38.600]And there's a kind of instability there
- [00:43:41.420]without tilting the horizon that I'm much more attracted to.
- [00:43:45.300]The instability there is not so much
- [00:43:48.080]the photographer's doing, but rather
- [00:43:49.610]the photographer's recognition
- [00:43:51.660]of what others have done to that space.
- [00:43:54.560]And that to me is just a lot more,
- [00:43:56.890]both interesting and rewarding as somebody
- [00:43:59.140]who's looking at a picture and thinking about, you know,
- [00:44:01.377]what kind of meaning does this carry
- [00:44:03.490]besides aesthetic pleasure?
- [00:44:05.090]You know, not that it's not there as well, okay.
- [00:44:09.580]So I wanted to tell a really quick little story,
- [00:44:13.500]my story about Robert Adams and the library,
- [00:44:15.860]and that is we go back to my graduate student days.
- [00:44:21.030]You know, after this kind of initial recognition
- [00:44:24.420]of, you know, the importance of these pictures,
- [00:44:27.490]to what I was somewhat naively doing myself,
- [00:44:30.350]I would go to the library and look for books
- [00:44:33.107]by Robert Adams and so on and so forth.
- [00:44:35.320]And I remember discovering that "The New West"
- [00:44:39.520]was in the section of Art Photography,
- [00:44:43.120]but "Denver" was in the section of Books on Colorado.
- [00:44:49.070]And then I sort of pursued that a bit further.
- [00:44:50.920]And if we, if you know, Edward Ruscha's
- [00:44:52.580]little photo books from the sixties
- [00:44:55.577]"Twentysix Gasoline Stations" was under Art,
- [00:44:59.900]but "Thirtyfour Parking Lots"
- [00:45:01.210]was under the History of Transportation.
- [00:45:04.158]And this was hilarious to me.
- [00:45:06.254]And at the same time in the Canadian magazine "Parachute,"
- [00:45:10.030]I read this essay by, is it Douglas Crimp, I think
- [00:45:13.680]called "The library's old, the museum's new subject."
- [00:45:16.260]And it was all about how that was all changing,
- [00:45:19.040]that books and photographs, 'cause you mentioned,
- [00:45:22.860]Bob finding these photographs in the library
- [00:45:25.160]were because of the market influence, pressures, et cetera,
- [00:45:29.100]and other things, academically,
- [00:45:32.610]photographs were now being categorized
- [00:45:34.800]under the author of the picture
- [00:45:36.160]rather than the subject of the picture.
- [00:45:38.140]And that's just, I don't know what it has to do with Bob,
- [00:45:40.780]that's really interesting to me though, you know.
- [00:45:42.940]Well, I actually, I have a funny,
- [00:45:44.820]I have a sort of a funny story from Bob.
- [00:45:49.250]I don't think he'd mind me telling it,
- [00:45:50.750]and then maybe we could take a,
- [00:45:51.760]if there are a couple questions we could.
- [00:45:53.840]And so those, he said that he was, you know,
- [00:45:57.630]driving around with his wife Kerstin and they stopped at a,
- [00:46:02.057]it was a little garage sale and he found two picture frames
- [00:46:06.140]and they were $10 each, and he asked the guy,
- [00:46:11.290]well, what about the photographs in the frames?
- [00:46:13.350]He goes, oh, you can have those, they're not worth anything.
- [00:46:15.730]And they were two of Bob's pictures.
- [00:46:17.801]Oh God, well, oh.
- [00:46:21.480]It depends on, you know,
- [00:46:24.031]who's cataloging the book or who organized the garage sale.
- [00:46:30.080]Right, well, you know, I mean,
- [00:46:33.840]we're getting kind of like two old men telling stories here,
- [00:46:37.250]but I, a couple years ago I bought my stolen Linhof on eBay.
- [00:46:47.880]Are there.
- [00:46:49.130]I'd like to congratulate Wally on his exquisite taste,
- [00:46:53.780]these are two of my favorite pictures, you know.
- [00:46:57.220]Yeah.
- [00:46:58.060]That's pretty good too, you know.
- [00:47:01.220]Thanks Mark.
- [00:47:02.053]That has, okay Toby, that has some of the instability
- [00:47:05.120]without the tilted horizon that I was trying to talk about
- [00:47:07.333]with the previous picture.
- [00:47:08.900]You know, like the way that that.
- [00:47:10.381]There's a sort of sense of things,
- [00:47:12.800]things that are sort of, I mean, there's the, you know,
- [00:47:15.800]the suburb in that gives an illusion of control,
- [00:47:18.170]but there's something in this picture that suggests
- [00:47:20.280]that there's some forces that are not so controllable.
- [00:47:25.880]Well, and I don't know that you would agree
- [00:47:29.260]with this necessarily, I think that my reading of this
- [00:47:32.050]can sometimes be a little more romantic,
- [00:47:33.820]but that it's almost this like gesture of mourning
- [00:47:37.700]from that branch that.
- [00:47:44.620]You know, a couple, maybe two or three years ago,
- [00:47:47.770]I was asked to write about something
- [00:47:49.990]in the Pier 24 Photographic Collection.
- [00:47:52.610]And I chose a composite work by Lewis Baltz.
- [00:47:56.064]And somewhere in there I wrote that, you know,
- [00:47:59.330]his pictures of eucalyptus could not be more different
- [00:48:02.140]than those of Robert Adams, you know, because Baltz is,
- [00:48:05.260]there's nothing romantic at all in what he's done,
- [00:48:09.050]you know, and superficially,
- [00:48:10.670]these two artists are often linked together
- [00:48:13.390]and for historically, you know, valid purposes,
- [00:48:16.180]but it looked at it in a different,
- [00:48:18.650]from a different direction, they couldn't be more different.
- [00:48:21.616]Well, and you know, it's funny because,
- [00:48:23.040]so I think a lot of people listening,
- [00:48:26.350]know the Bemis Center, and I don't know, 8, 10 years ago,
- [00:48:30.210]they asked a bunch of people to come in
- [00:48:31.670]and speak one minute on their favorite photograph.
- [00:48:34.080]And this was the picture that I'd selected, so.
- [00:48:38.497]Wally, you got both of our favorite,
- [00:48:41.860]both of our favorite Robert Adams prints in there.
- [00:48:44.250]Yeah, make sure they're caulked to the wall.
- [00:48:47.340]Toby, Mark, can we go back to,
- [00:48:50.030]when you were talking about the O'Sullivan
- [00:48:52.750]and you were mentioning the term tilt,
- [00:48:56.240]I'm not sure that all of our audience understood
- [00:48:59.500]what you meant by that, because then Mark went on
- [00:49:02.380]and talked about the idea that he couldn't use
- [00:49:05.690]that technique or the means
- [00:49:10.630]to tilt the camera in such a way.
- [00:49:12.650]I think maybe it's not clear that that the.
- [00:49:16.560]Well I would. What that means.
- [00:49:19.840]Most easily, you know,
- [00:49:21.610]when you're setting up the camera, you know,
- [00:49:23.930]most photographers
- [00:49:27.160]try to set the frame level to the horizon.
- [00:49:31.980]And if you really uninteresting,
- [00:49:34.300]you put the horizon right in the middle,
- [00:49:37.050]and O'Sullivan. I do that, Toby.
- [00:49:39.100]Pardon?
- [00:49:39.933]I do that often.
- [00:49:41.245](both laughing)
- [00:49:45.283]But in the 19, so O'Sullivan takes the frame
- [00:49:48.470]and he tilts it at an angle.
- [00:49:51.320]And, you know, one of the, when we were at the Smithsonian,
- [00:49:56.670]we worked with a number of people
- [00:49:57.880]on a Timothy O'Sullivan exhibition.
- [00:50:00.350]And there was a group of pictures
- [00:50:01.880]that we were trying to figure out,
- [00:50:03.250]they'd been misattributed and who, you know,
- [00:50:06.380]who made them, and was it AJ Russell?
- [00:50:08.400]Or was it O'Sullivan?
- [00:50:09.320]And our friend Glenn Willemsen said,
- [00:50:11.140]you know, Russell was too lazy to ever do anything,
- [00:50:14.470]but leave the camera straight on the tripod,
- [00:50:16.390]and he would never have done,
- [00:50:17.760]would've done something like that.
- [00:50:19.910]But he also came from a background as a topographic painter.
- [00:50:23.040]So that idea that, you know,
- [00:50:24.910]everything had to be sort of level and laid out,
- [00:50:29.810]you know, sort of straight to the horizon made sense.
- [00:50:32.740]But I think what O'Sullivan clearly does,
- [00:50:37.117]and it's really only through other photographers
- [00:50:40.010]who've gone there, in particular Rick Dingus,
- [00:50:41.880]who kind of rephotographed some of these sites
- [00:50:44.250]and you realize to make the picture,
- [00:50:46.010]you've suddenly gotta shift the camera like this
- [00:50:48.060]to have it make, you know, to have it match.
- [00:50:50.900]And I can't think of another 19th century photographer
- [00:50:54.840]who was doing that.
- [00:50:57.740]You know, in a more contemporary mode of thinking
- [00:51:02.680]the level horizon seems somehow more objective
- [00:51:05.750]and more, almost scientific because it,
- [00:51:09.110]when you tilt, it's like all of a sudden,
- [00:51:13.080]you're more aware that a person is making a decision.
- [00:51:17.700]It's less neutral as a point of view, or has the appearance.
- [00:51:21.480]I mean, obviously, I mean, we could go on and on about the,
- [00:51:25.010]you know, all the subjectivity of every photograph,
- [00:51:29.180]but that kind of subjectivity is much more obvious
- [00:51:33.640]when you do things that, because in fact,
- [00:51:36.269]these tilted horizon pictures are the equivalent
- [00:51:38.900]of standing there and looking at what's in front of you
- [00:51:43.140]with your head cocked.
- [00:51:44.819]Yeah.
- [00:51:46.034]Know what I mean?
- [00:51:47.730]So, and just a little technical note that, you know,
- [00:51:52.680]Bob and O'Sullivan and my, well less so myself,
- [00:51:56.660]but to some degree,
- [00:51:58.180]we're all using what are known as view cameras.
- [00:52:00.280]And I don't think O'Sullivan's camera had this,
- [00:52:02.460]but modern view cameras usually
- [00:52:04.840]have a spirit level mounted on the top of it.
- [00:52:07.710]Okay, so there's this kind of encouragement built in from,
- [00:52:12.780]I mean, right from the industry, you know,
- [00:52:13.948]photographic equipment and materials and that,
- [00:52:19.160]Hollis Frampton said that they're industrial necessities
- [00:52:22.440]masquerading as cultural preferences,
- [00:52:26.180]this is why every photograph is the same proportions.
- [00:52:31.190]Do you think we should take some questions if there's any?
- [00:52:36.000]Sure, sure.
- [00:52:41.890]I don't know how we do that, I'm waiting.
- [00:52:44.200]I've got one here, does Bob mention Carleton Watkins?
- [00:52:53.159]Bob, not that I can think of other than in passing.
- [00:52:55.780]I mean, the photographer that he really wrote the most about
- [00:53:00.820]was O'Sullivan, and he mentions AJ Russell
- [00:53:04.640]who photographed for Union Pacific,
- [00:53:07.520]and William Henry Jackson who was in Colorado.
- [00:53:12.050]But I think that Bob was really looking at
- [00:53:17.450]that kind of anti-romantic vision.
- [00:53:20.600]And when he talks about O'Sullivan, you know,
- [00:53:25.300]he says that what he figured out how to do
- [00:53:27.180]was photograph all that kind of empty space in the middle.
- [00:53:30.150]So not what you would,
- [00:53:34.870]I guess you could say, like,
- [00:53:35.960]not what you would consider distance, but volume.
- [00:53:38.590]So, you know, not what the mountains are in the back,
- [00:53:41.270]but what's all that stuff.
- [00:53:43.100]And, you know, thinking in particular about
- [00:53:44.970]like the photographs he was making in the desert in Utah,
- [00:53:47.160]where there's just nothing out there.
- [00:53:50.170]And so I think Bob was really drawn to pictures
- [00:53:52.980]that I guess you would say are more astringent.
- [00:53:57.650]And part of what that also has to do with,
- [00:54:00.780]was Watkins was in general, working for a client
- [00:54:04.766]who was gonna want something that was more appealing.
- [00:54:06.800]I mean, they were kind of, you know,
- [00:54:07.940]he was more of a commercial photographer in that way
- [00:54:11.240]and O'Sullivan was working for a geologist.
- [00:54:14.240]And so they were able to produce,
- [00:54:16.490]they needed to produce very different kinds of images.
- [00:54:26.650]Yeah, nothing to add to that.
- [00:54:29.677]But I was just thinking, no, I was,
- [00:54:31.270]what I was thinking about was, you know,
- [00:54:33.080]O'Sullivan versus Watkins.
- [00:54:36.277]And that, for me, that's like,
- [00:54:37.610]that's thinking about how they similar
- [00:54:41.500]and radically different is the same way I think about say,
- [00:54:45.490]Bob and Lewis Baltz,
- [00:54:49.937]or Baltz and Adams are like my Rauschenberg and Johns,
- [00:54:52.080]you know, superficially like really similar.
- [00:54:55.450]And you can say, you know, historically
- [00:54:57.230]they're paired together in all kinds of account,
- [00:55:00.280]historical accounts and critical arguments and that,
- [00:55:03.460]but the more you get to know their work,
- [00:55:06.270]the more you understand
- [00:55:07.180]how completely different they are as artists and that,
- [00:55:10.445]and the same with most of the New Topographics.
- [00:55:12.950]I mean, it's not like there was a club, you know,
- [00:55:15.540]like a curator sort of drew this work together,
- [00:55:18.550]'cause he saw something interesting
- [00:55:20.120]that was going on at the moment.
- [00:55:21.810]And then, you know, in retrospect they become this kind of,
- [00:55:25.100]you know, the New Topographics Club where they, you know,
- [00:55:27.540]they meet every two weeks and bowl or something,
- [00:55:29.470]I don't know or, you know,
- [00:55:33.280]and I, you know, when I was teaching,
- [00:55:35.530]I would use those kind of pairings
- [00:55:38.400]to kinda talk about how, you know,
- [00:55:41.580]Walker Evans and Dorothea Lang, is another, you know,
- [00:55:44.900]there's just, you know,
- [00:55:46.940]because of the historical moment and that
- [00:55:48.890]there's things you could say
- [00:55:51.170]that their work shares in common,
- [00:55:52.420]but the differences are much more interesting, you know.
- [00:55:59.100]Another, are the questions written or spoken?
- [00:56:02.020]I can't.
- [00:56:04.890]Well, we have one now.
- [00:56:07.390]Okay.
- [00:56:11.650]Let's see.
- [00:56:13.402]Does somebody wanna, here we.
- [00:56:17.717]Would you like me to read the question?
- [00:56:18.660]Yeah, Wally, why don't you do that?
- [00:56:21.386]Okay, in Ruwedel's photos, no matter what,
- [00:56:22.880]they have a pentimento to it, not in physical strokes,
- [00:56:27.570]but in the changes of the landscape.
- [00:56:29.283]Does the passage of time influence
- [00:56:31.350]how you capture landscapes,
- [00:56:33.150]or is it just a different way to look at your work?
- [00:56:37.440]I'm not sure what a pentimento is.
- [00:56:44.390]Could that be something like a palimpsest?
- [00:56:47.780]You know like a, we.
- [00:56:49.210]We could ask this person to unmute themself and explain.
- [00:56:54.790]Yeah, that would be easier, I think.
- [00:56:57.047]Hello, I asked a question, can you hear me?
- [00:57:00.430]Yeah.
- [00:57:01.909]Okay, so I'm in a drawing class,
- [00:57:03.430]and I just recently learned this word.
- [00:57:05.470]So like when you do a figure drawing, right.
- [00:57:07.550]You start with like a gesture and then you erase it
- [00:57:10.420]and then refine the figure.
- [00:57:12.040]So like pentimento is like the evidence
- [00:57:14.190]of that, like change in the drawing.
- [00:57:15.873]Oh, I see, I see.
- [00:57:17.510]I being a little fancy.
- [00:57:19.200]Okay, I don't think you, I mean, that's.
- [00:57:20.575]Photographers, you know, they really
- [00:57:22.027]just don't know that much about art history,
- [00:57:23.360]no matter what they tell you, they just don't.
- [00:57:29.690]The fundamental difference between a painting, drawing,
- [00:57:32.970]and all those other things and a photograph
- [00:57:35.090]is the image in a photograph,
- [00:57:36.240]the image is made all at once simultaneously.
- [00:57:39.060]So there's no trace of, there's no underpainting,
- [00:57:44.220]there's no erasure, and so those kind of analogies
- [00:57:48.220]are really difficult to sustain.
- [00:57:52.600]But I think in terms of the landscape
- [00:57:56.080]there's something there, because I think,
- [00:57:57.890]and that's, I guess that is something
- [00:58:01.370]I'm really interested in that we see these,
- [00:58:04.500]we see a kind of, there's a kind of evidence of a history,
- [00:58:08.720]that both the kind of a natural history and a human history,
- [00:58:13.550]you know, in other words, you know,
- [00:58:18.020]both forces have agency and we,
- [00:58:21.567]and there's kind of evidence of that history
- [00:58:26.060]that's visible to some degree.
- [00:58:27.570]And that's really, that's really interesting to me, I think.
- [00:58:33.280]And then there's of course also really interesting histories
- [00:58:35.720]that you can't photograph that I'm interested in.
- [00:58:38.747]And that's why books are really important to me,
- [00:58:41.860]like that photograph of the dead eucalyptus,
- [00:58:46.540]that was titled "Bolsa Chica" number so and so and so and so
- [00:58:51.890]that site in the turn of the 20th century,
- [00:58:56.579]it was tidal wetlands,
- [00:58:59.950]and it was damned to create freshwater ponds
- [00:59:03.290]for a duck hunting club.
- [00:59:05.760]And the road leading up to the lodge,
- [00:59:08.180]they planted these ceremonial trees
- [00:59:11.930]and about 10 or 15 years ago,
- [00:59:16.000]they opened up the damming material that to once again,
- [00:59:21.820]allow the mixture of salt and fresh water in this, a lagoon,
- [00:59:25.770]you know, which is like critically important ecologically,
- [00:59:28.690]lagoons are like, they're almost like lungs, if you will.
- [00:59:33.070]But of course the eucalyptus are salt intolerant
- [00:59:37.890]and they all died.
- [00:59:39.835]So this, again, it was like,
- [00:59:41.390]it's not this major catastrophe like bulldozing orchards
- [00:59:45.240]or anything, but it's kind of, it's interesting that,
- [00:59:48.530]you know, it's so hard to kind of sort all this stuff out
- [00:59:51.360]and that those paradoxes are just,
- [00:59:54.930]that's one of my subjects that is not necessarily visible,
- [00:59:59.210]but it propels that thinking about the landscape in that way
- [01:00:02.800]propels me to make the pictures.
- [01:00:06.260]And of course, then there's this further problem
- [01:00:10.130]that I think Bob Adams' work,
- [01:00:12.760]and a lot of other photographers share
- [01:00:14.720]in that this dead thing is incredibly beautiful
- [01:00:18.140]in a black and white photograph, you know, so.
- [01:00:23.299]Thank you.
- [01:00:24.370]So I don't know if that answers the question,
- [01:00:26.268]but it allowed for me to pontificate a bit anyway.
- [01:00:30.000]All right, looks like you're actually
- [01:00:30.950]in that drawing class right now as we speak.
- [01:00:35.480]If it's okay, if there is time,
- [01:00:37.510]I was just curious, Mark and Toby,
- [01:00:39.530]you guys both were mentioning how "Los Angeles Spring"
- [01:00:43.530]is you know, a little bit differently printed
- [01:00:46.170]than everything else.
- [01:00:47.350]And you guys both said it was maybe
- [01:00:50.680]the most beautifully printed, you know, in your opinion.
- [01:00:54.130]I'm just curious, was there
- [01:00:55.940]some sort of different techniques going on
- [01:00:57.900]or is it solely just the difference of light
- [01:01:01.560]that he was able to capture?
- [01:01:04.240]I think it's both, as Toby mentioned,
- [01:01:08.230]he didn't sort of define what it was, but he mentioned,
- [01:01:10.820]he used this word Portriga,
- [01:01:12.700]these pictures are printed on a German photo paper,
- [01:01:15.683]Agfa Portriga Rapid, which is no longer available.
- [01:01:19.810]And actually some of mine are as well,
- [01:01:21.430]because I have a cache in freezer of this paper,
- [01:01:25.530]but it's a warm paper, it's not just the emulsion is warm,
- [01:01:29.650]but also the paper base is warm.
- [01:01:33.574]And I'm not a hundred percent sure,
- [01:01:35.610]but I'm fairly certain that,
- [01:01:39.500]it's the only project that he printed on that paper.
- [01:01:43.596]And that might not be, I think, some of the
- [01:01:46.061]night photographs, right, the. Some of the,
- [01:01:49.440]no, I think that,
- [01:01:51.171]I think that from "The Missouri West" so that.
- [01:01:52.560]Oh, okay, yeah, you're right.
- [01:01:54.043]Right before that. And that makes sense too.
- [01:01:55.300]Yeah, I forgot that.
- [01:01:56.830]But when we're, you know,
- [01:01:58.223]talking about. The work before and after,
- [01:01:59.470]I'm sorry, Toby, I'm talking over you,
- [01:02:00.677]but the work before and after these two bodies of work
- [01:02:04.570]are printed on very cold tone papers, okay.
- [01:02:08.190]So, I mean, they're all kinda black and white,
- [01:02:11.970]but of course, when you lay, like, I used
- [01:02:15.280]in one of my classes,
- [01:02:17.680]I would lay out like 15 or 20 different photographs
- [01:02:20.110]from different people and say,
- [01:02:21.680]these are all black and white photographs, right.
- [01:02:23.710]But every single one of them is a different color, so.
- [01:02:27.360]And it's something that's fairly easy to see
- [01:02:29.900]between those papers.
- [01:02:30.970]So the cold tone papers really look,
- [01:02:35.110]they really look black and white.
- [01:02:37.470]And when Bob makes a shift for "LA Spring,"
- [01:02:41.260]I mean the best way to put it is they're the color of smog.
- [01:02:45.050]It's this almost, I don't wanna say sepia
- [01:02:47.830]to make it feel like a kind of 19th century picture.
- [01:02:51.140]But you can see they look brown next to the earlier work.
- [01:02:57.120]Right, right.
- [01:02:57.953]And I do think that part of it was the,
- [01:03:02.300]part of it was the scale.
- [01:03:04.330]And like I said, those early pictures, they're very small,
- [01:03:06.750]they're made with a Hasselblad, so they're square images
- [01:03:09.810]and, you know, a square camera's not necessarily
- [01:03:13.280]what you think about for making a landscape picture,
- [01:03:16.030]but Bob wanted to divide, you know,
- [01:03:17.900]what I was talking about before,
- [01:03:19.610]you've got all the housing development on the bottom
- [01:03:22.040]and this beautiful sky on the top.
- [01:03:23.630]So it allowed him to balance the image that way.
- [01:03:26.490]But then he starts working with a larger camera,
- [01:03:29.510]which allows him to make these bigger prints.
- [01:03:32.140]So again, this idea that, you know,
- [01:03:33.313]a 16 by 20 print was huge.
- [01:03:35.550]And I think that there really, you know,
- [01:03:37.870]there are other things
- [01:03:38.760]that he made that size afterwards, but.
- [01:03:41.580]Yeah, yeah, I used, you know, I used to,
- [01:03:45.000]I probably still do think that those earlier pictures,
- [01:03:47.380]the "Denver" and "The New West" pictures and that
- [01:03:49.190]were like really mean and angry. (laughs)
- [01:03:53.020]The picture, not him, but, you know, they were.
- [01:03:56.440]And I think there was something about the smallness of it
- [01:04:00.500]that, and this is a really subjective reading of it,
- [01:04:03.410]but I really, you know, for me,
- [01:04:05.470]that emphasizes kind of anger, you know.
- [01:04:10.420]I mean if you made that picture
- [01:04:12.970]of the the woman in the window there,
- [01:04:14.480]if you made that really, really large,
- [01:04:16.610]it would read really, really differently.
- [01:04:19.850]And I think this is a problem.
- [01:04:22.970]I mean, we've always had this problem,
- [01:04:25.130]but with the internet, of course,
- [01:04:26.990]it's greatly exaggerated, and that is,
- [01:04:29.550]we make a lot of assumptions about pictures
- [01:04:31.610]based on reproductions of the picture
- [01:04:33.530]rather than the picture itself.
- [01:04:34.860]And, you know, in an art history slide lecture,
- [01:04:38.290]a daguerrotype and a Jeff Wall could be the same size.
- [01:04:41.460]And the Jeff Wall in real life is eight feet wide.
- [01:04:43.950]And the daguerrotype is what two and a half inches,
- [01:04:46.741]you know, and size and scale is part of the way,
- [01:04:50.530]any picture, regardless of the medium,
- [01:04:54.730]gains its potential for meaning and enjoyment you know, so.
- [01:04:59.700]Matt, I think you're right about
- [01:05:04.570]that idea about sort of anger.
- [01:05:07.550]I would say that some of it was, you know,
- [01:05:10.040]when he writes about going out and making those pictures
- [01:05:13.170]and he describes a kind of threatening landscape
- [01:05:17.090]in a way that it doesn't necessarily come across in,
- [01:05:20.830]I mean, like when you're looking at some of Mark's pictures,
- [01:05:22.700]it's not hard to imagine somebody coming out from, you know,
- [01:05:27.180]from behind a tree with a bat coming at you.
- [01:05:29.620]But Bob talks about, you know,
- [01:05:33.630]this idea you're walking around in these kind of, you know,
- [01:05:36.270]these suburban and edge, you know, neighborhoods
- [01:05:38.790]or edge of suburbia with a camera, maybe a tripod.
- [01:05:41.810]And he says, you know, dogs come after you.
- [01:05:43.310]And you know, people are throwing, you know,
- [01:05:45.230]throwing bottles out their car and things like that.
- [01:05:48.090]And then he really talked about how threatened he felt,
- [01:05:52.070]making the pictures.
- [01:05:54.690]And just even the sort of, I mean, you know,
- [01:05:58.290]even today I think if somebody was walking around
- [01:06:00.400]a neighborhood with a view camera,
- [01:06:03.790]your neighbors would, you know, half the people in the block
- [01:06:06.280]would either call the cops or shoot at the guy.
- [01:06:10.630]You know, looking at this frontier gas station again,
- [01:06:14.830]there was one thing that I forgot to say earlier
- [01:06:17.700]that always struck me with some of these pictures
- [01:06:19.760]is that there's a kind of ironic component to the early work
- [01:06:23.930]that disappears as his career moves forward.
- [01:06:27.510]There's another picture from the same series,
- [01:06:29.440]it's a kinda distant view of a cul-de-sac
- [01:06:31.810]in a new housing development.
- [01:06:33.090]And, but if you look really closely,
- [01:06:34.390]the name of the street is Darwin Place.
- [01:06:37.860]I mean it can't be accidental,
- [01:06:39.420]there's hundreds of cul-de-sacs to choose from, you know,
- [01:06:42.480]or this idea of frontier, I mean.
- [01:06:46.410]You know, there's this kind of little twist
- [01:06:48.610]in just the choice of gas station
- [01:06:51.590]or the choice of the cul-de-sac or what have you
- [01:06:53.680]in that I think,
- [01:06:59.980]I mean, again, and he didn't tell me this,
- [01:07:02.620]looking at the work as a whole,
- [01:07:05.570]it seems he's come to distrust the kind of ironic stance
- [01:07:11.430]that some of the early work has, you know.
- [01:07:14.800]Well, I think that what is it, that he would counter it
- [01:07:18.810]with what he was writing in his essays.
- [01:07:22.000]So to me, I mean, when I first saw his work,
- [01:07:26.700]I really struggled with it.
- [01:07:28.920]Because I, you know, when I studied History of Photography,
- [01:07:33.090]nothing came up past 1920.
- [01:07:35.190]So you couldn't sit down and take a class in Robert Adams.
- [01:07:39.930]And so what I, you know, what I knew of landscape
- [01:07:44.594]again was Ansel Adams.
- [01:07:45.930]And, I first saw this work in probably like 1988
- [01:07:53.160]when he had his first big retrospective
- [01:07:54.940]and I walked away kind of angry.
- [01:07:56.600]And then I started reading the essays.
- [01:07:58.750]He has a little book called "Beauty in Photography."
- [01:08:01.570]And if you read that, it sounds like
- [01:08:04.420]it has nothing to do at all with these pictures.
- [01:08:06.390]And you really have to kind of go back
- [01:08:08.603]and tease that out from them.
- [01:08:10.240]So I think that, I guess
- [01:08:13.680]the only the way I would disagree
- [01:08:15.200]is that I think he always wanted you to have some sort of,
- [01:08:18.410]some little foothold to have hope in those early pictures.
- [01:08:22.270]And maybe that's what kind of has disappeared.
- [01:08:27.700]Yeah, okay, I, yeah,
- [01:08:29.840]we'll agree to disagree on that one.
- [01:08:31.730]Again, as somebody who was a teacher for over 30 years,
- [01:08:34.413]it's like, I trust the tale, not the teller.
- [01:08:38.461](all laughing)
- [01:08:40.660]I think that's a fitting way to end this tonight.
- [01:08:44.940]I want to thank Mark and Toby,
- [01:08:47.570]really interesting conversation.
- [01:08:50.190]I hope that all of you who are close enough
- [01:08:53.140]can see the exhibition
- [01:08:54.540]and see these prints in the galleries.
- [01:08:57.350]I would just remind you before I sign off
- [01:08:59.740]that on the 24th of March, Mel Chin will be with us
- [01:09:04.770]on a Zoom, a recent work that we just acquired
- [01:09:08.900]through our Sheldon Student Advisory Board.
- [01:09:11.280]And with that good evening,
- [01:09:12.710]and I hope you join us next month, thanks.
- [01:09:16.510]Thank you.
The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!
You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.
Log in to post comments
Embed
Copy the following code into your page
HTML
<div style="padding-top: 56.25%; overflow: hidden; position:relative; -webkit-box-flex: 1; flex-grow: 1;"> <iframe style="bottom: 0; left: 0; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; border: 0; height: 100%; width: 100%;" src="https://mediahub.unl.edu/media/18840?format=iframe&autoplay=0" title="Video Player: CollectionTalk: Los Angeles Spring" allowfullscreen ></iframe> </div>
Comments
0 Comments