Crowd Psychology and Crowd Management

Ivy Marshall Author

08/08/2021 Added

49 Plays

Description

This study examines the psychology of the crowd, specifically why people in a crowd become particularly violent in entertainment settings, and why people in crowds experience deindividuation.

Searchable Transcript

Search:

[00:00:01.140]Hi, my name is Ivy Marshall,
[00:00:02.670]and I'm a senior studying psychology at the University of Nebraska Lincoln.
[00:00:07.350]The research I've been conducting over the past several months with the guidance
[00:00:10.800]of Dr. Chelsea Witt is on crowd psychology and crowd management.
[00:00:15.510]I'd also like to acknowledge that I began my research amidst the COVID-19
[00:00:19.470]pandemic, but chose to exclude that data due to its inherent skewness,
[00:00:23.850]and instead, I focused my research within the 20th century.
[00:00:28.590]This study examines the psychology of the crowd specifically why people in the
[00:00:32.670]crowd become particularly violent in entertainment settings. Crowd psychology,
[00:00:37.200]commonly referred to as collective psychology is defined by the American
[00:00:41.940]Psychological Association as 'the mental and emotional states and
[00:00:46.590]processes characteristic of individuals
[00:00:49.890]when aggregated in such groups as audiences, crowds, mobs,
[00:00:54.510]and social movements,' it can also be referred to as crowd behavior,
[00:00:58.650]crowd mentality, or mob mentality.
[00:01:03.090]Here's some of the studies that have been conducted in the past that heavily
[00:01:06.180]influenced by research as well as the infamous Bubba Helms photo taken
[00:01:10.950]during the Detroit 1984 world series riot.
[00:01:17.580]These are some of the questions I wanted to answer in my research.
[00:01:20.790]We wanted to explore why certain events in the entertainment industry
[00:01:24.540]become more or less violent and explain why people in crowds experience
[00:01:29.200]deindividuation.
[00:01:31.140]Deindividuation is defined by the APA as 'an experiential state
[00:01:36.000]characterized by loss of self-awareness altered perceptions
[00:01:41.100]and a reduction of inner restraints that results in the performance of
[00:01:45.570]unusual and sometimes antisocial behavior.
[00:01:48.690]It can be caused by a number of factors,
[00:01:50.910]such as a sense of anonymity or submersion in a group.'
[00:01:57.720]Our method of analysis was to transfer all of the events and items from an Excel
[00:02:02.670]spreadsheet into SPSS to code and determine the effects of
[00:02:07.590]each category on the number of injuries and fatalities.
[00:02:12.660]I started collecting data by searching different keywords on Google and PsycInfo
[00:02:17.490]The data I researched was used to code and compare the events with each other.
[00:02:22.080]I categorized each event into items such as type of event, type of venue,
[00:02:26.550]presence of alcohol and drugs, presence of security, number of arrests,
[00:02:31.050]hotter or colder temperatures,
[00:02:33.000]number of people present and max capacity of the venue.
[00:02:36.870]I researched dozens of events,
[00:02:38.760]but narrowed it down to 56 to analyze all of which occurred in the 1900s
[00:02:45.330]out of these 56 events, we coded 40 of them in the analysis:
[00:02:49.770]34 sporting events and 6 concerts; 26 outdoor events,
[00:02:54.060]14 indoors; 12 in the spring,
[00:02:56.550]10 in the fall, 10 in the summer and 8 and the winter; 17 events
[00:03:01.480]in the Midwest,
[00:03:02.560]14 in the Northeast, 7 in the West and 2 in the Southeast.
[00:03:09.790]We excluded an event from the analysis
[00:03:12.220]if there was not enough information or there were no major stories written about
[00:03:16.540]it; if there were little to no injuries or arrests reported;
[00:03:20.800]if there were only one or two fans who became violent or the violence was kept
[00:03:24.700]among the athletes;
[00:03:26.110]or if a game was played outside the US and it was not US fans who instigated
[00:03:30.880]the violence.
[00:03:33.940]How we coded our information into SPSS: First,
[00:03:37.390]we coded and analyzed the effect of type of entertainment event with the number
[00:03:41.830]of injuries, then the type of entertainment event with the number of fatalities.
[00:03:46.660]Second, we analyzed the effect of venue type,
[00:03:49.930]whether indoors or outdoors on a number of injuries,
[00:03:53.290]then on the number of fatalities. Third,
[00:03:55.930]we analyzed the number of injuries with: whether there was a rival team,
[00:04:00.310]presence of alcohol, presence of drugs, amount of security, low or high
[00:04:04.930]temperatures, if there was a contingency plan in place,
[00:04:08.590]number of people present, max capacity of the venue, type of sport
[00:04:13.510]and region of the US.
[00:04:18.197]Our results: What did we find? Feel free to pause this video at any time to read the results.
[00:04:25.450]There were mixed results when analyzing the effect of type of event on the
[00:04:29.170]number of injuries.
[00:04:30.730]Since we didn't assume homogeneity our statistical P value was greater than
[00:04:35.140]0.05. However,
[00:04:36.850]we had a relatively large effect size given that the means were so far apart.
[00:04:41.500]Therefore, we tentatively conclude that more injuries occurred at concerts than
[00:04:45.850]sporting events.
[00:04:47.500]There were significantly more fatalities at indoor venues than outdoor venues.
[00:04:52.660]The larger the maximum capacity of a venue,
[00:04:55.630]the more injuries occurred, possibly due to the fact it is in a
[00:05:00.460]larger space with more people, and there may be a heightened sense of panic,
[00:05:05.620]especially if something goes wrong.
[00:05:08.860]A Tukey post-hoc test revealed that there were more fatalities in
[00:05:13.390]basketball compared to those in baseball or football.
[00:05:19.850]There were no significant effects in injuries based on whether the
[00:05:24.680]event was indoors or outdoors, if a game was against a rival team,
[00:05:29.210]when alcohol was present, if a contingency plan was in place,
[00:05:33.630]number of people present, type of sport,
[00:05:36.890]and where in the US the event took place.
[00:05:40.670]There were marginally significant effects in injuries based on drug
[00:05:45.410]influence and temperatures. Events that involved drugs had more injuries than
[00:05:50.330]those that did not mention drug use.
[00:05:52.790]More injuries occurred on days when the temperature was in the 50s and above
[00:05:57.200]compared to days when the temperature was in the 40s and below.
[00:06:01.820]The presence of security had no effect on number of injuries.
[00:06:06.620]A possible issue with these results could be due to the low sample sizes
[00:06:11.510]of rival teams and lack of alcohol and drug presence.
[00:06:16.820]There were no significant effects in fatalities based on whether it was a
[00:06:21.230]sporting event or concert, presence of alcohol or drugs,
[00:06:24.890]presence of security, temperature,
[00:06:27.680]and where in the US the event took place.
[00:06:30.890]Having a contingency plan in place,
[00:06:33.350]the number of people present, and max capacity had no effect on number of
[00:06:37.520]fatalities.
[00:06:39.290]No fatalities occurred when there were rival teams and the sample size was only
[00:06:43.610]7, so we did not compare the effect of rivalry on fatalities.
[00:06:49.100]Some of the possible issues with these results could be due to the low sample
[00:06:53.630]size of concerts, again, the lack of alcohol and drug presence,
[00:06:58.130]no rival team data,
[00:06:59.900]and no correlation between the number of people present and max capacity
[00:07:04.790]with fatalities*.
[00:07:08.030]Now let's briefly discuss our results. According to my research,
[00:07:12.020]concerts tend to have a higher injury rate,
[00:07:14.780]indoor venues tend to have a higher fatality rate, venues with a larger
[00:07:19.640]maximum capacity tend to result in more injuries,
[00:07:23.030]and basketball has a higher rate of fatalities when compared to baseball and
[00:07:28.010]football. Based on my findings,
[00:07:30.860]a rock concert / basketball game mashup at an indoor
[00:07:35.450]venue with approximately 40,000 or more seats would
[00:07:40.040]potentially be the most fatal event to attend if just
[00:07:44.930]one thing goes awry but I think it still sounds like a fun time.
[00:07:52.200]There were several limitations to researching details of events in which violence,
[00:07:56.600]riots, invading the field or storming the court occurred.
[00:08:00.410]There's a lot of missing data,
[00:08:02.090]which could be a result of the lack of record keeping of these types of
[00:08:06.470]incidents in the early 1900s or the shame that comes with the
[00:08:10.850]negligence of properly organizing an event or several other various reasons.
[00:08:16.490]Additional limitations of our study include: lack of a trustworthy database with
[00:08:21.110]established stats,
[00:08:22.760]only being able to find ticket prices in some articles or on eBay,
[00:08:27.680]either from that exact event or similar events around that timeframe.
[00:08:32.490]There were likely much higher property damage costs than predicted or reported.
[00:08:37.730]Our analysis only focused on 20th century events.
[00:08:41.810]Small sample sizes may explain some discrepancies in the analysis.
[00:08:47.450]And there weren't significant numbers of fatalities because we didn't use many
[00:08:51.590]events with significant fatalities.
[00:08:54.930]So my suggestion for future research would be to gather more events and collect
[00:08:59.610]more accurate information so to have larger sample sizes,
[00:09:03.630]which will give you more accurate results,
[00:09:09.020]Lastly, I would like to thank UCARE for funding and giving me this opportunity in
[00:09:13.190]research, as well as holding the virtual events over the summer. And of course,
[00:09:17.660]thank you to my advisor, Dr.
[00:09:19.460]Witt for asking me about my interests in the psych field and encouraging me to
[00:09:24.410]work hard and continue to pursue this topic of research even after this year's
[00:09:29.240]summer symposium. And thank you for watching my presentation.

The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!

You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.

Comments

0 Comments

Crowd Psychology and Crowd Management

Description

Searchable Transcript

Comments icon comment

Related Channels

Comments