Warm or Competent: Perceptions of Gender and How They Influence Consent to Search Situations
Corrie Day
Author
04/03/2021
Added
15
Plays
Description
UCARE presentation on the impact of perceptions of gender on the searchee's perceptions of a consent to search situation.
Searchable Transcript
Toggle between list and paragraph view.
- [00:00:01.970]Hello. My name is Corey Day
- [00:00:03.370]and this is my UCARE project titled:
- [00:00:05.060]warm or competent: perceptions of gender
- [00:00:06.910]and how they influence consent to search situations.
- [00:00:10.140]The Fourth Amendment of the United States constitution
- [00:00:12.480]states the citizens have the right to be free
- [00:00:14.360]from unreasonable searches and seizures
- [00:00:16.370]by government actors
- [00:00:17.400]and the individuals can waive this right
- [00:00:18.870]by giving valid consent.
- [00:00:20.570]For consent to be valid, consent must be voluntary
- [00:00:22.950]and not unduly coercive
- [00:00:24.300]as decided in Schneckloth versus Bustamonte in 1973.
- [00:00:28.330]This voluntariness is determined by examining the totality
- [00:00:31.060]of the circumstances which means courts must consider
- [00:00:33.420]the variables present at the time of the search
- [00:00:35.280]to determine whether or not the consent was voluntary.
- [00:00:38.120]When assessing the totality of the circumstances,
- [00:00:40.190]courts mainly look at whether or not
- [00:00:41.570]a defendant felt free to say no to the search request.
- [00:00:44.480]Little empirical research has been conducted
- [00:00:46.390]on Fourth Amendment search and seizure issues
- [00:00:48.450]and specifically on factors relating to the impact
- [00:00:50.760]of the gender of the searcher.
- [00:00:52.350]Historically, women are a small percentage
- [00:00:54.100]of police departments and have difficulty
- [00:00:55.590]breaking into a system dominated by men.
- [00:00:58.060]Research suggests that gender imbalances in police forces
- [00:01:00.630]can significantly affect an individual's experience
- [00:01:03.000]when interacting with the police.
- [00:01:04.670]For example, if an officer were a woman
- [00:01:06.670]how would you react to her pulling you over
- [00:01:08.100]and asking you to search your car
- [00:01:09.120]compared to if the officer were a man?
- [00:01:11.090]Police departments are highly gendered institutions
- [00:01:13.320]which can lead to women officers
- [00:01:14.660]existing at the periphery of police subculture
- [00:01:16.910]due to the stereotypes they experienced and exhibit.
- [00:01:19.670]Many of these behaviors are traditionally warm
- [00:01:21.770]including sympathetic responses to victims,
- [00:01:24.180]lower rates of force and better communication skills.
- [00:01:27.240]Fiske's stereotype content model
- [00:01:28.880]documents the importance of warmth
- [00:01:30.530]and competence as dimensions and social relations
- [00:01:32.850]group stereotypes and behavioral responses.
- [00:01:35.470]The different combinations of these dimensions
- [00:01:37.320]can create stereotypes.
- [00:01:38.610]For example, those viewed as high in competence
- [00:01:40.690]and low in warmth are viewed within the envious stereotype.
- [00:01:43.870]While those who are low in competence and high in warmth
- [00:01:46.320]are viewed within the paternalistic stereotype.
- [00:01:48.920]When paired with the dynamic of groups,
- [00:01:50.620]these stereotypes can become negative.
- [00:01:52.690]With the searcher and the searchee
- [00:01:54.020]they're already in separate groups
- [00:01:55.230]through the power dynamic
- [00:01:56.320]and by adding a second set of groups
- [00:01:57.930]like a woman who's a searcher and a man who is a searchee,
- [00:02:00.560]these differences can become exacerbated
- [00:02:02.600]changing the perceptions of the searchee even more.
- [00:02:05.310]Research shows that a quote unquote nontraditional woman,
- [00:02:08.060]like women in police forces
- [00:02:09.410]can elicit negative attitudes and stereotypes.
- [00:02:12.060]Additionally, although the amount of women
- [00:02:13.570]within police departments has been increasing
- [00:02:15.350]since the 1970s, research on perceptions of women officers
- [00:02:18.870]and police citizens interactions is lacking.
- [00:02:21.860]By investigating the relationship between searcher agenda
- [00:02:24.340]and perceptions of voluntariness,
- [00:02:26.290]one may be better able to understand the influences
- [00:02:28.450]on an individual's consent to search.
- [00:02:30.790]For this study, there are three hypotheses.
- [00:02:32.840]The first being that women research assistants
- [00:02:34.890]will be rated as higher in warmth and lower in competence
- [00:02:37.680]than research assistants who are men.
- [00:02:39.730]This hypothesis is slightly different than the following
- [00:02:42.040]because these participants never interact
- [00:02:43.850]with the researchers in person
- [00:02:45.440]where the woman would have had authority
- [00:02:46.810]over the participant.
- [00:02:48.090]According to Cody et al 2008 study,
- [00:02:50.250]origins of warmth and competence
- [00:02:51.720]lie within competition and status.
- [00:02:53.700]And since there was no status difference
- [00:02:55.460]between the search warrants searchee,
- [00:02:57.290]I do not think that the women researchers
- [00:02:58.880]would have been rated by cold,
- [00:03:00.423]rated cold by default.
- [00:03:02.610]My second hypothesis is that women will be rated
- [00:03:04.530]as more accusatory than men.
- [00:03:06.060]And my third hypothesis is that women
- [00:03:07.560]will be rated as less respectful than men.
- [00:03:09.940]These hypotheses are due to women research assistants
- [00:03:12.680]being represented in positions of authority,
- [00:03:14.670]similar to Fiske's note of how non-traditional women
- [00:03:16.900]can elicit negative stereotypes
- [00:03:18.329]and that they're more likely to be rated
- [00:03:20.040]with colder tendencies.
- [00:03:22.080]This study uses data from a larger study
- [00:03:24.070]through the lawn policy lab as well as new data
- [00:03:26.300]to determine participants perceptions
- [00:03:28.130]of those who search them.
- [00:03:29.590]The original blank lab study
- [00:03:30.870]investigates an individual's decision to consent to search
- [00:03:33.610]by creating a situation where request
- [00:03:35.400]to search persons belongings occurs.
- [00:03:37.730]In order to make the search request,
- [00:03:39.160]a cheating paradigm is employed
- [00:03:40.620]where to participant is incentivized to cheat
- [00:03:42.470]despite knowing there would be consequences for doing so.
- [00:03:45.300]Researchers then accused the participant of cheating
- [00:03:47.330]and ask if they would consent to a search of their bag
- [00:03:49.360]in order to see if there's evidence of their cheating.
- [00:03:51.580]There's never an actual search only the threat of one.
- [00:03:54.270]The second study uses photographs
- [00:03:55.760]of four of these researchers from the original study
- [00:03:58.040]and shows them to different participants
- [00:03:59.640]rate them on a five-point Likert scale.
- [00:04:01.830]These measures were from Cody et al 2008 study
- [00:04:04.480]focusing on friendliness and trustworthiness
- [00:04:06.340]as dimensions of warmth and assertiveness and capability
- [00:04:08.950]as dimensions of competence.
- [00:04:10.840]For both studies, the independent variable
- [00:04:12.810]was the gender of the searcher.
- [00:04:13.997]And the focus of the analysis was the impact
- [00:04:16.130]of the gender of the searcher
- [00:04:17.110]on perceptions of the searchee.
- [00:04:21.682]First the study one, there were 145 participants,
- [00:04:24.197]a hundred of which who were women,
- [00:04:26.050]45 of which who were men,
- [00:04:27.560]and an age range of 17 to 46 years old
- [00:04:29.950]but the largest age group being between 18 and 20.
- [00:04:32.910]For study two, there were 98 participants,
- [00:04:35.100]75 who were women, 22 who were men
- [00:04:37.900]and one participant who identified as other.
- [00:04:40.180]The age range was 18 to 26 years old.
- [00:04:42.540]And the largest age group was 19 to 21 years old.
- [00:04:46.540]All three of these hypotheses were run
- [00:04:48.260]with a two way ANOVA that yielded non-significant results.
- [00:04:51.400]However, there were some interesting results
- [00:04:52.960]regarding hypothesis two and three
- [00:04:54.450]that have potential to studies ever replicated.
- [00:04:57.070]After running chi-squares with hypothesis two and three
- [00:04:59.670]more to participants gave the women researchers
- [00:05:01.840]warm judgments than men.
- [00:05:03.870]So as you can see with hypothesis two,
- [00:05:06.020]it is non-significant as the P value is very high.
- [00:05:09.010]But you can see that more participants
- [00:05:10.310]said they felt the women research assistant
- [00:05:12.040]was not accusing them of a crime.
- [00:05:14.220]Participant three same or hypothesis three same issue,
- [00:05:18.220]P value is very high,
- [00:05:19.890]but you can see that more participants
- [00:05:22.340]said the research assistant
- [00:05:23.440]treated them more respectfully than men.
- [00:05:26.580]So for the main takeaways,
- [00:05:28.010]although none of the research results were significant,
- [00:05:31.030]there are some interesting results to discuss
- [00:05:32.960]not only where the second
- [00:05:34.050]and third hypothesis non-significant
- [00:05:36.110]but the opposite of my prediction.
- [00:05:38.070]This makes sense when looking
- [00:05:39.100]at the socio-emotional orientation of women
- [00:05:41.050]in society versus men.
- [00:05:42.670]Women are traditionally perceived as warm,
- [00:05:44.370]while men are traditionally perceived as competent.
- [00:05:46.500]Additionally, of looking through the lens
- [00:05:47.840]of benevolent sexism,
- [00:05:49.130]another element of the stereotype content model,
- [00:05:51.440]the default of this view is that women are kind
- [00:05:53.670]and would make sense as to why participants ranked the women
- [00:05:55.930]who were research assistants as more friendly
- [00:05:57.970]and warm than the men.
- [00:05:59.980]There are two main research limitations.
- [00:06:02.030]The first is poor research requirement timing by SONA.
- [00:06:04.870]This semester UNL research requirements
- [00:06:07.480]didn't exist for SONA, so I had less participants.
- [00:06:10.650]But I think the main issue here is limited exposure
- [00:06:13.180]to the research assistants.
- [00:06:14.950]It's very difficult to make a snap judgment
- [00:06:16.660]off a person's capability or assertiveness
- [00:06:19.200]based on one photo.
- [00:06:20.890]I think the main thing
- [00:06:22.140]is because people just weren't able to do that
- [00:06:24.390]they never met the research assistants.
- [00:06:26.910]Even if there were multiple photos
- [00:06:28.210]I still think this would be a difficult judgment to make.
- [00:06:30.280]And this ties in with my proposal for a future study.
- [00:06:33.150]One way to make this more cohesive
- [00:06:34.630]is to add warmth and competence questions
- [00:06:36.390]to the questionnaire the participant takes
- [00:06:37.980]in the original consent search study.
- [00:06:39.880]This would allow for direct perceptions
- [00:06:41.440]of a participant who's searched
- [00:06:42.700]instead of a participant who has never interacted
- [00:06:44.560]with the researcher in person.
- [00:06:46.960]I think that although this research
- [00:06:48.130]didn't go the way I intended, it still has value.
- [00:06:50.430]More and more women are joining police forces every day
- [00:06:52.630]and despite this there's still minimal research
- [00:06:54.420]on the impacts they can have with citizens.
- [00:06:56.700]Something that was in line with the results
- [00:06:58.170]is how women on the force have treated citizens in the past.
- [00:07:00.640]They've treated them kindly.
- [00:07:01.830]They're known for their deescalation abilities
- [00:07:03.980]at the county and honesty and low rates of misconduct.
- [00:07:07.020]By investing more research into women officers
- [00:07:09.200]this could increase the trust in police,
- [00:07:11.980]high rates of police approval,
- [00:07:13.440]and more citizen-officer cooperation.
- [00:07:17.350]So lastly, I just wanted to say thank you
- [00:07:18.850]to Dr. Eve Brank, Dr. Jennifer Groscup,
- [00:07:21.250]Emma Marshall, Katherine Hasan, and Abby Shnef.
- [00:07:23.405]Thank you so much.
The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!
You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.
Log in to post comments
Embed
Copy the following code into your page
HTML
<div style="padding-top: 56.25%; overflow: hidden; position:relative; -webkit-box-flex: 1; flex-grow: 1;"> <iframe style="bottom: 0; left: 0; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; border: 0; height: 100%; width: 100%;" src="https://mediahub.unl.edu/media/16245?format=iframe&autoplay=0" title="Video Player: Warm or Competent: Perceptions of Gender and How They Influence Consent to Search Situations" allowfullscreen ></iframe> </div>
Comments
0 Comments