Vegetable Variety Navigator: An Interactive Grower Decision-Support Tool

Ali Loker Author

04/02/2021 Added

16 Plays

Description

Vegetable Variety Navigator: An Interactive Grower Decision-Support Tool. https://agronomy.unl.edu/Vegetable-Variety-Navigator

Searchable Transcript

Search:

[00:00:01.410]Hello. My name is Ali Loker and I'm a Doctor of Plant Health student at the
[00:00:05.280]University of Nebraska.
[00:00:07.080]I'm excited to share some research I did in the summer of 2020 under the
[00:00:11.010]direction of Dr.
[00:00:11.820]Sam Wortman in the Agronomy and Horticulture Department. Together,
[00:00:15.630]we developed a tool called the Vegetable Variety Navigator,
[00:00:19.350]which is an interactive grower decision support tool.
[00:00:25.130]To begin,
[00:00:25.820]I would like you to take a moment and imagine that you're a vegetable grower in
[00:00:30.200]the middle of winter.
[00:00:32.630]You're planning what crops and what varieties you'd like to plant for the next
[00:00:36.440]season. And you're very excited when your seed catalogs finally arrive.
[00:00:41.180]But when you open them up, you see a vast number of choices.
[00:00:45.560]These are the number of varieties by different crops and suppliers for just a
[00:00:49.340]select few. Up to 24 different varieties of broccoli to choose from,
[00:00:53.930]74 of cucumber, 41 of pepper.
[00:00:57.170]So how do you go about making this decision?
[00:01:00.200]One opportunity is to consult variety trial information.
[00:01:03.920]These are typically conducted by university extension in a specific area,
[00:01:09.530]and they can provide really wonderful location-specific information about what
[00:01:13.970]cultivars might perform best in an area.
[00:01:18.200]Additionally,
[00:01:18.980]they're replicated experiments and have statistical analysis,
[00:01:22.730]so that adds another layer of rigor to the results.
[00:01:27.350]There are some limitations that come with variety trials.
[00:01:31.430]One of the major limitations for a grower is that these results are scattered
[00:01:36.230]across different websites, different databases,
[00:01:40.630]and they're just sometimes hard to track down.
[00:01:44.270]There's also limited interpretation ability outside of that particular study
[00:01:48.890]location. And lastly,
[00:01:51.950]there are relatively few variety trials for specialty crops,
[00:01:56.150]especially when we compare them to row crops, like corn or wheat or soy.
[00:02:03.380]So enter the Vegetable Variety Navigator.
[00:02:07.250]Our objectives for this project were to aggregate and
[00:02:11.690]synthesize global variety trial data for broccoli, peppers,
[00:02:15.560]and cucumbers.
[00:02:18.410]We also explore descriptive and explanatory trends,
[00:02:21.740]potential factors that would impact yield. Lastly,
[00:02:26.090]and most excitingly to me,
[00:02:27.620]we synthesized and present our results in an online decision support tool.
[00:02:32.300]This is available to anyone at the link you see on your screen.
[00:02:36.950]So.
[00:02:37.160]For our methods,
[00:02:38.300]we conducted a systematic literature review to hunt down all of those variety
[00:02:42.750]trials. We extracted data for analysis,
[00:02:48.170]and then we developed our own
[00:02:49.910]tool. So for the systematic literature review,
[00:02:54.380]we searched a variety of different avenues,
[00:02:57.080]including the academic search engine route,
[00:03:00.190]as well as a more general internet search and specific databases.
[00:03:04.300]So we wanted to conduct a broad enough search to be sure we were capturing all
[00:03:08.350]of the available data. And we specifically focused on these three crops.
[00:03:13.810]Our next step was data extraction.
[00:03:16.960]We extracted yield and our quality data where it was available and coded it by a
[00:03:21.430]variety of factors.
[00:03:23.470]We then grouped that data by crop and variety for our meta-analysis.
[00:03:30.190]In total, we analyzed nearly a hundred broccoli,
[00:03:33.910]cucumber and a little bit over a hundred bell pepper varieties.
[00:03:38.560]We calculated response ratios for yield or quality. So to do that,
[00:03:42.820]we took the yield or quality of variety A, for example,
[00:03:46.900]and then divided it by the average yield for all the other varieties included in
[00:03:50.530]that study.
[00:03:53.440]This allowed us to then calculate confidence intervals for each of the
[00:03:57.820]varieties. Finally,
[00:03:59.080]we conducted a meta-regression analysis to see if there was any correlation
[00:04:02.980]between yield and aridity. And lastly,
[00:04:07.360]we integrated these mean relative yield and quality values,
[00:04:10.630]along with their confidence intervals into our online tool where they're
[00:04:14.920]summarized in graph forms.
[00:04:18.490]We also have our data presented in a map form to further investigate the
[00:04:22.990]geographic distribution of studies.
[00:04:25.480]And it also allows us to present data from specific studies that didn't have
[00:04:29.800]enough data to be included in our meta-analysis.
[00:04:33.640]Now I'd like to show you a brief tour of the tool itself. On the
[00:04:38.320]screen,
[00:04:38.770]we'll see a graphical summary of the mean relative yield and the
[00:04:43.450]upper and lower expected relative yield for all of these different varieties
[00:04:48.430]of cucumbers.
[00:04:50.230]We can see that when we hover over one of these data
[00:04:54.850]points, a pop-up box will appear.
[00:04:57.820]This provides additional information such as the number of site years that
[00:05:01.870]contribute to these values, the number of studies,
[00:05:05.260]and also summarizes the relative yield potential,
[00:05:09.880]which we categorize as low, moderate or high. Finally,
[00:05:14.530]we can see that the study locations are highlighted in that small map on the
[00:05:19.210]pop-up box so that the user can get an idea of where these studies were
[00:05:22.960]conducted.
[00:05:26.940]Our map view allows the user to view a geographic distribution of the studies.
[00:05:33.000]I have this filtered by only broccoli varieties here on the right.
[00:05:36.810]I could do a further search, if I had a specific variety in mind.
[00:05:41.430]I can filter by my soil texture or aridity index value to further
[00:05:46.110]target the results.
[00:05:49.440]We have similar functionality here in terms of hovering over a data point
[00:05:54.270]to view additional information about that study.
[00:05:58.580]To
[00:05:58.760]conclude,
[00:05:59.270]I'd like to discuss a few future opportunities that we see for this research.
[00:06:05.120]We are
[00:06:05.390]currently beta testing the tool to get some feedback from Nebraska growers and
[00:06:09.830]extension agents.
[00:06:12.470]We plan
[00:06:13.190]to conduct broccoli,
[00:06:14.600]cucumber and sweet pepper trials in the summer of 2021 and 22.
[00:06:19.670]And we'll use the data from those trials to sort of crosscheck or ground truth
[00:06:24.620]those data with what's currently in the tool.
[00:06:29.660]On our website, we also have the opportunity for researchers, growers,
[00:06:34.160]and other folks to submit data for consideration.
[00:06:39.050]And
[00:06:39.200]we also plan to expand this tool to additional crops like sweet corn or
[00:06:43.790]lettuce
[00:06:44.380]in the future.
[00:06:47.380]I'd also like to take this opportunity to thank these folks
[00:06:50.860]on your screen. Um, both in the Wortman lab and at UNL Extension, uh, Dr.
[00:06:55.630]Sam Wortman, his grad student Chris Chen and extension agents, Katie King,
[00:07:00.580]and John Porter.
[00:07:03.670]Thank you.
[00:07:03.880]Thanks so much for your time and attention. And I would welcome any questions,
[00:07:07.750]feedback, or ideas; my email is on the screen.

The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!

You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.

Comments

0 Comments

Vegetable Variety Navigator: An Interactive Grower Decision-Support Tool

Description

Searchable Transcript

Comments icon comment

Related Channels

Comments