A de novo recessive mutation causative of Mandibulofacial Dysostosis in Hereford cattle

Renae Sieck Author

04/01/2021 Added

22 Plays

Description

This video describes the process our lab completed to identify the genomic variant underlying a congenital defect in a breed of cattle. We investigated pedigrees to develop a hypothesized mode of inheritance. Then we used whole genome sequencing data to investigate our hypothesis. We identified and verified a candidate variant. I end this presentation by describing the role we believe this variant is playing in craniofacial development.

Searchable Transcript

Search:

[00:00:00.920]I'm Renae Sieck,
[00:00:01.990]and today I will present our group's research
[00:00:04.030]that was recently published in "Genes."
[00:00:06.810]In March and April of 2020,
[00:00:08.720]three cattle herds reported a total
[00:00:10.610]of six purebred Hereford calves
[00:00:12.590]born with unusual defects of the face and jaw.
[00:00:15.810]These were attributed to a condition we term
[00:00:18.121]Mandibulofacial Dysostosis, which we abbreviate as MD.
[00:00:22.560]A common bull was identified in the pedigree
[00:00:24.730]of all of the affected calves,
[00:00:26.440]indicating a plausible genetic cause of the condition.
[00:00:30.620]Throughout the project, five affected calves were sent
[00:00:33.240]to the UNL Veterinary Diagnostic Center
[00:00:35.710]for autopsy evaluation.
[00:00:37.810]This table presents a summary
[00:00:39.370]of the external pathologic findings in these calves.
[00:00:42.900]One defining characteristic of all calves evaluated
[00:00:45.830]was bilateral skin tags near the fusion site
[00:00:48.310]of the mandible and maxilla.
[00:00:50.510]All affected calves also had skin tags
[00:00:52.930]in variable locations at or below the ears.
[00:00:56.720]Multiple other pathologic characteristics were present
[00:00:59.290]in a subset of the observed calves at varying severity.
[00:01:03.810]Further autopsy evaluation revealed
[00:01:05.940]two additional internal hallmarks of MD.
[00:01:08.890]The skin tags near the commissure of the lips were found
[00:01:11.700]to be attached through a short dermal band
[00:01:13.840]to cartilage encased in a bony process.
[00:01:16.890]The bony process then extended
[00:01:18.430]from the skin tag toward the ear.
[00:01:20.950]When the bony process was fractured,
[00:01:22.690]it revealed a cartilage tube that was freely removed
[00:01:25.240]from the bone encasing it, as shown in the central image.
[00:01:28.820]This cartilage is quite abnormal in this region of the skull
[00:01:32.400]and was identified to be Meckel's cartilage,
[00:01:34.980]a remnant of cartilage normally present
[00:01:37.120]in the region early in development.
[00:01:40.320]Histologic evaluation of the bony process confirmed
[00:01:43.160]that this cartilage was sandwiched
[00:01:44.620]between plates of bone.
[00:01:47.440]This pedigree shows cattle
[00:01:48.900]displaying the MD phenotype in black
[00:01:51.000]and those that had a normal phenotype in gray.
[00:01:54.010]A potential founder bull was present
[00:01:55.790]in both the maternal and paternal sides of the pedigrees
[00:01:59.010]of all of the affected calves.
[00:02:01.510]Based on the inheritance pattern of the MD phenotype,
[00:02:04.460]we hypothesized that a de novo autosomal recessive mutation
[00:02:08.240]is causative of this novel condition in Hereford cattle.
[00:02:12.280]To evaluate this hypothesis,
[00:02:14.270]we began by whole genome sequencing three affected calves,
[00:02:17.620]10 parents of affected calves,
[00:02:19.390]and seven individuals that were related
[00:02:21.590]to the suspect founder bull.
[00:02:23.640]The sequencing yielded a list of 143 candidate variants
[00:02:27.960]that matched the hypothesized mode of inheritance.
[00:02:30.830]To further narrow down this list,
[00:02:32.570]we evaluated whole genome sequence data
[00:02:34.900]from other cattle projects in our lab,
[00:02:37.160]publicly available data on the Sequence Read Archive,
[00:02:40.190]and Sanger sequencing results from additional animals
[00:02:43.230]related to the presumed founder.
[00:02:45.690]Variants were removed from consideration
[00:02:47.920]that didn't match our hypothesized mode of inheritance.
[00:02:51.160]This left us with two candidates remaining.
[00:02:53.820]From this point forward, we pursued the missense variant
[00:02:56.690]in CYP26C1 because of the predicted deleterious impact
[00:03:00.860]of the mutation on protein function
[00:03:03.240]and because of the biological role of this gene.
[00:03:07.420]To further evaluate the predicted function
[00:03:09.350]of the CYP26C1 variant, we looked at its conservation
[00:03:13.340]of the altered amino acids sequence across multiple species.
[00:03:18.100]The leucine at position 188
[00:03:19.900]of the cattle amino acid sequence that we show here in bold
[00:03:23.500]was conserved across all species
[00:03:25.150]except for in the affected MD calves
[00:03:27.770]where the missense mutation resulted
[00:03:29.860]in a proline at this position.
[00:03:32.460]Conservation across many species
[00:03:34.530]indicates a biological importance
[00:03:36.450]of that portion of the protein.
[00:03:38.640]Therefore, this evaluation provides further evidence
[00:03:41.480]that this missense mutation is deleterious
[00:03:43.770]to protein function.
[00:03:46.590]We also performed protein modeling
[00:03:48.220]to show the predicted location
[00:03:49.770]of the changed amino acid sequence
[00:03:51.750]within the protein structure.
[00:03:53.680]Image A and B in this picture show that our mutation was not
[00:03:57.040]in the active binding side of this protein
[00:03:59.160]but instead is located in an alpha helix
[00:04:01.840]near that binding site.
[00:04:03.580]In C and D, the horizontal red bars
[00:04:06.360]indicate the predicted position of an alpha helix,
[00:04:10.260]and our confidence in that prediction is displayed
[00:04:12.760]by the vertical black bars.
[00:04:14.750]C represents the wild-type leucine,
[00:04:16.920]and D represents the amino acid changed to proline
[00:04:20.130]as a result of our candidate missense mutation.
[00:04:23.310]Proline is known to be a helix breaker.
[00:04:25.940]This predictor confirms that that could be the case
[00:04:28.390]with our candidate mutation
[00:04:30.050]by showing a break in the helix
[00:04:32.240]around amino acid position 188.
[00:04:35.990]In order to confirm the inheritance pattern of MD
[00:04:38.820]in this line of cattle,
[00:04:40.260]we genotyped an additional 782 Herefords.
[00:04:44.180]It's important to note that all of the animals
[00:04:46.700]with a homozygous recessive genotype
[00:04:49.080]displayed the MD phenotype,
[00:04:51.120]and no other animals we genotyped
[00:04:53.710]displayed the phenotypic characteristics of this condition.
[00:04:57.200]Also, all animals with no pedigree tie to the founder
[00:05:01.020]genotyped as homozygous for the reference allele.
[00:05:05.250]In order to discuss the biological role
[00:05:07.340]we believe CYP26C1 plays in the MD condition,
[00:05:10.820]I will first provide you with an overview
[00:05:13.110]of the process of mandible formation.
[00:05:15.980]Cranial neural crest cells migrate from the neural tube
[00:05:18.970]to the first pharyngeal arch of the developing embryo.
[00:05:22.360]Next, endothelin-1 signaling in the first pharyngeal arch
[00:05:26.280]results in activation of DLX5 and DLX6 genes.
[00:05:31.440]This activation initiates the formation
[00:05:33.580]of Meckel's cartilage, which eventually serves as a scaffold
[00:05:37.420]during the formation and elongation
[00:05:39.780]of the intramembranous mandible bone.
[00:05:42.490]Retinoic acid is important
[00:05:43.770]for understanding the role of CYP26C1
[00:05:46.390]in craniofacial development.
[00:05:48.650]Retinoic acid is a metabolite of vitamin A
[00:05:51.430]and is a repressor of endothelin-1.
[00:05:54.410]Therefore, an excess of retinoic acid can result
[00:05:56.860]in craniofacial abnormalities involving the mandible
[00:06:00.260]via changes in Meckel's cartilage formation.
[00:06:04.160]Retinoic acid in craniofacial development is regulated
[00:06:07.140]by two main families of genes.
[00:06:09.400]The Raldh family synthesizes retinoic acid,
[00:06:12.890]and the CYP26 family degrades it.
[00:06:15.970]Retinoic acid's effect is highly tissue
[00:06:18.300]and time point specific.
[00:06:20.420]CYP26C1 is expressed in the first pharyngeal arch
[00:06:23.420]during mandible development.
[00:06:25.770]The phenotype of the MD-affected calves would result
[00:06:28.620]in changes in retinoic acid level
[00:06:31.020]during approximately day 21 to 22 of gestation.
[00:06:36.750]Several human conditions exhibit similar pathologies
[00:06:39.740]to the MD calves.
[00:06:41.450]Focal facial dermal dysplasia type four is interesting
[00:06:44.920]because the skin lesions seen in the affected human patients
[00:06:48.700]are resulting from a loss of function mutation in CYP26C1.
[00:06:53.730]Interestingly, these skin lesions are in similar locations
[00:06:56.950]to the skin tags we observed in MD calves.
[00:07:00.110]Next, hemifacial microsomia in humans
[00:07:04.270]results in skin tags
[00:07:05.620]caudal to the commissure of the lips
[00:07:07.460]and near the ear and changes in mandible elongation.
[00:07:12.290]The skin tags and mandible development changes
[00:07:15.370]are strikingly similar to the pathologic characteristics
[00:07:18.590]we observed in the MD calves.
[00:07:21.570]Our study has wide implications within the Hereford breed
[00:07:24.680]because multiple highly-prolific sires are carriers
[00:07:27.460]of the condition.
[00:07:28.800]This resulted in over 40,000 cattle
[00:07:30.930]with pedigree ties to the founder bull.
[00:07:33.620]Additionally, the novel pathology presented
[00:07:36.930]could aid researchers studying similar conditions
[00:07:39.250]in other species.
[00:07:41.490]I would like to acknowledge
[00:07:42.760]the American Hereford Association
[00:07:44.570]and the Hereford breeders who reported cases
[00:07:46.760]for their assistance in sample collection
[00:07:48.700]and for providing pedigree records.
[00:07:51.000]I would also like to thank Leah Treffer and Anna Fuller
[00:07:54.450]for their contributions in the lab.
[00:07:56.810]Thank you for tuning in to my presentation.

The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!

You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.

Comments

0 Comments

A de novo recessive mutation causative of Mandibulofacial Dysostosis in Hereford cattle

Description

Searchable Transcript

Comments icon comment

Related Channels

Comments