ALCOT Part 1

Robert Pennington Author

03/16/2021 Added

52 Plays

Description

ALCOT Part 1

Searchable Transcript

Search:

[00:00:03.720]Hi, welcome. I'm Rob Pennington.
[00:00:05.580]I'm a professor of special education
[00:00:06.757]at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte
[00:00:09.400]and I'm really excited to be here today.
[00:00:10.940]Today we're gonna talk about building better programs
[00:00:12.930]for our students' extensive support needs
[00:00:15.040]and I'd kinda like to lead off with a picture.
[00:00:18.960]So this is me in 1990-ish, I think.
[00:00:23.140]I was maybe a practicum student
[00:00:25.530]and it reminds me that I've spent over half my life
[00:00:29.680]in education as a special educator.
[00:00:33.250]So I was a peer tutor in grade school.
[00:00:35.830]I was in Future Teachers of America in high school
[00:00:38.620]which is not the coolest club to be in
[00:00:40.457]but I was so passionate about it.
[00:00:42.240]My dad was a teacher.
[00:00:44.580]I was developing that identity as a teacher early on.
[00:00:48.550]During college as an undergraduate
[00:00:50.270]I did some one-on-one work in homes
[00:00:52.430]with small children with autism,
[00:00:53.900]did respite work with families, tutoring, coaching,
[00:00:57.690]and then I started teaching and I taught elementary,
[00:01:01.090]middle school programs for kids with severe disabilities.
[00:01:04.130]I worked within districts
[00:01:05.310]as a district kind of support person.
[00:01:07.470]So a lot of coaching, a lot of helping teachers.
[00:01:11.341]And then I had this great opportunity to work as a director
[00:01:15.230]of an autism state technical assistance center,
[00:01:18.502]the Kentucky Autism Training Center,
[00:01:19.470]and during that time I was able to work with teachers
[00:01:22.140]in rural and urban communities to develop their practice.
[00:01:25.370]And so that was pretty fantastic
[00:01:26.510]'cause I got to see different groups of people
[00:01:28.900]working really hard with different access to resources.
[00:01:33.140]When I went to University of Kentucky,
[00:01:34.590]I still kept working in schools
[00:01:36.280]and most of my academic career
[00:01:37.870]has involved working in schools.
[00:01:39.530]My research is in schools.
[00:01:40.800]I teach classes within teacher preparation programs
[00:01:44.590]and I still consistently even this week engage
[00:01:47.580]in consultation with schools.
[00:01:49.310]And so again, this is important to me
[00:01:52.880]and across all these things, all these experiences,
[00:01:56.990]I've learned one thing
[00:01:59.180]and this is not gonna be a surprise to you, right?
[00:02:01.160]But that teaching is hard.
[00:02:02.477]And I kinda like to frame all the work that I do
[00:02:04.710]in teacher preparation, teacher support,
[00:02:06.510]with this kind of acknowledgement that the things
[00:02:08.700]that we ask teachers to do are almost impossible.
[00:02:12.070]This ideal teacher that we create in our heads
[00:02:15.760]that should be able to easily juggle everything,
[00:02:17.940]they're always happy with what they do,
[00:02:20.860]is really difficult to achieve, I think.
[00:02:25.120]You think about the daily practice of a teacher.
[00:02:26.670]Think about your daily practice, right?
[00:02:29.000]There's so much involved.
[00:02:30.520]You've got to teach a standards-based curriculum,
[00:02:32.400]make sure kids demonstrate progress in that curriculum.
[00:02:35.120]You've got to find time to plan that.
[00:02:37.270]You have to manage behavior, and for us, working with kids
[00:02:39.990]with pretty extensive behavioral support needs,
[00:02:43.480]some days when that kid comes in,
[00:02:45.640]everything else is off the table.
[00:02:46.960]We're just focusing, juggling that one ball, that student,
[00:02:50.370]right, while the rest of the balls have fallen to the floor.
[00:02:54.200]We're sometimes planning school functions.
[00:02:56.300]Sometimes we're expected to attend school functions.
[00:02:58.750]Sometimes we're expected
[00:03:00.200]to get our students access to those functions.
[00:03:03.110]So I remember my second year as a middle school teacher,
[00:03:05.349](laughs) big awakening
[00:03:07.340]when our principal had a school lock-in.
[00:03:10.410]So it was a unique experience to have hundreds
[00:03:12.830]of middle school students locked in together overnight
[00:03:15.930]but a part of that process is
[00:03:17.690]I had three of my students come with me
[00:03:19.220]and I supported them and made sure they had interactions
[00:03:22.270]and were able to hang out with their peers
[00:03:23.600]during that time.
[00:03:26.170]Adjusting instruction to data,
[00:03:27.680]so the whole data collection process, collecting it,
[00:03:30.550]looking at it, rethinking our teaching decisions
[00:03:33.550]based on those data, graphing data,
[00:03:36.070]all those things take a lot of time.
[00:03:38.630]Not only do we have to teach the core curriculum
[00:03:40.570]but we've got to teach those essential skills
[00:03:43.010]that sometimes are as important or more important
[00:03:46.630]than what we're teaching with our grade-aligned curricula.
[00:03:49.310]So communication skills, self-determination, advocacy,
[00:03:52.060]all those things are really important.
[00:03:54.690]But to find time to make sure we're engaged in instruction
[00:03:57.543]throughout the day and that our students are not, you know,
[00:03:59.970]they're not wasting their time in our program,
[00:04:01.740]that they're actually engaged in activities
[00:04:03.500]that will build their skills.
[00:04:05.440]Evaluating data, adapting curriculum,
[00:04:07.860]supporting our students in least restrictive environments,
[00:04:10.690]training staff, that's a whole nother job
[00:04:13.770]of supervising our paraprofessionals, working with them,
[00:04:16.050]listening to them, support and make sure
[00:04:17.240]they have supports and plans.
[00:04:20.697]Managing parent interactions.
[00:04:22.500]So listening to parents, communicating with parents,
[00:04:25.870]and we're expected to train parents
[00:04:27.720]and help parents implement things at home.
[00:04:30.560]It's a lot of responsibilities
[00:04:31.750]in our teacher education backpack, right?
[00:04:34.857]And then finally some of our teachers spend hours a day
[00:04:37.450]managing the medical needs of students.
[00:04:39.600]So their demands are immense
[00:04:41.377]and I think it's important for us to acknowledge that.
[00:04:43.160]And I think it's also important for us to acknowledge
[00:04:45.700]that I think that it's probably a contributing factor
[00:04:49.560]to several issues, one being
[00:04:51.110]that teachers leave the field pretty quickly.
[00:04:53.400]So we see high turnover rates and it becomes very difficult
[00:04:56.220]for districts and other entities to find teachers
[00:05:01.320]so we reduce the restrictions
[00:05:03.340]or the requirements for teachers to get in.
[00:05:05.310]We hope that we're gonna support them
[00:05:06.510]when they're in there and grow them.
[00:05:07.777]That doesn't always work.
[00:05:10.090]Sometimes I've seen some great lateral entry folks
[00:05:12.410]that have been spectacular
[00:05:14.050]but other times I've seen them really fall down.
[00:05:16.440]We see consistently poor outcomes
[00:05:18.240]in many areas for our students,
[00:05:19.930]not just our students with extensive support needs
[00:05:21.870]but a lot of students, we look at some of our national data.
[00:05:24.550]I do write into research and a lot of our individuals,
[00:05:27.630]you're looking at not even meeting proficiency
[00:05:29.520]in the area of writing, for example.
[00:05:31.838]We look at our students with extensive support needs
[00:05:33.720]and still post-secondary outcomes are pretty abysmal
[00:05:36.890]for many of them.
[00:05:38.040]They're having a hard time obtaining employment,
[00:05:41.730]post-secondary educational opportunities, independence
[00:05:47.170]and so again, I think that speaks
[00:05:49.780]to what we're doing at schools in preparing these folks.
[00:05:53.810]It's one of the factors for sure.
[00:05:55.590]We see students in classrooms that are not engaged.
[00:05:58.090]We see some of our teachers having difficulties
[00:06:00.810]addressing challenging behavior,
[00:06:02.160]especially those more severe ones.
[00:06:04.940]We see students with poor communication repertoires.
[00:06:07.680]And then we see kind of mass inequity, right?
[00:06:10.170]There are researchers
[00:06:11.160]that are just taking observational data
[00:06:13.110]and describing what's happening in schools
[00:06:14.337]and these data seem to reflect that, for instance,
[00:06:17.180]kids of color receive more negative feedback
[00:06:20.810]than their white counterparts.
[00:06:23.720]We drill down to kind of our population, right?
[00:06:25.930]We're talking students with extensive support needs.
[00:06:29.079]All the data seemed to suggest that kids are spending
[00:06:32.410]a lot of time sitting and listening,
[00:06:35.470]passively engaged in instruction, which, you know,
[00:06:38.679]it doesn't often work for our students.
[00:06:42.300]They need opportunities to practice,
[00:06:43.710]get feedback, repetition.
[00:06:47.060]Consistently data seemed to suggest that our students
[00:06:49.826]don't have the communication supports they need.
[00:06:52.890]So they're either not receiving communication instruction
[00:06:55.543]or if they have a speech-generating device,
[00:06:57.870]picture-based system, it's not around them.
[00:07:00.040]And then in some instances we are seeing
[00:07:02.250]that teachers will implement practices
[00:07:04.450]that are a contraindicator and sometimes harmful.
[00:07:07.290]And I don't think any teacher says I'm gonna go in
[00:07:09.240]and use harmful practices, but these things happen.
[00:07:13.140]Sometimes they're led astray.
[00:07:14.807]They've been given poor guidance.
[00:07:17.000]We didn't prepare them adequately in their prep program
[00:07:19.320]which I'll talk about in a second.
[00:07:21.140]But the fact is that it's happening.
[00:07:25.250]So how do we get there?
[00:07:26.700]So I always joke and say that, it's not, I don't joke,
[00:07:30.480]I say to my undergraduate students and I say, all right,
[00:07:32.870]how many guys are gonna be the awesome teacher?
[00:07:35.170]They all raise their hand and we (clapping) clap
[00:07:37.880]and give them high fives and say, nice job,
[00:07:40.740]and then I say, but you know, I'm a little worried
[00:07:42.520]because when I go out into classrooms,
[00:07:46.634]and I see hundreds of classrooms at this point,
[00:07:49.300]I say to them, I say to students, I say, well,
[00:07:51.660]there's really a small set of teachers
[00:07:53.163]that are just, really just incredible.
[00:07:56.100]And then there's this big middle group of folks
[00:07:58.990]that are struggling.
[00:08:00.980]Sometimes they're mediocre, right,
[00:08:02.700]but they're just trying to get it all done.
[00:08:05.060]And then there's a few teachers
[00:08:06.080]that are really doing a poor job.
[00:08:08.020]And so if you guys are representative of that group,
[00:08:10.170]it just means that maybe not all of you are gonna be awesome
[00:08:13.920]and their little faces kind of drain
[00:08:15.898]and then we talk about, well,
[00:08:17.310]here's what you can do about it.
[00:08:19.430]But the idea is that that speaks, I think,
[00:08:22.710]sometimes to the disconnect between this ideal world
[00:08:25.837]we prepare folks in teacher ed, right,
[00:08:29.140]to what really is out there in the classroom.
[00:08:31.810]So teacher preparation I think is a component
[00:08:34.710]of why folks, some of our educators need more assistance
[00:08:39.300]and not always the case
[00:08:40.440]but if you look at teacher preparation programs,
[00:08:43.660]curricula are vast, so I was duly certified
[00:08:47.200]so I had to learn, you know,
[00:08:48.800]all children's literature classes,
[00:08:51.020]I had to learn basically general education pedagogy
[00:08:55.090]and then special education on top of it.
[00:08:57.000]And my special education early in the '90s,
[00:08:59.460]it wasn't very detailed.
[00:09:01.090]I took a class on how kids get mental retardation.
[00:09:04.080]You know, I took a class, kind of a practicum
[00:09:06.210]where we did a couple of projects around kids
[00:09:08.680]with severe disabilities and then that was it.
[00:09:10.595]Everything else was either focused
[00:09:12.120]on kids without disabilities
[00:09:14.030]or our kids with high incidence disabilities.
[00:09:16.500]Somehow luckily I got support in my program
[00:09:19.200]and got more education but I think that's probably,
[00:09:23.507]from my perspective or my experiences working
[00:09:26.390]with other teacher prep programs, this hasn't changed.
[00:09:29.840]There's still a lot of variability
[00:09:31.550]in the quality of programs, the types of things
[00:09:33.430]that teacher candidates experience.
[00:09:37.250]Recently we did a survey
[00:09:38.527]and one of our teacher educators
[00:09:41.388]and one teacher educator said
[00:09:42.980]that she was still training folks
[00:09:44.540]to implement facilitated communication
[00:09:48.470]which has been completely debunked, right?
[00:09:51.000]And all the professional organizations say don't use it
[00:09:54.127]but this was still within their curriculum.
[00:09:56.620]So there's a lot of problems that way.
[00:09:58.950]I think something else that I recognize
[00:10:01.730]and this, maybe, I don't know,
[00:10:03.940]a decade ago, this kinda came to me.
[00:10:05.520]I went out and saw a teacher that I had trained.
[00:10:09.150]I've been a part of their training
[00:10:10.680]and then they weren't doing what they were trained to do.
[00:10:14.833]And I think many of us as teacher educators
[00:10:16.570]have gotten out there and been like, what's going on?
[00:10:19.030]This is not what you're supposed to be doing.
[00:10:20.673]This is not what you received in the program.
[00:10:22.930]And then I thought about it a little bit more
[00:10:24.757]and realized that it's very likely
[00:10:27.960]that most teacher prep programs don't get teachers
[00:10:31.610]up to acquisition on skills.
[00:10:34.030]So I teach courses, right,
[00:10:35.750]and they'll have a big assignment
[00:10:37.950]and they, you know, you're graded on that assignment,
[00:10:40.210]you do a good job, lots of support and models, right?
[00:10:43.650]And so that one assignment is one data point, right?
[00:10:48.340]So you've been able to do it once.
[00:10:49.277]You got an A on it and you passed on to the next course.
[00:10:52.030]How many data points do we need to show stability?
[00:10:55.430]Well, at least three, right?
[00:10:56.360]So they should have to do that assignment three times,
[00:10:59.540]right, for us to even have a sense
[00:11:01.000]of maybe they've acquired it
[00:11:02.650]before we consider that they have to generalize it,
[00:11:06.450]maintain it, basically go out and use it
[00:11:09.020]in the real life environment.
[00:11:11.930]Also sometimes supervision is limited.
[00:11:13.920]So a lot of my teacher prep programs, you know,
[00:11:15.110]we'd go out and observe them four times in a semester.
[00:11:18.090]You know, they got the plan and we rely a lot of supervision
[00:11:21.409]on their classroom teacher who may not have experience
[00:11:25.070]in supervision or may just, you know,
[00:11:27.000]be in the young teachers' corner.
[00:11:29.980]And so there's often missed opportunities
[00:11:33.280]for us to really see what's happening,
[00:11:36.370]to really provide lots of support and guidance
[00:11:39.220]to help teachers acquire those skills
[00:11:41.010]that were taught to them in their programs.
[00:11:43.961]And then we're seeing across the country
[00:11:45.230]fewer incentives for graduate work.
[00:11:47.500]So honestly most of my best training came
[00:11:49.980]from my master's program and my most focused training
[00:11:53.180]on behavior intervention and working with kids
[00:11:54.890]with developmental disabilities and autism and, you know,
[00:11:58.160]many states now have kind of removed incentives
[00:12:01.210]for people to get a master's degree
[00:12:03.820]and most states have removed the requirement
[00:12:05.279]that you have to.
[00:12:06.800]At one point, lots of states required
[00:12:08.540]that you had to go on and get a master's degree
[00:12:12.041]and that requirement's been removed.
[00:12:18.550]I just want to show you a quick example.
[00:12:20.086]I referred to it a minute ago,
[00:12:22.040]a couple of the quality of programming out there.
[00:12:25.590]So I'm also really interested
[00:12:26.550]in communication supports for students.
[00:12:28.090]So we surveyed teacher education programs
[00:12:31.183]and kind of asked them what they were doing
[00:12:32.980]in terms of preparing their educators
[00:12:34.910]and in the area of communication supports,
[00:12:37.202]and as you would suggest, there was a lot of variability.
[00:12:40.960]There are some programs that don't offer full courses
[00:12:44.330]and communication supports.
[00:12:45.630]Usually it's kind of smattered throughout their program.
[00:12:49.210]Teacher educators themselves thought
[00:12:51.320]that 33% of their undergraduates
[00:12:53.260]and 16% of their graduate students
[00:12:54.990]were not adequately prepared.
[00:12:58.510]There was a focus on behavioral interventions which is good
[00:13:01.462]because that's a lot of evidence-based practice.
[00:13:04.160]But basically most of, there was more of an emphasis
[00:13:07.100]on knowledge than actual practice in it.
[00:13:09.100]So they read about it in their textbooks.
[00:13:10.410]They'd heard about it in a lecture
[00:13:11.810]but they wouldn't actually get a chance
[00:13:13.679]to go out and practice it.
[00:13:16.550]So I guess pulling this all together is this idea
[00:13:20.030]that our teacher preparation programs here
[00:13:24.340]on the left, right, are probably really different
[00:13:27.060]than the real world.
[00:13:28.420]So you've got these contrasting contexts.
[00:13:31.290]So the teacher prep program,
[00:13:32.750]you're getting some direct instruction.
[00:13:34.330]We're telling you what to do.
[00:13:36.340]If we're doing a good job, we're letting you practice.
[00:13:40.440]There's instructor feedback so you turn assignments in.
[00:13:43.200]We'd say, yes, you know, we give you feedback
[00:13:45.570]or correct, incorrect, we have you revise it.
[00:13:48.500]There's some clear contingencies for getting things done.
[00:13:51.690]Like, they have to get done, or, you know,
[00:13:53.350]it's, read the syllabus, right?
[00:13:56.075]And then we have these kind of controlled set up classrooms.
[00:13:59.350]So you're practicing in a simulated environment,
[00:14:04.400]in a classroom and you're at your university,
[00:14:07.410]or you're in a practicum classroom
[00:14:10.756]with a experienced teacher that already has
[00:14:13.320]a lot of behavior management under control
[00:14:16.880]and then that's what they learn.
[00:14:18.393]Those are the conditions under which our educators
[00:14:20.830]or you might've learned.
[00:14:22.540]And then you go to the real life and, well, guess what,
[00:14:26.870]you're supposed to learn a lot of the things
[00:14:28.396]that you don't know kind of on your own.
[00:14:29.760]You have to go out and seek resources often.
[00:14:33.160]There's some peer feedback opportunities
[00:14:35.050]that are there, but that might be it.
[00:14:37.920]There's competing natural contingencies.
[00:14:39.760]So now not only do you have to implement
[00:14:43.523]or we expect you to implement the things trained
[00:14:45.850]in your program, but suddenly you've got parents' pressure
[00:14:49.690]that you didn't have before, administrator pressure,
[00:14:53.320]that one challenging student
[00:14:55.030]that if you don't meet his needs, your day's ruined
[00:14:58.970]even if it means not teaching other kids, right?
[00:15:02.666]And then there's all sorts of, like I said,
[00:15:04.140]there's all sorts of crazy challenging behavior
[00:15:05.680]that pops up so the worlds are very different,
[00:15:08.166]I think, that we paint in our teacher prep programs
[00:15:11.100]and then what's out in the classroom.
[00:15:14.007]And as a result, I think a lot of our new teachers
[00:15:17.550]and sometimes our experienced teachers, they crash, right?
[00:15:21.530]They don't make the leap between this program
[00:15:25.690]we train them to teach in, right?
[00:15:28.230]And then what really they're expected to do
[00:15:31.750]and so, and when they crash, parents, students,
[00:15:36.140]you know, they also suffer.
[00:15:37.720]So the teacher suffers and the students suffer.
[00:15:41.480]Sometimes they get in there and they're okay, right?
[00:15:45.387]But over time they kind of fade to mediocrity
[00:15:49.670]because the environment doesn't ask a lot more from them.
[00:15:53.060]So how many, so I'm sure there are people watching today
[00:15:59.603]that could probably do most of, you know,
[00:16:03.590]could teach all day long
[00:16:07.652]and unless a parent calls the administrator,
[00:16:12.370]there's just, you know, there's no,
[00:16:15.459]nobody cares what you're doing as long as kids are safe,
[00:16:21.690]parents aren't complaining,
[00:16:23.620]you're providing some sort of data.
[00:16:25.600]I mean, people, you care obviously
[00:16:27.980]but there's not strong contingencies
[00:16:29.930]for you to use specific practices
[00:16:31.940]or do something with a certain level of criteria.
[00:16:34.680]Basically a lot of our teachers
[00:16:35.870]I think sometimes contact environments
[00:16:37.640]where there's no interaction with anyone else
[00:16:39.670]and so as a result, they respond
[00:16:41.940]to what their classroom requires them to do.
[00:16:44.950]So for example, they've got a couple kids
[00:16:46.720]with extreme behavior support needs.
[00:16:49.330]And so to keep everyone safe, then they may use
[00:16:53.790]some intensive practice with these students
[00:16:55.690]that lead to other students working a lot
[00:16:57.550]on, like, independent work tasks
[00:16:59.060]where they're not learning skills, right?
[00:17:01.180]So basically your environment sometimes shapes
[00:17:04.697]the teacher that you become.
[00:17:06.760]And when there's not other people interacting
[00:17:09.310]with those environments, really the major driver
[00:17:12.570]is what's happening in your classroom.
[00:17:17.264]So teachers often receive very few reinforcers
[00:17:21.280]for effective teaching behavior.
[00:17:23.730]And we'll talk, there are some, right?
[00:17:25.210]So making student progress,
[00:17:26.370]all those things are really important,
[00:17:28.200]but just, you know, for instance, praise,
[00:17:31.540]how natural is praise?
[00:17:33.690]It's weird, right?
[00:17:34.710]I mean, we're supposed to give it to kids
[00:17:36.060]but in your daily life do you walk around and go,
[00:17:38.720]good job, honey, I love the way you, you know, wash the car.
[00:17:42.756]No, you don't.
[00:17:44.490]And so you're expected to engage in these behaviors
[00:17:47.170]to which there's no immediate reinforcer,
[00:17:49.570]a consequence for it to happen.
[00:17:51.090]So you have to kind of be better,
[00:17:53.530]you have to work beyond the science of human behavior
[00:17:59.700]which sometimes it's not realistic.
[00:18:02.950]So you go out, you know,
[00:18:04.150]maybe you know what you're supposed to do.
[00:18:05.780]You try them a few times your first years teaching.
[00:18:08.560]You get no feedback, it doesn't work immediately
[00:18:10.540]so your behaviors are put on extinction,
[00:18:12.740]means they get no reinforcers
[00:18:14.415]and then over time they start fading
[00:18:17.470]and then maybe something else happens.
[00:18:19.780]So, you know, you're exhausted.
[00:18:22.250]I've seen a lot of these recently.
[00:18:23.650]I've seen teach by YouTube where it's just constantly,
[00:18:26.820]kids are spending, you know, up to an hour,
[00:18:29.180]hour and a half watching YouTube videos
[00:18:32.440]that require very little interaction.
[00:18:34.560]Their teacher's like, okay, morning meeting.
[00:18:36.319](blows raspberry) YouTube is on and they're exhausted
[00:18:40.870]and they can do other things
[00:18:42.030]while the kids are watching YouTube.
[00:18:43.570]And so those behaviors become established in the classroom
[00:18:47.760]even though they're probably not very effective, right?
[00:18:51.070]But because they provide opportunities
[00:18:53.590]for teachers to do other things, kids generally enjoy it.
[00:18:56.710]So maybe they're not engaged in problem behavior.
[00:18:58.620]Other contentions come into play that kind of trap
[00:19:01.800]these ineffective practices in our classrooms.
[00:19:06.570]And sometimes we're led less astray or led astray
[00:19:09.610]by less trained and more experienced colleagues.
[00:19:11.900]I'll give you a great example.
[00:19:12.733]So one time I was working, my first year of teaching,
[00:19:15.450]I had a young man who was really one of my favorites.
[00:19:19.380]I still keep in contact with them via the Facebooks.
[00:19:23.420]But when he was young,
[00:19:24.300]he engaged in a lot of problem behavior.
[00:19:26.920]So he would go down the hallways and preach the Bible.
[00:19:29.310]He could tell you almost every verse of the Bible
[00:19:32.870]but then he would also switch and say,
[00:19:34.327]"I'm Wesley Snipes, you mother,"
[00:19:36.150]and just starts swinging at people, right?
[00:19:39.230]Biting his hand and going down the hall.
[00:19:40.820]And one day a paraprofessional grabbed me
[00:19:42.270]who had some experience with this student before.
[00:19:45.480]And she said, "Mr. Rob, let me show you what I do with him."
[00:19:47.660]I said, "Okay."
[00:19:48.820]So she grabbed his hands and pushed them against the wall
[00:19:51.010]and then looked at him and said, "Don't do that again."
[00:19:52.860]And immediately I said, "No, no, stop,"
[00:19:54.820]you know, I interrupt, I said, "That's fine,
[00:19:55.960]I'm gonna take care of it, please,
[00:19:57.210]you know, let me handle the student's issues."
[00:20:01.117]But the idea is that sometimes we get bad advice
[00:20:03.880]from other folks and certainly I knew better that,
[00:20:06.713]at least I had enough training to say that this use
[00:20:09.770]of these kinds of punishment borderline abusive practices,
[00:20:12.728]we shouldn't engage in these.
[00:20:16.160]But it happens all the time.
[00:20:17.570]Another example recently is we had a,
[00:20:19.340]not recently, about five or six years ago,
[00:20:21.100]I remember a paraprofessional had taught a peer tutor
[00:20:25.595]or had attempted to teach a peer tutor
[00:20:27.100]how to pinch a student so that it wouldn't leave a mark
[00:20:30.050]when he grabbed her, pulled her clothes.
[00:20:32.840]Fortunately that peer tutor had a conscience and was worried
[00:20:36.090]and came back and told the educator
[00:20:37.980]and then, and that situation was corrected,
[00:20:41.300]but these things happen all the time
[00:20:42.910]and so again, we wanna make sure that, you know,
[00:20:46.070]we have enough supports place to kind of help filter it
[00:20:49.170]and capture when those things happen.
[00:20:52.360]So maybe because of our training,
[00:20:55.560]maybe because our environment has kind of shaped us,
[00:20:58.230]we kind of feel stuck sometimes, right?
[00:21:00.180]All of us, so ever if you're here
[00:21:02.640]and you have been presenting or teaching for 20 years,
[00:21:06.200]you might get to that place of like, oh, I just,
[00:21:09.750]I'm still doing the same thing over and over again
[00:21:11.770]and I need to do better.
[00:21:14.570]And I would argue we all need to do better.
[00:21:16.780]And there's different points in our career
[00:21:18.140]where we get momentum, you know,
[00:21:19.890]and honestly those usually happen
[00:21:21.980]when there's a little bit of a change, right?
[00:21:23.300]When our environment changes, it requires more of us.
[00:21:27.910]So, but when we do feel stuck, you know,
[00:21:29.950]kind of what do we do?
[00:21:31.010]Well, sometimes we look to in-service trainings
[00:21:33.030]and despite the data suggested,
[00:21:35.130]there are some effective models out there, right,
[00:21:37.760]of training, of teacher training.
[00:21:39.750]We often rely on these kinds of broad PD events
[00:21:43.400]kind of like this one, so hence the picture
[00:21:45.610]of Alanis Morissette, isn't that ironic?
[00:21:48.950]But the idea is that they're often broad.
[00:21:51.647]They're not individualized necessarily
[00:21:53.660]to a specific teacher's needs or contexts
[00:21:57.120]and there's usually not follow-up.
[00:21:59.840]Sometimes it's out of context.
[00:22:01.110]So again, I'm gonna train you,
[00:22:05.763]outside of your classroom in this, you know,
[00:22:08.970]gym or this professional training area
[00:22:12.050]or in this virtual environment,
[00:22:14.340]and you don't get an opportunity to actually see it
[00:22:16.820]in action within the context of your environment,
[00:22:20.310]the stimuli, the occurrences, the schedule,
[00:22:22.830]you don't get to see it in practice
[00:22:24.430]and so therefore it's hard to kind of make that loop.
[00:22:27.290]Sometimes it's not evidence-based.
[00:22:28.800]And so I won't say this happens a lot but maybe it does
[00:22:31.800]but I'll see districts that will be really excited
[00:22:34.080]about a speaker or a presenter
[00:22:37.500]and they will bring in some information
[00:22:40.960]to the district to train their teachers on maybe a practice
[00:22:44.020]that just doesn't really have the solid research support
[00:22:47.470]for us to be disseminated widely.
[00:22:51.180]Maybe then some of our teachers say, you know,
[00:22:52.847]I'm gonna turn to the research.
[00:22:55.210]And maybe some of our teachers
[00:22:56.220]that are in graduate programs are gonna say, ha,
[00:22:58.730]I'm gonna go to my university library
[00:23:01.720]and access those articles.
[00:23:04.210]The reality is that oftentimes people don't have access
[00:23:08.010]to those articles and literature.
[00:23:09.310]Sometimes they're written in a way full of jargon
[00:23:11.430]that they're not accessible
[00:23:12.520]even if somebody can download the articles.
[00:23:15.080]And sometimes the literature is not helpful.
[00:23:16.810]Here's an example, recently we did a review
[00:23:19.270]that I think will be coming out this year
[00:23:20.890]in education training and autism
[00:23:22.530]and developmental disabilities
[00:23:23.363]and we're looking at requesting all the strategies
[00:23:25.980]that teachers are requesting in school settings.
[00:23:28.390]You know, and first of all, most of them are published
[00:23:30.470]in very non-special-education journals,
[00:23:33.090]so ABA or disability-specific journals.
[00:23:37.254]A lot of them were implemented
[00:23:39.096]in very restrictive controlled settings.
[00:23:40.200]So if you want to implement this
[00:23:41.860]in a more naturalistic setting
[00:23:43.500]or in a general education setting,
[00:23:46.120]the studies may not provide you as useful information.
[00:23:50.130]And probably most importantly,
[00:23:51.270]most of the studies were implemented under supervision
[00:23:54.310]or direct implementation by a researcher,
[00:23:57.120]somebody with a lot of training,
[00:23:58.330]with supports to make sure fidelity is there.
[00:24:00.750]And that's not really what it looks like in a classroom.
[00:24:04.260]Yes, these studies were,
[00:24:07.371]they were affective in terms of demonstrated change
[00:24:10.990]but were are they implementable in the classroom?
[00:24:13.970]And so we don't know.
[00:24:17.670]So I guess the moral of the story so far is this idea
[00:24:21.100]that no matter who you are,
[00:24:23.410]the school environment will shape our behavior.
[00:24:25.650]It can shape us in good directions
[00:24:27.080]and directions that we again would not be proud of.
[00:24:29.960]I recently had a conversation with a colleague,
[00:24:32.010]a very talented colleague, who's very excited
[00:24:33.990]because she might be, she's interested in working
[00:24:36.680]in a self-contained school, maybe leading that school.
[00:24:39.400]And my advice to her was, hey,
[00:24:43.340]you make sure you have good people around you
[00:24:45.340]that are honest and that will communicate with you
[00:24:48.180]because no matter how good you are,
[00:24:50.220]I know that you have research expertise.
[00:24:52.300]I know that your heart is in the right place.
[00:24:54.850]If you go into a school where the staff, you know,
[00:24:58.733]have a strong kind of institutionalized culture,
[00:25:02.360]maybe use restraints, use ineffective procedures
[00:25:06.530]or many of them do potentially,
[00:25:08.910]you have kids with severe behaviors, right?
[00:25:12.460]All those things, that complex environment will shape you
[00:25:16.930]and so you want people to be honest and be able to tell you,
[00:25:20.410]hey, we're steering away from what the evidence says.
[00:25:24.110]We're steering away from where we need to be going.
[00:25:26.120]So again, making sure that,
[00:25:28.730]my advice to her was basically create an environment
[00:25:30.810]around her to help protect, right,
[00:25:34.580]to soften those impending effects of a very complex school.
[00:25:42.780]So what are we gonna do about it?
[00:25:44.540]So we talked about, so in this last slide
[00:25:46.470]I said shaping teacher behavior.
[00:25:49.240]For the rest of today I'm gonna ask you
[00:25:50.880]to think about what does that mean?
[00:25:54.510]So what does it mean for,
[00:25:56.948]what, excuse me,
[00:25:59.700]what does it mean to behave as a teacher?
[00:26:02.700]So we look at our students, right,
[00:26:04.220]we say, well, Johnny engaged in a problem behavior.
[00:26:07.480]There was this antecedent.
[00:26:09.830]It resulted in some outcome for him.
[00:26:12.590]Maybe a student responded incorrectly, maybe, oh,
[00:26:15.770]so therefore our prompt was inaccurate, or,
[00:26:19.620]but I'm asking you now to look at your own behavior
[00:26:22.840]within that environmental context.
[00:26:27.130]So teachers behave all the time.
[00:26:29.430]We plan. We have planning behaviors.
[00:26:31.360]We have specific teaching behaviors,
[00:26:33.040]the delivery of a prompt, delivery of an instructional cue,
[00:26:35.910]application reinforcement, we interact with students
[00:26:38.270]in multiple ways, we respond to students' behavior.
[00:26:40.630]These are all ways that we behave.
[00:26:43.730]So again, taking the characteristic out of teaching
[00:26:50.180]but really looking at what behaviors do we emit,
[00:26:54.115]you know, under what conditions do they emit,
[00:26:56.800]how frequently we emit them.
[00:26:59.740]It's also, I want you to acknowledge the idea
[00:27:02.330]that your behavior is affected by your environment.
[00:27:05.190]So the things that work for you are there
[00:27:09.060]because they've worked in the past.
[00:27:11.020]And again, sometimes that puts us in good places
[00:27:13.340]and sometimes not so helpful places.
[00:27:17.640]The next thing I want you to think about, and again,
[00:27:20.190]will kind of lead us through the rest, next hour and a half,
[00:27:22.610]is this idea that if we're gonna change our own behavior,
[00:27:27.590]if we're gonna improve our practice,
[00:27:29.990]it may not just be enough that you're like,
[00:27:32.240]that you've got that oomph, that I'm gonna do this, right?
[00:27:35.420]You might need to change your environment
[00:27:38.600]to be able to make sure that happens,
[00:27:40.275]that you engage in that behavior
[00:27:43.383]and then that behavior continues over time.
[00:27:46.370]And then finally, and this is really important,
[00:27:48.840]I mean, I learned this probably over 15 years ago.
[00:27:53.540]So my, you know, the first time I was asked
[00:27:55.530]to come out to a classroom to support teachers,
[00:27:57.260]I had all sorts of, you know, descriptors for teachers
[00:28:00.080]that wouldn't do what I asked them to do, right? (laughs)
[00:28:03.430]And what I realized is it's not their fault.
[00:28:05.750]I would never say that to a kid.
[00:28:07.352]You don't want to learn.
[00:28:08.290]You don't want to change your behavior, right?
[00:28:10.220]I would just do something about it.
[00:28:11.850]I would make sure that I provided good instruction,
[00:28:15.220]that there was powerful reinforcers
[00:28:17.280]for engaging in targeted behaviors.
[00:28:19.800]I would basically plan the environment
[00:28:21.690]so these individuals have success.
[00:28:23.750]So the fact is that there is not a,
[00:28:26.192]teachers are expected to have a repertoire
[00:28:29.510]that they emit under certain conditions, right?
[00:28:31.550]Skills, behaviors.
[00:28:33.550]And sometimes they don't have those skills, right?
[00:28:35.890]And so, and therefore it's either a instructional issue
[00:28:39.420]where they don't have, they just don't have the skills,
[00:28:42.230]that's why they're not emitting them,
[00:28:44.100]or they don't produce an observed outcome.
[00:28:46.740]So part of us as maybe an interventionist
[00:28:49.780]might be helping teachers understand the effects
[00:28:53.000]of their behavior on their environment.
[00:28:56.050]So again, this idea for the rest of the day,
[00:28:58.110]there's no bad teachers.
[00:29:00.070]There's no lazy teacher.
[00:29:01.290]There's no teachers that we just need to put out to pasture.
[00:29:05.180]I've heard all those things before
[00:29:07.030]but our idea is to say we've got this person
[00:29:09.010]in the classroom, they're committed to be here.
[00:29:11.590]How can we help them improve their practice?
[00:29:14.130]Or if I'm speaking to you teachers watching this,
[00:29:16.720]how can you engage in a process
[00:29:19.810]through every year you're strengthening your program?
[00:29:23.120]And I promise that'll be much more rewarding
[00:29:25.000]than kind of getting stuck in kind of teaching doldrums.
[00:29:29.770]So again, think about your behavior in the context of,
[00:29:33.230]the environment signals you to do things all the time.
[00:29:36.020]A kid's late and you walk over to them
[00:29:37.780]and ask them why they were late.
[00:29:39.590]A kid doesn't respond or does respond
[00:29:42.230]on an instructional task.
[00:29:43.290]You provide corrective or positive feedback, right.
[00:29:45.920]And then what are those variables
[00:29:47.490]that maintain that responding?
[00:29:48.990]So antecedent behavior consequence, good old ABA 101, right?
[00:29:53.200]So let's think about that.
[00:29:54.033]So are all the things that we ask about
[00:29:56.270]are these antecedent stimuli,
[00:29:58.310]these events that trigger teacher behavior.
[00:29:59.960]It could be other staff behavior
[00:30:02.430]or the way our students behave
[00:30:04.350]or schedule changes or the instructional materials
[00:30:08.100]throughout the day that we've set up.
[00:30:10.810]But more complex,
[00:30:12.570]what do you think maintains those behaviors?
[00:30:15.210]So what do teachers do?
[00:30:16.620]How do they behave and what did they get
[00:30:19.100]from behaving certain ways?
[00:30:21.210]And right now let's just focus on strong teacher behavior.
[00:30:24.360]So when you're doing something good in your classroom,
[00:30:26.920]why are you doing it?
[00:30:28.770]What do you get out of it?
[00:30:30.280]And let's look at some, I want you to think for a minute
[00:30:33.210]just do a little brainstorming by yourself, right? (laughs)
[00:30:40.270]What do you get out of your best teaching practices?
[00:30:49.640]All right, let's see.
[00:30:51.870]So maybe it's student progress.
[00:30:53.210]And usually when I do this as a workshop
[00:30:54.920]and we sometimes run this as a whole day workshop,
[00:30:58.910]I'll ask teachers, I'll say, "Why are you doing this?"
[00:31:01.917]And it's always for the kids, right?
[00:31:03.980]For student progress. I do this and kids make progress.
[00:31:06.887]And I would agree that's a powerful reinforcer
[00:31:09.210]for teacher behavior.
[00:31:10.940]The challenge is that not for all teacher behaviors
[00:31:14.300]or very specific teacher behaviors,
[00:31:19.560]because sometimes teachers are not collecting data, right?
[00:31:23.010]So they don't see that, oh, wow,
[00:31:24.920]today he got an 80% over a 40% the day before.
[00:31:28.250]That really reinforced my use
[00:31:30.090]of these good teaching practices.
[00:31:33.300]Sometimes we're working with students,
[00:31:34.640]they don't respond, right?
[00:31:36.260]They have very low levels of responding
[00:31:38.330]and so we're not getting intensity of feedback.
[00:31:43.760]Again, that can also strengthen it.
[00:31:44.593]So when they do respond, you're like, yes,
[00:31:47.710]but here's another thing to think about.
[00:31:49.350]If teachers, if all of us were only out in the world
[00:31:53.610]to do right by kids and we only used those practices
[00:32:00.653]that were working, we wouldn't see teachers out there
[00:32:06.920]using practices that were not effective, right?
[00:32:09.200]'Cause they wouldn't be reinforcing it
[00:32:10.297]and would only select those practices
[00:32:12.880]to which produce outcomes.
[00:32:15.060]Basically the other behaviors, the poor teaching behaviors
[00:32:18.010]that weren't working would be put on extinction
[00:32:19.800]so we would see less of those.
[00:32:21.320]So there's gotta be some other mediating factors.
[00:32:23.980]So compensation, yeah, it's important.
[00:32:26.460]We all want to work. We want a better raise.
[00:32:29.180]Sometimes we switch districts 'cause one pays more
[00:32:31.340]'cause we've got to take care of our families.
[00:32:33.270]But the fact is that compensation
[00:32:34.770]doesn't reinforce particular behaviors really, right?
[00:32:37.530]So you, most of us could do a pretty mediocre job
[00:32:41.040]and still get paid.
[00:32:42.320]Some of us could just keep showing up every day
[00:32:44.180]and make sure kids aren't hurt and still get paid.
[00:32:47.420]So the idea that compensation is important
[00:32:50.620]but they don't select,
[00:32:53.010]usually select particular teaching behaviors,
[00:32:55.980]one's over the other.
[00:32:57.910]Sometimes we do things that avoid problem behavior, right?
[00:33:00.020]So we might engage a particular practice
[00:33:02.670]because it reduces problem behavior.
[00:33:04.650]So I've seen some teachers stuck in a rut.
[00:33:06.730]A couple of years ago we saw a teacher that,
[00:33:08.293]we were working with a team that,
[00:33:11.031]a student that had some severe problem behavior
[00:33:14.250]spent multiple 30-minute periods a day in sanctuary time
[00:33:17.620]basically sitting on a vibrating back massager.
[00:33:21.570]And yes, the student didn't engage in problem behavior,
[00:33:26.650]but he wasn't learning anything either.
[00:33:28.190]And it was, you know, some kind of half-cocked idea
[00:33:31.680]that, you know, he was engaged in problem behavior
[00:33:35.650]'cause he was sensory deprived
[00:33:37.220]and if we just give them this,
[00:33:40.360]spend basically a third of his day engaged
[00:33:42.790]in these sensory activities, then somehow it will affect it.
[00:33:46.610]Guess what?
[00:33:47.443]When he was asked to work,
[00:33:48.300]he still engaged in those problem behaviors.
[00:33:50.020]The only time he wasn't engaged in problem behaviors
[00:33:52.960]was in the sanctuary period, which was,
[00:33:54.850]he also wasn't asked to work.
[00:33:56.180]So sometimes that drives us to make some poor decisions
[00:34:00.420]or not engage in the right correct teaching behaviors.
[00:34:05.840]Sometimes we do things to avoid due process.
[00:34:08.070]So I've seen lots, I've been involved in several of those.
[00:34:10.827]And so teachers will shape their practice
[00:34:13.350]to do everything to avoid going to court.
[00:34:15.670]It's a terrible place. I had to testify once.
[00:34:17.473]I was on the stand nine hours.
[00:34:19.470]Fortunately it was an amazing educational team,
[00:34:21.780]great teachers doing a wonderful job,
[00:34:24.460]but I've also been on the other side
[00:34:27.380]where people weren't doing what they needed to do.
[00:34:29.870]So that's for administrator feedback, you know,
[00:34:32.040]sometimes people care about what their boss says
[00:34:34.160]but usually I think that we recognize
[00:34:36.620]as teachers of students with extensive support needs
[00:34:38.720]that oftentimes our principals don't really know what we do.
[00:34:41.987]And so they're really happy that when we're teaching
[00:34:45.760]and they don't get calls from the parents.
[00:34:47.163]I remember I did an observation or I had a,
[00:34:50.320]maybe my first year of teaching, second year of teaching,
[00:34:52.950]my principal went out with me
[00:34:54.740]on a community-based instruction activity
[00:34:57.410]and afterwards she cried.
[00:34:58.580]She was like, you're just the best thing,
[00:35:01.420]you know, this is so great for you.
[00:35:02.990]You just love those kids.
[00:35:03.997]And she didn't know, she couldn't give me feedback
[00:35:06.300]on the efficacy of my teaching procedures.
[00:35:08.720]She just thought it was a good thing, you know?
[00:35:10.903]Many of us have been on the bus or been somewhere
[00:35:13.720]and people are like, God bless you for your work.
[00:35:16.280]And you're like, great, (laughs) you know,
[00:35:18.530]but really what you're like, oh,
[00:35:20.080]so you're saying you're glad somebody else is doing it
[00:35:21.707]and not you.
[00:35:24.613]But the point is that, yeah, it really depends
[00:35:26.770]whether or not we know
[00:35:29.330]that our administrator can give us useful feedback.
[00:35:32.050]Usually we're just trying to avoid their scrutiny
[00:35:34.340]or something that will affect our job overall.
[00:35:38.280]Parent feedback, of course.
[00:35:40.220]We love when our parents love what we're doing
[00:35:42.530]but often that's few and far between.
[00:35:44.910]We might engage in behaviors
[00:35:46.590]to avoid certain types of parent feedback.
[00:35:48.983]So that could be a reinforcer.
[00:35:52.020]But here's the one that I think is the most important.
[00:35:54.000]I think that you, I think that I care
[00:35:56.820]what our colleagues think about us.
[00:35:59.560]So if I came out to one of your classrooms
[00:36:02.682]and I said, hey, you know what?
[00:36:05.219]I think you could do better than this.
[00:36:07.040]You might think about it and you might say, sure,
[00:36:08.990]or you can be like, this guy doesn't know me, I don't care.
[00:36:12.440]But, and if you heard that I said
[00:36:15.180]that you weren't a good teacher,
[00:36:16.830]your feelings might be hurt a little bit
[00:36:18.210]but you'd be more annoyed
[00:36:19.080]and not invite me in your classroom.
[00:36:21.180]But what if you heard that your colleagues,
[00:36:24.340]that the people around you just thought
[00:36:26.040]you were the worst teacher in the building?
[00:36:28.540]That would break many teacher's hearts, right?
[00:36:31.120]So the idea is that we really care
[00:36:32.780]about what our professional community thinks about us.
[00:36:35.707]And so today we're gonna talk about some processes
[00:36:39.150]to go through to improve your practice
[00:36:40.670]but I'm gonna recommend that you do it
[00:36:42.210]side by side with some other colleagues,
[00:36:43.670]you're public about it, because they'll hold you accountable
[00:36:46.560]because you care about what they think.
[00:36:48.740]And the final thing I'd just kinda like to point out
[00:36:49.983]because I do a lot of consultation is consultant feedback.
[00:36:54.230]Sometimes a consultant, we think we're more important
[00:36:56.220]than we are, right, but usually we don't have a lot of power
[00:36:58.950]and we come in and we say, you need to do this.
[00:37:02.830]And at first, you know, teachers are excited
[00:37:04.897]and we say good job, but really,
[00:37:06.696]a lot of times the data suggests that over time,
[00:37:10.930]after the first couple sessions of us coaching,
[00:37:14.010]if we haven't planned systematically for fading out
[00:37:16.731]of our coaching, usually those behaviors,
[00:37:19.920]those teacher behaviors will often drift back down
[00:37:22.020]to original levels because at first they were novel,
[00:37:24.680]they care, they realize we don't really,
[00:37:28.750]maybe we lose our reinforcer effectiveness.
[00:37:31.490]And sometimes consultants are just aversive, right?
[00:37:33.894]The way, if we just come in, we intrude in classrooms,
[00:37:36.640]we interrupt or we're taking notes,
[00:37:39.610]we tell them what they need to do,
[00:37:40.500]we're always hurried, you know?
[00:37:42.190]And so again, I don't always put a lot of weight
[00:37:46.730]on the power of a consultant to change behavior
[00:37:48.960]without really enlisting a team,
[00:37:50.610]without really spending some time with the team
[00:37:54.040]or engage in the team.
[00:37:55.710]So let's talk quickly about getting unstuck.
[00:37:58.510]So getting stuck involves several things.
[00:38:01.380]So one involves changing our environment, right?
[00:38:03.890]So we're gonna talk about that,
[00:38:05.530]really looking at some goals and what can we do
[00:38:07.670]to mix things up to make sure we're getting,
[00:38:09.520]that we continue, that we change our behavior
[00:38:12.780]and that we continue with those new teaching practices.
[00:38:16.960]It may involve us intervening.
[00:38:18.680]And so this is really focused on educators today.
[00:38:21.870]So it might involve some self-management strategies, right?
[00:38:25.480]And then sometimes it involves changing the behavior
[00:38:27.890]of those around us.
[00:38:28.990]So sometimes we're gonna have to do some training
[00:38:31.220]of other folks to implement things certain ways
[00:38:36.800]so that we can move our classroom forward.
[00:38:38.810]Sometimes it involves training them
[00:38:40.260]on certain things so they can give us feedback.
[00:38:45.460]So now we're gonna start kind of moving
[00:38:47.020]into the work a little bit.
[00:38:49.360]So, one is I think it's important
[00:38:52.470]for us to understand kind of where do we get started.
[00:38:55.690]So if you're sitting here thinking, gosh,
[00:38:57.100]this guy just told me
[00:39:00.563]that I probably need to improve my practice,
[00:39:02.820]maybe he's right, well, where would I even get started?
[00:39:06.240]I think it's important for us to do some assessment, right?
[00:39:09.140]We've got to figure out a baseline,
[00:39:10.700]kind of where are we now in our practice.
[00:39:13.300]Again, I think we're often so overloaded
[00:39:16.330]with so much information and so many responsibilities
[00:39:18.810]that sometimes it's hard to step back
[00:39:20.910]and take a whole view of our program.
[00:39:24.130]If we don't figure out where we are,
[00:39:26.130]we can't figure out where to go, obviously,
[00:39:28.070]and then we can't recognize when we get there
[00:39:29.740]and kind of praise ourselves
[00:39:31.250]and be really proud of our achievements.
[00:39:33.090]I think that sometimes, you know,
[00:39:34.393]I referred earlier about losing teachers.
[00:39:36.170]I think teachers don't have systems in place
[00:39:40.010]where they get to see their daily successes
[00:39:42.750]or their overall program successes.
[00:39:44.660]And so therefore they're not contacting enough reinforcers
[00:39:46.570]to want to stay in the job.
[00:39:49.240]So oftentimes we do assessment this way.
[00:39:51.130]We have the ostrich approach.
[00:39:52.280]We kind of keep our head down
[00:39:53.600]and unless something bad happens,
[00:39:55.860]a parent or administrator comes to my room,
[00:39:58.940]I just kind of keep doing my thing, right?
[00:40:01.090]And everything's good.
[00:40:03.719]I don't know if I'm improving every year
[00:40:05.930]but nobody's complaining.
[00:40:07.430]Everybody tells me I'm an awesome special ed teacher.
[00:40:10.280]It's fine, right?
[00:40:12.670]Sometimes we have an ER approach.
[00:40:13.990]And so you're like, your classroom's a hot mess.
[00:40:16.130]There's always things popping up
[00:40:18.020]but you just respond to them one at a time, right?
[00:40:20.540]And so therefore we're always caught in this reactive mode
[00:40:25.530]and we never get past the squeaky wheels.
[00:40:27.270]We can't look at some of those foundational elements
[00:40:29.300]of our programs that we might need to fix.
[00:40:32.160]Sometimes we had the CNN approach, right?
[00:40:33.683]So that's, we address everything.
[00:40:36.370]So we sit back and we look at our programs
[00:40:38.685]and kind of where they are but we never look
[00:40:40.640]at the system to which those program elements operate.
[00:40:45.720]So we don't look at, wow, I might have an issue
[00:40:47.670]with my relationships with my paraprofessionals.
[00:40:50.060]And so therefore all these other things
[00:40:50.973]that aren't happening
[00:40:52.060]are because I don't have enough support.
[00:40:54.730]I haven't supported them enough
[00:40:56.910]to be independent in certain tasks.
[00:41:00.010]So the idea is, again,
[00:41:01.040]that we may have a surface understanding of where we are
[00:41:03.630]but we never really spend some time to tackle
[00:41:06.430]some of the difficult issues within our programs.
[00:41:09.736]And as a result, it's a mess.
[00:41:11.810]So if you're a consultant watching this right now
[00:41:13.550]or your job is to be a technical assistant,
[00:41:15.928]I'm sure you've walked into a classroom
[00:41:17.643]and you're like, this is a mess of,
[00:41:20.330]a fog of like, oh my God, this is great,
[00:41:22.960]and uh-oh, why is that happening, right?
[00:41:24.927]And there's so many things, sometimes you figure out,
[00:41:27.255]I don't even know where to begin.
[00:41:28.890]I think as a first, when I first started consulting
[00:41:31.220]probably nearly 20 years ago or I don't know,
[00:41:34.350]15 years ago, (laughs) time passes.
[00:41:37.240]But the point is I'll walk into a classroom
[00:41:39.010]and I would kind of stick with what I was good at
[00:41:41.450]but that may not have been
[00:41:42.990]where support needed to be offered.
[00:41:45.710]And so I think to do that,
[00:41:47.420]you've got to have some sort of tool
[00:41:49.260]and we need some sort of assessment.
[00:41:51.210]And the first thing we do when we talk about assessment,
[00:41:53.637]and this is for my teachers
[00:41:55.070]and my teacher support personnel out there,
[00:41:57.140]you gotta be honest about the difficulty of the job,
[00:42:00.670]realize that nobody can do everything
[00:42:02.890]but that we're always moving forward.
[00:42:04.530]And I think good old B.F. Skinner said it best, right,
[00:42:06.957]"A failure is not always a mistake.
[00:42:09.130]It may be simply the best one can do
[00:42:11.360]under given circumstances."
[00:42:13.700]That environment piece, right?
[00:42:15.077]But the real mistake is to stop trying.
[00:42:18.040]So I ask you to, no matter where you are
[00:42:22.250]in your coaching practice, whether you're a new teacher,
[00:42:25.010]an experienced teacher, to say, you know what, I'm,
[00:42:27.810]what are those things I'm still not doing?
[00:42:30.340]How can I challenge myself, let myself off the hook
[00:42:33.900]but then commit to picking them up,
[00:42:36.600]right, to growth in that area.
[00:42:40.390]So one of the tools that's been effective
[00:42:41.870]for us is the ALCOT.
[00:42:44.274]So, and the ALCOT was born when I was the director
[00:42:48.500]of the Kentucky Autism Training Center.
[00:42:50.280]And so I started, we were a part of a coaching project
[00:42:56.260]with the National Professional Development Center on Autism.
[00:43:01.080]Again, I think one of the,
[00:43:04.350]one of the best movements, I think, in our field,
[00:43:07.490]I think that we saw it in a short period of time
[00:43:09.740]a quick change in, you know,
[00:43:13.070]our knowledge around what should be done
[00:43:14.580]with kids with autism in school settings.
[00:43:17.010]But anyway, a part of their process was coaching
[00:43:18.860]and they had had this tool, I think it was called the APERS,
[00:43:21.810]and at that time it was big.
[00:43:23.540]It was a binder, Likert scale items, lots of items
[00:43:27.170]and it just wasn't manageable.
[00:43:28.580]So when we were finishing the project,
[00:43:29.930]we wanted to keep doing the work out in the state.
[00:43:31.977]And so I sat down and just started redrafting,
[00:43:36.570]like, what would be maybe a more pragmatic tool to use,
[00:43:41.980]one sheet, one side I can go through,
[00:43:44.070]and from that we can develop targets.
[00:43:45.520]And that's from where the ALCOT came.
[00:43:48.890]It's not, there's no psychometric properties
[00:43:51.670]associated with it so the point is is you couldn't use it,
[00:43:55.260]we don't use it to go in and say, you're a bad teacher,
[00:43:57.620]you're a good teacher, right?
[00:43:59.150]This isn't about employment.
[00:44:00.210]This is like, hey, let's sit down and use this together
[00:44:02.560]and figure out where we want to grow next year.
[00:44:04.350]So it really is a coaching tool
[00:44:06.340]or for my friends in rural communities
[00:44:08.240]who may not have access regularly to a coach,
[00:44:10.760]for them to sit down with their team and say, all right,
[00:44:12.850]let's evaluate ourselves, figure out where we are
[00:44:16.560]and where do we want to go
[00:44:17.580]and how do we want to improve in our programming?
[00:44:22.130]We've implemented it across districts.
[00:44:25.465]We've used it on our teacher preparation programs
[00:44:28.590]for our statewide, in Kentucky,
[00:44:30.117]we had a state professional development grant,
[00:44:32.130]a SPD grant, and we used it as a tool
[00:44:35.422]for the people in our project to grow.
[00:44:37.700]So we're coaching people across the state.
[00:44:39.910]So again, so far it seems in its use
[00:44:42.960]that it's been very applicable to a wide audience.
[00:44:47.530]So it kind of, it's got 37 items.
[00:44:50.460]Two sources of data are appropriate so you can observe it.
[00:44:54.070]And usually we do, like, an hour observation
[00:44:56.140]and then we ask them questions, follow-up questions.
[00:44:58.620]Again, the idea is not to, you know, a teacher
[00:45:01.310]or you may report something's happening
[00:45:03.320]and maybe an error but we kind of figure that out
[00:45:06.190]as we develop a stronger relationship over time.
[00:45:08.470]So if somebody says they're doing something
[00:45:10.800]and we get out there, it's not doing something,
[00:45:12.841]it's not about a gotcha.
[00:45:13.940]It's like, oh, we just need to kind of recalibrate
[00:45:15.730]where our focus is.
[00:45:18.410]We have a couple of different scales.
[00:45:19.610]So we have, well, we have
[00:45:21.756]kind of a three-point scale there.
[00:45:23.040]It's not evidenced, partially evidenced or evidenced.
[00:45:26.760]And the reason we did this
[00:45:27.890]is that we used to have it just dichotomous, there are not,
[00:45:32.360]and what happened is that criteria was pretty high
[00:45:34.930]for there so what it meant is that a lot of teachers
[00:45:39.650]that we were working with would have nothing.
[00:45:41.290]They would get no credit
[00:45:42.270]for being almost there or partially there.
[00:45:44.377]And so we changed that a little bit
[00:45:45.787]just to kind of help, one, make the tool less aversive
[00:45:50.360]but also to see where, have teachers realized, oh,
[00:45:53.170]well, here's a place I'm making progress
[00:45:54.770]even if I'm not to where I need to be.
[00:45:59.100]So the tool itself also has a couple of cool features.
[00:46:01.540]So we have this nice operational definitions of behaviors
[00:46:05.270]and there are a scoring guide.
[00:46:08.460]And then we also have a statement
[00:46:09.740]as to why it's important, right?
[00:46:11.650]So if an administrator was using this
[00:46:13.970]or somebody that has a little bit less experience
[00:46:15.910]in our field, they may say, oh, okay,
[00:46:17.220]this is why this item's on there.
[00:46:19.220]I have to tell you, it was kind of a nightmare
[00:46:21.000]for a nerdy behavior analyst faculty person
[00:46:24.235]to trim down this device, this tool to 37 items.
[00:46:30.070]And so it doesn't cover everything
[00:46:31.450]but it does cover a broad swath,
[00:46:34.220]and within important items, program features,
[00:46:38.889]but it also within that, you know,
[00:46:41.250]we write unique goals to the teacher
[00:46:44.260]and we'll get to that in a little bit, in just a minute.
[00:46:47.530]It also has a list of sample recommendations
[00:46:49.230]kind of for each area.
[00:46:50.400]So just, you know, just some guidance
[00:46:53.390]and some things that you might consider if a student,
[00:46:56.852]if an individual has some weaknesses in this area.
[00:47:01.360]So let's talk about the tool for a minute.
[00:47:03.140]So the tool has six programming areas, right?
[00:47:06.400]So it has environmental supports.
[00:47:09.380]So kind of overall classroom supports.
[00:47:12.180]It has instructural support.
[00:47:13.490]So these are tools that will help guide instruction.
[00:47:16.560]We have instruction.
[00:47:19.010]Indicators around communication instruction.
[00:47:21.940]Behavior supports and staff interactions,
[00:47:24.960]which is really important.
[00:47:26.090]Probably one of the most subjective areas
[00:47:27.860]but probably one of the most essential in terms
[00:47:30.460]of making sure your classroom is running most effectively.
[00:47:34.428]So let's talk about the first area.
[00:47:36.450]So the first program area we call environmental supports.
[00:47:41.130]So the big idea about this is that, you know,
[00:47:43.140]is the class safe, right?
[00:47:45.330]So are kids protected from harm in that classroom?
[00:47:50.420]Are the routines predictable
[00:47:52.374]and is there access to broad items?
[00:47:54.612]Are there access to other peers,
[00:47:57.460]to materials that kids need to be successful?
[00:48:01.060]So I wanna just take a second to talk
[00:48:02.760]about the importance of predictability.
[00:48:04.600]One of the challenges that I see often
[00:48:07.960]in terms of programming
[00:48:09.770]is that teachers don't have a predictable routine.
[00:48:12.690]They don't have a well-set routine.
[00:48:14.020]Things change a lot.
[00:48:16.090]Sometimes it's an artifact
[00:48:18.027]of what's happening in the school.
[00:48:19.810]You know, they're on different schedules
[00:48:21.310]and those change every day.
[00:48:23.020]But the point is is that kids and staff don't really know
[00:48:26.300]what they're supposed to be doing each day,
[00:48:27.990]which produces anxiety,
[00:48:29.250]a lack of clarity around expectations,
[00:48:31.770]and it can be really tough.
[00:48:33.130]So some of the first things that we do with teachers,
[00:48:34.900]who, again, we want to make sure
[00:48:35.733]that we help them strengthen their routines,
[00:48:38.350]again, builds competence.
[00:48:39.840]The more you practice the same routine,
[00:48:41.790]the more likely you are to be effective at running it.
[00:48:44.510]It builds confidence
[00:48:45.850]'cause we've contacted success running routine before,
[00:48:48.889]we're more likely to do it again,
[00:48:51.580]and again, it just tells us
[00:48:54.880]about those important contingencies.
[00:48:56.650]So kids should know when they're gonna get a break.
[00:48:59.690]Kids should know when difficult tasks are coming
[00:49:02.310]that are gonna be challenging
[00:49:03.310]and when easier tasks are in general,
[00:49:05.630]at least early on in their program.
[00:49:07.190]Certainly we don't want kids that,
[00:49:08.280]we don't want to create an environment that's not natural
[00:49:10.580]'cause the real world is complex and always changing
[00:49:13.040]but we do want to make sure that we build up to that.
[00:49:17.400]Some of the items you're gonna see are arranging classrooms
[00:49:19.780]so that students can be observed at all times.
[00:49:22.570]Visual support and tactile cues
[00:49:24.010]throughout their day, classroom.
[00:49:25.900]There's visual schedules, assisted technology.
[00:49:28.510]I have this old picture 'cause it always reminds me,
[00:49:30.340]I was observing one time in a classroom with a parent
[00:49:33.490]so I had a wonderful but frustrated parent
[00:49:36.634]that wanted to look at other classrooms in the district
[00:49:38.730]and I was the positive young guy
[00:49:40.940]so the district would always say,
[00:49:42.110]Rob, take the moms on the tour.
[00:49:42.943]I'm like, okay, so we'd go and go on the tour.
[00:49:46.140]And there was a really great classroom.
[00:49:47.733]There was actually a really strong teacher
[00:49:49.610]but we're watching her teach a small group
[00:49:51.390]and one little kid somehow had gotten a paperclip
[00:49:53.980]and he was just inching, inching towards the socket.
[00:49:57.751](laughs) And I remember being like, come on,
[00:49:59.810]you gotta see this, you gotta see this.
[00:50:00.987]And the mom looked at me and I looked at her
[00:50:02.850]and I had to interrupt the lesson and kind of block it,
[00:50:06.720]which, you know, put the mom off.
[00:50:08.270]She was like, yeah, I know that this happens
[00:50:10.410]but if I have a choice, I wanna make sure
[00:50:12.560]that my child is in a safe environment.
[00:50:16.380]So in this section, you're gonna,
[00:50:18.032]you're hoping to observe that, you know,
[00:50:19.870]also the instructional areas correspond
[00:50:21.413]with routines and activities.
[00:50:23.850]So things aren't moved around all the time.
[00:50:26.300]So kids understand where literacy instruction
[00:50:28.370]is gonna happen.
[00:50:29.203]They need to know where they're gonna align up.
[00:50:32.590]You're gonna see visual supports
[00:50:34.160]throughout the entire program.
[00:50:36.320]You're gonna see, I mean,
[00:50:37.250]we have visual supports all over the place.
[00:50:39.500]I mean, I have cookbooks, I use road signs,
[00:50:41.820]I have things that are, I have, you know,
[00:50:44.044]all sorts of digital supports on my phone.
[00:50:46.100]So again, we want to make sure those supports are there
[00:50:48.010]to guide students so we're not always having
[00:50:49.610]to give them vocal directions, right?
[00:50:51.750]Because if we are always giving somebody vocal directions,
[00:50:54.820]we're not gonna be with those individuals in other places.
[00:50:57.060]So, you know, sometimes I'll sit back and be like, wow,
[00:51:00.010]there's so many supports we could put in place
[00:51:02.230]for students to navigate their classroom independently
[00:51:05.130]but the teacher just, instead of preparing for those,
[00:51:08.580]she's just telling them what to do all the time
[00:51:10.630]which, again, I think hinders some independence.
[00:51:14.340]And then teachers warn students prior to transitions.
[00:51:16.697]So again, sometimes you will see
[00:51:19.030]and I think it's also concordant
[00:51:20.590]with that lack of a predictable routine
[00:51:23.040]is that teachers are like, oh no, it's 9:36.
[00:51:25.920]We're late.
[00:51:27.220]You know, they discontinue all activities for the kids.
[00:51:29.480]One kid drops on the floor, meltdowns and cries.
[00:51:34.060]And so, you know, we want to make sure
[00:51:35.800]that within those routines, we've got signals.
[00:51:38.750]We have some teachers use timers on the smart board,
[00:51:41.730]even vocal, guys, we've got five more minutes,
[00:51:44.770]three more minutes, two more minutes,
[00:51:46.160]just letting kids know when it's time to transition.
[00:51:49.160]And I do it all the time.
[00:51:50.180]I've got a phone right now watching, monitoring my time.
[00:51:52.890]Some of our students don't have those skills.
[00:51:55.480]So we're gonna have to augment that by making sure
[00:51:57.320]we provide warnings for them.
[00:51:59.500]And I always use this as a great example
[00:52:01.443]of kind of a unconventional routine.
[00:52:03.777]We had a little guy that we were working with a teacher
[00:52:08.600]and this little guy was getting poop everywhere.
[00:52:11.710]He was coming out of the bathroom,
[00:52:13.320]smearing it, the teacher was already annoyed with him.
[00:52:15.750]She was saying there was poop smearing.
[00:52:17.160]And what we realize is
[00:52:18.050]that he was just not an effective wiper, right?
[00:52:20.360]So he'd wipe once, it was on his clothes,
[00:52:22.120]everywhere he'd go and of course it made the staff gag.
[00:52:24.340]They were turned off and upset with him.
[00:52:26.250]So we just made a little routine for them, right?
[00:52:28.840]So my clerk there was a smoker
[00:52:33.910]at the office, the central office where I worked.
[00:52:35.350]I was like, can I see your cigarette lighter?
[00:52:36.900]And we got some toilet paper and a Hershey's bar
[00:52:39.330]and melted it and made a little schedule
[00:52:40.950]where the student could look and we him them to look, wipe,
[00:52:43.750]look, wipe, look, oh, when you're done,
[00:52:46.220]then you can pull your pants up, right?
[00:52:47.860]And so basically that was a, we were able to fix it.
[00:52:49.940]But again, making sure there's lots of supports
[00:52:51.990]in the classroom.
[00:52:54.041]And then finally we want to make sure that kids have access
[00:52:56.790]to their peers with and without disabilities.
[00:53:01.200]Oftentimes, you know, I remember back in the early days
[00:53:03.670]of Kentucky when we first had our alternate assessment,
[00:53:06.660]you would get credit points on your score
[00:53:10.210]if students had friendships with kids without disabilities.
[00:53:13.050]Now, that always threw me off.
[00:53:14.270]I always wondered why it wasn't just as valid
[00:53:17.780]for them to have friendships with kids with disabilities.
[00:53:22.210]But the point is that we want to make sure in a classroom
[00:53:24.340]we don't see kids spending long periods of time
[00:53:27.520]unless there are safety precautions or it's written
[00:53:29.750]in a behavior plan without access to their peers.
[00:53:32.660]Again, that's not the type of world
[00:53:33.867]and they're not gonna learn to navigate
[00:53:36.260]in those natural environments
[00:53:37.150]unless they have opportunities to do so.
[00:53:40.140]So here's what we do now.
[00:53:41.820]We're gonna take a minute
[00:53:43.570]and I want for you to score yourself.
[00:53:47.110]So remember I asked you to get a little piece of paper out
[00:53:48.940]at the beginning.
[00:53:50.110]This is where I want you to do this.
[00:53:51.570]So if you're using this device, you would score yourself
[00:53:54.210]but I'm gonna read these items to you
[00:53:55.870]and I want you to make a note of this might be an area
[00:53:58.460]that I could improve upon.
[00:54:00.330]Or if you're a consultant or you work in schools
[00:54:04.040]supporting other people, I want you to think about,
[00:54:06.403]all right, this is a common problem that I see.
[00:54:09.950]So one, staff can observe all areas of the classroom, right?
[00:54:13.950]So we've had kids that are engaging in touching themselves
[00:54:17.490]but yet there's cabinets where they can go
[00:54:19.730]and do that, right?
[00:54:21.010]I remember we wrote a chapter a long time ago
[00:54:22.173]and the first recommendation
[00:54:23.890]about arranging your environment
[00:54:24.780]is don't put kids' desks right next to the door
[00:54:27.550]if they have problems with elopement.
[00:54:30.010]But yes, maybe visual supports or tactile cues
[00:54:33.850]are displayed throughout the classroom.
[00:54:36.210]Use of individualized student schedules
[00:54:38.190]or calendars are observed.
[00:54:40.420]Students are in close proximity to their peers
[00:54:43.550]or the use of assistive technology
[00:54:45.360]and other modifications are evident.
[00:54:49.420]So let's take a look, just take a second
[00:54:51.070]and I want you to engage in this process.
[00:54:54.240]Again, we usually do this as a workshop.
[00:54:55.440]In this virtual kind of pandemic setup,
[00:54:58.220]I want to make this as much like that as possible
[00:55:00.610]so I'll give you just another 30 seconds
[00:55:04.285]for you to think about it.
[00:55:25.057]All right, so now what I'd like to do
[00:55:27.410]is I'd like to take a little bit of a break
[00:55:30.600]and what we're gonna do
[00:55:31.820]is then you'll answer some questions here
[00:55:34.900]and then you will sign on into part two of this session.

The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!

You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.

Comments

0 Comments

ALCOT Part 1

Description

Searchable Transcript

Comments icon comment

Related Channels

Comments