Complementary Manure & Fertilizer Field Planning

Rick Koelsch Author

03/05/2021 Added

34 Plays

Description

From "Manure & Fertilizer: Complementary Roles" portion of Land Application Training 2021

Searchable Transcript

Search:

[00:00:00.730]We're gonna wrap up with a little discussion
[00:00:03.420]around kinda pairing up manure and fertilizer
[00:00:07.467]and trying to come up with some complementary uses
[00:00:10.220]of the two.
[00:00:11.310]What do you believe is most true
[00:00:12.590]in your decisions with respect to manure
[00:00:14.830]and fertilizer in a rural crop fertility program?
[00:00:19.410]Do they compete where fertilizer is preferred
[00:00:22.910]or where manure is preferred?
[00:00:26.010]Do they complement each other?
[00:00:28.710]Or do they rarely compete or complement each other?
[00:00:31.550]There are situations where they're gonna compete.
[00:00:33.230]And then I think certainly
[00:00:35.360]from the fertilizer dealers perspective,
[00:00:37.360]they can beat in some ways.
[00:00:39.440]But if we think about the individual characteristics
[00:00:43.900]of commercial fertilizer and manure, there's ways
[00:00:47.370]that we can make these complement each other.
[00:00:49.580]And I think there's gonna be some value
[00:00:51.250]that we see from this.
[00:00:52.480]And so we're gonna spend just a few minutes wrapping up
[00:00:55.690]with this and putting together a plan,
[00:00:59.070]a fertility plan that tries to take advantage of both.
[00:01:03.800]Reason we would like to think about that role of manure
[00:01:09.620]and fertilizer is that they each bring
[00:01:14.060]specific value, specific benefits.
[00:01:17.780]And in particular, I think we need to be recognizing more
[00:01:20.870]and more of that benefit of manure,
[00:01:23.120]'cause manure, if we are using it at a reasonable rate,
[00:01:29.190]a comparable rate to fertilizer,
[00:01:31.970]actually is probably gonna produce
[00:01:34.670]less environmental risk than fertilizer.
[00:01:39.270]And that's primarily because of that organic fraction
[00:01:43.070]of the nitrogen
[00:01:44.750]and also because of the phosphorus in manure
[00:01:48.960]typically is connected with organic particles rather
[00:01:52.610]than being something that dissolves easily.
[00:01:55.610]And so because of that, there can be some advantages.
[00:01:59.510]And so we'd like to take advantage of that manure,
[00:02:02.490]maybe both from a fertility perspective,
[00:02:05.140]but also from a water quality perspective.
[00:02:08.470]But here's that same question.
[00:02:10.450]It was asked in a group of...
[00:02:12.790]We received about 900 responses
[00:02:14.750]to this question from across the country.
[00:02:18.000]And I guess I'm showing just the private sector advisors
[00:02:22.480]and then the crop farmers and their responses to those.
[00:02:25.940]And we were quite surprised three quarters of those
[00:02:30.500]that responded suggested they complemented each other.
[00:02:34.190]And even as we looked at crop farmers that had no history
[00:02:37.710]or very limited history of using manure,
[00:02:41.590]they recognized that complementary role.
[00:02:45.030]And so for those of you that might be thinking in terms
[00:02:47.840]of marketing manure, I think we're already seeing farmers
[00:02:52.820]recognizing the value of manure and recognize its value
[00:02:56.250]in that complementary role.
[00:02:58.780]So let's think about what is the advantage of manure
[00:03:04.040]versus fertilizer in this fertility program.
[00:03:07.630]This graphic, the top part of this, this curve right here,
[00:03:15.270]see and I'm just kinda drawing alongside of it,
[00:03:18.480]that yellow curve indicates the rate
[00:03:23.180]at which the nitrogen is taken up by that corn plant.
[00:03:28.180]And as you can see, starting in mid June
[00:03:31.560]or so in through July, even into early August,
[00:03:35.730]that rate of nitrogen intake is pretty rapid.
[00:03:40.630]In fact, even with our new hybrids,
[00:03:43.810]we're seeing more and more that nitrogen being taken up
[00:03:47.468]later and later in the season.
[00:03:50.680]And so the ability to provide nitrogen connected
[00:03:56.850]with that curve would be the ideal situation.
[00:04:01.530]Now that's what we would like to provide to the crop.
[00:04:05.720]We also want to kind of keep in the back of our mind
[00:04:08.910]the balance of trying to provide that nitrogen
[00:04:12.130]so it's not gonna leach from that root zone.
[00:04:16.090]And the bottom graphic gives us an idea
[00:04:19.380]of that leaching potential.
[00:04:21.250]And you can see here that hump that occurs
[00:04:24.910]in late May, early June has extended early
[00:04:30.160]in the season starts, you know,
[00:04:31.990]as we get those spring rainfall,
[00:04:34.000]hopefully it starts coming here in another week or two
[00:04:37.230]and in through April when there's no growing crop.
[00:04:41.370]So what we would prefer to do is have a period
[00:04:46.770]where there was really very little nitrogen available here
[00:04:51.560]in April, May.
[00:04:53.400]And then starting in June, July, August,
[00:04:58.160]really have the bulk of our nitrogen come available
[00:05:02.310]in that period.
[00:05:03.630]So we've talked about rate.
[00:05:05.870]But now, we're getting at the idea that timing
[00:05:08.700]of the availability of that nitrogen is critical
[00:05:13.120]to ensuring that that nitrogen gets into the crop
[00:05:16.270]and doesn't leach from us into the groundwater.
[00:05:20.110]So keep that in mind.
[00:05:22.170]Now, what is it about...
[00:05:23.960]Why is manure....
[00:05:25.540]Why does manure have value in this kind of a scenario?
[00:05:31.380]And in particular, your feedlot manure, what did we say
[00:05:37.530]about the source of the nitrogen in our feedlot manure?
[00:05:41.780]What's in an organic or ammonium form?
[00:05:45.680]Organic, correct, okay.
[00:05:49.050]And that organic nitrogen really
[00:05:53.730]it is a slow release nitrogen.
[00:05:56.190]I like to call it mother nature's slow release nitrogen.
[00:06:00.680]And it becomes available primarily in that June, July,
[00:06:05.650]August time period as that soil is nice and warm.
[00:06:10.730]So there is real value to our high organic nitrogen sources
[00:06:17.110]because they match up pretty well with our modern hybrids
[00:06:20.780]and their use of nitrogen, June, July, August.
[00:06:25.460]But there is not much nitrogen available to that crop
[00:06:30.760]from that organic source in April and May.
[00:06:34.860]And so that is when our ammonium based fertilizers,
[00:06:39.640]whether they'd be manure that has a high ammonium content,
[00:06:43.250]or commercial fertilizer has a real advantage
[00:06:48.040]is getting that crop going early on.
[00:06:51.230]So here are things to keep in mind about what are some
[00:06:55.610]of the benefits or advantages of one versus the other.
[00:06:58.290]The organic nitrogen that's in manure
[00:07:00.980]and compost, it's gonna become most available
[00:07:04.300]during that summer months, June, July, August.
[00:07:08.040]It's many of our modern hybrids as the lowest risk
[00:07:11.620]of leaching because of the timing when it becomes available.
[00:07:16.020]So that makes it a friendly fertilizer
[00:07:18.830]from a environmental perspective.
[00:07:23.500]Our ammonium nitrogens,
[00:07:25.640]whether they'd be coming from commercial fertilizer
[00:07:28.740]or some of our manures that are higher in ammonium,
[00:07:31.410]such as a swine manure,
[00:07:33.400]they'd become available in the spring.
[00:07:35.310]They need those cool season nitrogen requirements
[00:07:38.240]to get that corn crop started.
[00:07:41.810]They also have the advantage that they're more predictable.
[00:07:44.750]If we put on 100 pounds of ammonium nitrogen,
[00:07:48.240]as long as we keep it into that root zone,
[00:07:50.820]it will have 100 pounds available.
[00:07:53.330]For that organic nitrogen, we made that guess.
[00:07:56.480]Remember that guess of how much was available?
[00:07:59.250]We said about 25% this year, maybe 15% next year, 7%.
[00:08:06.080]Well, those are ballpark guesses.
[00:08:09.370]And so that number may vary.
[00:08:11.930]Warm summer, warm moist soils, warm summer.
[00:08:15.740]It may be higher than that.
[00:08:17.550]In fact, the research is suggesting commonly
[00:08:20.030]it is higher than that.
[00:08:21.815]We get a cool summer.
[00:08:24.300]Well, maybe we're not getting all 25% of that available.
[00:08:27.950]And so we are doing some guessing up here on the organic.
[00:08:31.300]So recognize the strengths and weaknesses
[00:08:34.870]of both of those nitrogen sources.
[00:08:38.880]The literature would suggest that there's some
[00:08:42.730]real advantages of applying manure and fertilizer
[00:08:47.260]in some complementary role.
[00:08:50.490]The poultry industry, which has a manure
[00:08:53.090]that has very similar characteristics to your own,
[00:08:55.830]in terms of inorganic and organic nitrogen has learned
[00:09:00.150]and this is through quite a wide range
[00:09:02.210]of 90 different studies, 866 different observations,
[00:09:07.980]that the peak yields occurred when they used
[00:09:12.800]both fertility products, as compared to inorganic fertilizer
[00:09:17.080]by itself, and as well as compared to the common
[00:09:20.810]or all organic fertilizer, all manure.
[00:09:24.900]And that peak was in the range on average
[00:09:27.400]of an 18% yield increase.
[00:09:30.260]A different study that's been done with all kinds
[00:09:33.190]of manures suggested that when the manure was about 50
[00:09:37.960]to 75% of the crop nitrogen requirement,
[00:09:41.200]it was something in that 10 to 15% yield increase range.
[00:09:46.080]And again, above those when it was all manure
[00:09:49.420]or just fertilizer.
[00:09:51.490]So there seems to be some value in trying to find
[00:09:56.620]that complementary role of manure and fertilizer
[00:09:59.760]in terms of yield, as well as in terms
[00:10:02.460]of protecting water quality.
[00:10:05.500]So some things to keep in mind about
[00:10:09.720]what are those complementary benefits of these two products.
[00:10:14.550]If we're needing something in terms of that early season,
[00:10:18.000]a nitrogen source for that early season crop vigor,
[00:10:21.580]we need an ammonium source of nitrogen.
[00:10:24.280]That can come from some manures, excuse me.
[00:10:28.170]Or it can come from our commercial fertilizers.
[00:10:32.270]So that's the advantage for that early season need.
[00:10:37.660]We would like to see the bulk of that nitrogen showing up
[00:10:40.790]in June and July.
[00:10:42.760]We could get that value from organic nitrogen,
[00:10:46.430]from our manure that's applied pre-season.
[00:10:49.920]It could also come from a fertilizer with an inhibitor.
[00:10:54.210]It's been, could be pre-seasoned applied
[00:10:57.730]or possibly even side-dress.
[00:11:01.140]And then just any high ammonium nitrogen source,
[00:11:06.610]even including manure that has been side-dressed.
[00:11:09.700]These would be ways that we could get that bulk
[00:11:12.520]of that nitrogen available in that June and July period.
[00:11:16.590]And we also need to recognize that this even becomes
[00:11:19.590]more important in our sandy soils,
[00:11:22.520]where our ability to hold that nitrogen
[00:11:25.260]in the root zone is challenged.
[00:11:28.130]And so again, some of the same majors though.
[00:11:30.520]Organic source of nitrogen or an ammonium nitrogen source
[00:11:34.530]with an inhibitor,
[00:11:35.810]or nitrogen applied is during the growing season.
[00:11:39.510]So those are some of the advantages we need to keep in back
[00:11:43.460]of our mind as we put together a fertility program.
[00:11:48.070]So your goal in the next 10 minutes is to come up
[00:11:53.210]with a fertility program that would work well in your farm.
[00:11:59.040]And I'm gonna give you some parameters to work within here,
[00:12:02.770]but you're gonna try to find a program that may blend
[00:12:06.010]the manure and the fertilizer in complementary roles.
[00:12:10.270]Here again, are some of those strengths
[00:12:14.170]that we talked about just a briefly ago.
[00:12:17.960]So if you need to review, those are handy.
[00:12:21.310]And what I'm gonna have you do is put a fertility program
[00:12:25.840]together for a corn crop that's gonna be produced,
[00:12:30.130]or have a yield goal of 220 bushel per acre.
[00:12:33.820]And there's other characteristics that have been put in here
[00:12:37.150]to come up with a fertility plan for this field,
[00:12:41.410]this 220 bushel corn crop.
[00:12:44.480]For if we followed the UNL recommendations,
[00:12:47.220]and that's not a necessity in your fertility plans.
[00:12:51.290]But if you use that as your means of calculating nitrogen,
[00:12:56.040]that 220 would have an expectation
[00:12:58.790]of 299 pounds of nitrogen being required.
[00:13:04.990]After we took out of that calculation
[00:13:08.580]what the credit is from the soil organic matter,
[00:13:12.040]from the nitrogen credit that was in the soil,
[00:13:15.660]from the lagoon credits.
[00:13:16.940]And I didn't give it any here.
[00:13:18.290]It was consuming continuous corn and for more organic
[00:13:22.880]or from irrigation nitrogen,
[00:13:24.730]from nitrate in the irrigation water took in those credits.
[00:13:29.930]We come up with 204 pounds of nitrogen.
[00:13:35.320]That would be the rate that we're targeting, okay.
[00:13:40.400]So I'm gonna ask you to meet that 204 pounds with manure,
[00:13:47.210]and then whatever commercial fertilizers
[00:13:49.970]you would like to use.
[00:13:51.110]And I'm gonna give you four options here.
[00:13:54.900]Here's the feedlot option.
[00:13:57.200]I've already calculated in here what is available.
[00:14:00.870]So we did the same work that we did earlier.
[00:14:04.770]Took the original 16 pounds of organic nitrogen
[00:14:08.240]times the 25% availability.
[00:14:10.420]So now I've got four available.
[00:14:13.100]I'm gonna assume we're gonna not incorporate that manure.
[00:14:16.280]So I don't give any availability to the ammonium.
[00:14:18.820]And you can see the phosphorus and the potassium
[00:14:21.015]in this particular situation.
[00:14:23.700]Or you could use another manure source.
[00:14:26.960]All right, so that's your sources of manure.
[00:14:30.690]I'll let you choose your sources of fertilizer.
[00:14:33.760]And we know we need 204 pounds here of nitrogen net,
[00:14:40.330]and I want you to put together a fertility plan
[00:14:44.200]on that second page at the bottom.
[00:14:48.340]That would come up with that 204 pounds of nitrogen.
[00:14:54.050]You can choose to put your manure and fertilizer
[00:14:57.770]on all pre-plant.
[00:15:00.530]You can do some add or near planting.
[00:15:04.340]If you wanna do some side-dressing
[00:15:05.970]and you have that capability, include that in your plan.
[00:15:10.920]But start our first step would be
[00:15:14.430]to just describe the products you're gonna put on.
[00:15:17.950]Like in the example, the 20 times per acre,
[00:15:20.770]the feedlot solids put on in November.
[00:15:23.960]So describing under the pre-plan, or at planning,
[00:15:27.440]or post-plant, what you wanna use in your scheme.
[00:15:34.520]I'm gonna put on 30 ton per acre of...
[00:15:48.230]Okay, so that's my proposal.
[00:15:56.870]Now once you've done that, let's calculate the organic
[00:16:01.184]and the ammonium nitrogen from the manure.
[00:16:04.990]And in my case, I've got 30 tons times the four pounds.
[00:16:13.930]I've got 120 pounds again, per acre out of my 204.
[00:16:22.820]Zero here and 30 times, what was it?
[00:16:32.310]Times 14, I come up with about 420 pounds of,
[00:16:46.120]420 pounds of P2O5.
[00:16:52.390]And I think I'll just call her good here,
[00:16:54.850]worried about the potassium.
[00:16:58.410]So I've still got to make up some ground here
[00:17:04.912]in terms of my nitrogen.
[00:17:13.865]Not gonna allow me to put things where I want it here
[00:17:15.513]so I won't worry about that, okay.
[00:17:18.510]What were you, what's your reasoning behind the products
[00:17:21.280]that you wish to choose?
[00:17:24.600]Jot those reasonings down here.
[00:17:26.370]I might say, well, my feed lot solids
[00:17:29.170]slow release and great source of nitrogen
[00:17:31.940]in middle of the summer.
[00:17:36.440]I'm gonna need some nitrogen probably at planning time.
[00:17:40.490]Let me stay on.
[00:17:41.500]I'll just put on about, I don't know,
[00:17:43.970]150 pounds of ammonium nitrates.
[00:17:47.330]That's a third nitrogen.
[00:17:49.170]So that would be about,
[00:17:50.500]we'll just put in here about 50 pounds
[00:17:54.560]of right in the product.
[00:17:57.340]But that would be ammonium nitrate.
[00:18:00.630]My case, what did you put in here, if anything?
[00:18:04.630]Post-plant, I'm gonna have to come up
[00:18:06.610]with some more products.
[00:18:07.600]So I might put in another 35 pounds as a UAN, possibly.
[00:18:13.330]That would be about 10 gallons of UAN, my final.
[00:18:16.700]And that would give me my 205 and give me 205 pounds.
[00:18:24.000]So it gives me exactly where I'd wanna be.
[00:18:28.270]So that's my plan.
[00:18:30.870]So I've got a little bit of a problem cause I put
[00:18:33.260]on 30 pounds, or 30 ton per acre.
[00:18:35.650]So I've got 420 pounds of phosphorus to use up.
[00:18:42.570]And up above for that 220 pound corn crop,
[00:18:47.420]it looks like I'm gonna use up about 76 pounds
[00:18:51.110]of phosphate per year.
[00:18:54.610]So I've got five plus years of phosphorus
[00:19:04.380]waitin' for me, right?
[00:19:07.090]So I couldn't return to this field
[00:19:09.900]if I didn't wanna continue to grow that phosphorus level
[00:19:12.660]in that soil.
[00:19:13.493]So I might have to wait five years.
[00:19:16.750]We've come up with plans here.
[00:19:19.260]I hope you came up with a plan.
[00:19:21.930]All I'm suggesting here is that we need to think
[00:19:25.700]in terms of situations that might benefit
[00:19:30.830]from both manure and fertilizer.
[00:19:33.720]And all right,
[00:19:35.040]now let's wrap up here with a couple of comments.
[00:19:41.210]Just some rules of thumb or things to think about
[00:19:44.980]as you're putting together a fertility plan.
[00:19:47.780]And if it's not gonna be entirely reliant upon manure,
[00:19:51.070]probably a good ballpark to aim for is somewhere in that 50,
[00:19:57.519]75% organic nitrogen being kind of a base rate.
[00:20:03.580]You start getting too much above that 75%
[00:20:06.390]and you run into the challenge I ran into.
[00:20:08.910]Applying a lot of phosphorus,
[00:20:10.810]containing multiple years to use that up.
[00:20:14.340]The ammonium nitrogen,
[00:20:16.210]I need to have some of that early in the planning season
[00:20:19.860]for that early bigger.
[00:20:21.660]Could come from fertilizer.
[00:20:23.880]If you had access to a swine farm nearby
[00:20:26.450]that had some high ammonium manure,
[00:20:29.080]I guess that'd be a possibility.
[00:20:31.730]We then might begin to think in terms
[00:20:34.410]of doin' some side dressing
[00:20:36.320]so that we could test the crop during the growing season,
[00:20:39.800]see if that manure really is becoming available.
[00:20:42.640]And then supplementing
[00:20:43.780]with fertigation through the pivot,
[00:20:47.320]fertilizer through a high clearance piece of equipment.
[00:20:51.620]We're even seeing in some places in the country using,
[00:20:56.292]they're knifing in manure, high ammonium content manures,
[00:21:02.290]in that June, late May, early June period.
[00:21:06.980]So there's some options or even doing some of that
[00:21:10.430]into a row crop.
[00:21:12.630]But that gives us some complementary roles
[00:21:16.850]for both the manure and the fertilizer
[00:21:18.800]in this fertility program.
[00:21:22.102]A couple of suggestions that are programs,
[00:21:25.330]that you're getting.
[00:21:28.010]Charlie Wortmann has suggested in his recommendations,
[00:21:34.200]for those that have low clearance side-dress equipment,
[00:21:36.980]he likes to see a program that looks like something
[00:21:39.300]like this, a base manure nitrogen rate
[00:21:43.580]supplementing with 60 pounds of ammonium nitrogen
[00:21:47.230]right at or pre-plant period, and then sidedressing
[00:21:53.940]with a soil or a pre-sidedress soil nitrate test.
[00:21:59.940]When that crop is in the top 12 inches of the soil
[00:22:04.360]and using that soil nitrate test,
[00:22:06.720]then to drive a side dress application in early June.
[00:22:12.510]And this would be where you'd have
[00:22:13.783]low clearance sidedressing capabilities.
[00:22:18.560]Now there a recommendation that he put together
[00:22:22.740]follows this pretty closely.
[00:22:24.190]For high clearance sidedress equipment
[00:22:26.920]or a pivot fertigation, give the base nitrogen rate
[00:22:31.880]the application right at planting.
[00:22:34.860]And then using these canopy reflectance sensors
[00:22:39.860]for in season nitrogen rates that would always apply
[00:22:43.670]a minimum of 30 pounds and above that
[00:22:46.360]based upon what the sensors would tell you.
[00:22:49.460]So these are fertility programs that really allow us
[00:22:54.010]to do some late season checking of that manure
[00:22:57.380]and that organic nitrogen and what's truly available
[00:23:00.780]and then fertilizing accordingly.
[00:23:03.660]So that's kinda what we wanted to share
[00:23:07.720]in terms of trying to come up with these complementary
[00:23:10.560]or recognizing the complementary roles that manure
[00:23:13.500]and fertilizer can play with each other.

The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!

You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.

Comments

0 Comments

Complementary Manure & Fertilizer Field Planning

Description

Searchable Transcript

Comments icon comment

Related Channels

Comments