9 - 2020 Soybean Management Field Days - Interseeding Cover Crops in Soybean: Key Considerations for Success

Nebraska Soybean Board & Nebraska Extension Author

09/28/2020 Added

91 Plays

Description

Interseeding Cover Crops in Soybean: Key Considerations for Success - Chris Proctor, Nebraska Weed Management Extension Educator. Learn about: Overcoming challenges to cover cropping in a corn/soybean system; Interseeding Options; and Key Considerations for Interseeding Success (Timing of Planting and Cover Crop Selection)

Searchable Transcript

Search:

[00:00:01.006](upbeat music)
[00:00:06.850]I'm Chris Proctor.
[00:00:08.050]I'm a weed management extension educator
[00:00:10.040]at the University of Nebraska.
[00:00:12.120]I'm just gonna highlight
[00:00:14.640]some of the work we've done
[00:00:15.660]for the Soybean Management Field Days this year
[00:00:18.030]at our different locations
[00:00:19.810]trying to test interseeding of cover crops
[00:00:23.650]with the drill interseeder
[00:00:25.462]into soybean and in some of what we learned.
[00:00:29.570]But I wanna highlight this idea,
[00:00:31.220]this concept of interseeding in general first,
[00:00:34.660]and then I'll talk a little bit
[00:00:35.543]about the study as I get towards the end here.
[00:00:41.290]And so if I just think about cover crops
[00:00:42.593]and in general in corn and soybean
[00:00:45.320]which are predominantly how we're testing
[00:00:49.480]the use of cover crops in our state
[00:00:51.740]and how we're using them,
[00:00:53.920]there's just a number of challenges to cover cropping system
[00:00:57.670]within corn and soybeans.
[00:00:58.830]So you have that short window
[00:01:01.010]for establishment after harvest.
[00:01:03.430]There's always the question,
[00:01:05.070]do the benefits that I gained from my cover crops,
[00:01:07.110]do they justify the expense or the cost?
[00:01:10.000]And what about, how is it gonna,
[00:01:12.610]not only the direct cost,
[00:01:14.390]but how might that influence crop yields?
[00:01:19.220]There's a few things that we've known about
[00:01:20.600]this idea of how do we successfully establish cover crops
[00:01:25.290]within our corn and soybean systems?
[00:01:27.430]And so I just gonna highlight just a couple of those ideas.
[00:01:29.420]One being planting date has a pretty strong influence
[00:01:32.260]on how much cover crop biomass we accumulate.
[00:01:34.500]And we know that the more biomass that we accumulate
[00:01:38.100]that tends to be pretty strongly correlate
[00:01:40.650]or relate to the benefits that we see in those systems.
[00:01:44.250]And so this is just showing a study over two different years
[00:01:48.324]in Central Nebraska,
[00:01:49.800]and you can see the earlier the planting date
[00:01:52.330]on that bottom axis,
[00:01:53.590]the more cover crop biomass that we accumulated
[00:01:57.170]which are those green bars,
[00:01:59.020]that Spring biomass.
[00:02:00.170]And so planting in September, early October,
[00:02:04.190]that generated a lot more biomass
[00:02:05.760]than waiting until the very end of October to plant.
[00:02:09.300]We've seen this visually as well.
[00:02:12.530]And so you can just see this progression of planting dates
[00:02:17.960]from early September until the later part of October
[00:02:21.810]and there's a pretty significant difference
[00:02:24.040]come the next Spring.
[00:02:25.420]So this is the end of April when these pictures were taken.
[00:02:29.610]We had quite a bit more cover crop biomass showing.
[00:02:33.510]The other side of the coin in terms of biomass accumulation,
[00:02:37.080]if you can delay termination,
[00:02:39.450]that's a pretty big difference in biomass accumulation.
[00:02:41.960]So this was showing some data
[00:02:43.600]from a previous Soybean Management Field Day study,
[00:02:47.340]looking at termination date.
[00:02:48.640]And so this was a difference of about two weeks
[00:02:50.770]in termination timing.
[00:02:51.630]So we went from mid May
[00:02:55.366]to early June termination timing.
[00:03:00.107]You can see the two weeks difference
[00:03:02.310]made a pretty sizable difference in the amount of biomass
[00:03:05.970]that we were able to accumulate at that time of the year.
[00:03:07.950]And so that's another opportunity within the system
[00:03:11.200]to accumulate biomass.
[00:03:12.290]These are some of the ways that we've looked at,
[00:03:14.110]that we've studied more thoroughly.
[00:03:19.823]The question is what other opportunities are there in terms
[00:03:22.290]of getting cover crops into our systems
[00:03:24.760]into corn and soybean systems?
[00:03:26.930]And so there's other ideas
[00:03:28.214]that have been explored.
[00:03:29.900]So this idea of can we add wheat to the rotation
[00:03:32.110]at a third crop rotation?
[00:03:33.882]That just would give you a little bit broader window
[00:03:36.470]for establishing a cover crop.
[00:03:38.500]Seed corn, silage, using a shorter season maturity groups.
[00:03:43.120]All of these are just ways that you can gain a little bit
[00:03:46.560]of an extended season for establishing
[00:03:48.580]and growing a cover crop in Nebraska.
[00:03:51.610]Green planting is another one.
[00:03:53.470]So that would be delaying termination
[00:03:55.860]or delaying how long you let that cover crop
[00:03:57.610]grow in the Spring.
[00:03:59.310]There's certainly others that could be talked about.
[00:04:02.060]And then the last one I'll highlight
[00:04:03.780]and the one I'm interested to cover today
[00:04:05.530]is this idea of interseeding.
[00:04:08.740]When we think of interseeding,
[00:04:09.859]there's really two ways that it's done.
[00:04:11.720]So there's broadcast interseeding.
[00:04:13.210]So this would be an airplane or high-clearance applicator.
[00:04:16.010]And typically this is a late season application.
[00:04:18.280]And so you think of towards the end of the year,
[00:04:21.240]R5-R6 in corn,
[00:04:23.540]just as soybean leaves start to yellow
[00:04:25.730]before the leaves start to drop,
[00:04:27.000]often cover crops could be interseeded at that time.
[00:04:31.400]Really the drawbacks to interseeding this way
[00:04:33.861]is when you broadcast the seed just falls
[00:04:37.720]on top of the soil surface.
[00:04:39.030]A lot of it can get hung up in the plant canopies.
[00:04:42.170]So you just have poor seed to soil contact.
[00:04:45.090]And the other challenge
[00:04:45.980]is you need really timely precipitation.
[00:04:49.370]So if you're in a dry land environment and it doesn't rain
[00:04:51.910]within a couple of days of interseeding,
[00:04:56.010]your establishment tends to go way down
[00:04:58.350]or else you're gonna need to think about
[00:05:00.470]maybe a late season irrigation
[00:05:02.110]where you typically wouldn't irrigate,
[00:05:03.810]but if you have that seed on top of the soil,
[00:05:06.010]irrigation might be warranted.
[00:05:10.140]And then another type of interseeding
[00:05:12.250]that's starting to gain more attention
[00:05:14.470]is drill interseeding.
[00:05:15.860]And so there's a number of companies,
[00:05:18.220]a number of farmers that have just innovated these rigs
[00:05:23.220]or where they're kind of their high-clearance machines,
[00:05:25.470]where they can be driven through the field
[00:05:28.600]earlier in the season.
[00:05:29.720]This is kind of the V3 to V5 window in corn.
[00:05:34.583]When a tractor can still get through the field
[00:05:36.730]and the toolbars high enough to clear
[00:05:39.400]those plants without damaging them.
[00:05:41.380]But the advantage is you can use
[00:05:44.280]drill openers to put the seed into the soil
[00:05:47.000]and so you have a lot better seed to soil contact.
[00:05:50.630]And most of the work to date has been in corn
[00:05:53.330]evaluating how effective this type of system is.
[00:05:57.570]So I just thought I'd highlight maybe some ideas or things
[00:06:01.300]to think about to be successful with this type of system.
[00:06:05.690]So the timing of planting is certainly critical.
[00:06:13.118]When the seed goes into the system
[00:06:15.700]is gonna strongly influence how effective it can be,
[00:06:18.950]and just as a way to highlight that
[00:06:21.460]there was a study done a handful of years ago
[00:06:24.450]at our South Central research center,
[00:06:28.410]looking at the timing of interseeding in corn.
[00:06:32.040]I just show a couple of pictures here to show.
[00:06:34.990]In this system,
[00:06:36.207]when we seeded the cover crop at the same time as the corn,
[00:06:39.160]it had a pretty detrimental influence on that corn.
[00:06:42.180]And so that early timing just wasn't effective in corn.
[00:06:45.890]So getting the timing right is really critical.
[00:06:51.400]Cover crop selection.
[00:06:52.700]Now that you're planting cover crops in an environment
[00:06:55.600]where they're in some kind of competition
[00:06:58.089]with our cash crop,
[00:07:00.820]picking the right cover crop is really critical.
[00:07:04.530]What kind of light is available to that cover crop?
[00:07:07.250]How does that environment favor certain crops over another?
[00:07:10.570]Again, this is where there isn't a lot of research being,
[00:07:15.780]research is fairly new.
[00:07:17.240]Let's put it that way.
[00:07:18.130]There isn't a lot of information yet
[00:07:19.650]on what are the most effective crops
[00:07:21.850]for these drill interseeding environments.
[00:07:24.830]In the corn environments,
[00:07:27.370]the cover crops that I've listed here
[00:07:29.980]are ones that have been recommended.
[00:07:34.620]And so you can see annual rye.
[00:07:36.050]Some of the clovers tend to do okay in that environment.
[00:07:40.310]A lot of these environments, as you go farther north,
[00:07:44.570]the cropping systems tend to change the environments
[00:07:47.530]under those canopies is a little bit different,
[00:07:49.410]and so there's even suggestion of cereal rye, oats.
[00:07:54.640]These might even work in the Northern parts of Nebraska.
[00:07:58.990]But it's certainly something to consider
[00:08:02.100]is what cover crop are you wanting to put
[00:08:04.210]under these canopies and how well are they gonna survive
[00:08:06.388]under that environment?
[00:08:09.200]And then the last one I'll highlight here
[00:08:12.620]is herbicide selection.
[00:08:14.030]Now we've kinda changed our cropping system.
[00:08:16.500]So we've gone from really managing weeds
[00:08:19.360]with just the presence of corn or soybeans,
[00:08:21.510]but now we've added another crop into that system.
[00:08:24.550]And so our herbicide programs most likely
[00:08:27.210]need to be adjusted or adapted to consider that
[00:08:30.830]because many of the cover crops that we might use
[00:08:33.810]in these systems
[00:08:34.889]would not work well with a lot of our herbicides
[00:08:39.070]or herbicide programs.
[00:08:42.050]Now we're kinda led to think about
[00:08:44.631]what are the factors that influence
[00:08:46.680]or affect herbicide persistence?
[00:08:49.770]'Cause the longer that herbicide persist
[00:08:51.670]in that environment is gonna influence
[00:08:55.710]how that herbicide might impact our cover crop.
[00:08:59.240]So rainfall, soil texture, organic matter, pH,
[00:09:03.050]the rate of the herbicide,
[00:09:05.470]just the chemistry that herbicide itself, how long does it,
[00:09:08.130]what's the half-life of this herbicide.
[00:09:11.370]Those can all influence how well
[00:09:14.470]it might match with it with a cover crop.
[00:09:17.460]Just for an example, here's an herbicide label, Optill PRO.
[00:09:23.200]And if you look in this table here,
[00:09:25.850]this is showing the label recommendations
[00:09:28.810]on how long you need to wait
[00:09:30.150]between applying the herbicide
[00:09:31.750]and planting the subsequent crop.
[00:09:34.340]And they have a category for other crops.
[00:09:36.970]And most of our cover crops would fall under that category
[00:09:39.830]in that they haven't been researched thoroughly.
[00:09:44.210]For this herbicide that's a 40 month restriction.
[00:09:46.740]And so you can imagine if you applied Optill PRO
[00:09:49.520]and you wanted to plant a clover into that system.
[00:09:52.370]Well, according to the label,
[00:09:53.320]they would recommend you wait 40 months
[00:09:54.980]before applying that,
[00:09:56.650]planting that cover crop.
[00:09:57.660]So that's not feasible for any of our systems.
[00:10:00.370]And so thinking about the herbicides
[00:10:02.110]that you select is important.
[00:10:03.930]I'd highlight another label just to say more and more labels
[00:10:07.470]are now containing language that talk about cover crops.
[00:10:10.410]Here's a label in DiFlexx DUO that actually has a section
[00:10:14.600]that talks about cover cropping
[00:10:16.083]and their recommendation is if you're using a cover crop
[00:10:19.960]to either do a bioassay,
[00:10:22.190]how well that cover crop might grow on the soil,
[00:10:24.790]or to at least acknowledge that you're doing it
[00:10:26.770]at your own risk.
[00:10:29.046]If you wanna push the envelope
[00:10:31.980]and plant a little bit sooner your cover crop,
[00:10:34.750]you can try that
[00:10:35.910]and it may very well work in these systems,
[00:10:37.880]but this is something that the companies
[00:10:39.811]haven't thoroughly tested
[00:10:41.200]and so you need to kinda test it yourself.
[00:10:45.200]And so that's what the labels would describe.
[00:10:47.510]And then I just highlight,
[00:10:48.850]there's other resources available
[00:10:50.370]that would give you some indication of how,
[00:10:52.960]what herbicides might be compatible
[00:10:55.390]with different cover crops.
[00:10:58.320]We have our guide for weed disease and insect management,
[00:11:00.860]and we have a lot of these tables talking about herbicide,
[00:11:04.140]carry over replant restrictions and so forth
[00:11:07.360]that could be used to think through this question.
[00:11:10.970]There's some resources that talk about
[00:11:12.350]how to conduct a field bioassay.
[00:11:14.637]And so if you wanted to test yourself,
[00:11:18.090]how might a cover crop grow given your soil conditions
[00:11:21.870]and how much your herbicide
[00:11:23.080]you might have left in your soil.
[00:11:24.380]This would be one way to test it.
[00:11:26.930]Then another one I'd highlight,
[00:11:27.940]and this is one that is probably one
[00:11:29.870]of the more developed resources right now.
[00:11:31.640]PennState has done a nice job of listing a number of tables
[00:11:34.980]and how different herbicides might be compatible
[00:11:40.770]with different cover crops.
[00:11:43.320]And so I just highlight
[00:11:45.320]that webpage here.
[00:11:47.690]You can easily Google this and track it down.
[00:11:51.660]And I pull out one of the tables that they list there
[00:11:55.370]on their website.
[00:11:56.280]This is showing a number of soybean residual herbicides
[00:12:00.190]and how they might influence either a grass,
[00:12:02.800]a legume or a brassica cover crop.
[00:12:04.570]And so it kinda gives you at least
[00:12:06.120]some kinda reference as you're thinking through
[00:12:08.490]what herbicides might work best with cover crops.
[00:12:14.120]And then finally thinking about other considerations
[00:12:18.590]for effectively interseeding cover crops
[00:12:21.520]into soybeans in particular.
[00:12:23.650]And these are questions that I don't think
[00:12:25.280]we have good answers to,
[00:12:26.210]but I think we're gonna have to think through
[00:12:28.290]and soybean population.
[00:12:30.890]So a lot of cover crop success in interseeding
[00:12:33.750]is there enough light and resources for that cover crop
[00:12:36.360]to at least survive until that crop is harvested.
[00:12:39.860]So is lowering the soybean population down,
[00:12:43.330]is that an effective way
[00:12:45.670]to allow more light into the system?
[00:12:49.210]Row direction is something that's been considered.
[00:12:52.300]Is a North-South row more effective
[00:12:55.010]at letting light into the canopy
[00:12:56.290]compared to an East-West row.
[00:12:58.710]The stature of soybean plants.
[00:13:01.130]A lot of what we select our plants on,
[00:13:03.730]we might have to start thinking of different parameters
[00:13:05.730]that we use for cultivating hybrid selection.
[00:13:09.110]Are short stature plants better?
[00:13:12.930]It's thinking about maybe some of the determinant varieties
[00:13:15.270]that would cease growth at a certain height,
[00:13:17.580]maybe allow a little more light into that system.
[00:13:20.340]So again, there's a number of questions
[00:13:21.590]that we could begin to ask
[00:13:22.980]relative to making this successful in soybean.
[00:13:26.958]Those are some of the ideas we had in mind
[00:13:28.930]as we design our study for this year's field days.
[00:13:34.510]And so we have our four locations
[00:13:37.550]across our state.
[00:13:39.110]Arlington, Shelby, Elgin and Hildreth.
[00:13:44.720]And so we had,
[00:13:45.610]it was about the second week of May give or take
[00:13:48.670]that we planted most of our soybean.
[00:13:50.750]And then we came back.
[00:13:52.250]It was about a month,
[00:13:55.290]maybe a little bit more than a month later
[00:13:56.720]that we came back and we interseeded
[00:13:58.180]with a drill interseeder at those locations.
[00:14:02.660]And the soybean was roughly V3 growth stage
[00:14:05.540]when we interseeded.
[00:14:07.380]We had two soybean cultivars that we evaluated.
[00:14:11.756]One was kind of a typical maturity group 3 cultivar
[00:14:17.170]of this growing in Nebraska
[00:14:18.003]and then we tried to select another one
[00:14:19.920]that had a little bit shorter stature
[00:14:22.390]hoping that we might see a little bit more light
[00:14:24.540]into the canopy with that cultivar.
[00:14:27.530]We seeded all of our study
[00:14:30.540]at 100,000 soybean seeds per acre.
[00:14:34.839]And then we had two different herbicide programs
[00:14:36.940]that we evaluated.
[00:14:37.850]And so we looked at what we would call a typical program,
[00:14:41.850]or we had a burndown plus a pre-emerge herbicide.
[00:14:45.520]In this case, we used valor
[00:14:47.800]followed by a post-emerge herbicide,
[00:14:51.110]which we only use roundup for this particular study
[00:14:54.030]compared to no pre-merger beside it all.
[00:14:55.867]And so we were wanting to know,
[00:14:57.900]was our herbicide program having any influence
[00:15:00.030]on the establishment of our cover crop
[00:15:02.090]in this interseeded environment.
[00:15:04.750]And then for the cover crop that we utilized,
[00:15:06.720]again we don't have a good frame of reference,
[00:15:08.500]so what we came up with for this particular study
[00:15:11.330]was to evaluate.
[00:15:13.550]We planted a mixture of annual ryegrass
[00:15:15.930]at 2 pounds an acre mixed with a winter wheat
[00:15:18.760]planted at 10 pounds an acre.
[00:15:20.010]And so that was interseeded into the cover crop.
[00:15:24.970]Or excuse me, that cover crop was interseeded
[00:15:26.670]into our soybean.
[00:15:28.390]And so those have been evaluated throughout this season
[00:15:32.540]and as that data becomes available,
[00:15:35.700]that's gonna be compiled and made available to you
[00:15:40.280]in our research booklet here
[00:15:42.060]at the end of the season with the yields
[00:15:44.070]and the cover crop biomass and all that.
[00:15:48.572]The question is what are the common species and mixes used
[00:15:53.260]in these interseeding environments for cover crops?
[00:15:57.350]One, there's just not a lot that does well
[00:15:59.820]under that canopy.
[00:16:01.610]So the most common in corn is annual ryegrass.
[00:16:06.950]I think that one tends to do a little bit better
[00:16:08.610]under low light environment,
[00:16:09.580]and then there's a couple of clovers that seem to do okay
[00:16:12.840]and so I think some of the crimson clover
[00:16:16.030]is one that gets talked about frequently.
[00:16:19.550]I know there's more and more research coming out.
[00:16:22.260]I know some of our colleagues are doing some research
[00:16:25.520]in the central part of the state,
[00:16:26.353]and they're looking at much broader mixes.
[00:16:28.940]I think trying to capture some nitrogen fixing species
[00:16:32.800]along with some grass species and even some brassicas
[00:16:35.260]and seeing if they can make those successful
[00:16:38.780]at least in a corn environment.
[00:16:40.460]And in corn, you have just a little bit more light.
[00:16:42.160]I think the challenge is just that much more in soybean.
[00:16:44.900]And so I think we're gonna have to adapt our soybean system
[00:16:48.500]more dramatically if we wanna make this work in soybean.
[00:16:52.410]Does that answer your question?
[00:16:54.170]I don't have good answer but that's kinda what I know.
[00:16:58.270]The comment in question is we've used one suggestion
[00:17:02.460]to accumulate more biomass following soybean.
[00:17:05.160]The soybean crop is to shorten the maturity group
[00:17:08.180]that's used in that system
[00:17:09.530]so that harvest would occur a little bit sooner.
[00:17:12.010]And so in the research that we've done on that,
[00:17:14.700]what we've seen
[00:17:16.670]is that most,
[00:17:19.140]we really don't see any yield penalty
[00:17:21.340]all the way down to about a maturity group 3,
[00:17:23.670]maybe a very late two,
[00:17:26.130]but then from a three down to a two for Nebraska,
[00:17:31.850]for most of the Nebraska locations we've tested,
[00:17:33.940]we see about a three or four bushel decrease in yield
[00:17:37.700]to go from a three down to two,
[00:17:39.780]but we gained about two weeks of growing season
[00:17:42.170]in terms of harvest date.
[00:17:44.410]And so there's a window in there.
[00:17:46.190]I think in the kind of the mid to late 2s,
[00:17:50.470]your yield penalty would be fairly minimal,
[00:17:53.000]but you would probably gain in somewhere
[00:17:55.470]between a week to 10 days in terms of timing
[00:17:58.410]to establish a cover crop in the fall.
[00:18:01.200]So that's kind of our been our recommendation for Nebraska,
[00:18:04.030]for most of the parts of Nebraska.

The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!

You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.

Comments

0 Comments

9 - 2020 Soybean Management Field Days - Interseeding Cover Crops in Soybean: Key Considerations for Success

Description

Searchable Transcript

Comments icon comment

Related Channels

Comments