Stumpf Farm – Corn Rootworm Studies

University of Nebraska – Lincoln Author

08/31/2020 Added

18 Plays

Description

Dr. Julie Peterson presents results and recommendations for controlling corn rootworm larvae and beetles.
Feedback form

Searchable Transcript

Search:

[00:00:09.370]Hi, I'm Julie Peterson,
[00:00:11.240]associate professor and extension specialist in entomology
[00:00:14.770]at the West Central Research
[00:00:16.240]and Extension Center in North Platte.
[00:00:18.530]I'm pleased to share with you all
[00:00:20.090]some information that we have learned
[00:00:22.750]for Western corn rootworm management,
[00:00:25.050]based on several years
[00:00:26.610]of different trials and projects
[00:00:28.570]that we've done
[00:00:29.403]at the stumpf International Wheat Center
[00:00:31.620]and in some surrounding fields
[00:00:33.820]in that Grant in Ogallala area.
[00:00:36.230]Our most common species in Nebraska
[00:00:38.410]is the Western corn rootworm.
[00:00:40.580]This is a yellow beetle
[00:00:41.760]with black stripes.
[00:00:43.570]Adults emerge July through August,
[00:00:46.460]sometimes even later into September.
[00:00:48.940]They're gonna be mating and laying eggs
[00:00:50.690]in corn fields,
[00:00:52.110]and then spending the winter
[00:00:53.430]as eggs in the soil.
[00:00:55.490]They'll then hatch out
[00:00:56.490]as larvae next spring
[00:00:58.500]and this is when the larvae
[00:00:59.640]do most of their economic damage.
[00:01:01.900]They'll be feeding on corn roots
[00:01:04.190]and this can lead
[00:01:05.023]to physiological yield loss.
[00:01:07.130]Obviously, a corn plant
[00:01:08.290]that's been damaged by larval feeding
[00:01:10.430]can't take up water
[00:01:11.630]and nutrients as effectively,
[00:01:13.800]and then it can also result
[00:01:15.410]in goose snacking and lodging
[00:01:17.840]that makes harvest more difficult as well.
[00:01:22.540]Corn rootworm management
[00:01:23.900]in Nebraska usually involves
[00:01:26.250]the need to use
[00:01:27.083]more than one type of management approach
[00:01:29.627]and more than one management option.
[00:01:32.530]Some of those include crop rotation.
[00:01:34.780]This is by far
[00:01:35.920]the most effective management tool.
[00:01:38.900]The larvae really can only feed on corn roots
[00:01:42.230]and a few other species
[00:01:43.770]of closely related grassy weeds.
[00:01:46.420]So if you are rotating your crop to non-corn,
[00:01:49.890]and as long as you do a pretty good job
[00:01:51.630]of managing the volunteer corn in that crop,
[00:01:54.760]that can really just completely
[00:01:56.570]bring that rootworm population
[00:01:58.380]in the field
[00:01:59.310]all the way down to zero.
[00:02:01.219]That is a really a key part
[00:02:03.620]of a longterm management strategy
[00:02:05.670]to keep populations low.
[00:02:08.070]Aerial insecticide applications
[00:02:10.270]for adult beetles
[00:02:11.490]is also another tool,
[00:02:14.410]using Bt traits
[00:02:16.900]and using seed treatments,
[00:02:19.290]using at-plant insecticides
[00:02:21.200]that would target the larvae
[00:02:23.220]and then finally using biological control
[00:02:25.870]to supplement these other tools.
[00:02:28.160]And I'm gonna talk a little bit more
[00:02:29.690]about each of these options.
[00:02:33.280]So first, looking at aerial insecticides
[00:02:36.060]for adult control.
[00:02:37.610]This is really approaching it
[00:02:39.480]with two different goals in mind,
[00:02:42.220]depending on what you have going on
[00:02:44.210]in your field at the time.
[00:02:46.160]So the first would be
[00:02:47.520]the need to control adults right now
[00:02:50.070]within this season
[00:02:51.760]in order to prevent
[00:02:52.610]silk clipping from happening.
[00:02:54.910]Now, this occurs
[00:02:55.890]when you have really
[00:02:56.723]high beetle populations.
[00:02:58.930]So we're talking upwards of more than five
[00:03:02.010]up to 15 beetles per plant,
[00:03:04.860]so very large numbers.
[00:03:06.700]And they're also feeding on the silks
[00:03:09.110]and clipping those silks
[00:03:10.640]back to less than half an inch
[00:03:13.130]and this is when pollination
[00:03:14.930]is still 50% or less completed.
[00:03:19.210]So there's a window of time there
[00:03:21.100]where if you have
[00:03:21.940]very high beetle populations,
[00:03:24.000]you may need to spray
[00:03:25.200]to prevent silk clipping
[00:03:27.230]from being so bad
[00:03:28.430]that pollination is actually interfered with.
[00:03:31.900]Maybe a more common approach
[00:03:33.600]or a more often necessary approach
[00:03:36.750]for spraying for adult beetles
[00:03:39.120]is to prevent egg laying
[00:03:41.240]and you're actually not worrying
[00:03:42.950]about current beetles in the field,
[00:03:45.350]this season doing damage.
[00:03:47.350]What you're thinking about
[00:03:48.380]is the beetles
[00:03:49.213]that are there laying their eggs,
[00:03:51.140]and then those eggs will spend the winter
[00:03:53.580]and result in larval population
[00:03:55.860]the next year.
[00:03:57.140]So this other approach
[00:03:58.260]is thinking about management now
[00:04:00.370]that actually helps you
[00:04:01.390]down the line next year
[00:04:03.270]for managing beetle population.
[00:04:06.010]Choices insecticide product
[00:04:07.730]is gonna be really important
[00:04:09.130]whenever you're spraying
[00:04:10.060]for adult rootworm beetles
[00:04:11.930]and this is due to
[00:04:12.930]the numerous different times
[00:04:14.640]that rootworm beetles
[00:04:15.473]have evolved resistance
[00:04:17.040]to different products.
[00:04:18.820]Nebraska has a long history
[00:04:20.310]of this kind of resistance.
[00:04:22.250]The most recently documented
[00:04:24.580]is actually just in the last five years,
[00:04:26.680]we've shown that pyrethroids alone
[00:04:29.690]are really no longer adequate
[00:04:31.650]to control Western corn rootworm adults
[00:04:34.560]is where we first noticed it,
[00:04:36.410]but this actually does also translate
[00:04:38.870]over to larvae
[00:04:40.350]also showing pyrethroid resistance.
[00:04:43.120]And this is even documented
[00:04:44.630]in Southwest and West Central Nebraska.
[00:04:47.570]So some of our more common
[00:04:49.150]and some of our least expensive products
[00:04:51.840]that we have really relied on a lot
[00:04:54.270]things like Brigade and Capture
[00:04:57.380]Force would be another one,
[00:04:58.920]these are all in that pyrethroid grouping,
[00:05:01.670]and we are seeing concerns,
[00:05:03.790]we are seeing resistance
[00:05:05.710]to these products
[00:05:06.760]from Western corn rootworm
[00:05:08.380]and our part of the state.
[00:05:09.860]So I really wanna encourage you
[00:05:11.190]to move away from using those,
[00:05:13.550]especially using those by themselves
[00:05:16.100]and rotate in some other
[00:05:17.650]mode of action insecticides
[00:05:20.370]to try to move away from that resistance
[00:05:23.910]and try to move
[00:05:24.743]towards more effective products.
[00:05:27.250]So this is actually a figure
[00:05:29.240]that comes from some of that work
[00:05:30.970]that we did
[00:05:31.803]on the pyrethroid resistance,
[00:05:33.950]just to give you an idea
[00:05:35.150]of the sorts of issues
[00:05:36.200]that we were seeing.
[00:05:37.740]So what this is showing
[00:05:39.550]is the names of different populations
[00:05:43.072]of rootworms that have been collected from
[00:05:47.060]mostly from Nebraska,
[00:05:48.290]but from a few other states as well.
[00:05:50.610]Now, we expose these beetles
[00:05:52.970]to an amount of bifenthrin
[00:05:54.830]which is a very common
[00:05:56.150]active ingredient of Pyrethroid.
[00:05:58.430]We expose them to an amount
[00:06:00.010]that was supposed to kill 99% of them.
[00:06:04.130]Now, the populations here
[00:06:05.680]from Saunders County, Nebraska, Saline, Kansas,
[00:06:10.180]those are actually not different
[00:06:12.460]from the expected 99% dead.
[00:06:16.100]So those that are down the bottom in blue
[00:06:18.470]we're showing those beetle populations
[00:06:20.890]are still susceptible to the bifenthrin,
[00:06:23.840]the bifenthrin still works for them.
[00:06:26.280]But all the other populations
[00:06:28.180]that are up higher
[00:06:29.160]that's in sort of this reddish color,
[00:06:31.780]these are ones that actually died
[00:06:34.240]at a significantly lower amount,
[00:06:37.810]versus what was expected
[00:06:39.980]when they were
[00:06:41.100]had bifenthrin applied to them.
[00:06:44.050]So this would include
[00:06:45.010]multiple different populations
[00:06:46.630]these here on there from Keith County,
[00:06:48.880]Perkins County and Chase County,
[00:06:51.180]our Southwest part of the state of Nebraska,
[00:06:54.520]you can see there also were some
[00:06:56.190]from Northwest Kansas on there as well.
[00:07:00.450]But just to give you an idea that
[00:07:02.400]in some areas,
[00:07:03.730]in some fields in Southwest Nebraska,
[00:07:06.690]we expose the beetle
[00:07:08.570]to an amount of bifenthrin pyrethroid
[00:07:10.490]that was supposed to kill 99%
[00:07:13.710]and at very worst
[00:07:15.370]for a few of those
[00:07:16.370]Perkins County fields,
[00:07:18.530]it only killed 4% of the beetles.
[00:07:21.640]So definitely a significant resistance
[00:07:24.260]showing up there.
[00:07:25.610]And so this is the concern we have
[00:07:27.580]if folks are gonna be using
[00:07:29.050]pyrethroids by themselves,
[00:07:31.160]is that we don't want you
[00:07:32.140]to end up with this
[00:07:33.200]sort of a situation
[00:07:35.320]where you only have four or 5%
[00:07:38.160]of your beetles dying
[00:07:39.360]when you're expecting to see
[00:07:40.620]99% or more.
[00:07:43.720]Now, at the Grant research farm,
[00:07:46.210]our crew has done
[00:07:47.850]several years of Bt trait,
[00:07:50.680]seed treatment and at-plant insecticides testing.
[00:07:54.930]This is using small-plot trials
[00:07:57.320]mostly located at the Stumpf Farm itself,
[00:08:00.500]and we have been using
[00:08:02.070]this small-plot planter
[00:08:04.660]that's shown here.
[00:08:05.980]We have it set up
[00:08:06.890]where we can actually switch
[00:08:08.270]between different liquid
[00:08:09.620]and granular at-plant insecticides
[00:08:12.590]that are being put down in the furrow.
[00:08:15.000]We can also switch seeds,
[00:08:17.240]so we're able to test different seeds
[00:08:19.330]that have different Bt traits in them,
[00:08:21.250]or have different seed coatings
[00:08:23.570]or seed treatments on them,
[00:08:25.472]and this has really opened up our ability
[00:08:27.640]to test side by side,
[00:08:30.840]under heavy rootworm pressure
[00:08:33.140]at the Grant farm,
[00:08:34.660]how these different control methods
[00:08:36.850]and how these different products actually work.
[00:08:41.520]One of the main ways
[00:08:42.840]that we assess impact
[00:08:44.520]on corn rootworm populations
[00:08:46.930]and injury to the corn root system
[00:08:49.670]is by digging up plants
[00:08:51.350]and actually documenting
[00:08:52.660]the feeding injury.
[00:08:54.240]And we use a standardized scale
[00:08:56.410]from Iowa State University
[00:08:58.740]that rates from a zero to three,
[00:09:01.280]how much feeding damage
[00:09:02.770]to those nodal roots
[00:09:04.070]has been done by corn root worm larvae.
[00:09:10.250]Now there's a number of takeaway messages
[00:09:12.290]that we've gotten
[00:09:13.123]from doing these studies
[00:09:14.360]over the last several years also.
[00:09:17.010]One of those
[00:09:17.843]is to manage rootworm populations
[00:09:19.720]using crop rotation
[00:09:21.510]can really be great
[00:09:22.440]to keep the population low enough
[00:09:24.980]that really allows control methods
[00:09:27.140]to be the most effective.
[00:09:29.340]What we can see is that
[00:09:30.820]when larvae populations are really high,
[00:09:34.090]control methods can be overwhelmed,
[00:09:36.270]so even things that really
[00:09:37.500]are quite effective
[00:09:38.860]at low and medium infestation rates
[00:09:42.120]just can't make it over
[00:09:44.060]that threshold to very high population numbers.
[00:09:48.830]We also wanna avoid
[00:09:50.040]having the latest silking fields
[00:09:51.960]in your area.
[00:09:53.120]So this is actually a practice
[00:09:54.660]that we do on purpose to
[00:09:56.720]in order to attract in beetles
[00:09:59.300]because we'll have the latest
[00:10:00.590]silking fields in our area
[00:10:02.380]and then that sets us up
[00:10:03.470]to be able to have high populations
[00:10:05.190]to run our studies
[00:10:06.650]but this is something you obviously wanna avoid
[00:10:08.810]having happen in your fields if possible.
[00:10:12.760]We've also found
[00:10:13.700]that the Cry 34/35 protein
[00:10:16.550]is really the most effective Bt protein,
[00:10:19.270]but even that can be overwhelmed
[00:10:21.030]whenever those rootworms
[00:10:22.170]are at really high population densities.
[00:10:25.340]The Neonicotinoid seed treatments
[00:10:27.970]really can help protect the seed
[00:10:29.770]whenever you have low rootworm pressure
[00:10:32.155]but this really is only
[00:10:33.700]for early on in the season.
[00:10:36.560]And then not unlike what we talked about
[00:10:38.570]for the adults with the pyrethroids,
[00:10:41.250]we do find that for larvae as well,
[00:10:43.410]using a pyrethroid only
[00:10:45.630]is not going to be providing you
[00:10:47.663]with very much protection
[00:10:49.330]due to the resistance that's out there.
[00:10:51.830]So even though some of these
[00:10:53.040]liquified already products are inexpensive,
[00:10:55.920]they're easy to mix with your starter,
[00:10:57.890]if they're pyrethroid
[00:10:59.020]as the only active ingredient,
[00:11:01.390]they're not gonna be giving you
[00:11:02.810]a strong amount of protection
[00:11:04.470]against rootworm larvae.
[00:11:08.000]So the final thing
[00:11:08.890]I wanted to talk about
[00:11:10.040]was we've done some studies
[00:11:12.130]at Stumpf field
[00:11:12.963]and in some surrounding commercial fields
[00:11:15.180]and where we've actually identified
[00:11:16.720]some beneficial species of fungi
[00:11:19.520]and of nematodes.
[00:11:21.040]So that's what this picture
[00:11:22.320]is showing here
[00:11:23.153]is actually a corn rootworm larva
[00:11:25.690]that's been infested
[00:11:26.780]by this Metarhizium,
[00:11:28.090]which is a beneficial fungus,
[00:11:30.240]and it actually kills
[00:11:31.604]the rootworm larvae.
[00:11:33.200]So we're looking at ways
[00:11:34.130]that we might be able to introduce this
[00:11:35.930]as sort of a additional supplement
[00:11:39.090]that could work together
[00:11:40.270]and hopefully in synergy
[00:11:41.750]with things like Bt
[00:11:43.130]and with limited use of insecticides.
[00:11:46.600]A similar story
[00:11:47.690]for the entomopathogenic nematodes.
[00:11:50.090]These are nematodes
[00:11:51.090]that make their living
[00:11:52.090]by attacking and killing insects.
[00:11:54.490]They're not gonna be
[00:11:55.840]feeding on crop roots,
[00:11:57.590]they're not gonna be introducing
[00:11:58.820]any diseases to crops,
[00:12:00.550]really all they do
[00:12:01.390]is attack and kill insects.
[00:12:03.430]And so we're looking at ways
[00:12:04.760]to apply them
[00:12:05.760]and use these
[00:12:07.310]really as a biological control
[00:12:09.150]to help us combat this rootworm past.
[00:12:12.440]So really I think
[00:12:13.273]that kind of brings it back to
[00:12:14.890]my first point in all these
[00:12:16.180]which was that
[00:12:17.410]rootworm management is not a one
[00:12:19.370]or two silver bullets approach,
[00:12:21.730]you're gonna be looking at multiple
[00:12:23.090]different control strategies
[00:12:24.520]and how they can work together.
[00:12:27.100]So finally, I just wanted to say thank you
[00:12:29.580]and please feel free to contact me
[00:12:31.220]with any insect questions
[00:12:32.540]you might have,
[00:12:34.030]my email and phone
[00:12:35.880]and Twitter are all here,
[00:12:37.420]and thank you all very much.

The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!

You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.

Comments

0 Comments

Stumpf Farm – Corn Rootworm Studies

Description

Searchable Transcript

Comments icon comment

Related Channels

Comments