Glen Arnold - Side Dressing Crops with Manure

Glen Arnold Author

05/06/2020 Added

72 Plays

Description

Workshop presentation on side dressing growing crops with animal manures.

Searchable Transcript

Search:

[00:00:00.203]This is Glen Arnold with the
[00:00:01.300]Ohio State University Extension.
[00:00:03.270]Essentially, I do a lot of manure on growing
[00:00:05.710]crop research in the state of Ohio.
[00:00:08.290]We're trying to extend our manure application window
[00:00:10.870]as best we can by adding more days
[00:00:13.340]of the year that we can apply.
[00:00:15.100]Basically, we we know that we put out roughly about
[00:00:18.410]a half of our manure in the fall.
[00:00:20.470]And when we do that,
[00:00:21.550]we don't really get much opportunity to use
[00:00:23.930]the nitrogen that's in there.
[00:00:25.409]And one of our goals again,
[00:00:27.450]is to try to get manure application
[00:00:30.040]shifted to other windows of time.
[00:00:32.840]I always emphasize the need
[00:00:34.270]to look at your manure analysis.
[00:00:36.080]This is pounds per thousand gallons
[00:00:37.810]are liquid manures and talking with
[00:00:40.540]Dan Anderson from Ohio State,
[00:00:42.010]other places were much lower
[00:00:43.800]and nutrients than what you are perhaps in the Midwest,
[00:00:46.370]but this is fairly typical, typical of us to have
[00:00:49.380]about 37 point sic eight pounds of total nitrogen
[00:00:52.720]in 1000 gallons of manure,
[00:00:54.650]and almost all of that is in the ammonium nitrogen form
[00:00:57.740]readily available for crop uptake.
[00:01:00.760]In soil manure have very small amounts
[00:01:02.810]of organic nitrogen for us.
[00:01:04.770]And then of course P205 and K20 are very important.
[00:01:10.440]What I really try to emphasize the farmers you know,
[00:01:12.670]we we have generations of habits to overcome
[00:01:17.450]to do a better job with our manure,
[00:01:18.880]but when you really look at the value of those nutrients,
[00:01:21.740]about 40% of the nitrogen, phosphorus
[00:01:24.780]and potash total amount is the ammonium nitrogen portion.
[00:01:29.310]So again, if you're looking at a large pit of manure
[00:01:32.447]and our double wide hog buildings,
[00:01:34.520]and I said when I was about $20,000 with the nutrients
[00:01:38.180]in that pit, about 40% of that set nitrogen
[00:01:41.550]so you're gonna put that out in the fall.
[00:01:43.490]You generally are gonna say goodbye to most of it
[00:01:45.980]before the following year gets here.
[00:01:48.150]Also, the other thing I look for is a ratio.
[00:01:51.280]If I could have at least twice as much
[00:01:53.360]nitrogen per thousand pounds as I do P205,
[00:01:57.290]then I can look at a product I can use in corn
[00:01:59.500]later on for side dressing.
[00:02:01.430]So this is about a three to one,
[00:02:03.510]but I'd like to have a piece of two to one.
[00:02:06.380]Talk about a little bit on what we do with manure a week.
[00:02:09.380]This is a vin or a grassland applicator toolbar,
[00:02:13.040]also called a Vin hand toolbar, I believe.
[00:02:15.670]It's a European design.
[00:02:17.090]And when you run that through a field,
[00:02:19.100]you'll end up with slices in your wheat
[00:02:21.090]field much like this,
[00:02:22.210]they run that about two inches deep or so.
[00:02:25.040]And this was the very first plot I ever did with manure
[00:02:29.800]about 15 years ago,
[00:02:31.310]and it was about the very last plot I ever did with manure.
[00:02:34.180]The farmer was tremendously concerned
[00:02:36.510]about those slices in his wheat field.
[00:02:39.180]Then we went to harvest that fall
[00:02:40.640]on the urea on the left hand side
[00:02:42.670]that 120 pounds of nitrogen per acre yielded 84 bushel,
[00:02:47.310]the manure on the right hand side,
[00:02:49.490]at about 4000 gallons per acre, yielded 88 bushel per acre,
[00:02:53.700]and that kick started our work on manure
[00:02:56.360]in the state of Ohio.
[00:02:58.040]We couldn't get that grassland applicator
[00:03:00.760]in the following year.
[00:03:01.700]So we took a pecan toolbar we found in the woods,
[00:03:04.740]we modified it a little bit made it
[00:03:07.570]work similar to a grassland applicator.
[00:03:10.150]And then we did three types of manure applicator
[00:03:12.650]two types of manure application.
[00:03:14.730]We did surface applied manure using a tank and a tractor.
[00:03:18.780]We did incorporated manure with the tank and tractor
[00:03:21.380]and then we did urea as our control.
[00:03:26.270]This is just an example, the toolbar
[00:03:27.930]was only 13 and a half feet wide.
[00:03:29.650]So we had to make three passes across the field
[00:03:32.640]to reach so that we could use
[00:03:34.820]the 35 foot combine head that we had.
[00:03:38.500]If you look at the three years,
[00:03:39.930]all I really want to point out with this data
[00:03:42.170]is that in each of the three years
[00:03:43.990]we had great variability in wheat yields.
[00:03:47.160]That's one of the reasons it's hard
[00:03:48.340]to get people to grow wheat around here.
[00:03:50.680]Also, the gold bar surface supplied manure each year.
[00:03:54.820]The red bar is the incorporated manure
[00:03:57.970]where we slice the openings in the soil.
[00:04:03.150]And then the grey bar is the urea.
[00:04:06.510]We use urea is the most common
[00:04:08.490]spring nitrogen top dress that we use.
[00:04:11.320]And I just want to show that basically
[00:04:12.790]manure held its own each year.
[00:04:14.600]The only year there was really any statistical difference
[00:04:16.900]was the first year
[00:04:18.230]where the surface Blyton manure
[00:04:19.570]was a little bit statistically better than the other ways.
[00:04:22.680]But, you know, it's something that farmers looked at,
[00:04:26.410]we did a lot of plots on tankers.
[00:04:28.610]Eventually we went from using manure tankers
[00:04:33.080]to using drag hoses.
[00:04:36.120]I'll forward this video a little bit here.
[00:04:39.220]And essentially, this is what a lot was getting done.
[00:04:42.170]This past week in Ohio,
[00:04:44.430]was the surface application of manure
[00:04:46.280]to soft, red winter wheat in our stay.
[00:04:51.940]I personally would like to see this Incorporated.
[00:04:55.050]But if you're gonna do this surface application,
[00:04:57.100]we know it works.
[00:04:58.090]You just have to observe the proper setback distances
[00:05:01.550]between the field and the edge of the road
[00:05:04.650]and those types of things.
[00:05:06.210]So that's very commonly done around here
[00:05:08.340]is to look at the methods of surface application.
[00:05:13.340]You can see how the hose drags route
[00:05:16.930]across the wheat fields,
[00:05:17.790]so we really haven't had much trouble
[00:05:19.920]even with mendors and I'm and this is about
[00:05:21.770]a five and a half inch horse.
[00:05:23.840]We primarily work with between five and six inch
[00:05:26.240]hoses on most of our Ohio work that we do.
[00:05:36.580]The next thing we did was we went to using tankers.
[00:05:39.140]And when our plots and this is an example
[00:05:43.590]this is our university tanker that we modified,
[00:05:45.970]we took off the flotation wheels,
[00:05:48.860]and we put special rims and payloader tires on this tanker,
[00:05:53.900]so that we could traveled down through corn rows,
[00:05:56.650]and for about five years we did about 50 on farm plots
[00:06:00.140]with farmers up and down in western Ohio,
[00:06:02.810]and at the same time, we were also doing
[00:06:04.330]small plot research.
[00:06:06.740]We did we got about 10 bushel less per acre
[00:06:09.430]using a large tanker than we do with our small tankers
[00:06:11.930]and our small plots with manure.
[00:06:13.607]And we think that was primarily due to compaction
[00:06:17.660]caused by the large tanker going through the field.
[00:06:20.520]But if you kind of look at what the data shows for us,
[00:06:24.790]essentially over a five year period of time,
[00:06:27.460]we did several treatments.
[00:06:29.800]And if we look at the top half of that page,
[00:06:32.870]if you can see my cursor at all,
[00:06:34.520]everything above the top, my cursor over
[00:06:36.710]the top half of the page,
[00:06:38.330]we did incorporated 28% uranium ammonium nitrate
[00:06:42.820]at 200 pounds per acre as a side dress.
[00:06:46.160]We did incorporate it swine manure at 5000 gallons per acre
[00:06:49.870]because that got me 200 units of nitrogen.
[00:06:52.800]We did surface-applied swine manure at 5000 gallons per acre
[00:06:57.500]and then we did incorporate dairy manure
[00:07:00.070]at our legal limit in the state of 13,500 gallons per acre,
[00:07:05.020]plus we had to add about 65 pounds of UAN
[00:07:09.210]to get to our 200 pounds.
[00:07:11.840]And then we also did a surface-applied dairy manure,
[00:07:14.280]and those are all pre emergent plots.
[00:07:16.590]So when I started this way back in 2012,
[00:07:18.940]I didn't think the corn could be out of the ground,
[00:07:21.320]if we ever wanted to go to drag hoses.
[00:07:23.410]And then the bottom half are the same exact treatments,
[00:07:26.470]only their post emergent plots at the three year average.
[00:07:30.050]And if you look at at the results,
[00:07:34.010]if you compare incorporated swine manure on a second line,
[00:07:38.030]to the surface-applied,
[00:07:39.850]or scheme the incorporated commercial fertilizer,
[00:07:42.890]both pre emergent and post emergent plots,
[00:07:46.050]the manure actually beat the commercial fertilizer
[00:07:49.160]by double digits each year.
[00:07:51.070]You can see on a pre emergent plots,
[00:07:52.560]it was about 15 bushel per acre
[00:07:54.720]on a post emergent plots about 17.
[00:07:57.480]So this gave us a lot of pause before on this,
[00:08:01.890]if we went and looked at the surface application
[00:08:05.580]of the swine minerals in both instances,
[00:08:08.160]we gave back the yield advantage,
[00:08:10.940]but we were still within about 10 bushel
[00:08:13.510]of the incorporated commercial fertilizer.
[00:08:16.410]So when you leave manure on top the ground,
[00:08:18.440]you're leaving nitrogen on top of the ground,
[00:08:20.230]if you can smell it, it's leaving.
[00:08:22.680]And this kind of backed that up,
[00:08:24.070]at least it gave us something to think about.
[00:08:26.270]And then we looked at the dairy plots.
[00:08:29.310]Again, Incorporated dairy manure,
[00:08:32.440]competed very favorably with
[00:08:34.610]our commercial fertilizer and our plots.
[00:08:37.640]Surface-applied dairy manure
[00:08:39.570]was even worse than the surface applied hog manure.
[00:08:42.320]So again, we just want folks to understand
[00:08:45.280]when they're thrown on top the ground,
[00:08:46.800]they're still going to be donating a lot of nutrients
[00:08:49.510]and this is a five year average.
[00:08:51.326]Went through about one great season,
[00:08:53.530]two droughts and a couple other so so years on that one.
[00:08:58.780]So that led us to try it out to dry course.
[00:09:02.750]This is Herod farms in Darke county
[00:09:07.180]shit backup.
[00:09:09.890]This is Herod farms in Darke County,
[00:09:14.420]working with us on side dress plots.
[00:09:17.880]They were the first farmer in Ohio
[00:09:19.720]who was willing to give this a try.
[00:09:22.100]This is one of three University owned
[00:09:24.790]side dress toolbars that we run with in western Ohio.
[00:09:28.210]This happens to have a Dietrich
[00:09:29.620]rolling colder units on it
[00:09:31.930]and he's a No-Till farmer
[00:09:33.410]so the fields are usually pretty firm
[00:09:35.330]able to hold the hore,
[00:09:36.600]able to hold the equipment in pretty good shape.
[00:09:39.120]This corn is pretty close to the V4 stage.
[00:09:42.330]Um, a little bit tall but still were able to get it done.
[00:09:45.080]You can see some of the manure it's not
[00:09:46.700]completely absorbed yet.
[00:09:48.410]But it usually doesn't take very long
[00:09:49.930]and you can walk across that and
[00:09:53.120]not have your shoes smell like manure continuously.
[00:09:57.730]If you look at, we've worked with him for six years now.
[00:10:01.970]And if you look at his numbers
[00:10:05.220]over that six year period of time on the swine manure,
[00:10:08.310]he's averaged 200 point six bushels per acre,
[00:10:12.140]and on his commercial fertilizer,
[00:10:13.700]he's averaged 183 point three bushels per acre.
[00:10:17.040]So as he's gotten better at this,
[00:10:19.950]I think he's getting similar yield differences
[00:10:22.310]that we got with our small research plot tankers work,
[00:10:25.490]soil compaction wasn't an issue.
[00:10:27.810]So over his six years, we're running right at
[00:10:30.350]17 point three bushel per acre better
[00:10:33.300]with the manure and again,
[00:10:34.550]he does the whole field with manure
[00:10:36.300]except he'll leave four strips in there
[00:10:38.840]of commercial fertilizer for us for comparison.
[00:10:41.980]And then he believes based on his
[00:10:43.950]fertilizer savings based on his yield increase,
[00:10:47.078]that for him is worth about $157 an acre.
[00:10:50.880]Now he doesn't do every acre of corn of course,
[00:10:53.160]he simply sets aside each season 140 to 50 acre cornfield
[00:10:58.160]that he's going to try to side dress with manure
[00:11:00.970]and the rest of his fields pitrits,
[00:11:03.470]as he always would with commercial fertilizer.
[00:11:05.930]So it seems to work for him.
[00:11:07.780]The other thing that works for him is the balance involved.
[00:11:11.570]When we look at 200 bushel corn
[00:11:14.890]and the removal of 70 pounds of phosphorus per acre
[00:11:18.220]when it's harvested,
[00:11:19.660]and we look at coming back the following years
[00:11:21.980]with soybeans, and 65 bushel soybeans
[00:11:25.380]removes another 51 pounds of P205
[00:11:29.970]over a two year season,
[00:11:33.770]we would look at the removal of 121 pounds of P205 per acre.
[00:11:38.870]And that's pretty typical in Ohio,
[00:11:40.330]somewhere between 100 and 125
[00:11:42.910]is our typical removal P205 with a corn soybean rotation.
[00:11:47.000]When he puts his 6500 gallons of manure
[00:11:49.770]on this field every other year,
[00:11:51.950]he's putting 221 units of nitrogen.
[00:11:54.730]He's putting 117 pounds of P205.
[00:11:58.200]And so his balance is just about being breakeven
[00:12:00.660]over the two years time period
[00:12:03.190]and as P205 or K20 is potash isn't too bad either.
[00:12:07.090]It's about 29 pounds to the positive.
[00:12:10.139]And he's just pretty thrilled.
[00:12:11.950]Thinks it's just a great way to go.
[00:12:13.440]He's got three finishing buildings, so he tries to have
[00:12:17.530]fields for each of those buildings each season.
[00:12:21.360]The question then arises,
[00:12:22.410]how tall can you be with a corn
[00:12:24.620]so we drag hose cornfields,
[00:12:27.230]plots we did for five years
[00:12:29.330]where we would drag corn at
[00:12:30.940]V one, V two, V three, V four and V five.
[00:12:35.830]And when we would be done going across the field like this,
[00:12:38.360]we would turn right around and go back across it
[00:12:40.840]for the maximum amount of damage we could do.
[00:12:44.230]If you looked at the five years that we did that
[00:12:46.910]from 2014 to 2018,
[00:12:50.220]down the left hand side under the corn stage,
[00:12:52.920]you have no drag hose used.
[00:12:55.290]V one, V two, V three, V four and V five stages
[00:12:58.620]where the hose was dropped twice
[00:13:00.669]across the corner each of those stages,
[00:13:03.940]you bring the yield across the column the rows
[00:13:07.620]to the right hand column.
[00:13:10.140]Basically, we're around 170 bushel for each year.
[00:13:14.140]At no drag hose,
[00:13:15.680]we're about 169 point seven.
[00:13:18.345]At V one we're at 169 point nine,
[00:13:22.150]V two 168 point three,
[00:13:24.340]V three 171 point nine.
[00:13:27.420]We started to break a little bit at the V four stage,
[00:13:31.150]when we did break off a few plants,
[00:13:33.360]but the yield statistically was still there.
[00:13:36.190]But at V five, we definitely know that's a bad place to be.
[00:13:40.710]So we think we're comfortable in saying
[00:13:42.990]that we can go to V four
[00:13:44.640]using our drag hose,
[00:13:46.200]but we don't think we want to go to V five.
[00:13:50.900]Just so we're on the same page.
[00:13:52.870]You know, V one is the first leaf out of the ground.
[00:13:55.140]It's kind of rounded like the end of your thumb.
[00:13:57.570]V two this leaf on the left side
[00:14:00.160]has a collar it's gripping the plant.
[00:14:02.600]This V three leaf on the right hand side also has a collar.
[00:14:06.960]It's gripping the plant like you would grip a shovel handle.
[00:14:12.620]So we feel real comfortable that we can go to V four
[00:14:15.710]which V four leaf is here on the left hand side at the top,
[00:14:20.080]but it does not have a collar where it grips the corn plant.
[00:14:23.000]So this is still V three corn.
[00:14:26.580]The other thing to talk about a bit
[00:14:28.110]is how to plant the corn to make the drag hose work out.
[00:14:31.770]The way the Heroid to do it,
[00:14:33.480]and the most common way we do it in Ohio,
[00:14:35.840]is to plant two fields at the same angle
[00:14:38.130]that the commercial commercial drag hose
[00:14:39.920]persons gonna want to lie his hose.
[00:14:42.120]In this field, the corn is planted at a diagnal
[00:14:45.970]and the commercial applicator would also
[00:14:48.740]lay his his hose that way and he would do
[00:14:55.060]the left triangle on this field,
[00:14:57.210]that he would do a crossover maneuver,
[00:14:59.180]and he would do the triangle on the other side of the field.
[00:15:01.400]And that's how commercial dry hose guys operate best.
[00:15:05.500]We also have done it where we put a hose humper
[00:15:07.800]on the end of the field and did straight rows of corn.
[00:15:10.750]And that worked reasonably well
[00:15:12.490]but it's a lot of pressure on a drag hose.
[00:15:14.960]So the latest one that we did last summer
[00:15:16.800]that we liked quite a bit is to
[00:15:18.710]unroll the hose on that in a bean field
[00:15:21.010]right beside the corn field that we want to do
[00:15:23.113]this side dress work in,
[00:15:25.160]and that corn field's on the left hand side of this picture.
[00:15:28.340]And essentially as the applicator goes back
[00:15:30.850]and forth in this field,
[00:15:32.800]the hose humper guy just reaches in
[00:15:35.150]and hooks onto the hose.
[00:15:37.690]So here we have a tractor
[00:15:39.000]coming across doing a manure application.
[00:15:41.970]And then when he gets by the hose humper
[00:15:43.960]who's dead center in the middle of an 11,
[00:15:46.410]or quarter mile field, we'll reach over here with
[00:15:49.790]a hose humper and simply hook onto the field
[00:15:52.340]and brace it, didn't take a whole lot of tractor to do that.
[00:15:55.780]We've also done this and a half mile field.
[00:15:58.740]But again, that's getting pretty be hard on a dry hose,
[00:16:01.360]but it can be done.
[00:16:02.990]So that's an example of,
[00:16:04.350]and I think this next video maybe sums it up
[00:16:07.160]a little bit better.
[00:16:09.020]where he's gone, by he's reached in,
[00:16:11.260]he's grabbed the hose, and then a,
[00:16:13.830]the application trackers about to make the
[00:16:16.170]turn on the far end,
[00:16:18.240]when he gets down and he makes that turn and that hose stops
[00:16:21.410]flowing through the hose hopper or some
[00:16:24.150]people would call that a hose rustler,
[00:16:26.790]then this drag hose gentleman who's the owner
[00:16:29.480]of the field, he'll also get out of the road and,
[00:16:32.470]and at that application tractor come back
[00:16:34.190]through a little while.
[00:16:35.960]So you can see we're pulling all the hose
[00:16:37.780]from the left hand side out of that soybean
[00:16:40.780]field that we had.
[00:16:42.200]And we think this is probably gonna be
[00:16:44.230]the system that if a farmer absolutely thinks
[00:16:46.900]a field has to be planted straight,
[00:16:48.610]this would probably be the system that we
[00:16:51.160]would look at to make their drag hose thing work.
[00:16:55.830]Remember it takes a second tractor, takes a hose humper,
[00:17:00.110]that's more people, that's more involvement
[00:17:02.190]and not have your commercial applicator
[00:17:03.870]is would be interested in doing that.
[00:17:09.090]One last one I would throw out there is simply the
[00:17:12.610]surface application of manure on corn,
[00:17:15.240]we still do a lot of that mistake.
[00:17:19.290]Here we're throwing about 7000 gallons per acre
[00:17:22.290]of swine finishing manure on top corner, the V three stage.
[00:17:25.800]That's the first time this farmer ever did it.
[00:17:28.120]So he thought in the future,
[00:17:29.310]he would probably plant a corn at an angle
[00:17:31.830]and let that tractor follow the rows of corn.
[00:17:34.680]So it's kind of a baby step in the right direction
[00:17:36.980]of where I'd like them to go.
[00:17:38.700]And I just want to emphasize that that the field
[00:17:40.910]has to be solid enough to handle the hose.
[00:17:43.770]If you have a very soft spring work field,
[00:17:47.860]like this, what you'll do is you'll have
[00:17:50.580]that hose scour that loose dirt,
[00:17:52.580]see how we're starting to bury corn plants.
[00:17:55.507]This really looks bad and it makes everybody
[00:17:58.400]upset when you do it.
[00:17:59.440]So this field we also did two years later
[00:18:02.910]with the dry hose,
[00:18:04.270]and it had a heavy rain so the field
[00:18:06.230]was a lot firmer than it was this time around.
[00:18:09.130]And the hose drug pretty well cross there,
[00:18:11.690]they still got 243 bushel per acre.
[00:18:13.850]So I think their their anger was turned in cheek
[00:18:16.760]so to speak when the year was all over with,
[00:18:18.960]but this is just salmonella,
[00:18:20.220]you can see the sound units in the background
[00:18:21.980]and trying to make best avidly can.
[00:18:25.290]If for those who like to follow things on Facebook,
[00:18:28.360]or Ohio State Facebook page is here,
[00:18:30.190]I try to post as many pictures and videos
[00:18:34.040]on here as much manure research as I can.
[00:18:36.980]Because I know that's just a much faster way
[00:18:38.610]to reach larger audiences.
[00:18:40.540]So we get a lot of feedback from from folks
[00:18:42.930]and we'll sometimes put some stuff on manure
[00:18:44.630]kings and some of the other Facebook pages.
[00:18:47.840]And that was kind of my talk.
[00:18:49.200]Melissa, I will be happy to take questions
[00:18:52.270]if anybody wants to ask anything.

The screen size you are trying to search captions on is too small!

You can always jump over to MediaHub and check it out there.

Comments

0 Comments

Glen Arnold - Side Dressing Crops with Manure

Description

Searchable Transcript

Comments icon comment

Related Channels

Comments